Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Finding time to Exercise
Options
Replies
-
French_Peasant wrote: »Need2Exerc1se wrote: »French_Peasant wrote: »NorthCascades wrote: »@lemurcat12 I don't understand your weird obsessions on restricting what we're talking about to only people who have posted in this thread and only if they've said the magic number 30. You said you felt insulted because you imagine that people are talking about you, but we're not. There are millions of people in this country who don't get enough exercise, and many people who have said as much.
It seems like you'd prefer us not too talk about this because you're choosing to take it personally even though it's not directed at you.
I have just been following not participating, but if I might presume to arbitrate a moment:
The discussion on this thread was about people with more advanced fitness goals finding time to exercise, with frustrations and sensitivities about their limitations; threads about schlubs sitting on the couch and watching TV are a dime a dozen. I don't think heiliskrimsli needs to be told to get off her kitten, turn off the TV and exercise for half an hour a day because she is already rocking it when she can. The discussion was on another level.
So to use an analogy, it's like a group of people in a class entitled "Reading Comprehension" discussing, say, Faulkner's The Sound and The Fury and someone bustled into the class thumping his cane and saying all the damn kids should learn to read these day, and back in my day, we all know our alphabet. Well, yeah, that's true--but it's Faulkner comprehension being discussed, not remedial high school reading. Most people probably just ignore it, but others, being very orderly, logical, and (dare I say) lawyerly thinkers, tend to get annoyed by it, and say "WTF that's not what we are discussing here."
Perhaps the thread should have been titled "Finding Time to Exercise 401" so the CDC discussion could be had in "Finding Time to Exercise 101."
That doesn't really seem a fair comparison. A class titled "Reading Comprehension" would imply that people in the class know how to read, so starting a tangent that people should learn to read would be more off topic than sharing statistics on how many people don't exercise in a thread titled "Finding time to Exercise".
So title the class "Learning to Read." Regardless, if you walk in the room and hear the discussion is on Faulkner and not Dr. Seuss, you would probably want to listen a bit before making commentary.
Welcome to the internet. *shrug*1 -
I'm one of those that has some time to exercise, I'm a stay at home Mum/carer of autistic child (up 2-3x a night and needs close supervision 24/7) and get three days a week when my littlest boy is in pre-school, which allows me to spend a couple of hours at the gym along with attending a couple of classes. There also other classes I can attend when my partner isn't working (he works shifts). I also make time to run (get up at 5am) and my children benefit from the fact I'm very active. We don't have a car so if we want to go somewhere we walk or if it's too far to walk use public transport. Thanks to my Aspergers I can't settle unless I've done at least 20000 steps, so I'll wander round the house or get the step out and do intervals at 10pm to get there if I need to. Also thanks to my Aspergers I need the background noise of the TV near enough 24/7 (GoT rocks btw), but just cos the gogglebox is on it doesn't mean I'm not being active.
I've lost 120+lb in the last 19 months and living in a village means this has been noticed and people will say they wish they could lose weight/run/get fitter too, but when I suggest maybe going to a class, or the gym or to try C25K or whatever, their answer always seems to be "maybe next week". They don't want to make time, they don't want to do the actual work10 -
When I started my office job in the '70's, finding time to exercise was not such a big deal to most people like me. Days in the office back then were filled with carrying heavy binders, going to and from filing cabinets and carrying folders and other paperwork, lugging around large volumes of mail,and getting out of your desk to visit a coworker or attend a meeting because email was still science fiction. I imagine most other professions had similar physical demands before modern innovations. As I recall, hours of extra physical activity was largely the domain of competitive athletes. Look how far we've come.1
-
I have plenty of time to exercise. My issue is massive fatigue levels caused by a traumatic brain injury. I'm like in that sci fi story where one third the population slows down in time, one third stays on normal time, and one third goes on speed up time. I'm in the slow time. Everything takes me longer to do because I'm in slow motion and it feels like I'm expending more energy to do the simple things. I have never experienced this before and believe me, tried to push through it...result...loss of consciousness/fainting dead away..I have new scars to prove it. So I just do what I can when I can. I'll go for long rambles through the countryside and I'm getting back into doing yoga.2
-
No excuses here.
I'm retired, have all the time in the world and have all the lifting/cardio gear that I need at home.1 -
If some people converted "whining" time into exercise time, they would have enough training to take gold at the olympics6
-
You don't "find" time to do things that are important to you. They just are PART of your day. IMO, you "find" time to do things that aren't a priority. Washing the car isn't a priority to me, but if I "find" time, I may do it. Or not.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
4 -
Maxematics..you have indeed inspired me to do more. I walk 45 minutes every morning before work and then spend about 20 minutes strength training. Sitting here reading this post will get me up out of this desk chair here in a few minutes. I have atleast 3 hours before dark when I get home to move and here I sit. Thanks for the motivation.3
-
@walking4me2day I do most of my internet reading and phone calls while I'm walking, I'm walking right now as I'm typing this. Kills 2 birds with one stone.
I very often save the big 30+ page mfp threads for when I'm walking. It makes the time fly and i don't get bored!3 -
I'm considering retooling my daily schedule to make time to work out in the AM because my arthritis is too burdensome by the time I get home from work. Sometimes you have to do something fairly drastic like that. It is hard nowadays especially if you work more than one job. I think it's a matter of evaluating where all your time goes and when and being creative about it.2
-
Christine_72 wrote: »@walking4me2day I do most of my internet reading and phone calls while I'm walking, I'm walking right now as I'm typing this. Kills 2 birds with one stone.
I very often save the big 30+ page mfp threads for when I'm walking. It makes the time fly and i don't get bored!
Ditto! I also do my online job.1 -
For me, it's not about finding time, it's about having to take that time away from other things. I had hoped to get back to practicing piano this summer. Maybe do some writing. Those are things I haven't had time for because I've spent it at work or play practice, visiting family or friends, or meal prepping or at the gym. There's not enough time for everything.3
-
I make time without exception. But I'm lucky whereas I have a job that keeps me somewhat active, I walk to the train for my commute, I walk to the store because I don't have a car. I live across the street from the park and enjoy running 5 days per week. I can't stand sitting still except for when I'm eating. I eat and maintain at 2200-2400 per day. 31, F, 119lbs, 5'4". Most days I end up with 18K-20K steps plus whatever swimming and biking I may choose to do that day.
I personally spend zero time food prepping. I eat frozen dinners, cereal, PB&J, etc or I eat out/get take out. I travel 15 days a month for work and eat a lot of prepackaged food or I eat out on those days. I rely on a very active lifestyle, making time for exercise even when I'm tired, and a firm belief in everything in moderation and CICO.2 -
clicketykeys wrote: »For me, it's not about finding time, it's about having to take that time away from other things. I had hoped to get back to practicing piano this summer. Maybe do some writing. Those are things I haven't had time for because I've spent it at work or play practice, visiting family or friends, or meal prepping or at the gym. There's not enough time for everything.
This is definitely true. I'm lucky that most of my friends love hiking, so we can use the same block of time to socialize, experience natural beauty, and gay some exercise.2 -
NorthCascades wrote: »clicketykeys wrote: »For me, it's not about finding time, it's about having to take that time away from other things. I had hoped to get back to practicing piano this summer. Maybe do some writing. Those are things I haven't had time for because I've spent it at work or play practice, visiting family or friends, or meal prepping or at the gym. There's not enough time for everything.
This is definitely true. I'm lucky that most of my friends love hiking, so we can use the same block of time to socialize, experience natural beauty, and gay some exercise.
...And you all have a gay ol time
2 -
Packerjohn wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »Again, no one here is saying they cannot find time to do 30 minutes a day, are they?
Not sure, there are 6 pages of comments. However in virtually every study done on the topic, lack of time/busy schedule is on of the top reasons people give as to why they don't exercise.
My point is there is a lot of sedentary/exclusive screen time going on the in US and the not exercising is a choice, not a lack of time for many.
2 -
Christine_72 wrote: »@walking4me2day I do most of my internet reading and phone calls while I'm walking, I'm walking right now as I'm typing this. Kills 2 birds with one stone.
I very often save the big 30+ page mfp threads for when I'm walking. It makes the time fly and i don't get bored!
@Christine_72 I do the same thing! Except the workout is weight-lifting and I use the loooong threads to help me get adequate rest in between sets. Otherwise I rush them.1 -
Christine_72 wrote: »@walking4me2day I do most of my internet reading and phone calls while I'm walking, I'm walking right now as I'm typing this. Kills 2 birds with one stone.
I very often save the big 30+ page mfp threads for when I'm walking. It makes the time fly and i don't get bored!
@Christine_72 I do the same thing! Except the workout is weight-lifting and I use the loooong threads to help me get adequate rest in between sets. Otherwise I rush them.
Haha Good thinking!
I often skim read the long threads when I'm sitting infront of the computer, but i read every post when I'm walking, as i make a deal with myself that i can't stop until I've read the entiiiirrre thread.. It's a decision I've regretted a few times when I'm hanging for that last page to come, and then realise there's still 10 more to go
People here talk too much
4 -
Christine_72 wrote: »
People here talk too much
Says the woman with 14,000 + posts to her name!5 -
Christine_72 wrote: »
People here talk too much
Says the woman with 14,000 + posts to her name!
Bahaha Touche' :laugh:
2
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.4K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 388 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.2K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 917 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions