Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.

The sugar problem

2»

Replies

  • Ironandwine69
    Ironandwine69 Posts: 2,432 Member
    Yeah okay
  • This content has been removed.
  • Lenala13
    Lenala13 Posts: 155 Member
    OooohToast wrote: »
    Okaaaaaay - here we go !

    1. Both the WHO and the NHS recommend limiting ADDED sugar in anyones diet. From the NHS, the limit recommended is 30g per day for everyone over the age of 11 without any other criteria.That excludes fruit and veg but includes fruit juices.
    2. Sugar has limited / if any nutritional value - this does not detract from the fact that its yummy.
    3. T2 diabetes is considered the most signficant health crisis in the UK currently and it doesnt turn up overnight. Yes it as a lot to do with fat, internally and externally but it doesnt happen in a sugarless void. Sugar (note not carbs) consumption has a correlation to the development of T2 diabetes.
    4. Dentists would love us all to eat less - the first person to notice when I dropped my added sugar consumption down was my dentist (appreciate us Brits have a bad rep on the teeth front in general !).

    I do think we have quite the regional difference when it comes to sugar with the US side of the board seeing it as less of an issue. Thats not a criticism or a judgement and I hope we can respect our differences on this.

    I think it would have been helpful for the OP to distinguish between added sugar and all sugar, since it is not clear at all they were referring only to added sugar in the original post.

    I wholeheartedly agree with you on all your points from a health and nutrition perspective (and I'm on the US side!), but your post is a far more nuanced and reasonable position than OP's "calories don't matter if you're getting more than 30+ grams of sugar". Yes, calories do matter when it comes to weight loss, and limiting added sugar does matter when it comes to a nutritious and healthy diet. You can certainly lose weight on a Twinkie and junk food diet by limiting calories and not caring what the sugar is....but I don't think anyone would argue that is nutritious or healthy. Words matter. :)
  • lemurcat2
    lemurcat2 Posts: 7,885 Member
    edited June 2019
    Lenala13 wrote: »
    OooohToast wrote: »
    Okaaaaaay - here we go !

    1. Both the WHO and the NHS recommend limiting ADDED sugar in anyones diet. From the NHS, the limit recommended is 30g per day for everyone over the age of 11 without any other criteria.That excludes fruit and veg but includes fruit juices.
    2. Sugar has limited / if any nutritional value - this does not detract from the fact that its yummy.
    3. T2 diabetes is considered the most signficant health crisis in the UK currently and it doesnt turn up overnight. Yes it as a lot to do with fat, internally and externally but it doesnt happen in a sugarless void. Sugar (note not carbs) consumption has a correlation to the development of T2 diabetes.
    4. Dentists would love us all to eat less - the first person to notice when I dropped my added sugar consumption down was my dentist (appreciate us Brits have a bad rep on the teeth front in general !).

    I do think we have quite the regional difference when it comes to sugar with the US side of the board seeing it as less of an issue. Thats not a criticism or a judgement and I hope we can respect our differences on this.

    I think it would have been helpful for the OP to distinguish between added sugar and all sugar, since it is not clear at all they were referring only to added sugar in the original post.

    I don't think OP was at all limiting the post to added sugar, and the later poster arguing in favor of OP's post was talking about all sugar and expanded it to carbs. [Edit: oops, I guess that was the other identical thread OP started. Can't blame me for getting confused.]

    Many of us who responded specifically discussed eating veg and fruit, of course, as one reason the advice was bad, so I don't understand how one could read the discussion as us all saying "added sugar is great in any numbers." People did, of course, disagree with specific points made by OP, so if the newer poster thinks those are incorrect, it would be helpful to address specific incorrect points and not to accuse us (all of us here in the US who responded, and maybe the Canadians too, don't know about the UK responders) of saying things we did not.
  • stinkyfungus
    stinkyfungus Posts: 11 Member
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

  • Theoldguy1
    Theoldguy1 Posts: 2,496 Member
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?
  • J72FIT
    J72FIT Posts: 6,002 Member
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    What are you proposing will happen?

  • psychod787
    psychod787 Posts: 4,099 Member
    SUGAR BAD! ...
    <=== realizes its melon season in Florida... Nope... sugars good! That said, I do think that added sugar inside a highly palatable item might be problematic for SOME people who might then over consume calories COULD be an issue. I tend to get almost all my sugar from fruits and veggies.
  • stinkyfungus
    stinkyfungus Posts: 11 Member
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?

    I know right? It is pretty counter intuitive.

    IDGAS about the organic label, I drink it because

    1. It actually tastes good. Kinda like guava, and is kinda light and crisp on the palette. Not like fruity mystery syrup typical of other drinks.
    2. The sweetener in it is actual cane sugar (not HF corn syrup, not fake sweetners)
    3. the caffeine in it is taken from green coffee beans.
    4. The ingredient list is surprisingly short... and simple. see below.

    Ingredients:
    Carbonated water, organic cane sugar, citric acid,organic caffeine from green coffee beans, natural flavors, organic guarnara seed extract.

    So yeah... I’m not an organic foods nut or anything. Could care less really - but the product is among the best of a bad lot IMHO.




  • psychod787
    psychod787 Posts: 4,099 Member
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?

    I know right? It is pretty counter intuitive.

    IDGAS about the organic label, I drink it because

    1. It actually tastes good. Kinda like guava, and is kinda light and crisp on the palette. Not like fruity mystery syrup typical of other drinks.
    2. The sweetener in it is actual cane sugar (not HF corn syrup, not fake sweetners)
    3. the caffeine in it is taken from green coffee beans.
    4. The ingredient list is surprisingly short... and simple. see below.

    Ingredients:
    Carbonated water, organic cane sugar, citric acid,organic caffeine from green coffee beans, natural flavors, organic guarnara seed extract.

    So yeah... I’m not an organic foods nut or anything. Could care less really - but the product is among the best of a bad lot IMHO.




    Yeah dung is organic too...
  • stinkyfungus
    stinkyfungus Posts: 11 Member
    psychod787 wrote: »
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    Tandyman23 wrote: »
    Make sure to closely monitor sugar intake even if you are watching calorie intake. The effect sugar has on insulin level and fat isnt correlated with the amount of calories you are consuming. I personally try not to exceed 10g of sugar a day if that. Counting calories means absolutely nothing if you are still consuming 30g+ of sugar a day.

    Tell that to the 108 lbs I lost.

    And the 84 pounds I’ve lost thus far. (25 to go)

    46 grams of sugar every morning in the form of one can of rockstar organic energy.

    An average over all deficit of 2k cal a day due to exercise let’s you do all sorts of supposedly “bad” things... and still melt fat like an ice cube under a hot faucet.

    Great on the weight loss but about spit out my breakfast laughing when I read this, Rockstar "Organic" what the *kitten*?

    I know right? It is pretty counter intuitive.

    IDGAS about the organic label, I drink it because

    1. It actually tastes good. Kinda like guava, and is kinda light and crisp on the palette. Not like fruity mystery syrup typical of other drinks.
    2. The sweetener in it is actual cane sugar (not HF corn syrup, not fake sweetners)
    3. the caffeine in it is taken from green coffee beans.
    4. The ingredient list is surprisingly short... and simple. see below.

    Ingredients:
    Carbonated water, organic cane sugar, citric acid,organic caffeine from green coffee beans, natural flavors, organic guarnara seed extract.

    So yeah... I’m not an organic foods nut or anything. Could care less really - but the product is among the best of a bad lot IMHO.




    Yeah dung is organic too...


    Your point?

    Never said the the beverage is “good” because it’s organic.
    Hell, like I said I could care less about the organic label. The whole organic thing is mostly a scam as far as I can see. (Kinda like the low/no carb thing)

    I drink it because I LIKE it.
    And considering it does not seem to be costing me anything when it comes to my workout and diet routine... I see no net harm in consuming it provided I use the fuel it provides. Which I do, and I continue to shed fat, my blood work is good, I can ride a bicycle like an animal, and I’m starting to look really good again.

    Thereby pretty much rendering the whole preposterous original premise of this post one should consume “no more than10 grams of sugar to be healthy.”

    Pretty much moot.


  • This content has been removed.