Viewing the message boards in:

Oreos: The greatest packaged cookie of all time

1235754

Replies

  • Posts: 2,018 Member
    Carlos_421 wrote: »
    It was decided in another thread that a discussion around Oreos is in order so here goes.

    First, the original Oreos are perfect. No other variety comes close. They have the perfect ratio of cream to cookie and the cookies 'n cream flavor is perfect just the way it is.

    Now, if you're at someone else's house and all they have is double stuff, the good news is that while these are entirely subpar to the original, they are still fabulously delicious in a distant second place. The same can be said for peanut butter and brownie batter.

    Also, Jugg is wrong because mint Oreos are disgusting sacrilege.

    I disagree! I'll be the minority in saying that Archer Farm's gingerbread cookies OR Girl Scout Samoa cookies are the BEST of all time! :)
  • Posts: 127 Member
    Francl27 wrote: »

    Omg those waffles in the back look delicious.

    They are....eating them right now lol

  • Posts: 4,374 Member
    Francl27 wrote: »

    Blasphemy.
    It's like they don't love Christmas

  • Posts: 5,133 Member

    I disagree! I'll be the minority in saying that Archer Farm's gingerbread cookies OR Girl Scout Samoa cookies are the BEST of all time! :)

    Jesus loves you even though you're wrong.
  • Posts: 5,798 Member
    Birthday cake oreos are best oreos. I would sell off my firtborn for a package.
  • Posts: 505 Member
    pj9mih1ztgzw.jpg

    These are awesome, have a few every night as my treat! With the thins I like the Golden better. :)
  • Posts: 119 Member
    Agreed. The original oreos are amazeballs and I save calories so that I can have a few every night while I watch one of my shows. Popcorn + Oreos = My favorite time of the day.
  • This content has been removed.
  • Posts: 7,833 Member
    Francl27 wrote: »

    These would be a waste of tasty Oreo creme for me. I don't like Chips Ahoy at all.

    But I still prefer the Red Velvet and Cinnamon Oreos to the original ones. And the S'moreos were tasty too (RIP).

    How in the hell did I forget about the Smoreos?!
  • Posts: 127 Member
    Birthday cake oreos are best oreos. I would sell off my firtborn for a package.

    They are IMO. I tried a sh1tload of different flavors when I went to Japan (they have a ton of different flavors)....I mean they were all really good, but I really like the birthday cake ones. Followed by the green tea, cookies n' cream then the white chocolate macadamia flavors.
  • Posts: 6,212 Member
    Is it just me, or is MFP full of Quest Bar and Oreo shills?

    It's just you






    This post sponsored by....COOKIES AND CREAM QUEST BARS

    500005-Quest-Nutrition-Quest-Bar-Cookies-Cream.jpg
  • Posts: 335 Member
    glassyo wrote: »

    How in the hell did I forget about the Smoreos?!

    I forgot about them, too! They were my favorite of the "flavored" Oreos! I stand corrected. Cinnamon bun is my second favorite so far. :smile:
  • Posts: 7,739 Member
    elite_nal wrote: »

    They are IMO. I tried a sh1tload of different flavors when I went to Japan (they have a ton of different flavors)....I mean they were all really good, but I really like the birthday cake ones. Followed by the green tea, cookies n' cream then the white chocolate macadamia flavors.



    I like green tea, but - Green Tea Oreos? That just sounds nasty. Kinda like when I tried the green tea fried ice cream from one of the local Thai restaurants. Big mistake.
  • Posts: 1,382 Member
    This thread is 5 pages of awesomeness!!!!!
  • Posts: 7,833 Member
    In for the gifs.

    And the oreos.

    And the Quest bars.

    And that waffle cookie thingy.
  • Posts: 7,833 Member

    I forgot about them, too! They were my favorite of the "flavored" Oreos! I stand corrected. Cinnamon bun is my second favorite so far. :smile:

    They could stop coming out with new flavors and the oreo thins (original or golden) will continue to make me happy throughout the rest of my life.

    I'm looking forward to the birthday cake flavor in my stash. I'm not sure about the gingerbread but I heard it was more of a subtle taste so that'll work. :)

    And they should bring back the smoreos for real!

    (Also, the lemon and lemon twist oreos were actually pretty good. Cotton candy...not so much.)
  • Posts: 160 Member
    Oh, man, this might be my favorite thread on here. I LOVE Oreos and admit to a very unhealthy addiction to them.

    Seriously.

    You should see my pantry right now - we have probably 6-8 packages of Oreos, of all varieties. Regular, double stuf, the new Cinnamon Bun ones, Red Velvet, Cookies & Cream, and Berry Burst - these are all flavors I know we currently have in there. Every time they come out with a new flavor, we get a package to try it. Brownie Batter was hands down MY FAVORITE. Oh my word - so good.

    They have a new one coming out next week - it is supposed to be like a Hostess Cupcake.

    Oreos are definitely my "guilty pleasure" food and the one I go to when I WANT SUGAR AND I WANT IT NOW, which fortunately doesn't happen too often.
  • Posts: 101 Member

    It's just you






    This post sponsored by....COOKIES AND CREAM QUEST BARS

    500005-Quest-Nutrition-Quest-Bar-Cookies-Cream.jpg

    I may have snort-laffed at this.
  • Posts: 1 Member
    the oreo.. aka the sandwich cookie. many are delicious, but one stands high above the rest.
    Dare's Maple Cream from Canada. i have a patent in the sandwich cookie industry, I've seen these come out of a machine at 3600/minute..
  • Posts: 6,212 Member
    jaynee7283 wrote: »
    Oh, man, this might be my favorite thread on here. I LOVE Oreos and admit to a very unhealthy addiction to them.

    Seriously.

    You should see my pantry right now - we have probably 6-8 packages of Oreos, of all varieties. Regular, double stuf, the new Cinnamon Bun ones, Red Velvet, Cookies & Cream, and Berry Burst - these are all flavors I know we currently have in there. Every time they come out with a new flavor, we get a package to try it. Brownie Batter was hands down MY FAVORITE. Oh my word - so good.

    They have a new one coming out next week - it is supposed to be like a Hostess Cupcake.

    Oreos are definitely my "guilty pleasure" food and the one I go to when I WANT SUGAR AND I WANT IT NOW, which fortunately doesn't happen too often.

    Redundant flavor seems redundant.
  • Posts: 441 Member
    i love everything about this entire discussion. Oreos ftw. Original > Double Stuf bc the DS don't seem to soak as well in milk and well, that's just unacceptable.
  • Posts: 5,377 Member

    It's just you


    This post sponsored by....COOKIES AND CREAM QUEST BARS

    500005-Quest-Nutrition-Quest-Bar-Cookies-Cream.jpg

    Oddly, I like cookies and creme flavored things like Quest bars and protein shakes, but I don't really like Oreos. This thread is making me think about getting out an Cookies and Creme Quest bar though.
  • Posts: 809 Member

    It's just you






    This post sponsored by....COOKIES AND CREAM QUEST BARS

    500005-Quest-Nutrition-Quest-Bar-Cookies-Cream.jpg

    Gold star for your exemplary performance, sir.
  • Posts: 5,133 Member
    the oreo.. aka the sandwich cookie. many are delicious, but one stands high above the rest.
    Dare's Maple Cream from Canada. i have a patent in the sandwich cookie industry, I've seen these come out of a machine at 3600/minute..

    Oreo = technically a sandwich cookie
    any other sandwich cookie =/= Oreo

    And no other packaged cookie, none, is as good as Oreos.
  • Posts: 60 Member
    edited February 2016
    I'm gonna get so much hate but I LOVE OREOS...without the cream. The filling is just too sweet and the texture is so grainy.

    But that cookie part though...they need to sell that by themselves <3
  • Posts: 790 Member
    I'm gonna get so much hate but I LOVE OREOS...without the cream. The filling is just too sweet and the texture is so grainy.

    But that cookie part though...they need to sell that by themselves <3

    So the plan is, we hang out, I twist off half the cookies of the Double Stuf Oreos and give them to you, and I get my Quadruple Stuf Oreos without wasting anything. Deal?
  • Posts: 6,212 Member
    richln wrote: »

    Gold star for your exemplary performance, sir.

    43b6744e64363d471aa0bef695330bdc54b52514353e2435161cedd3f6bd4386.jpg
  • Posts: 456 Member
    CooCooPuff wrote: »
    This thread needs more ice cream.
    oreo_sandwich.png
    I've been meaning to pick up some Blue Bell cookies and cream.

    My husband loves that ice cream and oddly enough is not a oreo's fan, he will eat cookies and cream ice cream, just not the oreos.
    elite_nal wrote: »
    Best! Got a few of these when I went to Japan. Also, a green tea flavored Kit Kat...but already killed it.
    0n3ks6h3o6qa.jpg

    On the note of Japanese oreos, they are different than the American counter parts. I had the strawberry ones, want to try the green tea, but unfortunately most of them contain dairy. :(

  • Posts: 15,357 Member
    WinoGelato wrote: »
    I give you...

    oreo-truffles31-copy.jpg

    This is what I came to say.
  • Posts: 15,357 Member

    Unfortunately no ;-)

    Lies. How can you go for cookies that lie?!
This discussion has been closed.