Favorite Halloween Candy?

Heath Bars, well love peanut m&m's almost as much. According to a survey the candy that came up most often as a favorite was the Reeses peanut butter cups.

PAPYRUS3 wrote: »

kosseychick wrote: »

I know.... I'm crazy..lol

Now I finally know the one person in the world they make these for
Also, speaking of 'ick'...candy corn!

Team peanut butter cups and mini butterfingers

Do you still like the new butterfingers? They were my ultimate favorite before the recipe change but I don't really care for them anymore. So sad.

Smarties (the Canadian type)

PAPYRUS3 wrote: »

Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »

PAPYRUS3 wrote: »

kosseychick wrote: »

I know.... I'm crazy..lol

Now I finally know the one person in the world they make these for
Also, speaking of 'ick'...candy corn!

Team peanut butter cups and mini butterfingers

Do you still like the new butterfingers? They were my ultimate favorite before the recipe change but I don't really care for them anymore. So sad.

The last time I had a Butterfinger was probably when I was a kid. When did they change the recipe?

When nestle sold them to Ferrara this past December. Everyone is complaining if you check out reviews on a amazon, twitter, fb page, etc.

They taste a LOT different with a weird aftertaste and different peanut flavor. I am so sad because I’ve been really craving a REAL butterfinger for months. They just are not the same. Butterfingers were my favorite candy of all time. If you only had one once in awhile you may not notice though.

cheriej2042 wrote: »

pancakerunner Milk Duds is the TOP Halloween candy in 4 states in the US. That caramelly chocolately goodness!!!!
No hating on Milk Duds!

Wow I am so surprised. Kind of don’t believe that figure lol. No way most popular in my state is m&m!

pancakerunner wrote: »

Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »

PAPYRUS3 wrote: »

Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »

PAPYRUS3 wrote: »

kosseychick wrote: »

I know.... I'm crazy..lol

Now I finally know the one person in the world they make these for
Also, speaking of 'ick'...candy corn!

Team peanut butter cups and mini butterfingers

Do you still like the new butterfingers? They were my ultimate favorite before the recipe change but I don't really care for them anymore. So sad.

The last time I had a Butterfinger was probably when I was a kid. When did they change the recipe?

When nestle sold them to Ferrara this past December. Everyone is complaining if you check out reviews on a amazon, twitter, fb page, etc.

They taste a LOT different with a weird aftertaste and different peanut flavor. I am so sad because I’ve been really craving a REAL butterfinger for months. They just are not the same. Butterfingers were my favorite candy of all time. If you only had one once in awhile you may not notice though.

@Noreenmarie1234 have you ever tried 5th Avenue or Clark bars??

I have maybe years ago but don’t remember what they tasted like! I’ll have to try them this year since I’m in search of a new favorite candy bar to replace my beloved butterfingers. 😂

I don't like most Halloween candy because it is the same thing I can get year-round, just in a different packaging. BUT, I have to give a shout out to one of my favorite chocolate companies. Tony's bars are usually huge, but for Halloween they have bite size versions of their 32% milk chocolate caramel sea salt bar. It's a little pricier than the usual grocery store chocolate because Tony's mission is ethical, fair trade chocolate, and their stuff is also delicious.

Yes, I am the one who has a chocolate ratings spreadsheet.

https://tonyschocolonely.com/us/en/chocoshop/product/milk-caramel-sea-salt-32-halloween-tiny-tonys

M&Ms the favorite in NY? Boooo, they're the worst. I'll take a Heath bar or Twix, please.

seltzermint555 wrote: »

apullum wrote: »

I don't like most Halloween candy because it is the same thing I can get year-round, just in a different packaging. BUT, I have to give a shout out to one of my favorite chocolate companies. Tony's bars are usually huge, but for Halloween they have bite size versions of their 32% milk chocolate caramel sea salt bar. It's a little pricier than the usual grocery store chocolate because Tony's mission is ethical, fair trade chocolate, and their stuff is also delicious.

Yes, I am the one who has a chocolate ratings spreadsheet.

https://tonyschocolonely.com/us/en/chocoshop/product/milk-caramel-sea-salt-32-halloween-tiny-tonys

My husband LOVES Tony's but the idea of giving it out for Halloween to random children is giving me hives lol.

I didn't say anything about giving it away

apullum wrote: »

seltzermint555 wrote: »

apullum wrote: »

I don't like most Halloween candy because it is the same thing I can get year-round, just in a different packaging. BUT, I have to give a shout out to one of my favorite chocolate companies. Tony's bars are usually huge, but for Halloween they have bite size versions of their 32% milk chocolate caramel sea salt bar. It's a little pricier than the usual grocery store chocolate because Tony's mission is ethical, fair trade chocolate, and their stuff is also delicious.

Yes, I am the one who has a chocolate ratings spreadsheet.

https://tonyschocolonely.com/us/en/chocoshop/product/milk-caramel-sea-salt-32-halloween-tiny-tonys

My husband LOVES Tony's but the idea of giving it out for Halloween to random children is giving me hives lol.

I didn't say anything about giving it away

I gotcha! hehe

I just was looking at the link and thinking, "no no no! Give them the cheap stuff" haha

I LOVE candy corn! Can’t get it here.
My friend and I used to celebrate if we got a lot of Reeses Peanut Butter Cups when our trick or treating. Tootsie Roll! Can’t eat them now my teeth would all fall out!