Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Can you gain fat while in ketosis?
Options
Replies
-
60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Congratulations - and your success is well-documented in your thread about your transformation! Further proof that the insulin obesity theory is an outright lie, or your transformation wouldn't have been possible. Your results and photos tell the story.14 -
60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol
Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
26 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
You do realize this is a split thread and is tangent to the OP - a separate thread now in the debate forum - because it’s no longer relevant to the original post?8 -
jseams1234 wrote: »
You do realize this is a split thread and is tangent to the OP - a separate thread now in the debate forum - because it’s no longer relevant to the original post?
Yes I do but the comment I quoted the other posted as saying has nothing to do whatsoever with the original question. Its a pattern that is so common all over the forum of any questions asked of something to do with keto, anyone against it spews all kinds of unrelated nonsense in to de rail from the original posted questions. Such a common occurrence we discuss it in our other groups cause we see the main boards turning into a laughing stock.17 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
You're saying someone is going to store sugar as fat if they're in a deficit just because they don't work out?9 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »PaulChasinDreams wrote: »60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
You're saying someone is going to store sugar as fat if they're in a deficit just because they don't work out?
And more de railing. Keep er going!
15 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »livingleanlivingclean wrote: »PaulChasinDreams wrote: »60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
You're saying someone is going to store sugar as fat if they're in a deficit just because they don't work out?
And more de railing. Keep er going!
I'm just asking for clarification?10 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »60% carbs including sugar....so...much...sugar and losing fat and am almost in my best shape yet.
Lol Anybody can burn glucose if they are working out. That has nothing to do with fat storage from over consuming sugar when not working out. Basic old common knowledge.
So another thread de railed again i see... hmmm is there a pattern?
Let's see "Can you gain fat while in Ketosis" a question caused by someone who said you can only lose fat when you're in Ketosis. Someone answers they eat a ton of carbs and lost fat just fine.
I only see one person trying to derail the thread...16 -
Fail. Eating tons of sugar and working out is not being in ketosis so claiming to lose fat while eating sugar and working out is completely 100% irrelevant to what the OP posted. But nice try and keep the de railing going! Just proving my point again. Feel so bad for people who want real help with the actual questions they ask then have to read through so much needless junk causing so many threads to get de railed and shut down. I've never seen a forum where this happens to as much as it does here. Very sad in deed and the reasons are obvious why sub forum needed to be formed where rational peaceful talks go on. Carry on though I'm sure some are entertained by the antics.stevencloser wrote: »
Let's see "Can you gain fat while in Ketosis" a question caused by someone who said you can only lose fat when you're in Ketosis. Someone answers they eat a ton of carbs and lost fat just fine.
I only see one person trying to derail the thread...
19 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »
Fail. Eating tons of sugar and working out is not being in ketosis so claiming to lose fat while eating sugar and working out is completely 100% irrelevant to what the OP posted. But nice try and keep the de railing going! Just proving my point again. Feel so bad for people who want real help with the actual questions they ask then have to read through so much needless junk causing so many threads to get de railed and shut down. I've never seen a forum where this happens to as much as it does here. Very sad in deed and the reasons are obvious why sub forum needed to be formed where rational peaceful talks go on. Carry on though I'm sure some are entertained by the antics.stevencloser wrote: »
Let's see "Can you gain fat while in Ketosis" a question caused by someone who said you can only lose fat when you're in Ketosis. Someone answers they eat a ton of carbs and lost fat just fine.
I only see one person trying to derail the thread...
There is no original post. There is a awful lot of waffle about high insulin and fat storage though. A comment about eating sugar but still losing fat is completely relevant to the debate.
Can you please answer my question, I'm genuinely interested in your response.14 -
PaulChasinDreams wrote: »
Fail. Eating tons of sugar and working out is not being in ketosis so claiming to lose fat while eating sugar and working out is completely 100% irrelevant to what the OP posted. But nice try and keep the de railing going! Just proving my point again. Feel so bad for people who want real help with the actual questions they ask then have to read through so much needless junk causing so many threads to get de railed and shut down. I've never seen a forum where this happens to as much as it does here. Very sad in deed and the reasons are obvious why sub forum needed to be formed where rational peaceful talks go on. Carry on though I'm sure some are entertained by the antics.stevencloser wrote: »
Let's see "Can you gain fat while in Ketosis" a question caused by someone who said you can only lose fat when you're in Ketosis. Someone answers they eat a ton of carbs and lost fat just fine.
I only see one person trying to derail the thread...
Can you read?
This was caused by a guy who said you literally 100% "no ifs and buts" can not lose weight if you're not in ketosis, the only way to lose weight is ketosis and it's literally impossible to get fat on ketosis.
There is one person who came into this thread, not knowing anything about it, throwing a hissy fit and derailing the thread. I'm talking with him right now.10 -
stevencloser wrote: »Can you read?
This was caused by a guy who said you literally 100% "no ifs and buts" can not lose weight if you're not in ketosis, the only way to lose weight is ketosis and it's literally impossible to get fat on ketosis.
There is one person who came into this thread, not knowing anything about it, throwing a hissy fit and derailing the thread. I'm talking with him right now.
Then you're looking in the mirror cause you can't read and or understand that keto has NOTHING TO DO WITH EATING TONS OF SUGAR WHILE WORKING OUT LIKE THE POSTER SAID WHOM I QUOTED. IS THAT BIG ENOUGH WRITING FOR YOU TO UNDERSTAND NOW?
Beautiful keep the derailing going. We all know the regulars who are good at that.21 -
Closed for review.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.4K Getting Started
- 259.6K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 387 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.2K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 913 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions