5yr old used Wii to lose weight
Replies
-
WOW!Really??
Maybe you shuld not have LET her get so big instead of having her have to lose weight .
I blame parents like you in part for the childhood obesity problem our country is facing!!
YOU should have been feeding her better and having her move more from the start.
Shame on YOU!
Obviously the OP is here on MFP because she's working on changing bad habits in her own life (like most people here - yourself included, I'm sure). Is it really necessary to chastise her for something she clearly knew was an issue? Her daughter is healthier now and for that, she should be commended, not put down.
Additionally, I really don't think someone doesn't have kids, was at least 95 lbs overweight, and lost their own weight using the HCG diet is really the best person to give advice to a parent whose kid has lost weight in a natural healthy way!
thank you so much heidi, I appreciate that more then you know
0 -
Aww she's gorgeous! You must be so proud of her, and im sure she will be uber proud of mummy too. xx0
-
What you did was amazing for your little girl. Ignore those that can't understand that. 0
-
What you did was amazing for your little girl. Ignore those that can't understand that.
Thank you 0 -
she looks so good!! congrats to you and here, and boo on the haters of this thread. she's 5 years old, you certainly didn't starve her. she just had fun playing a video game, and got healthier because of it.0
-
It's insane to see all the negative comments on this. Clearly the child is happy and healthy. People need to see this post as an example that it is perfectly healthy and fine to get your kids in shape, not ignore their children's well being and health. This is not a case of mommy dearest telling her child she is fat and needs to lose weight to be perfect, this is a mother recognizing and preventing future health issues like juvenile diabetes and asthma. This little girl is not starving and miserable. People need to get out of that "She is still young, you don't need to worry about her weight right now" mentality.0
-
You are doing an amazing job with her - gorgeous! Kudos to you for caring enough to show show herthe healthy way of living. :-)0
-
we sure will spring/summer..... we do a lot of activities summer time, but where we live its currently -47
Do I hear that... wind chill last night was -50, blankets on the windows, and even with a block heater the car just refused to start. I do love Alberta, but I sure miss Nova Scotia winters!!!
Thanks for this thread, you motivated me to get the Wii back out. I just left the board out in the living room, and the girls have been on and off it a lot the last few days.
) 0 -
Obviously the negative comments have some issues themselves because they are just being rude. I wish my parents had realized how they were feeding me was hurting me and then done something to make me more active. Maybe I wouldn't be in this situation I am now. Kudos to you for teaching your little girl better habits both in eating and exercise, I bet she will keep these lessons her whole life and will be healthy because she is watching you and learning! It's not like you are making her do adult exercises or anything.
She is adorable btw and looks so happy in both pictures!0 -
That is seriously awesome! I'm glad your daughter found something to motivate her to get healthier and increase her activity level.
I just recently put new batteries into our Wii and have been using it for my own exercise. Of course my daughters are very interested, and it's proven to be a fabulous tool to keep them moving during the winter months. However, I do hate the way that the scale makes the dramatic plumping of the Mii if they are larger than they "should" be. My daughter is almost 9, and she's getting dangerously close to puberty (it hits our family early) and she's been preparing for a growth spurt. Right now her weight is in the higher end of *normal*. But the Wii plumps her up and makes the Mii look terrible, as well as saying that she's in the 'at risk for being overweight' category. Once she saw her younger sister (who is 3 with an insane metabolism) weigh in at the "perfect" body weight and saw it all sparkly, she started saying things about not wanting to be fat and needing to lose weight. It made me super worried.
While I do want my kids to be healthy and active, I wanted to stress to her that it's just not necessary for children to try to lose weight. I told her that she weighed exactly as much as she needed to. I tried to explain that children's bodies will slim down as they grow. But of course, my daughter *isn't* overweight, and I know that. I'm sure my feelings on teh subject, and my choice of wording, might change if that were the case. Of course, I still don't like the idea of a little girl focusing so much on her weight and body in general. It's a hard balance to achieve, I think.
In any case, I think you seem to have set a fine example for your daughter. She looks wonderful, and that is such an amazing accomplishment for anyone-- let alone a 5-year-old. Hopefully this experience has taught her a respect and appreciation for exercise that she will be able to carry with her into adulthood. I have a feeling that if many of us had the opportunity to experience something similar as children, then we might not be on this website today. Good job mama!0 -
She is gorgeous.
I wish my parents had taken measures to help me become healthier.
Going through grade school as one of the chubby kids was a traumatizing experience.
Please ignore the negative comments. People who say rude things like that have their own issues.0 -
luvmybaby333 - There are fit games for kids that don't do that, like KidFit and Nick Jr also has one. Maybe they'd enjoy one of those?0
-
Sorry, this isn't meant as a rude comment but I do feel where some of the posters are coming from. From my personal experience having attention brought to your weight at such a young age really can have negative effects.
My Mom was very hands on, she never called me fat, but from a very young age...probably pre-elementary, she would weigh me monthly and then stand me in front of a mirror and ask me where all that weight was going. She would also ask little questions like did I like the way other (skinner) siblings looked, and would mention if only I liked sports I could look like them too.
She was a constant dieter, and would always include me on her weight loss plans. Her special Weight Watcher meals were just for me and her. The rest of the family got something else. When that didn't work she would put everyone on the diet plan, and if anyone complained she would remind them it was a good chance for them to support me.
Now while this sounds like good parenting, it led to me having severe food issues, where I felt like I had to eat in secret because people were always watching what I ate, including the teachers at school. And it inevitable lead to bullying from my siblings, because kids are mean.
I applaud you for the healthy lifestyle change (the Wii), but the doctor visits about her weight, the before and after photos, the repeated mentions of how she now looks like the other children, the focus on her exact weight loss and its specific timeframe... Well these all make me fear you may be being more obvious than you feel. Kids are very perceptive, as a mother I am sure you are even more aware of that than I am.
The changes are great, but if you are in the habit of weighing your daughter regularly, and if she is aware that it is such a good thing that the number went down. Please be considerate of the fact that she is still growing, and that she will have to be able to deal with seeing the number go back up as she grows. At 5 years old to attribute only weight loss as positive is very misleading, there aren't many adults who weigh 61 pounds...well at least not healthy ones.
For these reasons and my own personal experience, I really tend to caution encouraging per-pubecent weight awareness. I think you are doing a great thing, but there are many ppl hear who can attest to what happens when it is done wrong, and I think those ppl are probably the source of the negative feedback.
So don't think of it like a personal attack, these are just warnings from ppl who remember what it was like to be in your daughters shoes. I love the idea of getting kids active and healthy, maybe with just less emphasis on the numbers. Because chances are, if you're watching them, so is she.0 -
Sorry, this isn't meant as a rude comment but I do feel where some of the posters are coming from. From my personal experience having attention brought to your weight at such a young age really can have negative effects.
My Mom was very hands on, she never called me fat, but from a very young age...probably pre-elementary, she would weigh me monthly and then stand me in front of a mirror and ask me where all that weight was going. She would also ask little questions like did I like the way other (skinner) siblings looked, and would mention if only I liked sports I could look like them too.
She was a constant dieter, and would always include me on her weight loss plans. Her special Weight Watcher meals were just for me and her. The rest of the family got something else. When that didn't work she would put everyone on the diet plan, and if anyone complained she would remind them it was a good chance for them to support me.
Now while this sounds like good parenting, it led to me having severe food issues, where I felt like I had to eat in secret because people were always watching what I ate, including the teachers at school. And it inevitable lead to bullying from my siblings, because kids are mean.
I applaud you for the healthy lifestyle change (the Wii), but the doctor visits about her weight, the before and after photos, the repeated mentions of how she now looks like the other children, the focus on her exact weight loss and its specific timeframe... Well these all make me fear you may be being more obvious than you feel. Kids are very perceptive, as a mother I am sure you are even more aware of that than I am.
The changes are great, but if you are in the habit of weighing your daughter regularly, and if she is aware that it is such a good thing that the number went down. Please be considerate of the fact that she is still growing, and that she will have to be able to deal with seeing the number go back up as she grows. At 5 years old to attribute only weight loss as positive is very misleading, there aren't many adults who weigh 61 pounds...well at least not healthy ones.
For these reasons and my own personal experience, I really tend to caution encouraging per-pubecent weight awareness. I think you are doing a great thing, but there are many ppl hear who can attest to what happens when it is done wrong, and I think those ppl are probably the source of the negative feedback.
So don't think of it like a personal attack, these are just warnings from ppl who remember what it was like to be in your daughters shoes. I love the idea of getting kids active and healthy, maybe with just less emphasis on the numbers. Because chances are, if you're watching them, so is she.
This is a very good point, though I posted my response way back in the thread with a big thumbs up to the mom for posting & for the kid's weight loss.... put this way, I can now see both sides.
Good ideas here & personal sharing, and thumbs up to you for articulating yourself so well. I think it's posts like these that really improve the quality of this forum.0 -
Sorry, this isn't meant as a rude comment but I do feel where some of the posters are coming from. From my personal experience having attention brought to your weight at such a young age really can have negative effects.
My Mom was very hands on, she never called me fat, but from a very young age...probably pre-elementary, she would weigh me monthly and then stand me in front of a mirror and ask me where all that weight was going. She would also ask little questions like did I like the way other (skinner) siblings looked, and would mention if only I liked sports I could look like them too.
She was a constant dieter, and would always include me on her weight loss plans. Her special Weight Watcher meals were just for me and her. The rest of the family got something else. When that didn't work she would put everyone on the diet plan, and if anyone complained she would remind them it was a good chance for them to support me.
Now while this sounds like good parenting, it led to me having severe food issues, where I felt like I had to eat in secret because people were always watching what I ate, including the teachers at school. And it inevitable lead to bullying from my siblings, because kids are mean.
I applaud you for the healthy lifestyle change (the Wii), but the doctor visits about her weight, the before and after photos, the repeated mentions of how she now looks like the other children, the focus on her exact weight loss and its specific timeframe... Well these all make me fear you may be being more obvious than you feel. Kids are very perceptive, as a mother I am sure you are even more aware of that than I am.
The changes are great, but if you are in the habit of weighing your daughter regularly, and if she is aware that it is such a good thing that the number went down. Please be considerate of the fact that she is still growing, and that she will have to be able to deal with seeing the number go back up as she grows. At 5 years old to attribute only weight loss as positive is very misleading, there aren't many adults who weigh 61 pounds...well at least not healthy ones.
For these reasons and my own personal experience, I really tend to caution encouraging per-pubecent weight awareness. I think you are doing a great thing, but there are many ppl hear who can attest to what happens when it is done wrong, and I think those ppl are probably the source of the negative feedback.
So don't think of it like a personal attack, these are just warnings from ppl who remember what it was like to be in your daughters shoes. I love the idea of getting kids active and healthy, maybe with just less emphasis on the numbers. Because chances are, if you're watching them, so is she.
This is a very good point, though I posted my response way back in the thread with a big thumbs up to the mom for posting & for the kid's weight loss.... put this way, I can now see both sides.
Good ideas here & personal sharing, and thumbs up to you for articulating yourself so well. I think it's posts like these that really improve the quality of this forum.
Just letting you know its not like that for her, she still eats anything she wants and we dont make a big deal of it, I know i did the right thing because she used to weigh more then her 8 year old cousin whos a boy.... she definitely was a bigger girl, now shes more active then before is all im sayin, we dont tell her she GOT to lose weight or she GOT to eat certain things, so to each his own!0 -
I applaud you for the healthy lifestyle change (the Wii), but the doctor visits about her weight, the before and after photos, the repeated mentions of how she now looks like the other children, the focus on her exact weight loss and its specific timeframe... Well these all make me fear you may be being more obvious than you feel. Kids are very perceptive, as a mother I am sure you are even more aware of that than I am.
The changes are great, but if you are in the habit of weighing your daughter regularly, and if she is aware that it is such a good thing that the number went down. Please be considerate of the fact that she is still growing, and that she will have to be able to deal with seeing the number go back up as she grows. At 5 years old to attribute only weight loss as positive is very misleading, there aren't many adults who weigh 61 pounds...well at least not healthy ones.
That's the tightrope I'm trying to walk right now, too... but to be fair, you need to realize that it's more than likely the doctor who brought it up. Annual health checkups for kids do include a weight/height check, tracking on the growth charts, BMI, etc - and it's the health nurse or doctor's job to call attention to it if there is a concern. And then it's our job to do with that information the best thing we know how to do. In our case, we were offered a referral to a dietitian at her last checkup, like the OP. I said no, I knew the changes we needed to make. I did kind of put it off with the idea that she'd grow into herself. But now my daughter is seven, has had a major growth spurt, and hasn't grown into the "baby fat" that was there at five; instead, it's started inviting friends. So changes have to be made. And habits changed this young will change the future in a positive way.
We're trying to keep the focus on "healthier" vs "smaller", and I'm doing my best to correct her when she starts to equate "skinny" with "better". But you're right - kids are very perceptive. Mine has picked up on everything that I've been doing lately and is asking questions every day, so I'm taking the opportunity and trying to guide her while still keeping it positive. It's hard!! I'm still fighting my own negative voices at the same time as I'm trying to keep hers from ever developing.0 -
Way to go girlie and mama. So great that you and her took the time to do that. With childhood diabetes(type 2) and high cholesterol in some elementary kids good for you for making that purchase. She looks great and I bet she feels so much better. Kids can feel stress and I'm so happy for you both that she got to a normal weight. As an adult who got heavy at the end of elementary school I wish my mom had taken a roll into helping me reduce my weight to normal/ideal range. I tried in high school but had little control over what I ate. I went vegetarian(unhealthily, meaning didn't watch protein counts) and started a walk/jog program. In my senior year I joined a gym started to run but moved across country and life kicked in. I've been up and down since. Getting active would have been the best things.
We are enjoying our active games on the Wii. We just got Just Dance 3 and The Michael Jackson Experience game to keep moving. Its tons of fun and we can play for 1-3 hours and just have so much fun the time flies by. My 8 year old LOVES these games. She is already very well proportioned at 4'6" and 64-65 lbs but she wants to build some strength(for cartwheels and playing NOT weight lifting just wanted to clarify that) and get better at the dancing movements and flexibility.0 -
I wish there was a Wii when I was a kid. I could've been saved the trouble of working my butt of thousands of times trying to lose the weight I gained as a kid because I was a reader and not into sports.0
-
Not like she's an ad or anything, I'm saying little girl gets on the PC and sees her pic (I wouldn't post my child on the internet, but again, I'm not a parent) and she's all freaked out about getting "fat" again.I'm not a parent, but I wouldn't hype this up by posting before and after pics and stuff like that. Chics have enough stigma attached to their weight. And at 5?
i doubt shes showing her daughter it like shes a diet ad or anything.. i think she looks fabulous!! good work !
If she wants a twinkee or pizza she should have one. She will have enough time to be concerned about her weight once she hits like 12.
That's all I'm saying.
I disagree 5-6 is prime time they learn about confidence. And hearing other kids or heck even the Dr. call you fat/overweight because your a little over what the charts say or what everyone else looks like their age will cause trauma to their confidence WELL before 12. Been there! My confidence is HORRIBLE. I wish someone of my parents(mom, dad or step mom) would have encouraged something as simple as get active. Well my dad did my 5th grade year he signed me up for basketball. That was the only year I lived with them then it was back to my mom's where I was lucky to be at the same school the entire year. Nothing said about twinkies. My daughter eats junk food sometimes. Its just not in our daily meal planning. She's healthy proportioned and I do encourage activity. I'd like to keep her in a healthy range and make sure she grows up learning what it means to be active and fit.
This mom teaching her 5 year old to be active will save the 12 year old from being called out. I just don't think teaching a young child to move is going to cause more damage to the ideals placed in little girls by tv shows and other media like magazines that are totally photoshopped. I think making exercise fun(a game literally) is the way to go.0 -
I totally second that!I'm not a parent, but I wouldn't hype this up by posting before and after pics and stuff like that. Chics have enough stigma attached to their weight. And at 5?
It is great that she lost weight just by using the WII but.... NOW is the time to show her (and be an example for) a healthy lifestyle with healthy foodand interesting but healthy lunch boxes. Good luck on your journey0 -
I moved the theme of thos topic (go op), but some of the comments are just horrible or very personal...
The parents like you comment was way out of hand... The way things worked out, the op's parenting May turn out better than many... I mean she gave her daughter freedom and choice, but eventually threw the rigjt tools in the mix and now the daughter is choosing to be fit... To me that's huge... For her to aware of this and making a good decision to exercise.
And on that point, I think awareness is good. I was actually called fat a lot and eventually righted the ship using that as motivation... Now if everyone tells you that you're perfectly fit and fine being overweight, I think this would be a problem that is far worse.0 -
This is alarming.
Why??, at that age kids start doing lots of activities, football, dance, baseball gym etc - Wii is just another activity.
If it helps promote a healthy habit that she keeps for life it can only be a good thing.
YES DItto...How is playing the Wii games different from say putting her in karate or a sport to get her active.0 -
What an awesome mum you are! I hope to learn a lesson or two from your daughter - I'm going to be taking a page out of her book. You're both a wonderful inspiration 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!