Keep gaining weight but doing everything right
Replies
-
diannethegeek wrote: »
EXACTLY! Literally 4 pages of USEFUL information, but WHY focus on the useful information when we can deflect and start a mean people thread!? Friday came early!
0 -
I've lost weight before, when it was needed before competition etc. I've done it several times and haven't done anything different than now.
Of course I check exactly how much I eat, I prepare my portions for every meal each day. I don't just throw random things into a smoothie.
I wrote this post to see if there is anyone with medical conditions who have had a hard time or some who have gone through something similar.
Also, I eat fish and vegetables because I can stand them. A lot of food make me nauseous. I'm not American, I know what a normal portion size is. I grew up in Sweden where people are a normal size and live a very healthy lifestyle.
Why I don't give a number of calories I am eating is because I don't always eat the same amount to one calorie every day.
I've lost weight rapidly before even by only cutting sugar entirely, so it isn't only calories, even though that is what I am usually doing, with fat, protein and carb in mind as well, as well as I haven't logged my food for two weeks now as I have also mentioned.
Also, I haven't gained weight for awhile now, I said it was when I did extensive workouts last summer, now my weight just isn't dropping.
How do you make out that if you eat a specific diet, no exercise and maintain weight. Then you add exercise and no loss in weight.
There have been times my coach has told me I need to eat more when I have almost fainted after 4 hours training, because I've only taken in liquid nutrition.
It isn't just as simple as in and out. I do high performance sports and it is hard to find a balance, especially if you get sick from food constantly.
Anyway thanks for all the same messages, I think we can stop it here.
@mccindy72 great that is works for you. I have just started with those restrictions and I am constantly bad and get even worse when I go exercising. Still trying to adjust it.
But I am someone with medical conditions who has had a hard time and has gone through something similar. and it is as simple as in and out. I have had times when I could exercise, and have burned hundreds to a thousand or more calories in a day, and still had the ability to find the balance.
To say to me, that it's great that it works for me is rather rude. I'm trying to help you, considering I fit all the conditions of who you are trying to reach out to and proof of what works. We aren't special from anyone else. Despite what you want to believe, despite our food restrictions and issues, we still have to weigh our food and count our calories. The exercise and food issues don't affect our weight, the food intake does.0 -
Well for once, I am on FODMAP because I am also taking medication for IBS. I'm in the uk so I don't pay for my visits to the gp/hospital.
I've always had it easy to gain muscle as well. I've been very athletic throughout my younger years and I'm closer to Serena than Sharapova in body type.
What I tried to say was simply that I know what foods are good or bad to weight loss in general.
I'm going to continue the FODMAP as I haven't for too long yet and see if I can see a change.
I don't believe I am a special snowflake whatever that is supposed to mean?
If you overeat these "good foods" to the point of being in a calorie surplus, you'll still gain weight.
I'd wager that if you had recorded everything on MFP rather than Fitbit (so we could see it), we'd see that you either weren't being consistent or/and you were eyeballing a lot of things.0 -
I've lost weight before, when it was needed before competition etc. I've done it several times and haven't done anything different than now.
Of course I check exactly how much I eat, I prepare my portions for every meal each day. I don't just throw random things into a smoothie.
I wrote this post to see if there is anyone with medical conditions who have had a hard time or some who have gone through something similar.
Also, I eat fish and vegetables because I can stand them. A lot of food make me nauseous. I'm not American, I know what a normal portion size is. I grew up in Sweden where people are a normal size and live a very healthy lifestyle.
Why I don't give a number of calories I am eating is because I don't always eat the same amount to one calorie every day.
I've lost weight rapidly before even by only cutting sugar entirely, so it isn't only calories, even though that is what I am usually doing, with fat, protein and carb in mind as well, as well as I haven't logged my food for two weeks now as I have also mentioned.
Also, I haven't gained weight for awhile now, I said it was when I did extensive workouts last summer, now my weight just isn't dropping.
How do you make out that if you eat a specific diet, no exercise and maintain weight. Then you add exercise and no loss in weight.
There have been times my coach has told me I need to eat more when I have almost fainted after 4 hours training, because I've only taken in liquid nutrition.
It isn't just as simple as in and out. I do high performance sports and it is hard to find a balance, especially if you get sick from food constantly.
Anyway thanks for all the same messages, I think we can stop it here.
@mccindy72 great that is works for you. I have just started with those restrictions and I am constantly bad and get even worse when I go exercising. Still trying to adjust it.
The passive aggression is strong with this one....wow.It isn't as simple as in and out
Sorry, with weight loss yes....yes it is. If you're not in a defcit, you won't lose weight. If you're not in a surplus you won't gain weight.
For health, nutrition, satiety and performance...yes your calories matter, but not weight loss.
But I'm American, so what do I know about nutrition, am I right?
Right? No such thing as a fat person from Sweden :indifferent:0 -
Has anyone suggested yet that you are probably eating more than you think?
Cause that's probably it.0 -
Sounds like the majority is saying she's eating too much. So I won't add my two cents.0
-
Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.0
-
3dogsrunning wrote: »Has anyone suggested yet that you are probably eating more than you think?
Cause that's probably it.
Impossible! Because from Sweden....0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.
Except there's pro ping pong so...0 -
PikaKnight wrote: »I've lost weight before, when it was needed before competition etc. I've done it several times and haven't done anything different than now.
Of course I check exactly how much I eat, I prepare my portions for every meal each day. I don't just throw random things into a smoothie.
I wrote this post to see if there is anyone with medical conditions who have had a hard time or some who have gone through something similar.
Also, I eat fish and vegetables because I can stand them. A lot of food make me nauseous. I'm not American, I know what a normal portion size is. I grew up in Sweden where people are a normal size and live a very healthy lifestyle.
Why I don't give a number of calories I am eating is because I don't always eat the same amount to one calorie every day.
I've lost weight rapidly before even by only cutting sugar entirely, so it isn't only calories, even though that is what I am usually doing, with fat, protein and carb in mind as well, as well as I haven't logged my food for two weeks now as I have also mentioned.
Also, I haven't gained weight for awhile now, I said it was when I did extensive workouts last summer, now my weight just isn't dropping.
How do you make out that if you eat a specific diet, no exercise and maintain weight. Then you add exercise and no loss in weight.
There have been times my coach has told me I need to eat more when I have almost fainted after 4 hours training, because I've only taken in liquid nutrition.
It isn't just as simple as in and out. I do high performance sports and it is hard to find a balance, especially if you get sick from food constantly.
Anyway thanks for all the same messages, I think we can stop it here.
@mccindy72 great that is works for you. I have just started with those restrictions and I am constantly bad and get even worse when I go exercising. Still trying to adjust it.
The passive aggression is strong with this one....wow.It isn't as simple as in and out
Sorry, with weight loss yes....yes it is. If you're not in a defcit, you won't lose weight. If you're not in a surplus you won't gain weight.
For health, nutrition, satiety and performance...yes your calories matter, but not weight loss.
But I'm American, so what do I know about nutrition, am I right?
Right? No such thing as a fat person from Sweden :indifferent:
They're all born with degrees as registered dietitians.0 -
I've lost weight before, when it was needed before competition etc. I've done it several times and haven't done anything different than now.
Of course I check exactly how much I eat, I prepare my portions for every meal each day. I don't just throw random things into a smoothie.
I wrote this post to see if there is anyone with medical conditions who have had a hard time or some who have gone through something similar.
Also, I eat fish and vegetables because I can stand them. A lot of food make me nauseous. I'm not American, I know what a normal portion size is. I grew up in Sweden where people are a normal size and live a very healthy lifestyle.
Why I don't give a number of calories I am eating is because I don't always eat the same amount to one calorie every day.
I've lost weight rapidly before even by only cutting sugar entirely, so it isn't only calories, even though that is what I am usually doing, with fat, protein and carb in mind as well, as well as I haven't logged my food for two weeks now as I have also mentioned.
Also, I haven't gained weight for awhile now, I said it was when I did extensive workouts last summer, now my weight just isn't dropping.
How do you make out that if you eat a specific diet, no exercise and maintain weight. Then you add exercise and no loss in weight.
There have been times my coach has told me I need to eat more when I have almost fainted after 4 hours training, because I've only taken in liquid nutrition.
It isn't just as simple as in and out. I do high performance sports and it is hard to find a balance, especially if you get sick from food constantly.
Anyway thanks for all the same messages, I think we can stop it here.
You don't have an understanding of what healthy is at all.
And the blasphemy you are suggesting in that Science CAN be altered.
Oh, please!
You claim you take in different amounts of calories each day but even if it was a small range, you obviously went over your TDEE by enough to gain that weight. Cutting out sugar works because sugar is calories and reducing the amount you take in relative to the amount you burn helps you lose weight.
0 -
Op,I'm pretty sure you are the only one being nasty on this thread. With that being said,good luck.0
-
PikaKnight wrote: »enterdanger wrote: »Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.
Except there's pro ping pong so...
I didn't know that. See MFP. No day you learn something is wasted. I just keep thinking of that Balls of Fury movie.
(edited to fix my dyslexic typing)0 -
No, I ate between 1500-1800 because that is exactly what this app also suggests and every single nutritionist on earth.
There you go, happy now.
You met them all, really?
And they all said the exact same thing? . . . let's just cool our jets here.
You said you're searching for people with medical conditions to see if they've had the same experience buuuuuuut you've been tested who knows how many times for anything and everything that's ever happened to anyone on earth and yet you said the results all came back as nothing is wrong.
So is it possible . . . maybe just a little bit . . . stay with me here, that you're just plain eating too much and not burning nearly as much as you thought?
Just a thought . . .0 -
Both ping pong and badminton are Olympic sports. However, in order to compete in the Olympics you have to maintain amateur status.............
Although if OP is at that level I'd expect them to have dietary help from their team, which will include their coach, doctors, dieticians, physios etc. I'd also hope an elite athlete would have a better grasp of basic physiology, I was certainly taught it at dance school but you know, I'm just a mean person who is mean.0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.
Hellllooooooooooooooo! Ping Pong is a pro sport! Look at Forrest Gump! Not to mention Balls of Fury! *is offended!*0 -
Yeah, but curling is also an olympic sport and have you seen those dudes? I wouldn't call them athletes.0
-
@acorsaut89 Depends on what level you play it. Like I said, I play both tennis and badminton and competitively. There is such a thing as pro badminton and I am doing it, only because it isn't as prestigious as tennis doesn't make it less real. I have sacrificed much to get to where I am and I also love it. There are a lot of training outside of badminton as well, like I mentioned, I swim and run and do weight training in addition, as of course badminton doesn't provide for everything.
@mccindy72 if you are taking it as an insult that is on you. I was genuinely happy for you that you found a good combo of things you can eat, not for the weight-loss but to relieve the IBS. As I said, I just started fodmap and need to adjust to it. I love broccoli and now I have to leave it out. Not sure how that is rude but sure whatever.0 -
If I can manage on 1000 cals a day I can cut out 500, but I hope I won't get dizzy again, that is all.
I'll see how it works for a while, thanks @rabbitjb
Unless you have a serious thyroid condition there is no way that your calculation of eating 1500-1800 calories (gross I assume) and your exercise is accurate
But I think if you address it with a whole new enthusiasm, even if it's just to prove us wrong
Logging everything properly ...pleas read the calorie counting link I posted earlier...lots of entries in the MFP food database are wrong...the fitbit database is worse0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.
It's somewhat more cardio intensive, I'm sure even more so on a competitive level.
I can remember chasing the ol' shuttlecock around in gym class back in middle/high school, and recall I'd work up a pretty good sweat doing it.0 -
I KNOW EVERYTHING THAT I'M DOING IS RIGHT BUT IT'S NOT WORKING SO TELL ME WHY IT'S NOT WORKING BUT GOD HELP YOU IF YOU TRY TO SAY I'M DOING SOMETHING WRONG.0
-
^^ thisDeguelloTex wrote: »If you're gaining weight over time, you're eating over maintenance level.
0 -
enterdanger wrote: »PikaKnight wrote: »enterdanger wrote: »Ok. I didn't really read this since all these "why am I gaining weight" threads are the same, but are we sure this is for real. Is there really such a thing as Pro Badminton? That's actually kind of funny. I'm sure this is offensive, but in my mind badminton is in the same sports category as ping pong.
Except there's pro ping pong so...
I didn't know that. See MFP. No day you learn something is wasted. I just keep thinking of that Balls of Fury movie.
(edited to fix my dyslexic typing)
:laugh: Forgot about that movie!0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Yeah, but curling is also an olympic sport and have you seen those dudes? I wouldn't call them athletes.
The stones weigh in the neighborhood of 40 lbs each.
To carry those, while on ice, I would imagine requires a few athletic skills (strength, balance, etc)0 -
Just checking to see if the OP is still refusing to open her diary, or as how many calories she eats.0
-
-
AllonsYtotheTardis wrote: »Just checking to see if the OP is still refusing to open her diary, or as how many calories she eats.
She said she logged her food on Fitbit so she can't open her diary.0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Yeah, but curling is also an olympic sport and have you seen those dudes? I wouldn't call them athletes.
You obviously haven't seen Russia's Womens Curling team at last year's Olympics!!
0 -
AllonsYtotheTardis wrote: »Just checking to see if the OP is still refusing to open her diary, or as how many calories she eats.
Well, it's apparently somewhere in the neighborhood of 1500-1800 calories but they're logged in her FitBit so we can't see them.0 -
AllonsYtotheTardis wrote: »Just checking to see if the OP is still refusing to open her diary, or as how many calories she eats.
We got a calorie range on pg 4, but she still mostly refuses to give us details or answer questions that might help.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions