St Louis area trainer posts picture of overweight fan at Cardinals game
brianpperkins
Posts: 6,124 Member
http://www.kmov.com/story/28999430/trainer-not-apologizing-for-body-shaming-woman-at-busch-stadium
A few details that show up on the trainer's facebook site that aren't in the news story (besides her food intake which she then logged on this site) ... apparently the fans originally sitting to this woman's left relocated during the game due to her infringing upon their seat after having to sit sideways. I don't agree with his methodology, but, there does need to be an honest discussion about weight ... about when one person's size starts infringing upon others ... about the societal cost of obesity ... about what is saying a condition is unhealthy in general and shaming an individual ...
A few details that show up on the trainer's facebook site that aren't in the news story (besides her food intake which she then logged on this site) ... apparently the fans originally sitting to this woman's left relocated during the game due to her infringing upon their seat after having to sit sideways. I don't agree with his methodology, but, there does need to be an honest discussion about weight ... about when one person's size starts infringing upon others ... about the societal cost of obesity ... about what is saying a condition is unhealthy in general and shaming an individual ...
0
Replies
-
Never a legitimate reason to body shame someone. Reveals far more about the person doing the shaming than about the person being shamed.0
-
lessismoreohio wrote: »Never a legitimate reason to body shame someone. Reveals far more about the person doing the shaming than about the person being shamed.
Is pointing out that being so large that they spill into adjacent seats and cause others to relocate truly shaming?
0 -
The guy definitely sounds like an *kitten* on his Facebook page in general, but his post about the people next to her having to move does not bother me. I don't know that I'd call it fat shaming, more like an observation. Reporting what she was eating? Yeah....all aboard the douche canoe. While I don't think it was necessary to post her picture, I agree that people should not have to be uncomfortable in a seat they paid for because the person next to them is sharing it with them!
ETA: The media definitely didn't need to post it all over the place. It's likely the woman would have never seen it had they not.
0 -
So I should be angry when these two obese guys tried to ride and stalled the roller coaster by a half hour because they were to big to use the seat belt?0
-
Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.0
-
Wow. I want to cry for that woman, even though her face is never shown. Does this guy think she's completely unaware of her weight?
Yes, we need to be having frank discussions about weight - with our Doctors, family, and others who care about our wellbeing. Some a-hole fat shaming a stranger on social media is not having a discussion. It's a DB being insensitive and using someone else's misfortune to his advantage. It's sickening.
At the risk of the other MFPers jumping down my throat, I'm going to use the B-word here. This guy is a bully. Plain and simple.0 -
Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.
There are some people who are unaware of their size. My 500 lb BIL insists that he is just "big boned" for example. It does happen. Not saying this excuses what the personal trainer did.
The lady should have bought two seats. Same as air travel. If you use two seats/spaces, pay for them.0 -
brianpperkins wrote: »lessismoreohio wrote: »Never a legitimate reason to body shame someone. Reveals far more about the person doing the shaming than about the person being shamed.
Is pointing out that being so large that they spill into adjacent seats and cause others to relocate truly shaming?
Yes, this is fat shaming in my opinion. Especially when a picture is posted on Facebook.
What is the value in doing this?
What does it profit the shamer?
0 -
amyrebeccah wrote: »
I don't see why you shouldn't be annoyed--angry seems like a bit of a reaction but that's your call. But I wouldn't find it appropriate to post a picture of them so their bodies can be judged and pretend like you had some kind of magnanimous purpose.yopeeps025 wrote: »So I should be angry when these two obese guys tried to ride and stalled the roller coaster by a half hour because they were to big to use the seat belt?
Well I honesty would not do that because I would be hurt if it was done to me. I am sure that my dirty looks at them two were enough. Also I don't see how they got pass the checkpoints where ride attendees check every person seat.
The ride was
at the top.
0 -
amyrebeccah wrote: »
I don't see why you shouldn't be annoyed--angry seems like a bit of a reaction but that's your call. But I wouldn't find it appropriate to post a picture of them so their bodies can be judged and pretend like you had some kind of magnanimous purpose.yopeeps025 wrote: »So I should be angry when these two obese guys tried to ride and stalled the roller coaster by a half hour because they were to big to use the seat belt?
Agreed on both counts. I really can't stand it when strangers touch me, and I do not think that being overweight makes it okay for someone to touch me when I don't want them to. My feelings are just as valid as the person in the plane or stadium or roller coaster seat and I don't like being told that it's body-shaming to expect my own body to be free from unwanted contact.
But posting a picture of someone, using them to get likes and $$ and make yourself feel like a stud, is truly disgusting. It's just bullying, nothing but.0 -
fallenoaks4 wrote: »Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.
There are some people who are unaware of their size. My 500 lb BIL insists that he is just "big boned" for example. It does happen. Not saying this excuses what the personal trainer did.
The lady should have bought two seats. Same as air travel. If you use two seats/spaces, pay for them.
When I was 225, I knew I was fat, I just had no idea how fat. Actually, it's only now, when i look at comparison pictures do i realize just how big i had let myself get.
0 -
I think most of us agree with that. Pictures tell the story.wolverine66 wrote: »fallenoaks4 wrote: »Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.
There are some people who are unaware of their size. My 500 lb BIL insists that he is just "big boned" for example. It does happen. Not saying this excuses what the personal trainer did.
The lady should have bought two seats. Same as air travel. If you use two seats/spaces, pay for them.
When I was 225, I knew I was fat, I just had no idea how fat. Actually, it's only now, when i look at comparison pictures do i realize just how big i had let myself get.
But this wasn't done out of concern, it was spite. They guy is just nasty.
0 -
wolverine66 wrote: »fallenoaks4 wrote: »Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.
There are some people who are unaware of their size. My 500 lb BIL insists that he is just "big boned" for example. It does happen. Not saying this excuses what the personal trainer did.
The lady should have bought two seats. Same as air travel. If you use two seats/spaces, pay for them.
When I was 225, I knew I was fat, I just had no idea how fat. Actually, it's only now, when i look at comparison pictures do i realize just how big i had let myself get.
agree. There is a reason why my center pic is what it is. My picture of me at my highest weight ever.
0 -
What makes me sad is you also never know someone's journey. Maybe that person has already lost 100 pounds, or had an extreme medical condition that made them gain, or as some of us have been, we knew we were heavy, but not "that" heavy.0
-
What else is sad is that if you read some of the comments on his Facebook page, people go off on him for body shaming, and follow it up with "curves are beautiful, sticks are not". Way to make your whole argument invalid.0
-
I think most of us agree with that. Pictures tell the story.wolverine66 wrote: »fallenoaks4 wrote: »Was the trainer concerned perhaps that the fan was unaware of their size? If there were inconvenienced fans, shouldn't it have been dealt with there rather than publishing the incident? When I was at my largest, should I have deferred air travel until I could fit in the seats without infringing on my neighbours? Don't laugh. I have acquaintances that pretty well turned themselves in to shut-ins because of the shame.
There are some people who are unaware of their size. My 500 lb BIL insists that he is just "big boned" for example. It does happen. Not saying this excuses what the personal trainer did.
The lady should have bought two seats. Same as air travel. If you use two seats/spaces, pay for them.
When I was 225, I knew I was fat, I just had no idea how fat. Actually, it's only now, when i look at comparison pictures do i realize just how big i had let myself get.
But this wasn't done out of concern, it was spite. They guy is just nasty.
I was specifically commenting on the notion that this woman knows how big she is. She might not.
That doesn't make what the trainer did justified. It doesn't.
It's totally possible (if not likely) we have an inconsiderate and/or oblivious big woman AND a douche trainer guy showcasing his douchiness.0 -
I_Will_End_You wrote: »What else is sad is that if you read some of the comments on his Facebook page, people go off on him for body shaming, and follow it up with "curves are beautiful, sticks are not". Way to make your whole argument invalid.
It's like the people lambasting him for judging then judging him ... logical consistency is not one of Facebook's strong points.0 -
Wow. I want to cry for that woman, even though her face is never shown. Does this guy think she's completely unaware of her weight?
Yes, we need to be having frank discussions about weight - with our Doctors, family, and others who care about our wellbeing. Some a-hole fat shaming a stranger on social media is not having a discussion. It's a DB being insensitive and using someone else's misfortune to his advantage. It's sickening.
At the risk of the other MFPers jumping down my throat, I'm going to use the B-word here. This guy is a bully. Plain and simple.
Agree with all this.I_Will_End_You wrote: »The guy definitely sounds like an *kitten* on his Facebook page in general, but his post about the people next to her having to move does not bother me. I don't know that I'd call it fat shaming, more like an observation. Reporting what she was eating? Yeah....all aboard the douche canoe. While I don't think it was necessary to post her picture, I agree that people should not have to be uncomfortable in a seat they paid for because the person next to them is sharing it with them!
ETA: The media definitely didn't need to post it all over the place. It's likely the woman would have never seen it had they not.
And with this.
I'm embarrassed, living in St. Louis, that this guy breathes some of the same air as me.
I think he was trolling and sensationalizing and I think it is going to come back and kill his business.
0 -
http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.0 -
Oh I need to read this.bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
0 -
I_Will_End_You wrote: »What else is sad is that if you read some of the comments on his Facebook page, people go off on him for body shaming, and follow it up with "curves are beautiful, sticks are not". Way to make your whole argument invalid.
I didn't look at his Facebook page but the comments of people from the KMOV article are laughable. I swear, the opportunity to post semi-anonymously on the internet just brings out the stupid in some people. Oh, wait... hang on. Nevermind.
0 -
How dare he! That is awful, does he think she should sit indoors and not be seen?0
-
Wow. That was amazing.bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
What a great response. So proud of her.
0 -
amyrebeccah wrote: »
You won't be sorry. She kicks *kitten* and I just hope she knows how awesome she is.
Oh I need to read this.bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
Says she's on MFP. She might be reading this thread right now!
0 -
I hope so! I want to friend her!amyrebeccah wrote: »
You won't be sorry. She kicks *kitten* and I just hope she knows how awesome she is.
Oh I need to read this.bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
Says she's on MFP. She might be reading this thread right now!
0 -
bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
Wow what an awesome response!!
0 -
Her response, and the link to the Women's Health article is awesome.
Beverly, if you do find yourself in this thread, way to go, not only for taking such a proactive approach to your weight loss, but for having the balls to put that idiot in his place.
ETA - Go Cards!
0 -
Wow. I want to cry for that woman, even though her face is never shown. Does this guy think she's completely unaware of her weight?
Yes, we need to be having frank discussions about weight - with our Doctors, family, and others who care about our wellbeing. Some a-hole fat shaming a stranger on social media is not having a discussion. It's a DB being insensitive and using someone else's misfortune to his advantage. It's sickening.
At the risk of the other MFPers jumping down my throat, I'm going to use the B-word here. This guy is a bully. Plain and simple.
Agree with all this.I_Will_End_You wrote: »The guy definitely sounds like an *kitten* on his Facebook page in general, but his post about the people next to her having to move does not bother me. I don't know that I'd call it fat shaming, more like an observation. Reporting what she was eating? Yeah....all aboard the douche canoe. While I don't think it was necessary to post her picture, I agree that people should not have to be uncomfortable in a seat they paid for because the person next to them is sharing it with them!
ETA: The media definitely didn't need to post it all over the place. It's likely the woman would have never seen it had they not.
And with this.
I'm embarrassed, living in St. Louis, that this guy breathes some of the same air as me.
I think he was trolling and sensationalizing and I think it is going to come back and kill his business.
Agree with this, To me Troll all the way,, in the end his business will suffer
0 -
I'll chime in because I am a big girl. I see both sides here. What the trainer did was rude and hurtful. However, (and I am not excusing him here) when you are out in public, everyone is fair game. Is it nice? No. Is it fair? no. There are mean people out there so get used to it. Grow some thick skin. He did pixel out her face and not post her name however, there are other ways to make the point he was making. I, like another person posted on here, was not aware of how big I am (or was, 245 down to 210 and yes I know I am still big) and yeah its a little disconcerting that you spill over into other seats. I hope this is a wake up call for her to get some professional help if she isn't already working with someone. And I hope it is a wake up call to him not to be such a insensitive jerk.0
-
bingo_jenn wrote: »http://theantijared.com/2015/05/i-was-the-so-called-unhealthy-fat-woman-at-the-cardinals-game-2.html
I just found this on his FB page with her response. Haven't finished reading it yet.
Strong and inspirational woman. Good for her!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions