Is anybody here trying to lose weight via keto? I'm finding it hard to go a whole day...
KingPeasant
Posts: 12 Member
...without giving in to my cravings. Does or did anybody have any problems getting started on keto? I need to lose about 100lbs (I'm 6'2", 21m, and 290lbs(.
1
Replies
-
If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?19
-
I did keto about a month ago for three weeks and lost 20lbs in water weight. I cheated for one day and have struggled to get back on since then!MichelleSilverleaf wrote: »If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?
1 -
join the Keto group, they are a wealth of ideas and help. I have been doing Keto for over 6 months now and have lost 16kg. YES it is hard to start and sometimes continue but so is any new way of eating after years of food abuse.9
-
ThinManRuning wrote: »join the Keto group, they are a wealth of ideas and help. I have been doing Keto for over 6 months now and have lost 16kg. YES it is hard to start and sometimes continue but so is any new way of eating after years of food abuse.
I'm 21 y/o and have been abusing food for all those years. I'm glad to hear it's not just me who found it a bit of a struggle with keto. I'll join the group on here. Hopefully, I can get back on the wagon for longer than 24 hours.2 -
i look forward to see you there... http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/1143-keto1
-
There is nothing wrong with doing keto if it is something that suits you and helps you control the calories you eat and seems to you like it may be a way of eating you will enjoy sticking to longer term.
For longer than you've been alive I did not bother to try to control my weight because only people on keto lose weight, and every single one of them (who I had met to that point of time) sooner or later run into your current problem... and didn't go back on keto till after they regained all the weight they had lost.
It really doesn't sound like keto is THAT exciting for you. Which would make me question you choosing it as your future way of eating.
Are you aware that you can pretty much eat anything you want* and still lose weight? "All" you have to do is eat less calories than you burn for a long enough period of time!
*Most people who successfully eat "anything" they want discover that this involves a number of trade offs and choices in order to achieve satiation and optimum satisfaction within their caloric budget. "Anything" does not mean "everything", nor does it mean "all the time". Even "healthy eating" is good from time to time. Maybe even a lot of the time!
It is never too early to start exploring and learning to eat the way you plan to continue to eat in order to maintain your weight loss once you've achieved it.17 -
KingPeasant wrote: »...without giving in to my cravings. Does or did anybody have any problems getting started on keto? I need to lose about 100lbs (I'm 6'2", 21m, and 290lbs(.
is there a medical reason you need to cut carbs?4 -
KingPeasant wrote: »
I did keto about a month ago for three weeks and lost 20lbs in water weight. I cheated for one day and have struggled to get back on since then!MichelleSilverleaf wrote: »If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?
20lbs in 3 weeks?
I assume about half of that was water weight. That still leaves you with more than 3lbs loss per week. The problem might not be keto or not keto (if it suits you there's nothing wrong with it). You might simply have been under-eating so badly that you eventually couldn't sustain it anymore.
How many calories were you eating per day on average? Were you tracking your calories to make sure you were feeding your body a suitable amount?
Even at my heaviest (115kg (roughly 250lbs), as a 170cm female), I couldn't sustain more than 1lbs loss per week. Mentally I couldn't deal with more. So it's taking me longer, but after a year of maintaining a 35kg loss, I feel confident that I will maintain that loss and any future loss I will have.
Here's how I approached weightloss this time around:
1. tracked everything I ate for a week.
2. Analyzed what I ate and figured where I could cut without feeling deprived (serving sizes was a huge problem with me. I would eat 2-3 servings of pasta as 1 meal.)
3. After a month of eating to lose 1lbs a week and having achieved that, I rechecked what I was eating to see if there was anything I could change to increase satiety (more protein, moderate amounts of starchy vegetables and grains, and less fat. I don't feel full on fats. More veggies and less fruits. Desserts less often, but still regularly).
4. Then I kept going again. Over and over and over again until I had reached my first goal (80kg).
5. Then I took a year to learn how to maintain that weight. Sometimes more, sometimes less successful. A stint on Corticosteroids did a number on my weight due to water weight and near uncontrollable hunger attacks. I stuck with the numbers I knew worked for me and I'm nearly back to the 80kg goal I had set for myself.
6. Next year, I'll attack the next 5 kg. If I'm not struggling too much because of the meds (chronic health problems, so chances are high I'll be back on those sometimes next year), I might even try for a healthy BMI (72kg and less).
I'm not aiming to be perfect (whether with my diet nor with exercising). I'm simply striving to be better than yesterday.
So figure out what you like to eat and what serving sizes are appropriate for you. Then be consistent at eating those serving sizes.9 -
ladyreva78 wrote: »KingPeasant wrote: »
I did keto about a month ago for three weeks and lost 20lbs in water weight. I cheated for one day and have struggled to get back on since then!MichelleSilverleaf wrote: »If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?
20lbs in 3 months?
3 weeks1 -
TavistockToad wrote: »ladyreva78 wrote: »KingPeasant wrote: »
I did keto about a month ago for three weeks and lost 20lbs in water weight. I cheated for one day and have struggled to get back on since then!MichelleSilverleaf wrote: »If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?
20lbs in 3 months?
3 weeks
Thank you for catching that... I shouldn't be typing early in the morning before coffee
0 -
Sorry, but you are making mistake! You are over the optimal weight for Keto and you won't get results that you wish.
Keto is too difficult for newbies and you can harm himself.
You should start Keto when amount of body fat will be about 15%.30 -
OK... on behalf of Keto... what the **kitten** are you drinking?Sorry, but you are making mistake! You are over the optimal weight for Keto and you won't get results that you wish.
Keto is too difficult for newbies and you can harm himself.
You should start Keto when amount of body fat will be about 15%.
err, excuse me, forgive me, err, @Zobakka , kindly do point out your sources for this insightful information! Please and thank you?
10 -
General hints....
#1
Smart people make the process as easy as possible rather than hard as possible - choose an eating style or method of creating a deficit that you enjoy (or dislike the least!). Invest some time in really thinking and planning ahead rather than stumble into something. A day, a week, a month of adherence is an irrelevance to you with the amount you need to lose.
#2
Starting a diet is easy, anyone can do that with a tiny bit of motivation - it's sticking to it for the required duration that is difficult (commitment). #1 helps reduce the effort/pain of that commitment.
#3
Think ahead how you will deal with setbacks or wobbles. If you can maintain weight rather than start to regain during a time when your resolve is low it will make a huge difference.
Best of luck (but don't rely on luck!).14 -
Sorry, but you are making mistake! You are over the optimal weight for Keto and you won't get results that you wish.
Keto is too difficult for newbies and you can harm himself.
You should start Keto when amount of body fat will be about 15%.
so you're saying that women shouldn't do Keto, given that few women are 15% bodyfat?10 -
Sorry, but you are making mistake! You are over the optimal weight for Keto and you won't get results that you wish.
Keto is too difficult for newbies and you can harm himself.
You should start Keto when amount of body fat will be about 15%.
Wait, what?
I'm no fan of keto but it is just a way of eating less calories and be done at any size.
8 -
err, excuse me, forgive me, err, @Zobakka , kindly do point out your sources for this insightful information! Please and thank you?
My sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly. There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
16 -
I personally would never do keto. I like my carbs too much and find them more filling than fat. In fact most foods high in fat are not enjoyable for me. Except nuts. I love nuts.
Saying that, there are some that have brilliant success with this diet. They enjoy the food, find it satiates them more than a higher carb diet, reduces their craving and know they can stick with it long term because it works well for them. If you don't have medical issues which would benefit from a keto diet and don't enjoy it, why would you stick with it?
The only people that have long term success are those that choose an eating plan they can continue for the rest of their lives. This is not a short journey where you can resume normal eating habits once you have reached your goal. It is a change of lifestyle that you have to stick with for the rest of your life if you want to maintain your goal weight long term.7 -
FIFYMy sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly.
And FIFY, again! (Your translation is NOT what @RuNaRoUnDaFiEld actually said)There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
6 -
err, excuse me, forgive me, err, @Zobakka , kindly do point out your sources for this insightful information! Please and thank you?
My sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly. There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
so you were under 15% bodyfat wth 50lbs to lose? what are your stats?8 -
err, excuse me, forgive me, err, @Zobakka , kindly do point out your sources for this insightful information! Please and thank you?
My sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly. There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
Where did I say there are more effective ways?
All WOE will be as effective as the next if the CICO are the same long term.4 -
FIFYMy sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly.
And FIFY, again! (Your translation is NOT what @RuNaRoUnDaFiEld actually said)There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
Thanks for the tag.0 -
And FIFY, again! (Your translation is NOT what @RuNaRoUnDaFiEld actually said)RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: »Where did I say there are more effective ways?
All WOE will be as effective as the next if the CICO are the same long term.
I'm sorry, guys. English is not my native language and I have some "lost in translation"...
3 -
TavistockToad wrote: »so you were under 15% bodyfat wth 50lbs to lose? what are your stats?
Text is in Russian, but there are some photo below
https://vk.com/id262078216?w=wall262078216_2251/all
4 -
TavistockToad wrote: »so you were under 15% bodyfat wth 50lbs to lose? what are your stats?
Text is in Russian, but there are some photo below
https://vk.com/id262078216?w=wall262078216_2251/all
I don't speak Russian...2 -
Don't know what the text says BUT, your transformation is impressive! Congratulations!Text is in Russian, but there are some photo below
https://vk.com/id262078216?w=wall262078216_2251/all3 -
KingPeasant wrote: »
I did keto about a month ago for three weeks and lost 20lbs in water weight. I cheated for one day and have struggled to get back on since then!MichelleSilverleaf wrote: »If keto is hard to stick to, then perhaps it's not for you. There's nothing magical about keto, it's just another way to do a calorie deficit. How long have you been at keto?
Have you considered making smaller changes as opposed to one big change. Maybe start with getting calories under control while working in foods you like and maybe focusing on whole foods 90% of the time. Then maybe focusing on macros later? What I have found in my time here, is that people make so many changes as once, that they struggle to stick with things.
Alternatively, maybe start by going lower carb and slowly decreasing carb intake as you go.4 -
err, excuse me, forgive me, err, @Zobakka , kindly do point out your sources for this insightful information! Please and thank you?
My sources are my experience that helped me lost nearly 50 lbs in 5 months. I think use Keto with 290 lbs is as use a cannon to kill a fly. There are more effective ways, as RuNaRoUnDaFiEld said.
Using Keto or low carb when you are morbidly obese is one of the better times as insulin resistance increases with obesity. If anything, it's better to come off the more lean you get because you are more insulin sensitive and less likely for your body to process carbs.8 -
Yeah , I been on it for a bit, getting more confused about it (and dieting in general).0
-
I found getting started with keto, or even just with cutting back, was the hardest part. Easing into it might be the easiest but you'll need to make the jump at some point.
I do doubt you list 20lbs of water weight. Maybe 10lbs of water but 20? That other 10lbs was probably fat. Congrats.1 -
ClockWorKitten wrote: »Yeah , I been on it for a bit, getting more confused about it (and dieting in general).
The main thing to be concerned about is calories as that drives weight loss and gain. Outside of that increases to protein is beneficial from a metabolic and energetic standpoint, and carbs and fats can be whatever.
For keto, carbs should be sub 50g and sodium 3000 to 5000mg +.
Ultimately, there is no more important factor than finding a sustainable diet that allows you to addressed energy balance (CICO). Keto and low carb can be beneficial for those with certain medical conditions and those who are satiated by fat. If you are a volume eater and more insulin sensitive, than a lower fat diet tends to prevail.3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions