Calories and carbs

Chic_geek31
Chic_geek31 Posts: 34 Member
edited December 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
If weight lost is truly calories in vs calories out. Why are we told to limit carbs and sugars to avoid gaining weight?

I just watched a video of a doctor saying that eating sugar/carbs causes the body to store fat and use sugar for energy.
«1

Replies

  • lemurcat2
    lemurcat2 Posts: 7,887 Member
    edited May 2019
    Personally, carbs and sugar cause me to overeat. My insulin levels will spike after eating a cliff bar or a sugary yogurt. Ultimately, those foods will trigger me to eat more and send me over my calorie goal for the day.
    Everyone is different of course but I try and eat nutrient dense foods and a healthy balanced diet for that reason alone.
    Weight loss IS all about calories but certain foods will put you over your calorie limit or trigger you to over eat.

    I also try to eat a nutrient dense diet, and I tend to limit lower nutrient/high cal foods (which if dessert foods tend to have lots of added sugar, as well as fat), but I would never suggest that "carbs and sugar" = less nutrient dense foods or would not be in a nutrient dense diet.

    Food that I eat that contribute carbs and sugar (sugar being just a subset of carbs) include vegetables, fruit, beans and lentils, potatoes and sweet potatoes, pulses like peas, whole grains, etc. I find all the foods I listed quite filling, and they certainly don't cause me to overeat.

    I think a nutritious diet should also contain good sources of protein and healthy fats, of course (some of which come with carbs, like nuts and olives and avocados for fats, and beans and lentils and chickpeas and tofu or tempeh, etc., for protein, and some of which come with both fats and protein, like plain greek yogurt (I don't consider yogurt a food that causes me to overeat!)).

    Generic advice like "to lose weight or avoid gaining you must limit carbs and sugar" is IMO not very informative or helpful or accurate, as weight loss depends on calories and nutrition is about the overall diet and not everyone tends to overeat carbs, especially without fat included.
  • katechris65
    katechris65 Posts: 30 Member
    lemurcat2 wrote: »
    Personally, carbs and sugar cause me to overeat. My insulin levels will spike after eating a cliff bar or a sugary yogurt. Ultimately, those foods will trigger me to eat more and send me over my calorie goal for the day.
    Everyone is different of course but I try and eat nutrient dense foods and a healthy balanced diet for that reason alone.
    Weight loss IS all about calories but certain foods will put you over your calorie limit or trigger you to over eat.

    I also try to eat a nutrient dense diet, and I tend to limit lower nutrient/high cal foods (which if dessert foods tend to have lots of added sugar, as well as fat), but I would never suggest that "carbs and sugar" = less nutrient dense foods or would not be in a nutrient dense diet.

    Food that I eat that contribute carbs and sugar (sugar being just a subset of carbs) include vegetables, fruit, beans and lentils, potatoes and sweet potatoes, pulses like peas, whole grains, etc. I find all the foods I listed quite filling, and they certainly don't cause me to overeat.

    I think a nutritious diet should also contain good sources of protein and healthy fats, of course (some of which come with carbs, like nuts and olives and avocados for fats, and beans and lentils and chickpeas and tofu or tempeh, etc., for protein, and some of which come with both fats and protein, like plain greek yogurt (I don't consider yogurt a food that causes me to overeat!)).

    Generic advice like "to lose weight or avoid gaining you must limit carbs and sugar" is IMO not very informative or helpful or accurate, as weight loss depends on calories and nutrition is about the overall diet and not everyone tends to overeat carbs, especially without fat included.

    Umm that is not at all what I was trying to convey. I know if I could eat 1200 calories worth of sugary carbs I would lose weight--im just saying personally, those are triggers that cause me to overeat. I do eat high fiber carbs everyday along with fats-- as I said, its always good to balance.
    I would down a bag of hershey kisses right here and now if it fit my calorie budget.
    And I didnt mean plain greek yogurt (i eat lots of that as well) I said sugary yogurts like chobani flips (ugh theyre so good)
  • JRsLateInLifeMom
    JRsLateInLifeMom Posts: 2,275 Member
    edited May 2019
    Tall isn’t obese I tell them I got a app that does measurements it’s what I go by instead of the Doctors.I use dieticians when needed they say he’s fine just tall kid.
    Here’s Shaq measurements
    My son age 2yrs
    Son at 1yr last pic
  • JRsLateInLifeMom
    JRsLateInLifeMom Posts: 2,275 Member
    So true Lynn so true lol his paws are huge lol.
    His sisters a tiny 5”2 gal 112lbs soak y wet with a sz 6 foot .
    He’s catching up fast with her lol. Funny part is everyone laughing at how much padding my home has but he trips over his feet so much it’s the best option you know the saying bigger they are harder they fall!
    North have you seen that JimmyKimmel guys episode where they ask people if they think we should save homosapiens from extinction got a lot of No’s lol. Yeah doing all the homework I can my great grandpa was 8ft tall man. Got a cousin who texts with me a lot his mama tries to remember stuff for me (For 90 she has a great memory) he’s 7ft tall his wife too. Trying to get family members measurements to go by best I can to run stuff past them problem is we’re all old now so things like BMI y starvation diets are well not in our data base sort to say lol. Cousin who’s actually a 3rd cousin y me find apps together for everything we need from grocery lists to weight loss he opted for Ketos but I got a headache on it had to stop. The DMV sent me their manual for employees for the little one so I know the rules to laws they measured him for us think he’ll outgrow his car seat super early. We’re on our 4th car seat now the insurance company sent us 2 more that are bigger for older kids to grow into only charged $35 each or so. We bought a taller person home but he can still reach lol so not easy to put stuff out of reach. We buy taller everything we can so he can’t reach the fridge handles that open without ease to get into the pickle jars lol.Opens easy from the inside only. All I do is research praise God it’s out there but not going by the latest fads.Old tried and true when I can .
    https://youtu.be/WfEqAolZFB0
  • JRsLateInLifeMom
    JRsLateInLifeMom Posts: 2,275 Member
    https://www.texaschildrens.org/departments/weight-management-obesity/body-mass-index-bmi
    Hospitals in Texas are bad about using it to Kids Doctors y schools.
    I think Texas needs to stop using BMI on kids,especially babies!
    My son they say is over 100% found a newer app that includes his head to body measurements says he’s 85% for BMI
  • JRsLateInLifeMom
    JRsLateInLifeMom Posts: 2,275 Member
    I thought the wheat or whole wheat breads /pastas are supposed to be healthy their on the type2 diabetic lists even. My gastronologist says stay away from white bread he made me switch. Lol he was eating McDonald’s burger y fries while he added no fried foods lol. You bet I made him give me some fries.
This discussion has been closed.