Any low Carbers out there?
Replies
-
Do you feel better about yourself now that you've made someone else "look bad"?
Okay, let me amend what I said to please some anonymous person. I dont think people should cut something completely out of their diet unless supervised by a professional. DERP
Okay, now. The reaction from the previous guy was understandable. We low-carb eaters always get folks talking about how we're "extreme", that we are killing ourselves, that Atkins/Paleo/Keto are "crazy talk", etc. You probably didn't mean it that way. Drinks all around, people.
Just like I wouldn't berate a diabetic for not eating the normal amount of sugars in the SAD (Standard American Diet, an apt acronym), people who have had struggles eating any other way and losing and keeping weight off and feeling better have suceeeded famously with low-carb. At the end of the day, I try to live by this saying here on MFP: I'll "do" me. You "do" you.
I agree that one should not undertake this without a healthcare providers guidance...but then again, isn't that true of ANY diet or exercise regimen?0 -
Low carb is what got rid of my diabetes. When I was at this same weight years ago I was still diabetic. Now I have normal HgbA1c on NO MEDS. Even my doctor was shocked at what difference cutting the carbs did. You can still eat everything with low carb, you just have to be very selective. The glycemic index is a good guide.0
-
[/quote]
i haven't dropped dead either, i was advised by a doctor to limit carbs for weightloss. my 1st week i lost 8 lbs.if it works dont knock it.
[/quote]
WAHOO!!! GO YOU!0 -
No. And personally I dont think anyone should completely reduce/cut out a portion of their diet. Just stick within your calorie goals and try and switch up things to healthier choices. I still eat bread/tortillas/wraps most days and haven't dropped dead or stopped losing weight.
Everybody has their own methods. What works for us, works for us... I haven't dropped dead either. Just sayin'
i haven't dropped dead either, i was advised by a doctor to limit carbs for weightloss. my 1st week i lost 8 lbs.if it works dont knock it.
My last "quote" didn't work.... Wanted to repost and make sure you got my congratulations on a job well done!!!!!0 -
I am aiming for 20g carbs per day and have been doing thi for about six weeks. Love the food, feel great and my body shape is changing which is great!0
-
Wow, there is a lot of drama in this thread.
I eat keto with 5%/20g of carbs a day, feel free to add me0 -
I'm a fellow Keto-er as well. It's working for me, it's a change I need, and I desperately want to avoid the complications I've seen diseases like Diabetes cause throughout my family - to me, this is a good way to keep myself healthy and happy.
Also, feel free to add.0 -
That would be me! Feel free to add me.0
-
low carber here0
-
yep, under 50g per day of carbs and I'm in the UK. Eating lots of oils and fats, naturally.
The photo isn't me, it's a guy that nobody told about starvation mode ;-)
Ha! I friggin laughed out loud on that one. I do love me the "OMG, I ate less than 2000 calories do you think I am in starvation mode" threads.0 -
Hi! I typically follow 50/30/20 - Pro/Fat/Carb Once a week I do a carb load day, usually the day before my heavy leg workout. It all depends on how I feel, what the mirror says & on rare occasion, what the scale says!
I'm new here & could use some friends - add me!0 -
yep, under 50g per day of carbs and I'm in the UK. Eating lots of oils and fats, naturally.
The photo isn't me, it's a guy that nobody told about starvation mode ;-)
He wasn't taking his Multi Vits lol0 -
I do love me the "OMG, I ate less than 2000 calories do you think I am in starvation mode" threads.
Lmao0 -
Also Low Carber here
Pleased to make new friends0 -
Hi,
For about 8 months now I've been eating moderate/low carb I guess in a 'primal' way of eating. I try to not eat anything processed and would love some friends to motivate me and give me some recipe ideas
I try not to go over 100g/day and it's working for me so far - Being that I was diagnosed as Insulin resistant and having issues with the dietitian telling me to eat 200g+/day and taking Metformin.
Feel free to add me (with a msg please)
Jess0 -
no need to get personal and make fun of her hair!
I don't agree with what she said, but there's no need to be mean, even if her tone was...0 -
or maybe you have brain damage from the dye used to color your hair PURPLE!??!!!
no need to get personal and make fun of her hair!
I don't agree with what she said, but there's no need to be mean, even if her tone was...0 -
Edit:
edited by mod0 -
Edit:
I love how people have started drama over one comment.
I think you guys might have low blood sugar and are just a bit crankywanky. D'awwww
too bad keto diets keep the most even blood sugar. do you read much?0 -
Hi guys
I am not new to MFP by any stretch and adore the friends I have made on here. However, I only know one lady who is doing low carb. Are any of you lovely folks trying to reduce your carb intake or following a more ridgid no carb diet?
It would be lovely to hear from you, please feel free to add me with a little message.
Good luck with your weight and fitness journey, I look forwards to sharing it with you.
Lotte
Im doing the 90 day challenge of P90X following the nutrition guide as best as possible. So for my first month Im aiming low carb and high protein to help burn the fat I want to lose ( 50% Protein, 30% carb, 20% fat). Next month I change it up (40% protein, 40% carb, 20% fat) . The final month changes again to balance out.0 -
I am going to low-carb.. Need to reduce my waist line for health and looks.. Also have very HIGH Triglycerides. My Nutritionist suggest this site to track food and for moral support.. I joined yesterday.,,,0
-
I am going to low-carb.. Need to reduce my waist line for health and looks.. Also have very HIGH Triglycerides. My Nutritionist suggest this site to track food and for moral support.. I joined yesterday.,,,
Welcome, Nancy!0 -
I am trying very hard to cut out the white stuff - bread, pasta, rice, white sugar, etc.
I am still eating fruit and "high carb" veggies and I do indulge in fried foods here and there.
But my doctor has recommended that I have a diet consisting primarily of organic meats and veggies and I have started trying to take his advice..0 -
Wow! I am amazed at the large variety of "low carbing" we have here. Some people are keeping it under 28 gms a day while others are staying under 100 gms a day. I do agree you shouldn't eliminate or severly restrict a portion of your diet, (a no carb diet is as dangerous as a 400 calorie a day diet would be), but don't think we need a doctor to tell us every move we need to make (whe I was having high cholestrol - I researched foods to lower cholesterol - not my MD). We need to research what diet will be best for our individual situation and alter it from there. We do need carbs, but have the choice to make smart decisions of which carbs we consume. I am trying to reduce my carbs, but also get most of the carbs I consume from fresh fruit/vegetables 6 days a week. The seventh day I have a free day so if I am really craving something, i know I can have it later in the week. I have also increased my protein. Is it working? Yes when I stick to it. I have been really struggling this last 2 weeks with bad carbs. I can tell a major difference when I consume them and have to get a control on this. Basically I believe everyone has to determine what is right for thier situation (diabetic, heart problems, just want to lose a few pounds, morbidly obese ect....) and what works for them. I plan on this being a lifestyle / diet change and to continue it after I lose my weight. Good luck to us all!0
-
a no carb diet is as dangerous as a 400 calorie a day diet would be
I do agree with your saying that we need to adjust our diet to our individual situation.
A 400-calorie diet is one step from starvation, and is indeed dangerous. However, people do very well on diets with 20g of carbs, which is the next thing to no-carb. What's the science behind your assertion that it's dangerous not to eat carbs?0 -
a no carb diet is as dangerous as a 400 calorie a day diet would be
Where is the science to back it up?
The only essentials are
Essential Fatty Acids (FAT)
Essential Amino Acids (Protein)
There is no such thing as an essential carbohydrate. Why? Because your body can make it's own glucose from the two Essentials. Going low carb is not dangerous, only to Type I diabetics, the high levels of keytones (sugar) can create serious issues depending on the quantity.
That being said, carbohydrates are nice to have, but not essential.0 -
:bigsmile:
Yes I have been on a moderate low carb. Still eat fruit and losing. How are you doing.0 -
I've been working my way to low carb over the past 5 or so days. Yesterday and today I was under 20g and I plan on keeping it that way. I spent a LOT of time reading and asking questions first to make sure that I knew what I was doing, especially as I have some medical issues that I like to keep on top of. So far I'm feeling quite well and energetic, and so does my SO who is doing this with me. Making a change to your diet is important and you should definitely educate yourself, but once you find something that works for you and keeps you healthy you should totally go for it.
Feel free to add me if you want .0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions