What's more important: Weight or Physique?
Replies
-
Right now, weight is more important, but in the long run, physique is. I know that a lot of people say that BMI is a piece of crap measurement, but it's still important to me to be in the 'healthy weight' classification for my own motivation. Once I hit my goal weight (only 10 more pounds!), I'll still be almost at the max. healthy weight for BMI. However, at that point, if I lose more while I focus on toning, great, but if I stay the same weight but have a nice physique, that's great too.
I was obese by the BMI when I took that picture, 5'7"...185lbs. No goal I have includes that ridiculous chart. I would literally be terrified to see what I looked like if I were in the 'healthy' range.
Physique all the way.0 -
At the moment - getting the weight down is my first priority. It doesn't make much sense for me to worry about physique when I'm still carrying an extra 60 pounds of flab. But I plan to start working strength training and toning into my exercise routine fairly soon.0
-
Weight for me.. I'm married so who cares? I figure lose the weight first, worry about the physique after that.0
-
I suppose physique. I know what I want my body to look like, and what I want it to be able to do but I have no idea what weight that will put me at. I've selected a number but I'm more than willing to adjust it up or down, depending on how I look/feel as I get closer to my goals. So while my ticker says I'm aiming for 140, I'm more focused on having a strong, fit body, whether it's at 140, 120, or 160 or whatever number I feel good at. I used to love running (pre-injury) and that's mostly what I want to get back to, along with some strength training.0
-
Of course not, but exercising with weights more than just affects your muscles. Your metabolism becomes more efficient, you build a stronger heart, you increase blood flow, you increase your immunity, etc. These are aspects of health also.
Just a thought. Wouldn't it make more sense to get to a "healthy weight" and actually "be healthy" at the same time? If you reach the weight without being physically fit, then how healthy is the weight?I'm certainly in no rush to get to my goal, and for me it's better to focus on one thing at once. It's important to me to know that I'm down to a healthy weight, before I start any form of weight training.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
I wouldn't say muscles are the only measure of health.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
And surely ones also available without working on physique?
What can improving my physique do that working on eating right, getting the right nutrition, hydrating well and doing cardio can't? Other than (as has been said) a faster metabolism resulting in faster loss, which isn't something I'm bothered about?0 -
Of course not, but exercising with weights more than just affects your muscles. Your metabolism becomes more efficient, you build a stronger heart, you increase blood flow, you increase your immunity, etc. These are aspects of health also.
Just a thought. Wouldn't it make more sense to get to a "healthy weight" and actually "be healthy" at the same time? If you reach the weight without being physically fit, then how healthy is the weight?I'm certainly in no rush to get to my goal, and for me it's better to focus on one thing at once. It's important to me to know that I'm down to a healthy weight, before I start any form of weight training.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
I wouldn't say muscles are the only measure of health.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
And surely ones also available without working on physique?
What can improving my physique do that working on eating right, getting the right nutrition, hydrating well and doing cardio can't? Other than (as has been said) a faster metabolism resulting in faster loss, which isn't something I'm bothered about?
You can lead a horse to water...that's for sure.
How about basic physical ability for one. Sure, you may not NEED to use it, but it makes every day tasks much easier, and less taxing on your body. How about the proven health and anti-aging benifits of naturally produced growth hormone that weight training stimulates (and cardio absolutely does NOT!)? How about the fact that your body isn't using a substantial portion of its own lean mass for an energy resource?
The list is long, and I could continue...but it's clear that you've no interest whatsoever in listening to it, so I'll stop right there.0 -
Physique :-)0
-
Physique, but the weight is a way to see that I'm actually making progress.0
-
PHYSIQUE DEFINITELY!0
-
I need to get the number down! But im more concerned with how Ill look over the number. Even though I need the number to be much lower if I feel good with the way I look before goal weight ill stay but if at goal weight i still dont like the way i look ill lose more0
-
Weight is important for me right now due to me being above the weight I want to be at, however once I hit that weight then I will focus on physique which I know will increase my weight again due to muscle gain. After that I will then be looking at lowering my body fat % while maintaining muscle mass.0
-
It's not about what's more noticeable to other people, it's about what's important to ME.
My defining moment in this journey was when we had a physical at my school and when we all started talking about our results I was ashamed to admit my weight out loud because it was the second highest in my class. I was never the one to fool myself, I already knew that I was overweight and I was also aware that everyone else could see it, but that moment completely broke me. That day I swore to myself that something like that would never happen again.
So yes, it's first and foremost about the number on the scale. I could look like Gisele freaking Bundchen, if I'm not comfortable with the number. It would still mean mean that there is, indeed, some weight left to lose.
(Disclaimer, before anyone jumps at my throat.
My Gisele example is just a exaggerated figure of speech. I do realize that the right physique would most likely be paired with the right weight, all I'm trying to do is explain just how much weight matters to me.
Even though I'm mainly focused on weight, I realize that it changes day-to-day and I do not have ONE particular number that's okay. Instead, I have set a range of 15 pounds, at any point of which I'd be okay with weighing that much.
End disclaimer)0 -
Physique every time! I have battled most of my adult like with my weight, I am 5ft 8 and when I weighed 140lbs I looked like crap and my legs were as thin as arms! I have weighed 154lbs and looked great, more toned and healthier. I am aiming for 154lbs this time around :-)0
-
Definitely physique. I'm at the point where I would start creeping into skinny fat territory if I were just concerning myself with scale weight.0
-
The insecure fatty in me says weight :grumble: , but deep down I know it's physique :bigsmile:0
-
Most people will say physique, because at the end of the day, it's all about how you look to yourself and others. However, depending on what your situation is, the number on the scale might carry more weight (ha). Some people who are severely overweight are probably more concerned with losing the weight to improve their health. It really just depends. Personally, I choose physique.0
-
Physique - my actual weight has always been higher than people would guess, looking at me, and that's unlikely to change. The way I'm built, and my genetic propensity to muscle mean that the number on the scale is always going to be higher-than-average, so as long as I like what I see, and my body does what I ask it to without complaint, I'm not going to worry about that. I've set an initial goal weight which still gives me quite a way to go, and I have an idea of roughly where I'd like to end up, numerically, but I'm certainly not going to obsess about that number. If there's a number I AM interested in, it's the number on the tag in my clothes - to fit a small UK 14 (US10-ish), I will have to be slim and toned.0
-
Physique,
Weight is only a guide,
Once you start to train you soon know what healthy and unhealthy is, you know the difference.0 -
Of course not, but exercising with weights more than just affects your muscles. Your metabolism becomes more efficient, you build a stronger heart, you increase blood flow, you increase your immunity, etc. These are aspects of health also.
Just a thought. Wouldn't it make more sense to get to a "healthy weight" and actually "be healthy" at the same time? If you reach the weight without being physically fit, then how healthy is the weight?I'm certainly in no rush to get to my goal, and for me it's better to focus on one thing at once. It's important to me to know that I'm down to a healthy weight, before I start any form of weight training.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
I wouldn't say muscles are the only measure of health.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
And surely ones also available without working on physique?
What can improving my physique do that working on eating right, getting the right nutrition, hydrating well and doing cardio can't? Other than (as has been said) a faster metabolism resulting in faster loss, which isn't something I'm bothered about?
You can lead a horse to water...that's for sure.
How about basic physical ability for one. Sure, you may not NEED to use it, but it makes every day tasks much easier, and less taxing on your body. How about the proven health and anti-aging benifits of naturally produced growth hormone that weight training stimulates (and cardio absolutely does NOT!)? How about the fact that your body isn't using a substantial portion of its own lean mass for an energy resource?
The list is long, and I could continue...but it's clear that you've no interest whatsoever in listening to it, so I'll stop right there.
'but it's clear that you've no interest whatsoever in listening to it'?
Then why would I have gone to the effort of asking? Really, there's no need to be so rude. I'm asking people to tell me the benefits of starting work on my physique now, rather than at a time when I'm closer to goal weight, so that I can consider whether or not I feel it's worth it.
I hope someone will bother to explain the benefits that I can't get from my current exercise. I'll take away the information about the growth hormone from your post, though, so thanks for that.0 -
I started my mfp journey over a year ago, trying to lose 10 lbs for a family trip. I had lost 20 lbs before joining and went from 230+ to 210.
After about a year of dieting and exercise (but not much in terms of strength training), I had gotten into the 160s but was still not happy with my body composition.
Here's a picture from a trip in January of this year at 165 lbs:
I realized that I had lost a good amount of muscle chasing "the last 10 pounds". After the trip, I made to decision to commit to strength training and have been in the gym 4-6 times per week, alternating cardio and lifting heavy (for me!).
Here are my results so far:
I'm actually heavier in the last picture, now weighing 170. I've noticed my best results from a consistent program and getting my butt into the gym & moving that weight! My plan now is to get back up to 175 before cycling back into fat-loss mode again.0 -
Exactly! That's muscle for ya!0
-
Physique for sure although I use weight as a guide. I know at this weight its not healthy and as I lose and gain muscle my physique will improve for sure.
Thats why I have an estimate goal weight. I didnt set an exact number Im aiming for 125-130 but if I get to 135 and look and feel great I might stop there. We shall see.0 -
Of course not, but exercising with weights more than just affects your muscles. Your metabolism becomes more efficient, you build a stronger heart, you increase blood flow, you increase your immunity, etc. These are aspects of health also.
Just a thought. Wouldn't it make more sense to get to a "healthy weight" and actually "be healthy" at the same time? If you reach the weight without being physically fit, then how healthy is the weight?I'm certainly in no rush to get to my goal, and for me it's better to focus on one thing at once. It's important to me to know that I'm down to a healthy weight, before I start any form of weight training.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
I wouldn't say muscles are the only measure of health.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
And surely ones also available without working on physique?
What can improving my physique do that working on eating right, getting the right nutrition, hydrating well and doing cardio can't? Other than (as has been said) a faster metabolism resulting in faster loss, which isn't something I'm bothered about?
You can lead a horse to water...that's for sure.
How about basic physical ability for one. Sure, you may not NEED to use it, but it makes every day tasks much easier, and less taxing on your body. How about the proven health and anti-aging benifits of naturally produced growth hormone that weight training stimulates (and cardio absolutely does NOT!)? How about the fact that your body isn't using a substantial portion of its own lean mass for an energy resource?
The list is long, and I could continue...but it's clear that you've no interest whatsoever in listening to it, so I'll stop right there.
'but it's clear that you've no interest whatsoever in listening to it'?
Then why would I have gone to the effort of asking? Really, there's no need to be so rude. I'm asking people to tell me the benefits of starting work on my physique now, rather than at a time when I'm closer to goal weight, so that I can consider whether or not I feel it's worth it.
I hope someone will bother to explain the benefits that I can't get from my current exercise. I'll take away the information about the growth hormone from your post, though, so thanks for that.
Building lean mass, otherwise known as muscle tissue, means that your body burns calories more efficiently. In the long run, that means you will lose weight more easily, and critically, keep it off more easily.
Lean mass also doesn't store various potentially-harmful hormones and chemicals in the same way that fat does, so an increase in lean mass and a commensurate decrease in non-lean mass may be protective against various diseases and illnesses that are related to excess fat.
Lean muscle mass also provides protection and support for your joints. Strength training can have a preventitive effect against various joint-issues.
On a purely visual level, a little strength training now (I use a five lb hand weight and a few body-weight exercises) will mean that as you lose weight, your physique will already be more in line to match up visually with your weight-related goals.
Why do you not want to do strength training? It needn't be a 'one-or-t'other' strength or cardio approach - both are good.0 -
100% physique.
The issue is it a lot more difficult having a good physique at a higher weight.0 -
Physique.. Yea the number on the scale is great, but the fact I look good naked is even better!0
-
Building lean mass, otherwise known as muscle tissue, means that your body burns calories more efficiently. In the long run, that means you will lose weight more easily, and critically, keep it off more easily.
Lean mass also doesn't store various potentially-harmful hormones and chemicals in the same way that fat does, so an increase in lean mass and a commensurate decrease in non-lean mass may be protective against various diseases and illnesses that are related to excess fat.
Lean muscle mass also provides protection and support for your joints. Strength training can have a preventitive effect against various joint-issues.
On a purely visual level, a little strength training now (I use a five lb hand weight and a few body-weight exercises) will mean that as you lose weight, your physique will already be more in line to match up visually with your weight-related goals.
Why do you not want to do strength training? It needn't be a 'one-or-t'other' strength or cardio approach - both are good.
Thanks for responding. I haven't wanted to do strength training as I'm focusing on reducing body fat (not necessarily adding muscle in its place for now), and getting to a healthy BMI as my goal. It's not that my 120lbs goal weight based on BMI is a final goal, but that it's the marker to show I'm at a 'healthy weight' which I feel is important.
I'm going to keep the weight off, that's not an issue, nor is the speed at which I lose, or the look. For me, it's about nutrition and health, with the focus being on a body that will last, not necessarily one that looks good. That's why, for now, I'm solely doing cardio - working on my heart and lungs.0 -
Physique. Since coming on here I've learned a lot about the body and honestly I wouldn't care if I went back up to the weight I started at as long as I wasn't flabby and had muscle to show for it.0
-
Both are equally important for health and vanity. lol0
-
Weight is a measure while physique is a subjective opinion. People consider weight to be important as it often is the main measure of success in weight loss. But it's ultimately the subjective opinion that people will really consider to be important.0
So screw you scale, kiss my 
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions