water fasting
Replies
-
No thanks, that sounds like a huge waste of time. If i were to spend an hour completely explaining it, provide peer reviewed medical studies, and show examples of people who have improved their lives through water fasting, it still wouldn't change your opinion. You didn't come in here to be enlightened, and we both know it.
Ignorance. You don't see the point, but there is one.
Taking supplements would not be fasting. And taking supplements during a fast is not necessary. It's helpful to have a lead in diet, for a few days before the fast, with a lot of micro-nutrient rich food.Are you taking any supplements with it? I heard that you can get pretty sick doing a just water fast without any vitamins for an extended amount of time.
Or. You could just eat food and not do a pointless water fast.
Enlighten me, please0 -
No thanks, that sounds like a huge waste of time. If i were to spend an hour completely explaining it, provide peer reviewed medical studies, and show examples of people who have improved their lives through water fasting, it still wouldn't change your opinion. You didn't come in here to be enlightened, and we both know it.
Ignorance. You don't see the point, but there is one.
Taking supplements would not be fasting. And taking supplements during a fast is not necessary. It's helpful to have a lead in diet, for a few days before the fast, with a lot of micro-nutrient rich food.Are you taking any supplements with it? I heard that you can get pretty sick doing a just water fast without any vitamins for an extended amount of time.
Or. You could just eat food and not do a pointless water fast.
Enlighten me, please
Ok then.0 -
No thanks, that sounds like a huge waste of time. If i were to spend an hour completely explaining it, provide peer reviewed medical studies, and show examples of people who have improved their lives through water fasting, it still wouldn't change your opinion. You didn't come in here to be enlightened, and we both know it.
Ignorance. You don't see the point, but there is one.
Taking supplements would not be fasting. And taking supplements during a fast is not necessary. It's helpful to have a lead in diet, for a few days before the fast, with a lot of micro-nutrient rich food.Are you taking any supplements with it? I heard that you can get pretty sick doing a just water fast without any vitamins for an extended amount of time.
Or. You could just eat food and not do a pointless water fast.
Enlighten me, please
0 -
I am aiming for 52 days done research and plenty of people have done this long plus i finding fasting pretty easy0
-
I am aiming for 52 days done research and plenty of people have done this long plus i finding fasting pretty easy
You are going to water fast for 52 days...am I reading that correctly?0 -
My best friend is a personal trainer and is joining the marines he said doing a fast is fine i have an 18 month old son and he says its fine as long as i font over do it if anyone wants to try a fast j suggest a juice fast first before doing a water fast so you get an idea of how hard it is every individual has different experience with fasting look it up and check out videos on youtube x0
-
No thanks, that sounds like a huge waste of time. If i were to spend an hour completely explaining it, provide peer reviewed medical studies, and show examples of people who have improved their lives through water fasting, it still wouldn't change your opinion. You didn't come in here to be enlightened, and we both know it.
Ignorance. You don't see the point, but there is one.
Taking supplements would not be fasting. And taking supplements during a fast is not necessary. It's helpful to have a lead in diet, for a few days before the fast, with a lot of micro-nutrient rich food.Are you taking any supplements with it? I heard that you can get pretty sick doing a just water fast without any vitamins for an extended amount of time.
Or. You could just eat food and not do a pointless water fast.
Enlighten me, please
^^nice. Promoting starvation while having an 18 month old child to look after. You should be ashamed of yourself. You have no idea what 'research' the OP had done and did not even deign to get any facts whatsoever, yet you encouraged it. Shame on you.I am aiming for 52 days done research and plenty of people have done this long plus i finding fasting pretty easy0 -
My best friend is a personal trainer and is joining the marines he said doing a fast is fine i have an 18 month old son and he says its fine as long as i font over do it if anyone wants to try a fast j suggest a juice fast first before doing a water fast so you get an idea of how hard it is every individual has different experience with fasting look it up and check out videos on youtube x
Its ridiculous and irresponsible.0 -
Yes you read it correctly if you don't agree with fasting than just don't comment this page is for people who are curious and might want to give it ago not for people to say its wrong if its so wrong why can doctors recommend the diet to people and monitor people they would tell you not to not help you with the fast j suggest anyone who doesn't no about fasts looks them up and does there research Jesus done a 40 day fast Ghandi done a 21 day fast0
-
My best friend is a personal trainer and is joining the marines he said doing a fast is fine i have an 18 month old son and he says its fine as long as i font over do it if anyone wants to try a fast j suggest a juice fast first before doing a water fast so you get an idea of how hard it is every individual has different experience with fasting look it up and check out videos on youtube x
Its ridiculous and irresponsible.
Oh my god. Please don't listen to your marine buddy. Seriously. He has no idea what he is talking about. You need to talk to a doctor and a registered dietitian before you even attempt something like this. Bad. Idea.0 -
Im on a water fast ive done juice fasts and now am doing a water fast if anyone else is doing a fast let me know and we can compare fasts and weight loss xx
i. smell. a. troll.0 -
Yes you read it correctly if you don't agree with fasting than just don't comment this page is for people who are curious and might want to give it ago not for people to say its wrong if its so wrong why can doctors recommend the diet to people and monitor people they would tell you not to not help you with the fast j suggest anyone who doesn't no about fasts looks them up and does there research Jesus done a 40 day fast Ghandi done a 21 day fast
Is there anyone that can check in on you daily and take care of your son?0 -
I am aiming for 52 days done research and plenty of people have done this long plus i finding fasting pretty easy
Pretty sure this will result in death :huh:0 -
Yes you read it correctly if you don't agree with fasting than just don't comment this page is for people who are curious and might want to give it ago not for people to say its wrong if its so wrong why can doctors recommend the diet to people and monitor people they would tell you not to not help you with the fast j suggest anyone who doesn't no about fasts looks them up and does there research Jesus done a 40 day fast Ghandi done a 21 day fast
No...it's an open forum so we have every right to comments and its actually against the rules to promote unsafe diet practices.
BTW - some of Ghandi's followers died doing fasts. Plus, you are not Jesus, and you mentioned doing a 52 day fast.
Your logic and excuses are very telling.0 -
Water fasting... please. I do vodka fasting. Much better results.
^ in sufficient quantities it's a natural purgative.
I only do it when I'm doing a cut. Or bored. Or lonely.
I usually cry during extended vodka fasts too, it helps flush out the toxins in my life.0 -
My best friend is a personal trainer and is joining the marines he said doing a fast is fine i have an 18 month old son and he says its fine as long as i font over do it if anyone wants to try a fast j suggest a juice fast first before doing a water fast so you get an idea of how hard it is every individual has different experience with fasting look it up and check out videos on youtube x
Its ridiculous and irresponsible.
Oh my god. Please don't listen to your marine buddy. Seriously. He has no idea what he is talking about. You need to talk to a doctor and a registered dietitian before you even attempt something like this. Bad. Idea.
This ^
I am studying to become a personal trainer and nothing says anything about fasting (water/juice/etc.) being a good thing.0 -
Long term extreme fasts are only ever safe if your regularly being monitored by a doctor . So consult one before you start otherwise, you know, death is a likely outcome.0
-
I am aiming for 52 days done research and plenty of people have done this long plus i finding fasting pretty easy
Pretty sure this will result in death :huh:
But isn't that the ultimate weigh loss strategy? The will never gain it back either.0 -
Lol, but jesus had god in his corner.:laugh: And have you ever seen pictures of Ghandi? I believe in fasting, but not for long periods of time. Long fasts slow metabolic rate significantly and catabolize lean tissue.Yes you read it correctly if you don't agree with fasting than just don't comment this page is for people who are curious and might want to give it ago not for people to say its wrong if its so wrong why can doctors recommend the diet to people and monitor people they would tell you not to not help you with the fast j suggest anyone who doesn't no about fasts looks them up and does there research Jesus done a 40 day fast Ghandi done a 21 day fast
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Yes i have consulted my doctor i have weekly appointment to check blood pressure heart rate and everything else in not doing any thing wrong here my husband is here during the day to help with my son ive done everything right consulted my doctor made sure there's someone else here during the day to help.me out i drink green tea as well as water for the caffeine to give me energy lots of people do fasts if you font agree wit my fast that's fine but don't say in a bad mum and promoting starvation that's really not nice and i don't appreciate someone i don't even no commenting on my parenting skills0
-
Yes i have consulted my doctor i have weekly appointment to check blood pressure heart rate and everything else in not doing any thing wrong here my husband is here during the day to help with my son ive done everything right consulted my doctor made sure there's someone else here during the day to help.me out i drink green tea as well as water for the caffeine to give me energy lots of people do fasts if you font agree wit my fast that's fine but don't say in a bad mum and promoting starvation that's really not nice and i don't appreciate someone i don't even no commenting on my parenting skills
So basically you are hoping to find people who are also starving themselves.
Starting to wonder if this is the new pro-ana peeps ad method for finding each other. :grumble:0 -
Yes i have consulted my doctor i have weekly appointment to check blood pressure heart rate and everything else in not doing any thing wrong here my husband is here during the day to help with my son ive done everything right consulted my doctor made sure there's someone else here during the day to help.me out i drink green tea as well as water for the caffeine to give me energy lots of people do fasts if you font agree wit my fast that's fine but don't say in a bad mum and promoting starvation that's really not nice and i don't appreciate someone i don't even no commenting on my parenting skills
Oh, so now you are suddenly supervised by a doctor, and not just by your marine friend.. Convenient.0 -
Yes i have consulted my doctor i have weekly appointment to check blood pressure heart rate and everything else in not doing any thing wrong here my husband is here during the day to help with my son ive done everything right consulted my doctor made sure there's someone else here during the day to help.me out i drink green tea as well as water for the caffeine to give me energy lots of people do fasts if you font agree wit my fast that's fine but don't say in a bad mum and promoting starvation that's really not nice and i don't appreciate someone i don't even no commenting on my parenting skills
1. Just because a lot of people do fasts does not mean it's a good thing.
2. If a doctor has approved a 52 day water fast......drop him immediately.
3. Pretty sure this is the definition of starvation.
4. The fact that you even need to make sure someone is around to help out suggests that this isn't healthy
Also if you google water fast, this is what pops up on the very top of the first page.
water fast
Web definitions
Water fasting is a type of fasting in which the practitioner consumes only water. One may water fast for a variety of reasons, including medical and religious requirements. Such fasting for prolonged periods poses significant health risks.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fast0 -
Look im sorry i even put up that im on a water fast I'm sorry if i upset anyone this is the diet i have chose and most likely i wont last that long any way im 20 ok i don't need people having a go at me or slagging me off calling me a bad mum or a liar or stupid or whatever else it is your saying i didn't mean to upset anyone ok sorry0
-
Yes i have consulted my doctor i have weekly appointment to check blood pressure heart rate and everything else in not doing any thing wrong here my husband is here during the day to help with my son ive done everything right consulted my doctor made sure there's someone else here during the day to help.me out i drink green tea as well as water for the caffeine to give me energy lots of people do fasts if you font agree wit my fast that's fine but don't say in a bad mum and promoting starvation that's really not nice and i don't appreciate someone i don't even no commenting on my parenting skills
Oh dear lord. Where to even start?
Forget it,...one question only,...
Weekly doctor appointments? Really? As in once every 7 days? For how long now and for how long going forward? Seems odd to say the least. If true, can you add me to your health plan? Thanks.0 -
Holy crap did I stumble into a pro-ana site?!?!
You should not be "water fasting" for weight loss.
Excuse me? I fast 40 hours 3 times a week on nothing but water.
Does that make me ana now?0 -
Why are you against just reducing your cals and doing it the normal way though?0
-
Holy crap did I stumble into a pro-ana site?!?!
You should not be "water fasting" for weight loss.
Excuse me? I fast 40 hours 3 times a week on nothing but water.
Does that make me ana now?
I fast between 42-70 hours a week on a no food no water fast...I call it the Sleeping Method.
But you aren't trying to do a 24/7 water fast for 52 days straight. Just walking a marathon everyday at speeds that break world records, right?0 -
Why are you against just reducing your cals and doing it the normal way though?
Didn't you know that weight loss is supposed to be as complicated and uncomfortable as possible?0 -
Putting aside the fact that water fasting over a period of 52 days is just insane, fasting should never be about weight loss. Usually, people fast to clean their bodies or for spiritual/religious reasons. Yes, you will lose weight but that is just a side effect not the main goal. There is a reason why fasting cures are supervised and should include (almost) daily checks on health, etc.
Everyone should be aware that it cannot be healthy to consume just water for 52 days. (And green tea because of the coffeine? What about some nutrients so you won't be that tired anymore?)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions