women should lift weights?? wtf?
Replies
-
So if I posted a thread titled 'Why People Should Eat Clean', or 'Why People Should Exercise', or 'Why People Should Do Cardio'...you'd be offended?
Right.
I think in the context of this discussion some people are equating should with must. "Why people must eat clean" , "Why people must exercise" or "why people must do cardio."
.
possibly. I read "should" as saying someone should be obliged to. "women should lift weights" as a general recommendation that all women need to, and should feel obliged to lift weights, regardless of other circumstances, needs, or whatever else they are already doing.
Im pretty sure thats what "should" means where i come from. Maybe slightly less instructional than "must" but still an instruction.0 -
why "should" i lift weights? What do weightlifters have that i dont have, apart from the ability to lift big things, and put them down again slowly? seriously?
Im slim, im reasonably strong, im fit,I have muscle definition, I carried my ten year old boy down the street the other day in one arm when he hurt his foot, ive even carried my 4 year old on one hip and my 3 year old on the other down the street at the same time when they both decided they were going to refuse to walk at the same time recently. I can run over two hours straight . My blood pressure is spot on, i rarely get ill.
Tell me, why "should" I be out lifting weights rather than doing what im doing?
Not saying lifting weights is bad - its great. A lot of you weight lifters have awesome bodies, but really, theres no SHOULD about it. There are many ways. Its beneficial to exercise and to eat healthily as much as possible, and its fine to say that you could possibly benefit from lifting weights, but thats very different from saying YOU SHOULD LIFT WEIGHTS
Stength training doesn't mean weight lifting. I work with a personal trainer and I told him that I am very much against machines, my strength training in those sessions is all body weight with some added weight because I'm strong. That being said, I'm a pump instructor and believe that my level of fitness (I am by no means a body builder, but I am particularly fit and have a low bf %) is from the mixture and various types of cardio and strength training that I partake in. If someone asks me what they're doing wrong or how to fix whatever is happening (not losing weight, not toned the way they want to be, etc) I'll ask about over all habit (food, types of exercise) because I know what has worked for me. there are long term proven scientific benefits to strength training including a reduction in osteoporosis. Strenght training isn't just about overall fitness, but plays a role in long term overall health. I defintely don't do it so that I can lift things up and put them down.
We all do what we want, unless you ask me a question an my analysis leads me to say to you "you should be strength training" I wouldn't say it to you or anyone else, but if you ask me a question and that's what my analysis leads me to believe you have a few choices: 1) ignore my advice, 2) take my advice, or apparently 3) get pissy because I gave you honest advice believing that you asked an honest question but I didn't give you the answer you wanted to hear.0 -
my post was about weight training0
-
If someone asks me what they're doing wrong or how to fix whatever is happening (not losing weight, not toned the way they want to be, etc) I'll ask about over all habit (food, types of exercise) because I know what has worked for me. there are long term proven scientific benefits to strength training including a reduction in osteoporosis. Strenght training isn't just about overall fitness, but plays a role in long term overall health. I defintely don't do it so that I can lift things up and put them down.
We all do what we want, unless you ask me a question an my analysis leads me to say to you "you should be strength training" I wouldn't say it to you or anyone else, but if you ask me a question and that's what my analysis leads me to believe you have a few choices: 1) ignore my advice, 2) take my advice, or apparently 3) get pissy because I gave you honest advice believing that you asked an honest question but I didn't give you the answer you wanted to hear.
See this is the crux of it. If someone specifically asks for advice on how to acheive a particular goal, and a good way would be weight lifting, then of course "you should maybe try weightlifting" is the perfect answer.0 -
So here's the breakdown. If muscle isn't "stressed" it atrophies. When this happens then loads gets shifted to other "supports" in your body. Normally it will be the bones. So now your weak leg muscles (running doesn't build muscular strength unless you're running uphill, stairs or sprints) are holding up your erect body each day while grinding away at the cartilage and leading to osteoarthritis. And this is much more common in women than men. So yeah, you SHOULD lift weights or do resistance training if you want your body reduce this from happening.i keep hearing this all the time on here. Why?
What if i dont like lifting weights?
I never really enjoyed resistance exercise much when i used to go to the gym, and tbh, thats what put me off going.
Surely its all about finding an exercise or a sport you really enjoy, so you are able to stick at it long term.
I cant imagine starting threads about why people should go running, because i know its not for everyone
I was at the gym 4 times a week for 18 months doing resistance, and didnt make any difference to my physique, and i didnt enjoy it. I only every enjoyed the running, and cardio is the only thing that seems to have changed my body too
I think it would be nice if people laid off the word "should" a bit when it comes to what sort of exercises people choose to do, because the ONLY thing worth sticking at, is the one you enjoy doing, otherwise its only ever going to be a fad.0 -
what did the person say to you suzy? just randomly you need to do weight training?0
-
y'know i always thought i put my opinions across clearly and wasnt too cryptic or anything, but im really surprised by how many people seem to have read that ive got something against weight lifting. Id challenge anyone to read back and tell me where they got that from0
-
what did the person say to you suzy? just randomly you need to do weight training?
not directly to me, but general posts saying that women should weight train.
a few people seem to have got what i mean, but im surprised this has gone on so many pages0 -
Well if you don't like something, it's an indication that you would be against it. You also said it did nothing for you. So if you did all that work and nothing happened, it's another indication that you're against it.y'know i always thought i put my opinions across clearly and wasnt too cryptic or anything, but im really surprised by how many people seem to have read that ive got something against weight lifting. Id challenge anyone to read back and tell me where they got that from0 -
No. It isn't. Eating is crucial Breathing is crucial. Sleeping and drinking and some level of activity are crucial. Lifting weights isn't. Most people get throughout their lives just fine without it. So it isn't by any definition of the word, crucial.
It may be preferable if you want a certain body composition. But that isn't the same thing as crucial.
Well, fine. Crucial if you don't want things like osteoporosis. Or if you want to effectively burn fat, while retaining muscle, burn more calories. Maybe you won't die if you don't do it. But you won't have optimal health.0 -
I would never view someones advice based on their success as a personal affront! It's pretty unbelievable that someone being proud of their work turned into this!0
-
running doesn't build muscular strength
really? So how come people get better and better at it, and get better muscle definition etc?0 -
Well if you don't like something, it's an indication that you would be against it. You also said it did nothing for you. So if you did all that work and nothing happened, it's another indication that you're against it.
well no, not at all, not against it in general, just dont think its the best exercise for me0 -
Well, techinically I think everyone SHOULD lift weights....Meaning everyone should be doing something to build muscle and to most people that means lifting weights. Of course lifting is not the only way to build muscle. I think statements like "women should lift weights" is more geared toward the women who want to "just lose fat" and focus solely on cardio without ever doing anything to build muscle.
Yes, running builds muscle but it is also important to do strength-specific exercises to get the best results visually and in order to be at your healthiest.
I'm rambling. I just mean that yes women SHOULD strength train, be it through lifting, resistance, plyo or body weight exercises. And so SHOULD men.0 -
Because it's easier to run when you weigh less, and when you have less fat it displays more musculature. But you get that lifting weight too.
really? So how come people get better and better at it, and get better muscle definition etc?
Cardio only regimens burn a lot of muscle if you're trying to lose weight. It's been documented by several peer viewed studies. Just look at a long distance runner and sprinter physique wise. Both run, but their running workouts are much different. One is more aerobic while the other anaerobic.
If you don't like lifting weights that's fine, but science and study indicate that optimal health requires that the muscle be under some moderate resistance to keep it from atrophying.0 -
running doesn't build muscular strength
really? So how come people get better and better at it, and get better muscle definition etc?
Perhaps there is a confusion here between muscular strength and muscular endurance?0 -
surely muscle atrophy is only going to be a real problem when youre talking about someone bed bound? Ive never known of a normal healthy active person who eats properly to have muscle atrophy?0
-
That's by how you feel. But contrary to how you feel, study after study will show that people who strength train (along with a good cardiovascular regimen) will have optimal muscle strength and conditioning compared to those that don't.well no, not at all, not against it in general, just dont think its the best exercise for me0 -
Just because suzy doesn't like it doesn't meant she's against it! I don't like spinning but I'm not against it0
-
When a muscle is "sore" after a workout, it's because it's been broken down. This is an direct indication of non use of a muscle (unless of course the muscle was overloaded during a workout). Non use of a muscle is a cause for atrophy.surely muscle atrophy is only going to be a real problem when youre talking about someone bed bound? Ive never known of a normal healthy active person who eats properly to have muscle atrophy?
If you look at an athlete who trains consistently, then look at them in later years when they don't, you can definitely see that they look much different. This is atrophy of muscle. It doesn't just apply to bed ridden people.0 -
you should all pay me $100 for everytime someone says "should".
lol j.k
:flowerforyou: 
0 -
optimal muscle strength maybe, but thats like saying that everyone should run marathons, because studies prove that people who run marathons can run longer than people who dont.
Really, its all about personal goals. If your personal goal is to be able to lift really heavy weights and have amazing muscular strength over and above anything you might need in real life, then thats absolutely fine, and i am totally in awe of people who set themselves high goals, and reach them,0 -
When a muscle is "sore" after a workout, it's because it's been broken down. This is an direct indication of non use of a muscle (unless of course the muscle was overloaded during a workout). Non use of a muscle is a cause for atrophy.surely muscle atrophy is only going to be a real problem when youre talking about someone bed bound? Ive never known of a normal healthy active person who eats properly to have muscle atrophy?
If you look at an athlete who trains consistently, then look at them in later years when they don't, you can definitely see that they look much different. This is atrophy of muscle. It doesn't just apply to bed ridden people.
not saying atrophy doesnt happen, but usually its a problem when youre talking about some terrible muscle wasting disease, or when people are in wheelchairs and their legs get all withered etc. Not just normal shrnking of muscles to a normal size.
Why would an ex athelete expect or want their muscles to be exactly the same size as they were at the height of their training?
for show?0 -
The thread would have never came up if she wasn't against it. The WTF gave a pretty good indication of it.Just because suzy doesn't like it doesn't meant she's against it! I don't like spinning but I'm not against it0 -
Again, study after study shows that people who strength train have less wear on bone joints and extremities. It makes total sense since if the muscle "holds" up the weight rather than shifting the weight to the joint directly, less wear happens. Older people who take up strength training have less joint problems. Why would you deny what scientific study has shown?not saying atrophy doesnt happen, but usually its a problem when youre talking about some terrible muscle wasting disease, or when people are in wheelchairs and their legs get all withered etc. Not just normal shrnking of muscles to a normal size.
Why would an ex athelete expect or want their muscles to be exactly the same size as they were at the height of their training?
for show?
My point about the athlete was that atrophy happens when strength training stops or is drastically reduced. That's all.0 -
you should all pay me $100 for everytime someone says "should".
lol j.k:flowerforyou:
hahahahaha!!!0 -
Unfortunately, as we age we lose muscle mass. Muscle is important for efficiently burning calories as well as your posture, balance and decreasing joint pain. Strengthening exercises only need to be done 2-3x/week with a day off in between to allow your muscles to recover. If you get bored with strengthening consider trying Kettlebells which is an awesome cardio and strengthening workout, or try a class at the gym to keep it exciting.0
-
OK my take to the OP is that people need to stop going straight to weights. There are other strength building things people can do that do not include the weights. Me personally I hate the gym. I have a slight anxiety about people being around and the stupid feeling that they are watching me (I know their not I don't need another 920503297 people telling me so please). And I'm kinda on the low income side so I don't have money to go buy weights for my house. So how did I cope? I started doing other things. Sit ups, push ups, pull ups etc. It strains the muscles to help build the muscles up and doesn't require weights.
I think people should suggest weights as a possibility but the word should can and often does turn people on the defensive side.
Just my opinion tho.0 -
finding exercise that works for you is the most important thing i feel0
-
The thread would have never came up if she wasn't against it. The WTF gave a pretty good indication of it.Just because suzy doesn't like it doesn't meant she's against it! I don't like spinning but I'm not against it
im not against it ffs. Im against people saying that people SHOULD do it. If people want to do it, thats fine. If they dont want to, there are other things they can do that are just as effective for some things, and more effective than others.
Do you need me to say it again? I can say it again if youre not quite sure.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions