Personal safety when hiking alone
Replies
-
No! You are not overreacting. Bad men are women greatest threats.
Go on Meet Up and sign up for Hiking groups. Our group has hikes every week. It is a lot of fun when I go.
I live in a gated community and my backyard is a Preserve. I walk the open trail around the lake.
But, I won’t go into the woods alone. I WANT TO!
It is just too risky that some man might be lurking about waiting for female hikers.
It only takes a few minutes to commit an assault.
Outside the neighborhood gates it is a city park .....so, everyone has access to this wooded park.
Or, start your own Hiking Group.0 -
The reason to take a dog is not so that it will defend you it is so that you become a less desirable target. That is the same reason to take a stick with you. The goal is to avoid defending yourself at all because no matter how much training and what weapons you have you are always at risk of losing. If someone sees you with a dog that can bark and get attention and a stick that can hurt they will be much less likely to try anything.
I also agree that you are never in as much risk as the "stories" would have you believe. Most people are just trying to get through their day too and probably barely even notice you are there.
I scared a young girl not to long ago. I am a creature of habit and I like filling my gas at the same gas station and even using the same pump. So I pulled into my pump and there was a young girl on the other side. There was no one else getting gas and I guess the fact I pulled in next to her when I could have picked another pump alarmed her. She quickly headed inside looking back to make sure I wasn't following her. She started talking to the attendant and a few times she pointed at me. She stayed there until I left watching me the entire time. I would have barely known she was there if she hadn't been so obviously scared. I could have gone inside and tried to calm her but I decided that even if I told her I meant her no harm there was a chance she would think I was lying.10 -
My sister hikes a lot in CO wilderness and she carries bear spray and a knife.0
-
Not that I hike but I have a taser disguised as a hiking stick thing lol.1
-
The reason to take a dog is not so that it will defend you it is so that you become a less desirable target. That is the same reason to take a stick with you. The goal is to avoid defending yourself at all because no matter how much training and what weapons you have you are always at risk of losing. If someone sees you with a dog that can bark and get attention and a stick that can hurt they will be much less likely to try anything.
I also agree that you are never in as much risk as the "stories" would have you believe. Most people are just trying to get through their day too and probably barely even notice you are there.
I scared a young girl not to long ago. I am a creature of habit and I like filling my gas at the same gas station and even using the same pump. So I pulled into my pump and there was a young girl on the other side. There was no one else getting gas and I guess the fact I pulled in next to her when I could have picked another pump alarmed her. She quickly headed inside looking back to make sure I wasn't following her. She started talking to the attendant and a few times she pointed at me. She stayed there until I left watching me the entire time. I would have barely known she was there if she hadn't been so obviously scared. I could have gone inside and tried to calm her but I decided that even if I told her I meant her no harm there was a chance she would think I was lying.
Are people really taking their dogs on long hikes? What kind of dogs do y’all have?
For mine.....it is tiring and hot! Making them walk for a long amount of time on dirty uneven grounds, with rocks, sticks, insects, etc. Mud! I don’t do it.
Short walks are ok on better weather days.
But, when I think of a hike it is like 7+ miles. A few leisure hours of me-time walking enjoying nature.
I have a jogging stroller for my little dog.....and, she really loves that. Makes her feel like the Queen of the World!
For my larger dogs....I walk about a mile with them. Then drop them off at home and keep walking by myself.
(I do live in very hot humid weather. We also get a lot of rain. Ground is either too hot or mud)
What breeds are good for long wooded hikes?
1 -
both my collie mix and my lab mix can do 10+ walking. i bring them water and usually give them a chance to play in water too2
-
One thing I see a lot at a nature hike I take in a park...it's about three miles round trip and the first leg ends at a beach, so the dogs do quite a bit of running around at the beach in the sun. People bring their puppies. Big puppies, like labs and retrievers. These puppies tend to bonk after the first leg. There is plenty of water available but these people aren't bringing food for the dogs. The pups need food! If they haven't eaten within a half hour of their walk, bring food for them! These pups are flat-out refusing to walk, lying down on the trail, and people are trying to force them to walk.
No. Puppies need to be eased in to longer walks and should never be run. Check with the vet before exercising young animals.
And now we'll have dog arguments...gosh, I know better than to get in threads about this.9 -
MamboRumba wrote: »The reason to take a dog is not so that it will defend you it is so that you become a less desirable target. That is the same reason to take a stick with you. The goal is to avoid defending yourself at all because no matter how much training and what weapons you have you are always at risk of losing. If someone sees you with a dog that can bark and get attention and a stick that can hurt they will be much less likely to try anything.
I also agree that you are never in as much risk as the "stories" would have you believe. Most people are just trying to get through their day too and probably barely even notice you are there.
I scared a young girl not to long ago. I am a creature of habit and I like filling my gas at the same gas station and even using the same pump. So I pulled into my pump and there was a young girl on the other side. There was no one else getting gas and I guess the fact I pulled in next to her when I could have picked another pump alarmed her. She quickly headed inside looking back to make sure I wasn't following her. She started talking to the attendant and a few times she pointed at me. She stayed there until I left watching me the entire time. I would have barely known she was there if she hadn't been so obviously scared. I could have gone inside and tried to calm her but I decided that even if I told her I meant her no harm there was a chance she would think I was lying.
Are people really taking their dogs on long hikes? What kind of dogs do y’all have?
For mine.....it is tiring and hot! Making them walk for a long amount of time on dirty uneven grounds, with rocks, sticks, insects, etc. Mud! I don’t do it.
Short walks are ok on better weather days.
But, when I think of a hike it is like 7+ miles. A few leisure hours of me-time walking enjoying nature.
I have a jogging stroller for my little dog.....and, she really loves that. Makes her feel like the Queen of the World!
For my larger dogs....I walk about a mile with them. Then drop them off at home and keep walking by myself.
(I do live in very hot humid weather. We also get a lot of rain. Ground is either too hot or mud)
What breeds are good for long wooded hikes?
Probably any working dog breed; in fact, these can have behavior issues if they don't get enough exercise - cases in point my mom's Australian Shepherd and my Husky. (Sadly both deceased.)
Mom's dog would take herself for walks if Mom didn't get on it fast enough. (Mom has a hard time with the concept of leash laws and lives in a quiet neighborhood with dirt roads where she could get away with this.)
My uncle uses border collies on his working sheep farm and they need tons of exercise as well.
This is not very comprehensive, but perhaps a good starting point: https://news.orvis.com/dogs/dog-exercise-needs-by-breed3 -
MamboRumba wrote: »
Are people really taking their dogs on long hikes? What kind of dogs do y’all have?
For mine.....it is tiring and hot! Making them walk for a long amount of time on dirty uneven grounds, with rocks, sticks, insects, etc. Mud! I don’t do it.
Short walks are ok on better weather days.
But, when I think of a hike it is like 7+ miles. A few leisure hours of me-time walking enjoying nature.
I have a jogging stroller for my little dog.....and, she really loves that. Makes her feel like the Queen of the World!
For my larger dogs....I walk about a mile with them. Then drop them off at home and keep walking by myself.
(I do live in very hot humid weather. We also get a lot of rain. Ground is either too hot or mud)
What breeds are good for long wooded hikes?
I have an 11 year old Papillon who did a 9 mile hike with me last weekend. I figured since she's only about 7 pounds I would just carry her if she got tuckered out, but she happily kept up the whole way.3 -
cmriverside wrote: »One thing I see a lot at a nature hike I take in a park...it's about three miles round trip and the first leg ends at a beach, so the dogs do quite a bit of running around at the beach in the sun. People bring their puppies. Big puppies, like labs and retrievers. These puppies tend to bonk after the first leg. There is plenty of water available but these people aren't bringing food for the dogs. The pups need food! If they haven't eaten within a half hour of their walk, bring food for them! These pups are flat-out refusing to walk, lying down on the trail, and people are trying to force them to walk.
No. Puppies need to be eased in to longer walks and should never be run. Check with the vet before exercising young animals.
And now we'll have dog arguments...gosh, I know better than to get in threads about this.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 no, no arguing, please! I love it that people have dogs that can tolerate long hikes in their areas.
2 -
MamboRumba wrote: »The reason to take a dog is not so that it will defend you it is so that you become a less desirable target. That is the same reason to take a stick with you. The goal is to avoid defending yourself at all because no matter how much training and what weapons you have you are always at risk of losing. If someone sees you with a dog that can bark and get attention and a stick that can hurt they will be much less likely to try anything.
I also agree that you are never in as much risk as the "stories" would have you believe. Most people are just trying to get through their day too and probably barely even notice you are there.
I scared a young girl not to long ago. I am a creature of habit and I like filling my gas at the same gas station and even using the same pump. So I pulled into my pump and there was a young girl on the other side. There was no one else getting gas and I guess the fact I pulled in next to her when I could have picked another pump alarmed her. She quickly headed inside looking back to make sure I wasn't following her. She started talking to the attendant and a few times she pointed at me. She stayed there until I left watching me the entire time. I would have barely known she was there if she hadn't been so obviously scared. I could have gone inside and tried to calm her but I decided that even if I told her I meant her no harm there was a chance she would think I was lying.
Are people really taking their dogs on long hikes? What kind of dogs do y’all have?
For mine.....it is tiring and hot! Making them walk for a long amount of time on dirty uneven grounds, with rocks, sticks, insects, etc. Mud! I don’t do it.
Short walks are ok on better weather days.
But, when I think of a hike it is like 7+ miles. A few leisure hours of me-time walking enjoying nature.
I have a jogging stroller for my little dog.....and, she really loves that. Makes her feel like the Queen of the World!
For my larger dogs....I walk about a mile with them. Then drop them off at home and keep walking by myself.
(I do live in very hot humid weather. We also get a lot of rain. Ground is either too hot or mud)
What breeds are good for long wooded hikes?
My puppy loves the mud, uneven ground, rocks, sticks. and he routinely eats insects... so basically a normal dog. When choosing a rescue I picked a, then, 28lb dog so he is not huge for being indoors which is what my wife wanted and certainly big enough for fairly long treks. I am more careful on hot days because he is still a puppy and I bring water for him to drink but he is not a fragile animal by any definition. He will max out under 35 pounds so definitely a medium sized dog.2 -
Hi all, so My guy is a kelpie cross border collie and can go 20km easy so taking him on a hike is fine.
Other questions, any kind of spray is illegal here as are guns, knives and tasers. I do like the air horn idea though. I’m completely set up for my hikes when it comes to other ways and I don’t hike out of phone service but our phone service here is very long reaching even in the middle of nowhere. I also have an emergency app in my phone where I press a button and it connects so I can speak to them and sends lat and long directly to their system.
I cannot defense train my dog because I would then need expensive insurance as he’d be considered a weapon in many states. I also wouldn’t be able to take him with me to my job. No wild animals where I am except kangaroos and wallabies. But I do hill climb so I’m definitely covered in that area. I also have a very strong otter box case for my phone to make it harder to break if I do fall.
Some great advice here! I really appreciate it!
7 -
I have nothing to add, but I really empathize with you. I also like long hikes alone. It's so care free and restorative. Unless you feel unsafe, which really destroys the whole care-free and restorative point of the endeavor. Since your dog can handle it, that's a great solution. No special training needed. As others said, a dog introduces too many variables for a predator... even a wimpy little dog discourages someone looking for an easy target. I wish you the best and happy trails.3
-
I trail run alone and sometimes early morning so I carry a taser. There are a lot of homeless who camp in or near the state park where I run and after an incident it became necessary5
-
Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.7 -
Hannahwalksfar wrote: »Never mind. It’s illegal here.
Here in Texas Monday for the first time in several decades it will be legal to possess and carry brass knuckles. Maybe that for you there?
0 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Australia, where the homocide rate is more than 5 times lower than the US.14 -
Diatonic12 wrote: »Who absorbs all of the costs for search and rescues.
They're volunteers. It costs about $400 to get the training necessary to volunteer. Helicopters are flown and maintained by volunteers, fuel is paid for by donations from the public. (I donate regularly.) When a helicopter isn't available, the armed forces steep in and use it as an excuse for a training flight.
Charging people for rescues would be a disaster, people will avoid calling for help until they're in much worse trouble and put their rescuers at much greater risk.
https://helicopterrescue.org/7 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Haa haa. Our homicide rate is tiny in comparison to the US and here most victims are known to the perpetrator. We have crocodiles and sharks which we won't have a problem with when hiking. There are snakes which will leave you alone if you leave them alone. Kangaroos, koala, emus, wombats .... certainly don't need a spray to protect us from those. That only leaves those killer drop bears3 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Australia, where the homocide rate is more than 5 times lower than the US.
It was like that before they banned every reasonable method of self defense.
Pretty sure pepper spray and tasers aren't major contributors to the homicide rate of any country.6 -
Lillymoo01 wrote: »Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Haa haa. Our homicide rate is tiny in comparison to the US and here most victims are known to the perpetrator. We have crocodiles and sharks which we won't have a problem with when hiking. There are snakes which will leave you alone if you leave them alone. Kangaroos, koala, emus, wombats .... certainly don't need a spray to protect us from those. That only leaves those killer drop bears
Banning pepper spray and tasers aren't the cause of the low homicide rate in Australia.
For that matter, neither is the gun ban considering your homicide rate was just as low before the ban.
And you forgot the spiders. Y'all got spiders that make it reasonable to carry a bazooka. Lol9 -
Lol the internet is full of Australians poking fun at all the large and/or scary bugs, animals, and plants in Australia. There's a tough crowd in here tonight.
OP, I don't think you're over reacting. You need to do what you have to in order to feel safe and confident. I suspect the most useful strategies are the ones that make you look like a bad target, so you never get to the point where you have to defend yourself, and making sure someone knows where you are and when you expect to return. I sympathize, I have a tough time feeling safe when I'm by myself out in the world and not in a crowded place. I'll only go solo on short hikes with a quick route out, and even so I tend to bail if anything looks sketchy, probably unnecessarily.8 -
Carlos_421 wrote: »Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Australia, where the homocide rate is more than 5 times lower than the US.
It was like that before they banned every reasonable method of self defense.
Pretty sure pepper spray and tasers aren't major contributors to the homicide rate of any country.
Yeah ... no. Our homicide rates are actually at a record low but don't let a little fact get in the way of fiction.7 -
I was thinking more kidnapping or assault. Didn’t even consider being murdered. Glad it’s statistically unlikely.4
-
Carlos_421 wrote: »Lillymoo01 wrote: »Carlos_421 wrote: »Australia, where everything wants to kill you and you're not allowed to stop it. Lol
ETA: with your options for self defense being so limited, I would second the suggestions for a sturdy stick and taking the pup.
Also, walk tall and make eye contact with everyone. It portrays confidence which makes you seem less vulnerable.
Haa haa. Our homicide rate is tiny in comparison to the US and here most victims are known to the perpetrator. We have crocodiles and sharks which we won't have a problem with when hiking. There are snakes which will leave you alone if you leave them alone. Kangaroos, koala, emus, wombats .... certainly don't need a spray to protect us from those. That only leaves those killer drop bears
Banning pepper spray and tasers aren't the cause of the low homicide rate in Australia.
For that matter, neither is the gun ban considering your homicide rate was just as low before the ban.
And you forgot the spiders. Y'all got spiders that make it reasonable to carry a bazooka. Lol
Again, statistics show our homicide rates are significantly lower since bringing in tighter gun controls.8 -
I feel like this may turn into a dumpster fire regarding gun control. Please don’t.11
-
Hannah--get bear spray. If you had a gun you'd just hesitate to use it anyway, because in most cases you'd still be trying to calculate a way to get out of the situation without killing someone (especially in a remote area where emergency response to their gunshot wound would be delayed). With bear spray you put them in a nasty backwoods pickle, but you can get away and they probably won't die unless they do something stupid like walk off a cliff while they can't see anything.
I understand what lilly is saying about the stats, however your personal experience is informing your fear. We don't know the nature of the creepy experience, but one thing to remember is that even as you were at the time it happened, without training or weapon, you got away and are here to post about it now. Whatever you did worked--your existing survival skills were adequate to that particular challenge.
It makes sense to become better prepared in case the next threat is more dangerous, but take some comfort in the fact you already prevailed in one situation.
PS: now I go back and see pepper spray is illegal where you live. In a pinch a handful of dirt can be pretty effective.
Martial arts come in two broad flavors--striking and grappling. I suggest taking up a grappling type art because it will teach you ways to escape when someone grabs you. The problem with a striking art for us women is if we fail to deliver adequate power in a strike we'll just piss the attacker off. With a grappling art you keep escaping, he's expending much more energy than you are, and if you can make him fall one or more times then all his weight and energy are working against him when he hits the ground. Grappling arts include jiu jitsu, aikido, judo, etc---but you want to focus on situations where *you* stand and *they* fall, not wrestling around in holds on the ground.4 -
It's not clear that bear spray is legal in Australia. I haven't seen any indication that it is or any place that seems to sell it.
Even if it was, bear spray is NOT the same thing as pepper spray and not considered an effective defense against human attackers. It is much weaker and while it may possibly scare off a human attacker, it will not incapacitate them.2 -
We don’t have bear spray for the simple reason that we completely lack bears15
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions