Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.

Does your doctor comment on your weight?

1151618202125

Replies

  • crazyinspired11
    crazyinspired11 Posts: 46 Member
    I have had doctors in the past comment on my weight, my last doctor was the worst. No understanding about anything just that I was over weight. I quit going to him at the beginning on this year. The doctor I have now hasnt said anything and is very understanding
  • 33gail33
    33gail33 Posts: 1,155 Member
    nooshi713 wrote: »
    Doctors should tell pregnant women when they are gaining too quickly. No reason to get offended. I say this having recently been pregnant. My baby is 3 months old.

    Why? Does it harm the baby somehow to gain weight quickly vs slowly?

    I remember my doctor telling me the same thing (many years ago) when I gained 7 lbs one month. Made some snide comment about "eating too much ice cream" and how I'd just have a lot more to lose. But everyone I know who has been pregnant has been like that, big jumps in weight some months. I think I ended up gaining 32 lbs total, at 5' 10" and starting weight of 130. Sometimes doctors are just *kitten*.

    (He also told me my 10 lb baby was going to be "average size" - I switched doctors for the next two.)
  • sheahughes
    sheahughes Posts: 133 Member
    Many of the (Australian) pregnancy magazines I read whilst expecting in 2004 mentioned that 1) weight gain was probably inevitable (weight loss was cause for medical concern) but that minus the weight of the baby/waters etc, 5-10kgs was probably "normal" and that expectant mums might experience ligament/joint/muscle issues if weight was gained quickly or more than 10kgs was gained during the pregnancy. When you consider the strain that carrying a full-term baby plus 10 or more kilos would put on a tired, hormonal person, I can understand why doctors might be concerned about a sudden or "excessive" weight gain ("" because excessive means something different to everyone). Of course, I think doctors treating expectant people should have a better bedside manner.
    I gained about 5kg, and if it weren't for the untreated "sick-all-day-and-night" morning sickness I probably would have gained more.
  • paperpudding
    paperpudding Posts: 9,228 Member
    I think 10 kg is considered about the right amount to gain

    Of course there are other factors influencing what is best for each person - but as a rough rule of thumb.
  • 33gail33
    33gail33 Posts: 1,155 Member
    I think 10 kg is considered about the right amount to gain

    Of course there are other factors influencing what is best for each person - but as a rough rule of thumb.

    Really? That seems way too low to me - I have always heard 25 - 35 lbs is recommended amount for an average weight woman.
  • KeithBarrows
    KeithBarrows Posts: 34 Member
    Late the the thread - answering the original question:

    My cardiologist never talks about weight. Don't know about my new PCP as we won't meet until next month. Besides, what do 95% of docs KNOW about nutrition? Having several docs as friends I came to learn that nutrition is a single course during their undergrad days. One freaking course on nutrition! They! Do! Not! Know! Nutrition!

    So I stumble on with my wife and we dig in to the research. <sigh/>
  • simply_shawnmarie
    simply_shawnmarie Posts: 23 Member
    My doctor will talk about it if I bring it up. I have been losing weight and I slowly gained weight in my last pregnancy, so I got more positive comments about my weight from my doc. Also, because I was working with a nutritionist, she just said that was great.
  • paperpudding
    paperpudding Posts: 9,228 Member
    Late the the thread - answering the original question:

    My cardiologist never talks about weight. Don't know about my new PCP as we won't meet until next month. Besides, what do 95% of docs KNOW about nutrition? Having several docs as friends I came to learn that nutrition is a single course during their undergrad days. One freaking course on nutrition! They! Do! Not! Know! Nutrition!

    So I stumble on with my wife and we dig in to the research. <sigh/>


    But the question was Does your doctor comment on your weight - not Does your doctor comment on your nutrition.

    Doctors don't need to know detail about nutrition to know about healthy weight ranges.

    I would expect a doctor to refer somebody to a dietician if they need detailed nutrition advice - but that the starting point for that might be a need to reduce weight.
  • MargaretYakoda
    MargaretYakoda Posts: 2,945 Member
    Late the the thread - answering the original question:

    My cardiologist never talks about weight. Don't know about my new PCP as we won't meet until next month. Besides, what do 95% of docs KNOW about nutrition? Having several docs as friends I came to learn that nutrition is a single course during their undergrad days. One freaking course on nutrition! They! Do! Not! Know! Nutrition!

    So I stumble on with my wife and we dig in to the research. <sigh/>

    Just popping by to say hello to a fellow Scadian.
    upulw40yipcs.gif
  • My doctor hasn't said anything other than congratulations, and asked me how I did it (presumably to make sure I wasn't doing something unsafe) and was understanding when I said, "Something's wrong, because my weight loss has stopped dead in the water." (My thyroid has crapped out. Surgery to remove the tumors in January hopefully.)

    I'm sorta-kinda trying to maintain at this point because I am also going to try to get a breast reduction and they like you to be at the same weight for six months. Which I have been, thanks to thyroid. (sigh)
  • KeithBarrows
    KeithBarrows Posts: 34 Member
    edited October 2021
    Just popping by to say hello to a fellow Scadian.

    Hello m'Lady (as I have no idea your rank - yet.) Lord Iohannes at your service. Once of An Tir, then the Outlands where I became the 2nd Squire to Sir Leifr, now residing in Trimaris (Shire of Sangre del Sol). But shhh! We never told anyone we were here since we moved in 3 years ago.

  • 33gail33
    33gail33 Posts: 1,155 Member
    33gail33 wrote: »
    I think 10 kg is considered about the right amount to gain

    Of course there are other factors influencing what is best for each person - but as a rough rule of thumb.

    Really? That seems way too low to me - I have always heard 25 - 35 lbs is recommended amount for an average weight woman.


    Yes really.

    I did say 10 kg, not 10 lb.

    Which is about 22 lb.

    Slightly lower than your range but not way lower.

    Yes I did the math. :) Given that it is lower than the lowest end of the recommendation it is actually "way lower".

    At any rate not sure what area of Australia you are in but this is from the Queensland Health Department:

    Target weight gains during pregnancy:
    Pre-pregnancy BMI (kg/m2) Recommended total weight gain range (kg)
    <18.5 underweight 12.5 to 18
    18.5 to 24.9 normal weight 11.5 to 16
    25.0 to 29.9 overweight 7 to 11.5
    ≥ 30.0 obese 5 to 9

    You'll notice that my comment mentioned "average weight" woman - and the range I gave is exactly what is recommended here. Maybe you see a lot of overweight women in your practice or something so for you "average weight" is overweight? What I meant was "normal weight" or not in the under or overweight BMI range. So for those women 10 kg is below the recommendations in your country for that group.
  • Theoldguy1
    Theoldguy1 Posts: 2,486 Member
    edited October 2021
    Late the the thread - answering the original question:

    My cardiologist never talks about weight. Don't know about my new PCP as we won't meet until next month. Besides, what do 95% of docs KNOW about nutrition? Having several docs as friends I came to learn that nutrition is a single course during their undergrad days. One freaking course on nutrition! They! Do! Not! Know! Nutrition!

    So I stumble on with my wife and we dig in to the research. <sigh/>

    And the one course in nutrition the doctor gets as an undergrad is one more course than probably 98% of the population gets.

    So if they know nothing, the vast majority of the general population is really screwed regarding their own knowledge.

    P.S. I do think doctors as well as PAs, NPs, nurses, etc. should have more training in nutrition than they get.


  • KeithBarrows
    KeithBarrows Posts: 34 Member
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    P.S. I do think doctors as well as PAs, NPs, nurses, etc. should have more training in nutrition than they get.

    I cannot agree more. Unfortunately, the general attitude is to rely on Nutritionists or fake it because "I am the doctor and I *should* know this." The insurance companies have not made it any easier for the doctors or the patients. Prevention is NOT a focus. There is no $$$ in it.

  • Theoldguy1
    Theoldguy1 Posts: 2,486 Member
    Theoldguy1 wrote: »
    P.S. I do think doctors as well as PAs, NPs, nurses, etc. should have more training in nutrition than they get.

    I cannot agree more. Unfortunately, the general attitude is to rely on Nutritionists or fake it because "I am the doctor and I *should* know this." The insurance companies have not made it any easier for the doctors or the patients. Prevention is NOT a focus. There is no $$$ in it.

    Agree with lack of preventive medicine.

    Personally I don't mind if a medical professional (or really anyone for that matter) says they don't know something and suggests I consult another professional, even better if they can refer me to the appropriate person.