"Cheese is not meant for human consumption"
Replies
-
Also completely OT (and a little dark):this entire thread has made me consider what an expansion to "A Modest Proposal" by Johnathan Swift would look like, especially if you added in today's technology.
"We could milk the mothers after we take the infants away and make delicious cheese that way we would no longer have to rely on cows."0 -
I like to think that cheese is meant for me to eat. But about an hour or so after consumption, my boyfriend begs to differ...0
-
0
-
Meant by whom?KameHameHaaaa wrote: »Someone just said this to me. I love hard cheese. But I also love a lot of things this person doesn't, as they avoid entire food groups including dairy. I also love research/studies. So... discuss.
Why is cheese meant or not meant for human consumption?
What studies are available that I can review on this topic?
Thanks.
0 -
If cheese is wrong, I don't want to be right. So many to choose from! An extra mature cheddar so strong that it makes your saliva glands ache, an ancient brie that is so runny it needs to be spooned up, wensleydale with apricots, swiss cheese slices on burgers, red leicester eaten with an apple, so much variety.
Bury me in cheeeeeesee
0 -
Sorry but mammary glands do not have intent. Milk is produced because genes for growing mammary glands and passing nutrition/energy to one's young provided an advantage in the propagation of those genes. So if milk were to have an intent or purpose, it would be to aid in the propagation of the genes of the animal that produced it.Docbanana2002 wrote: »She is probably referring to the fact that cows produce milk to feed their babies, like all mammals. Not so adult humans can make the baby into veal and then suck at mama cow's teats....
You missed the part where producing milk makes them valuable to humans, who feed them and protect them from disease and predators and ensure the propagation of cow genes. So ultimately the milk does the same thing but via a slightly more circuitous route.
Someone without an agenda might even consider it a symbiotic relationship.0 -
herrspoons wrote: »How anyone could get anything that smells like that past their nose and into their mouth and then chew it and swallow it is truly a human mystery.
I've never eaten cheese in my life. Aside from a very occasional slice of pizza where the smell and taste of the cheese is disguised by the pork toppings and the tomato sauce. And even still, it skeeves me a little.
Because it tastes awesome.
That's so wrong. It smells like extreme body odor. When it's a person, that smell is considered SOCIALLY DISGRACEFUL. When it's cheese that smell says LET'S EAT.
Do you eat fish or other seafood? Mushrooms? Yeast?0 -
Physiologically, we don't need to consume dairy. Calcium and other nutrients from dairy can easily be attained from other sources of food and drink.KameHameHaaaa wrote: »Someone just said this to me. I love hard cheese. But I also love a lot of things this person doesn't, as they avoid entire food groups including dairy. I also love research/studies. So... discuss.
Why is cheese meant or not meant for human consumption?
What studies are available that I can review on this topic?
Thanks.
That said, I'll be damned if I give up ice cream, yogurt and cheese.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
Honest question.
Based on the presumption that the only food we need to consume are foods that contain nutrients we can't get from other foods/drinks ...
Are there any foods that we NEED to consume? 'Cause I can't think of any offhand.0 -
I use wedges of parmesan under my tires in winter to keep my car from sliding out of the driveway. Of course I eat it in spring0
-
Just Bacon. Everything else is just window dressing.
Physiologically, we don't need to consume dairy. Calcium and other nutrients from dairy can easily be attained from other sources of food and drink.KameHameHaaaa wrote: »Someone just said this to me. I love hard cheese. But I also love a lot of things this person doesn't, as they avoid entire food groups including dairy. I also love research/studies. So... discuss.
Why is cheese meant or not meant for human consumption?
What studies are available that I can review on this topic?
Thanks.
That said, I'll be damned if I give up ice cream, yogurt and cheese.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
Honest question.
Based on the presumption that the only food we need to consume are foods that contain nutrients we can't get from other foods/drinks ...
Are there any foods that we NEED to consume? 'Cause I can't think of any offhand.
End thread.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
I'm a human and right now I'm munching down on a Jalepeno String Cheese stick....Nom Nom Nom. Oh, and I just finished a Greek Coconut yogurt that was as equally yummy.0
-
Marianne802 wrote: »I suppose if you look at it this way - We are the only species on earth that continue to have milk/dairy after we are weened.
Do we need it? Probably not.
Do we want it? Hell yeh!!
If it's available, many species of animals will happily drink milk or eat cheese.
Cats, dogs, mice, rats, coyotes, racoons, ...
I mean, if a horse will drink a beer from a bottle or eat a duckling - and I've seen both happen without human encouragement - isn't it clear diets are pretty much down to availability, what seems tasty, and what will/won't kill you?0 -
Let's just remember that the cheese didn't ferment and strain itself from milk products derived from farmed animals... somebody stepped in and made it and these unknown people in history will forever live in my memory as doing something much more wonderful than sliced bread ever thought of being. Sounds like it was made for human consumption to me!0
-
Analysis:
Can I eat cheese? Yes. Does cheese taste good? Yes. Do I suffer adverse effects from the consumption of cheese? Nothing apparent.
Conclusion:
Cheese is fit for consumption.
Thank you for your inquiry.
/thread0 -
If cheese is wrong, I don't want to be right. So many to choose from! An extra mature cheddar so strong that it makes your saliva glands ache, an ancient brie that is so runny it needs to be spooned up, wensleydale with apricots, swiss cheese slices on burgers, red leicester eaten with an apple, so much variety.
Bury me in cheeeeeesee
Gimme that runny brie and a spoon. Mmmmmmmmm
0 -
I have no patience for people that avoid whole categories of food. They deserve to starve. I live by the rule of Andrew Zimmern: If it looks good, eat it.0
-
There's a misconception, mostly put forth by the vegan community, that it's unnatural to consume the milk of other species. To my knowlege humans are the only species that does it however I have heard of zoo and other animal rescues crossing species to save animals, etc. However just because we are the only ones that routinely do it does not make it wrong. We have evolved to be true omnivores. I even have a problem with my fellow Paleo peeps saying our ancestors would not have drank other species milk...do you really think that if our hunter-gatherer ancesters killed a lactating animal for thier meat they would have just dumped out the milk? Nope...all part of eating nose to tail.0
-
Docbanana2002 wrote: »herrspoons wrote: »Docbanana2002 wrote: »She is probably referring to the fact that cows produce milk to feed their babies, like all mammals. Not so adult humans can make the baby into veal and then suck at mama cow's teats....
What?
Not sure if you are being sarcastic or actually confused. Assuming the latter, let me spell it out: Cheese is made from the milk of a cow (or goat). Cows don't make milk for humans, not willingly anyway. They produce it for their babies. The dairy industry operates by taking away the baby to slaughter or other uses and taking the milk for us humans.
Milk (and yogurt, cheese, other things we make from milk) is meant for baby cows. Not adult humans.
I don't think trees produce nuts for us to eat either. Those nuts are their babies. You're not eating almonds, you're eating tree babies!
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
herrspoons wrote: »How anyone could get anything that smells like that past their nose and into their mouth and then chew it and swallow it is truly a human mystery.
I've never eaten cheese in my life. Aside from a very occasional slice of pizza where the smell and taste of the cheese is disguised by the pork toppings and the tomato sauce. And even still, it skeeves me a little.
Because it tastes awesome.
That's so wrong. It smells like extreme body odor. When it's a person, that smell is considered SOCIALLY DISGRACEFUL. When it's cheese that smell says LET'S EAT.
I don't know what type of cheese you're used to, but I've never smelled cheese that's eau the body odor. Maybe your cheese rotted. you should keep it in the fridge.0 -
I like cheese. Without getting theological about the issue, I'm okay with eating it. I'm not lactose intolerant, and I've learned to manage the issues related to calorie density.
Others may feel differently, but their right to an opinion does not extend to judgment about my dining choices.0 -
Everybody is talking about how great cheese is, but nobody is talking about how awesome baby cow is as well.
Tasty, tasty veal.0 -
-
htimpaired wrote: »herrspoons wrote: »How anyone could get anything that smells like that past their nose and into their mouth and then chew it and swallow it is truly a human mystery.
I've never eaten cheese in my life. Aside from a very occasional slice of pizza where the smell and taste of the cheese is disguised by the pork toppings and the tomato sauce. And even still, it skeeves me a little.
Because it tastes awesome.
That's so wrong. It smells like extreme body odor. When it's a person, that smell is considered SOCIALLY DISGRACEFUL. When it's cheese that smell says LET'S EAT.
I don't know what type of cheese you're used to, but I've never smelled cheese that's eau the body odor. Maybe your cheese rotted. you should keep it in the fridge.
Two I can think of are sap sago and Limberger
0 -
htimpaired wrote: »herrspoons wrote: »How anyone could get anything that smells like that past their nose and into their mouth and then chew it and swallow it is truly a human mystery.
I've never eaten cheese in my life. Aside from a very occasional slice of pizza where the smell and taste of the cheese is disguised by the pork toppings and the tomato sauce. And even still, it skeeves me a little.
Because it tastes awesome.
That's so wrong. It smells like extreme body odor. When it's a person, that smell is considered SOCIALLY DISGRACEFUL. When it's cheese that smell says LET'S EAT.
I don't know what type of cheese you're used to, but I've never smelled cheese that's eau the body odor. Maybe your cheese rotted. you should keep it in the fridge.
Two I can think of are sap sago and Limberger
Note to self-don't buy sap sago or Limberger.
0 -
sorry, this is the first thing that popped into my head. XD
0 -
People weren't meant to ride in cars, ride in airplanes, use toiletries, use synthetic materials to make clothes or as building materials either.
So when all the cheesophobes start eating nothing but bark, wearing clothes made from their own hair, stop all bathing and grooming, take off their shoes, move into a mud and grass hovel, and walk everywhere barefoot, etc etc etc....
...nope, nevermind, I'm still eating cheese.0 -
I once had a friend try to argue that cows weren't natural but iPads were.
Basically, he was trying to say that cows aren't natural because we bred them to have certain qualities and they no longer resemble a wild, original cow. Then he argued that iPads are natural because they are a a tool crafted by humans, thus a natural progression.
As you can tell my friend needs to sort out which point they're going to argue rather than using both, but also that you can manipulate anything to fit either of those stances. Including cheese.0 -
sorry, this is the first thing that popped into my head. XD
Wait seriously? This is a question? It's straightforward -- people took milk with them on trips and needed something to carry it in. If you're using all the parts of the animals you're eating, the stomach becomes a logical tool to carry liquids. Milk + stomach + bouncing around = cheese. Centuries of deliciousness ensue.0 -
bettybing1 wrote: »I once had a friend try to argue that cows weren't natural but iPads were.
Basically, he was trying to say that cows aren't natural because we bred them to have certain qualities and they no longer resemble a wild, original cow. Then he argued that iPads are natural because they are a a tool crafted by humans, thus a natural progression.
As you can tell my friend needs to sort out which point they're going to argue rather than using both, but also that you can manipulate anything to fit either of those stances. Including cheese.
There is nothing more human than this sort of justification of whatever we want to justify, consistency be damned.
It's probably related to the mental skills that allowed us to decide to domesticate cows and drink their milk and make cheese.
Therefore, cheese makes us human! (But it's okay lactose intolerant folks, you are human too.)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions