Vitamin D Effect On Weight Loss Study
Replies
-
webmd.com/food-recipes/vitamin-d-deficiency
Symptoms from a more traditional source.
articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/05/28/vitamin-d-deficiency-signs-symptoms.aspx
A less traditional source.
drfranklipman.com/symptoms-diseases-associated-with-vitamin-d-deficiency/
Symptoms, etc in list format. Does have some vitamin brand promotion.0 -
I'm just glad we have Vitamin D supplements that are easy to take. My mom grew up in Minnesota (1920's-30's) and she would tell me about the god-awful cod liver oil she and her siblings had to take every day when she was little. Blech!
That was when my parents grew up but they past the tradition on down to their children.
At least we did not get the rickets.
0 -
Yeah that's why I said "same page".0
-
GaleHawkins wrote: »webmd.com/food-recipes/vitamin-d-deficiency
Symptoms from a more traditional source.
articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/05/28/vitamin-d-deficiency-signs-symptoms.aspx
A less traditional source.
drfranklipman.com/symptoms-diseases-associated-with-vitamin-d-deficiency/
Symptoms, etc in list format. Does have some vitamin brand promotion.
All of those symptoms vague and could be a symptom of something else.0 -
GaleHawkins wrote: »webmd.com/food-recipes/vitamin-d-deficiency
Symptoms from a more traditional source.
articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/05/28/vitamin-d-deficiency-signs-symptoms.aspx
A less traditional source.
drfranklipman.com/symptoms-diseases-associated-with-vitamin-d-deficiency/
Symptoms, etc in list format. Does have some vitamin brand promotion.
All of those symptoms vague and could be a symptom of something else.
I think most people agree with you that people should ask for a test.0 -
Maybe my sources are off but can't you get your daily need of Vitamin D by being in the sun 15-20 minutes? Going out side for 15-20 minutes in a short sleeve shirt seems cheaper than buying a supplement.
I guess there would be some cases where you might consider a supplement like you have some allergy to the sun, you can't process Vitamin D from sun exposure, you live in a place where there is little sun shine, or work the night shift.
A doctor's consultation and to each their own I suppose.0 -
that 15-20 minutes depends. in northern climates, we're too far from the sun to do well with just 15 minutes in a t-shirt. plus, we have snow 6 months of the year.
people in north carolina? you're probably good with 15 minutes in the sun.0 -
I work over nights, so barely see the sun lol.0
-
health.harvard.edu/newsweek/time-for-more-vitamin-d.htm
This has a map for the USA UV potential. The article is dated however.0 -
that 15-20 minutes depends. in northern climates, we're too far from the sun to do well with just 15 minutes in a t-shirt. plus, we have snow 6 months of the year.
people in north carolina? you're probably good with 15 minutes in the sun.
I defiantly see your point there. I also agree that you should get blood work done and consult a doctor before assuming any need for a supplement.0 -
I'm going to try and get a little more sun. I'm a redhead with freckles and avoid it.0
-
that 15-20 minutes depends. in northern climates, we're too far from the sun to do well with just 15 minutes in a t-shirt. plus, we have snow 6 months of the year.
people in north carolina? you're probably good with 15 minutes in the sun.that 15-20 minutes depends. in northern climates, we're too far from the sun to do well with just 15 minutes in a t-shirt. plus, we have snow 6 months of the year.
people in north carolina? you're probably good with 15 minutes in the sun.
I live in Los Angeles, and I was Vitamin D deficient. At the time I was diagnosed, I was spending a minimum of an hour a day outside in the sun with my children, plus being outside to tend the garden, to take walks and similar ventures.
I was constantly exhausted and my doctor ran a blood panel to rule various possibilities out, but instead she found one.
Vitamin D was not my full story, and my thyroid condition was only found out later, but yes, one can live in a high sun index locale and be D deficient.
I agree with those who say blood tests, not just guessing and grabbing for a supplement, are in order. I would never have guessed at a D deficiency, but my doctor said she did discover the same issue once in a while among her patients, so it's not like I'm a medical anomaly or anything, apparently.
0 -
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18793245
A 2008 study. Looks like Vitamin D3 levels above 40 scored less depressed and experience weight loss. I think my level was like 22 July 2013 and 28 July 2014. The doctor just said it needs to be above 40. Had he talked about cutting risks Type 2 Diabetes, cancer, etc I think it would have clicked. Hopefully July 2015 I will have it up to 60.
articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2014/01/02/vitamin-d-deficiency-depression.aspx#_edn4
I think the depression/weight connection is real in the minds of many of us. It seems we are as tight to the sun as are plants. 0 -
That is interesting, but I think there was another study I read that potentially correlates low vitamin D3 in children with an increased risk of type 1 diabetes (and/or vitamin D deficiency could be a precursor to type 1 diabetes development). It explains why instances of type 1 diabetes are higher in locations further from the equator compared to locations closer to it.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/02/140227115426.htm
Shockingly, I'm also vitamin D deficient, though I have no experienced easier weight loss by taking my prescribed supplement.0 -
many people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
0 -
many people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
well, we have an idea of the range. FACT
i was deficient. FACT
i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT0 -
This content has been removed.
-
well, we have an idea of the range. FACTmany people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
The "idea of the range" is so broad as to be useless.i was deficient. FACT
That's not what "fact" means.i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT
I lost weight after swapping cotton jeans for wool dress pants. I guess its time to start a wool-deficiency and/or cotton-is-the-devil thread...
0 -
So because you know some people in your area that are Vitamin D deficient does that mean all areas have that problem?many people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
well, we have an idea of the range. FACT
i was deficient. FACT
i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT
I also love the amount of emotion you post with.
i said my area has that problem, not all areas.0 -
well, we have an idea of the range. FACTmany people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
The idea of the range is so broad as to be useless.i was deficient. FACT
That's not what "fact" means.i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT
I lost weight after swapping cotton jeans for wool dress pants.
And...?
i doubt it's useless. i'm also pretty sure there was a link between the vitamin d deficiency and weight loss for me. your cotton jeans example is irrelevant and rude.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
So because you know some people in your area that are Vitamin D deficient does that mean all areas have that problem?many people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
well, we have an idea of the range. FACT
i was deficient. FACT
i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT
I also love the amount of emotion you post with.
i said my area has that problem, not all areas.
What is the % of people in your area that are deficient? How many people are in your area?
who cares0 -
i'm not your google monkey. look it up if you want to.0
-
I was diagnosed as Vitamin D deficient after struggling with extremely low energy levels and aching joints (felt like my "bones hurt"; though I'm fairly sure that might be impossible). I was placed on 50,000 IU once a day for a week (I felt a surge of energy and the pain went away starting on the fourth day), and now continue to take about 10,000 IU per week through supplements. Oh yes, and the weight did seem to come off more quickly; perhaps because I was more energetic, pain free, and moving around a lot more!0
-
This content has been removed.
-
So because you know some people in your area that are Vitamin D deficient does that mean all areas have that problem?many people in my area of the country ARE deficient in vitamin d if they are not taking it in some sort of supplement. FACT
It's not a "Fact" because we don't actually know what the "right" amount is. It varies tremendously between individuals and is affected by everything from geography to fitness levels to diet to mood to time of year.
"FACT."
well, we have an idea of the range. FACT
i was deficient. FACT
i lost weight after taking vitamin D supplements. FACT
I also love the amount of emotion you post with.
i said my area has that problem, not all areas.
What is the % of people in your area that are deficient? How many people are in your area?
who cares
Well you are making the claim that many of the people in your area have the problem so I'd like to see the data backing up that claim. So its not who cares, it's relevant. And how would I look it up if I don't know what area in the country to research?
manhattan. why exactly does it matter?
i had the problem. i resolved the problem.0 -
If you suspect you're low on vitamin D (especially if you fit one of the descriptions that experts look at -- no time in the sun, etc.), I don't see anything wrong with taking a little. If you're not taking any other supplements that contain vitamin D, and you're not taking amounts over the upper limit (US government says 4000 IU for upper limit, although some other people will say more), you can't get dangerously high levels from taking small/moderate amounts.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions