Would you spend $5-$7 on a fresh customizable protein shake after your workout ?

gmariani14
gmariani14 Posts: 2 Member
edited May 25 in Food and Nutrition

would you purchase a fresh shake at your local fitness center if the price was reasonable?

Replies

  • PAV8888
    PAV8888 Posts: 15,102 Member
    edited May 25

    Is that in US$? Is $5 to $7 considered reasonable these days? 😛

    Food Bank still claims that they can provide two meals for $1 CAD, which is less than US$1, by a bit.

    I'm fairly sure that when buying a package of pre made protein shakes from Costco you will end up at way less than $5 per shake.

    So, really, just as with any other convenient quick food location, it will depend on disposable income, convenience, taste, and "attraction".

    If your clients have the money and want to be seen having that special shake... you will sell shakes.

    Heck, it might even work even if your clients don't have the money--if it is scammed "marketed" "right"!🤔

    Would *I* buy one? No. But I'm also not your target client!😝

  • AdahPotatah2024
    AdahPotatah2024 Posts: 3,228 Member

    No..i might pay that much rarely for a smoothie or milkshake, but not a protein drink as iI don't like to overdo protein for kidneys sake.

  • AnnPT77
    AnnPT77 Posts: 36,546 Member

    No. I don't enjoy protein shakes at all, and can get ample protein without them, so never drink them.

    If I'm going to pay $5-7 for a post-workout beverage, I'm heading to my delightful locally-owned coffee shop for the largest possible nonfat latte, hot, no flavor. In fact, I do that a few times a week in season after rowing, with my rowing buddies: Socializing is a bonus.

    A lot of people seem to like protein shakes, though, so you might find a customer base.

  • Alatariel75
    Alatariel75 Posts: 18,994 Member

    There's probably a market for it, Boost Juice still does a roaring trade. If it was at the gym, I'm sure people would buy it, it's about the cost of a coffee. For me, no. But I can see it having customers.

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member

    when I’m done with my workout, all I’m thinking about is getting out, getting home, and getting into the shower.

    The last thing hot and sweaty me wants to do is hang out and wait for someone to make me a drink, if I were ever inclined to want a protein shake, which I’m not.

    I used to be a member of a gym that had a nice smoothie bar attached to it. I don’t ever remember seeing anyone in there or walking out with a cup in their hands. Same when I’ve visited my daughter’s gym in SoCal, and that one is absolutely slammed full every time I’ve visited.

    And of course, only members can use it. People can’t just walk in off the street so it’s a limited clientele from the get go. Better off opening one next to a gym?

  • yirara
    yirara Posts: 10,540 Member

    I spent about 7 EUR on food for 2-3 days. Thus this is no way reasonable and I would not. What does customizable mean anyway? Various added fruits? Specific amino acids?

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member

    there’s smoothie bars here in malls, shopping centers etc. I think you can either pick a pre-suggested mix, or specify what you want, including what kind of protein powder. I’ve never even been in one. I can make a great smoothie at home in minutes so why bother?

    Our yoga studio foyer used to contain a tiny smoothie bar that did smoothies and bowls, using fresh and frozen fruits, coconut, oat sprinkle and different nut butters. Now, for that I did splurge occasionally, but it was rare, because with a tip, a (generous sized) bowl was about $15. They closed it when that end of the building got bought out and gutted for a new restaurant space.

    A new one has opened up a couple doors down, but tbh, they’ve got these weird rap-type lyrics on their window about “we be so healthy, we be so fine, yada yada” that it’s totally put me off. I don’t know why, maybe just too “poser” for me, or the lack of proper English, me being a snarky old *kitten* about that kind of thing

  • claireychn074
    claireychn074 Posts: 1,833 Member

    Nope. I’ll spend money on a treat - which is often a coffee and croissant or cake - but never on a protein shake. Firstly I find them pretty disgusting and secondly, I drink them at home when I absolutely need to (for a LOT less money - and I know exactly what goes into them). A lovely blended coffee feels like a real luxury, as does a fresh buttery croissant. A protein shake is (to me) a grim sometimes useful dietary addition.

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member


    What @claireychn074 says!

    my idea of a protein shake is with milk, cottage cheese or yogurt, maybe peanut butter powder, and fruit and/or cocoa.

    I only have one when calories or protein need topping off, so I try to make them a worthy treat.

    I rarely add protein powder to anything except pancake batter.

  • Leeleelahlah
    Leeleelahlah Posts: 48 Member

    No. I buy a big tub of protein powder. I don’t have money to waste on something I can make at home. I don’t even go to coffee shops anymore. In my circle, the days of disposable income is over.

  • xxslim_pickinsxx
    xxslim_pickinsxx Posts: 13 Member

    Lol no, absolutely not

    Also: the more money someone has access to, probably the less likely susceptible they're likely to be

    Is this some kind of MLM herbalife thing??

  • Corina1143
    Corina1143 Posts: 4,784 Member

    I did it once. No magic. Just didn't bother to repeat. But the bakery down the street—-

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member
    edited May 27

    I’m trying to finagle the hubs into Christmas markets this winter, just so we can visit bakeries and I can load up on quarkini. I literally dream about theM sometimes.

  • Corina1143
    Corina1143 Posts: 4,784 Member

    Quarkini sounds good. Never heard of them before. Here it's October and Kolaches.

  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,271 Member

    5 days a week is $25-$35 for a shake. You can BUY a 5lbs tub for under $70 and customize it yourself. But if you can afford it, then go for it.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer

    IDEA Fitness member

    Kickboxing Certified instructor

    Been in fitness for 40+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

  • COGypsy
    COGypsy Posts: 1,436 Member

    To me the gym is a necessary evil, not a place I’m interested in hanging out for drinks and snacks. They also get plenty of my money through my membership fees, why would I give them any more money on something I can just as easily keep in my fridge for exactly the same satisfaction level?

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member

    I’m just curious, are any of you guys that ravenous or hangry after a workout?

    I keep Chimes ginger chews in my bag and will pop one in my mouth between or after workouts if I’m feeling any sort of low energy. But they’re just little 15 calorie chews that are almost straight up cane sugar and ginger. Nice spicy hot little on-the-spot boost. (Or I’ve trained my brain to think that way. 🤷🏻‍♀️)

    I’ll go home, shower and occasionally eat lunch an hour early if I’m really feeling I need something. But the idea of slurping down something immediately after a workout is kind of nauseating.

    To me, that’s an indication of all around under-nourishment. Is that fair? Or am I just weird?

  • COGypsy
    COGypsy Posts: 1,436 Member

    It depends on the workout for me. I’m always starving after I lift, but cardio seems to actually blunt my appetite, if anything. But after lifting, I want FOOD, not some sweet milky frothy something or other. If there were a shop selling protein rich actual food—not shakes and bars, but non-sweet food you can chew and feel full from—that might be worth stopping for.

  • nossmf
    nossmf Posts: 14,088 Member

    After cardio, my appetite is unchanged, I'm just thirsty since I sweat a lot and don't drink anything during.

    After weights, where I can hit the water fountain as often as needed (and don't sweat much/at all), I find myself hungry after. Part of that can be explained from doing my lifting first thing in the morning, fasted. Part could be psychological conditioning (lifting = protein after), a myth that's been debunked but was fed to us for long enough to become ingrained in some of us long-time lifters. Regardless, I enjoy throwing back a protein shake immediately after a good lifting session.

    That said, I don't do fancy protein shakes. I just buy off-the-shelf, ready-made drinks for about $2 each, toss one in my bag before I leave home, and then after lifting when I go back to my locker I can pound the shake before hitting the showers.

  • glassyo
    glassyo Posts: 7,841 Member

    Ok, I'm going to be the outlier here. Obviously, it's going to be cheaper if it's home made but, as someone who buys her boss a protein smoothie 5 days a week, $7 is a damned good deal.

    And it would be convenient for people who want something refreshing and hopefully healthy after their workout.

  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 9,552 Member
    edited May 27

    I gave you a hug for that because, it requires a hug. That’s going above and beyond, or else you’re really really fond of your boss!

  • glassyo
    glassyo Posts: 7,841 Member

    LOL thanks but he pays me back. Eventually. He sorta owes me like $3,500 but that's on me for not telling him to give me an extra $1,000 more often. It really added up fast! 😁

    Honestly, I should be bending the knee to you. From a comment in a post about making tea popsicles, I got the idea to make protein shake (both store bought and reeeeeeally simple home made) popsicles. They're my last blood sugar test of the evening reward.

  • PAV8888
    PAV8888 Posts: 15,102 Member

    But, unless rent is free, why would you not place the store OUTSIDE / NEAR / around the gym? There is a reason why having "goodies" near the gym is a very common pattern…. and when you look carefully many of the more successful ones offer "indulgence" as opposed to "health alternatives"—'cause everyone can splurge on cheesecake after a good gym session :-)

    As to protein shake? I've long fallen for the chocolate milk commercials… cause legit reason to drink chocolate milk 😋 But there are a metric crap-ton(ne) of ready to drink containers available at every corner store.

    The real question is who is hanging out at the gym eating and drinking instead of…. "gyming". And who has to get something from you on the way in or out because it is SOOOO much of a better alternative than getting something else somewhere else along the way to where they're going.

    If you have enough of them around and you can hook them and if the rental costs are right… go for it!

  • yirara
    yirara Posts: 10,540 Member

    Not really. With strength I'm just tired. With running I urge sour fruits. Hence i always have kiwi or grapefruit at home.