Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.

Helping with Form

13»

Replies

  • afwatson15
    afwatson15 Posts: 39 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    lol +1

    My general response to someone with bad form is to slyly and discretely pull my phone out, pretend I'm messing with my music, and take a long video. Then, my buddies and I have a long laugh and drink beer.
  • moe0303
    moe0303 Posts: 934 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    To be fair, that isn't a kipping pull up either.
  • French_Peasant
    French_Peasant Posts: 1,639 Member
    moe0303 wrote: »
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    To be fair, that isn't a kipping pull up either.

    I believe it is intended to be comedic, but I might be going out on a limb there. ;)
  • moe0303
    moe0303 Posts: 934 Member
    moe0303 wrote: »
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    To be fair, that isn't a kipping pull up either.

    I believe it is intended to be comedic, but I might be going out on a limb there. ;)

    I know, but you said you had to look it up and provided this as if you now understand. Lot's of people believe things that were intended to be jokes. The interwebz is weird.
  • moe0303
    moe0303 Posts: 934 Member
    I created a crossfit bashing thread so we can debate whether it is a good idea to correct someone's form here.
    Even though @usmcmp basically ended the thread on the first page.
  • tulips_and_tea
    tulips_and_tea Posts: 5,744 Member
    moe0303 wrote: »
    This is why i so badly want to become a Crossfit instructor. I love helping people...help themselves

    regarding this situation, are you talking about an occurrence at a crossfit box?

    The crossfit has its one end of a plane hanger (it's huge) and there is a place for military personal to do there "workouts" so...yes and no

    I think you have good intentions and this is not meant to be mean, but to make a point. As far as unsolicited advice, even if it is correcting someone, well, how's this:

    "The crossfit has its one end of a plane hanger (it's huge) and there is a place for military personal personnel to do there their "workouts" so...yes and no"
  • brucealfred3
    brucealfred3 Posts: 47 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member

    How are partial reps a good excersise strategy? That's ridiculous..."here...do half the work and you'll do fine". Maybe for the people who like not making progress.

    It depends on the context, and context is a very, very, very (note my emphasis) critical thing when trying to evaluate whether or not someone is using their time productively.

    Here are some things to be aware of:

    1) Individual limitations/injury status may prevent someone from full ROM but allow them to use partial ROM.
    2) Partial ROM on specific exercises might be warranted to overload a portion of the exercise. Spoto Press and to a lesser extent board/pin presses and rack pulls might be examples.
    3) You may have no idea what goals someone has and it may dictate how they perform a given exercise.

    There are probably more examples than this.

    Finally your statement about "maybe for people who don't like making progress" is false. You can make plenty of progress using partial ROM.
  • French_Peasant
    French_Peasant Posts: 1,639 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

    Must...resist..correcting...bad...grammar...
  • queenliz99
    queenliz99 Posts: 15,317 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

    Must...resist..correcting...bad...grammar...

    No need, he's shooting himself in the foot!
  • Carlos_421
    Carlos_421 Posts: 5,132 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

    Actually, it's not even her opinion. She was quoting someone else.
  • zoeysasha37
    zoeysasha37 Posts: 7,088 Member

    This is hilarious and pretty much summed up what I was imagining while reading this thread
  • windee52
    windee52 Posts: 1,690 Member
    edited June 2016
    usmcmp wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    This is why i so badly want to become a Crossfit instructor. I love helping people...help themselves

    crossfit and form don't always go hand in hand....

    Then you dont know what the heck youre talking about Nice try though.

    Pretty sure I do...just watch some of them do pull-ups...Kiiping , really???

    So from what you watch...you think you know about it all?? That's rich. You see....the only difference in a killing pull up is that you move your legs for momentum...that's not bad form...unless of course you want to do 200 pull ups strict in a competition for time...good luck with that

    Kipping pull ups to most lifters is similar to how you feel about partial reps. Kipping removes a significant portion of the work from the back, which is the point of doing a pull up. Many lifters would never do 200 pull ups, they would add weight to ensure they can't do that many. More bang for their buck when it comes to building size and/or strength. This is why I said I would not correct people in the gym, you don't know their training or their goals.

    Preach! I don't think you should be allowed to call it a pull-up if you're using momentum to get reps.

  • Packerjohn
    Packerjohn Posts: 4,855 Member
    edited June 2016
    usmcmp wrote: »
    I only say something if they're on the verge of hurting themselves. Otherwise it's not really any of my business.

    But shouldn't we as...people...help each other. It's not like I'm the *kitten* who walks around as a no it all...but i genuinely want to help people.
    And as a fellow athlete, I think it's right we should hold each other to a higher standard

    Understand trying to help but do you know anything more than they do? Do they have some limitation thar can't allow them perfect form and they need to modify an exercise?
  • Packerjohn
    Packerjohn Posts: 4,855 Member
    edited June 2016
    Partial reps are very helpful! Rack pulls have helped my lockout on deadlifts for sure

    I belonged to a gym where the owner did partial reps sometimes in his workout. He had a bronze medal from the Olympics in weight lifting
  • moe0303
    moe0303 Posts: 934 Member
    edited June 2016
    windee52 wrote: »
    usmcmp wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    This is why i so badly want to become a Crossfit instructor. I love helping people...help themselves

    crossfit and form don't always go hand in hand....

    Then you dont know what the heck youre talking about Nice try though.

    Pretty sure I do...just watch some of them do pull-ups...Kiiping , really???

    So from what you watch...you think you know about it all?? That's rich. You see....the only difference in a killing pull up is that you move your legs for momentum...that's not bad form...unless of course you want to do 200 pull ups strict in a competition for time...good luck with that

    Kipping pull ups to most lifters is similar to how you feel about partial reps. Kipping removes a significant portion of the work from the back, which is the point of doing a pull up. Many lifters would never do 200 pull ups, they would add weight to ensure they can't do that many. More bang for their buck when it comes to building size and/or strength. This is why I said I would not correct people in the gym, you don't know their training or their goals.

    Preach! I don't think you should be allowed to call it a pull-up if you're using momentum to get reps.
    You're not using momentum to get reps. You're engaging multiple muscle groups in order to meet the objective (chest to bar). Kipping is not simply "moving your legs to get momentum" the OP described. It is a gymnastics technique centered around core engagement. takes timing, power, and coordination.
  • Packerjohn
    Packerjohn Posts: 4,855 Member
    Packerjohn wrote: »
    Partial reps are very helpful! Rack pulls have helped my lockout on deadlifts for sure

    I belonged to a gym where the owner did partial reps sometimes in his workout. He had a bronze medal from the Olympics in weight lifting

    But does he CrossFit? ;)

    Unfortunately he passed away before crossfit became a thing. He weighted about 260 and would do a set of 20 dips with 180 pounds chained around his waist as a finisher, did jumps to a 4 ft box, etc. Would probably be okay as a crossfitter
  • Carlos_421
    Carlos_421 Posts: 5,132 Member
    Packerjohn wrote: »
    Partial reps are very helpful! Rack pulls have helped my lockout on deadlifts for sure

    I belonged to a gym where the owner did partial reps sometimes in his workout. He had a bronze medal from the Olympics in weight lifting

    But does he CrossFit? ;)

    No, or he'd have won gold.

    /sarc
  • brucealfred3
    brucealfred3 Posts: 47 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

    Must...resist..correcting...bad...grammar...

    It's one word...Grow up.
  • French_Peasant
    French_Peasant Posts: 1,639 Member
    I had to look up a kipping pullup. What the what? Lotta flappin' going on.

    "Crossfit takes complicated movements and gets rid of all the useless [crap] like effectiveness and safety and replaces it with cool [crap] like violence and danger. Case in point: the kipping pullup. Crossfit has revolutionized fitness by teaching the correct way to do an incorrect pullup."

    "Crossfit is...intense athletic training for the professional non-athlete. This is good for sports like...running your mouth about how awesome crossfit is."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnjYyfkcaNI

    That's your opinion...too bad your wrong.

    Must...resist..correcting...bad...grammar...

    It's one word...Grow up.

    LOL..."grow up" says the snot-nosed kid who wants to run around correcting the universe. This entire thread has been dedicated to telling you to grow up. I assume you are utterly uncomprehending as to the delicious irony of this. As well as the irony of writing "your wrong." I suspect you would bring the same scintillating knowledge to the form corrections you would like to make.
  • annaskiski
    annaskiski Posts: 1,212 Member

    It's one word...Grow up.

    That's two words.
This discussion has been closed.