Exhausted with Low/No Carb Eating
Replies
-
i meant my original post to the person saying carbs make you fat
However, carbs do you make you fat and increase your insulin sensitivity which is what insulin resistance is.
Since you are so found of pub med...............
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15800559
See the detrimental effect on the high carb group of people where insulin sensitivity increased significantly?Both the high-carbohydrate and high-protein groups lost weight (-2.2+/-0.9 kg, -2.5+/-1.6 kg, respectively, P <.05) and the difference between the groups was not significant (P =.9). In the high-carbohydrate group, hemoglobin A1c decreased (from 8.2% to 6.9%, P <.03), fasting plasma glucose decreased (from 8.8 to 7.2 mmol/L, P <.02), and insulin sensitivity increased (from 12.8 to 17.2 micromol/kg/min, P <.03).0 -
Carbs are not good for you and they can make you fat. When you take in a large amount of carbohydrates the resulting insulin response helps turn those sugars into fat storage for future use. High Carb diets can also create Insulin resistance in some people. Insulin resistance can impede the absorbtion of glucose to muscle and fat cells which raises blood glucose levels. This will eventually lead to diabetes, weight gain, high triglyceride, high blood pressure and vascular disease. Google is your friend here.
You are slightly misinformed.
http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/carbohydrates-full-story/index.html#when-sugar-management
Perhaps I should have been clear..."refined" carbohydrates. The article you posted a link to confirmed what I posted. Diets hihgh in carbohydrates cause all sorts of health problems in otherwise healthy people. I will see your article and raise you one?
http://www.nytimes.com/2002/07/07/magazine/what-if-it-s-all-been-a-big-fat-lie.html0 -
Just end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.0
-
ive already addressed this. you are proving to me once again that you dont read any of the information i post. If you wish to continue this conversation go back to page 1, read everything, and PM me0
-
i meant to quote youi meant my original post to the person saying carbs make you fat
However, carbs do you make you fat and increase your insulin sensitivity which is what insulin resistance is.
Since you are so found of pub med...............
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15800559
See the detrimental effect on the high carb group of people where insulin sensitivity increased significantly?Both the high-carbohydrate and high-protein groups lost weight (-2.2+/-0.9 kg, -2.5+/-1.6 kg, respectively, P <.05) and the difference between the groups was not significant (P =.9). In the high-carbohydrate group, hemoglobin A1c decreased (from 8.2% to 6.9%, P <.03), fasting plasma glucose decreased (from 8.8 to 7.2 mmol/L, P <.02), and insulin sensitivity increased (from 12.8 to 17.2 micromol/kg/min, P <.03).0 -
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.0 -
why would the government lie about that?lol there is no way you believe that. you are a very good trollI had an entire reply typed out to Jordan, but i'm not going to bother. Anyone who tells someone else that it's okay to eat pop tarts everyday like he has in a previous post dosen't have the slightest clue about nutrition.
of course you can eat pop tarts. your body breaks food down into its smallest parts it doesnt recognize that this is pop tarts, its not good for, so it turns to fat.
that was worded awkwardly but you know what i mean.
im going to use another example that everyone has side stepped so far.
if you need 2000 calories to just maintain your body ( not adding or taking away any muscle, fat etc) and you ate 1800 cals of pop tarts what would happen to your weight?
also same scenario with 2200 of lettuce, what would happen?
tomorrow on this website go to your foods for the day and put pop tarts in for everything until you reach your caloric goal. tell me what it says will happen to your weight. if you dont understand energy in vs energy out theres no reason for me to argue with you.
im trying to make your goals easier to attain. if you want to be scared of bread for the rest of your life go ahead but im going to have bread and get the same results as you
Once again, you are not understanding it is not about the QUANTITY.....it is about QUALITY.
Its not as simple as energy in, energy out as the government leads you to believe.
How about this. You do you and I will keep doing me. Sound fair, good luck with the inflammation cuased by grains in your future.0 -
Body/Mind needs Cards. I did Atkins and ran into same prob. I would say focus on High Protein/Med Carbs/Low Fat ie. 50%/30%/20% Just try to eat complex carbs to fuel you. Drink 8cups/1gallon of water a day and add a soup somewhere too every other day or so.0
-
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.
I read enough to know you do not understand this stuff. You said 1800 calories worth of pop tarts correct? Ive also read enough books and articles from experts to understand the benefits and pitfalls of eating certain ways.0 -
i used the pop tarts as an extreme example to prove a point. i never promoted eating junk food all day, i even said most of your nutrition should come from whole foods but if at the end of the day poptarts fit in your macros and caloric intake then its fine.Jordan,
The last time that I checked most people weren't just on this site to lose weight, but to maintain a healthy lifestyle. I'm sure you could lose weight eating crap all day long, but you can also lose weight by sticking your finger down your throat & making yourself puke. Does that make it healthy? Nope. You can sit there & argue it however you would like, but different things work for different people. I could print every diary entry off of fitday.com that I entered back when I was doing low calorie. I never ate more than 1500 calories a day, exercised the same amount that I do now, but couldn't make my weight budge more than 5 or so lbs. Now, I eat the same amount of calories, perform the same amount & type of exercise, and I don't eat refined carbs or starches yet the weight & fat are melting off. Please explain that to me since it's all based on calories in vs calories out in your opinion? Oh, and could you also please explain to me how I eat low carb ( all of my carbs come from veggies & low sugar fruts), a lot of fat, and yet my bad cholesterol (LDL) along w/triglycerides have dropped?
im not arguing anymore on this thread. if you still want to argue go read all my posts, and PM me0 -
you mustve not read the part where i said i used that as an extreme example to prove a point. go read all my posts so you actually understand what im trying to prove, and PM me if you want to keep arguing
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.
I read enough to know you do not understand this stuff. You said 1800 calories worth of pop tarts correct? Ive also read enough books and articles from experts to understand the benefits and pitfalls of eating certain ways.0 -
why would the government lie about that?lol there is no way you believe that. you are a very good trollI had an entire reply typed out to Jordan, but i'm not going to bother. Anyone who tells someone else that it's okay to eat pop tarts everyday like he has in a previous post dosen't have the slightest clue about nutrition.
of course you can eat pop tarts. your body breaks food down into its smallest parts it doesnt recognize that this is pop tarts, its not good for, so it turns to fat.
that was worded awkwardly but you know what i mean.
im going to use another example that everyone has side stepped so far.
if you need 2000 calories to just maintain your body ( not adding or taking away any muscle, fat etc) and you ate 1800 cals of pop tarts what would happen to your weight?
also same scenario with 2200 of lettuce, what would happen?
tomorrow on this website go to your foods for the day and put pop tarts in for everything until you reach your caloric goal. tell me what it says will happen to your weight. if you dont understand energy in vs energy out theres no reason for me to argue with you.
im trying to make your goals easier to attain. if you want to be scared of bread for the rest of your life go ahead but im going to have bread and get the same results as you
Once again, you are not understanding it is not about the QUANTITY.....it is about QUALITY.
Its not as simple as energy in, energy out as the government leads you to believe.
How about this. You do you and I will keep doing me. Sound fair, good luck with the inflammation cuased by grains in your future.
The government lies about EVERYTHING, including saying we need carbs when we don't. We don't need grains, carbs,etc.......... They have the majority of people brainwashed to think we need carbs for brain function so they can push Monsanto GMO grains along with Kelloggs and General Mills grain foods on you all as healthy.
For your information, the brain runs on fatty acids, which is derived from FAT, not carbs.
There is enough scientific evidence to back up everything I say and I am in NO way a troll.
Before you resort to name calling GO READ and RESEARCH everything that we have all said. You fill find yourself VERY, VERY WRONG.
I am done with you. Don't say anything else to me.0 -
there is no way you are real life. i hope your a troll. you apparently dont know what a troll is either, im not making fun of you
why would the government lie about that?lol there is no way you believe that. you are a very good trollI had an entire reply typed out to Jordan, but i'm not going to bother. Anyone who tells someone else that it's okay to eat pop tarts everyday like he has in a previous post dosen't have the slightest clue about nutrition.
of course you can eat pop tarts. your body breaks food down into its smallest parts it doesnt recognize that this is pop tarts, its not good for, so it turns to fat.
that was worded awkwardly but you know what i mean.
im going to use another example that everyone has side stepped so far.
if you need 2000 calories to just maintain your body ( not adding or taking away any muscle, fat etc) and you ate 1800 cals of pop tarts what would happen to your weight?
also same scenario with 2200 of lettuce, what would happen?
tomorrow on this website go to your foods for the day and put pop tarts in for everything until you reach your caloric goal. tell me what it says will happen to your weight. if you dont understand energy in vs energy out theres no reason for me to argue with you.
im trying to make your goals easier to attain. if you want to be scared of bread for the rest of your life go ahead but im going to have bread and get the same results as you
Once again, you are not understanding it is not about the QUANTITY.....it is about QUALITY.
Its not as simple as energy in, energy out as the government leads you to believe.
How about this. You do you and I will keep doing me. Sound fair, good luck with the inflammation cuased by grains in your future.
The government lies about EVERYTHING, including saying we need carbs when we don't. We don't need grains, carbs,etc.......... They have the majority of people brainwashed to think we need carbs for brain function so they can push Monsanto GMO grains along with Kelloggs and General Mills grain foods on you all as healthy.
For your information, the brain runs on fatty acids, which is derived from FAT, not carbs.
There is enough scientific evidence to back up everything I say and I am in NO way a troll.
Before you resort to name calling GO READ and RESEARCH everything that we have all said. You fill find yourself VERY, VERY WRONG.
I am done with you. Don't say anything else to me.
i also told you to PM me if you wanted to argue so we didnt spam up this thread. i guess you didnt read that either.
good luck with your carbophobic nutrition goals of 20110 -
you mustve not read the part where i said i used that as an extreme example to prove a point. go read all my posts so you actually understand what im trying to prove, and PM me if you want to keep arguing
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.
I read enough to know you do not understand this stuff. You said 1800 calories worth of pop tarts correct? Ive also read enough books and articles from experts to understand the benefits and pitfalls of eating certain ways.
JORDAN! stop trying to make everyone eat only poptarts. How many time do we have to say it. Jeez0 -
lol im sorry gawjuss. im trying to end this
you mustve not read the part where i said i used that as an extreme example to prove a point. go read all my posts so you actually understand what im trying to prove, and PM me if you want to keep arguing
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.
I read enough to know you do not understand this stuff. You said 1800 calories worth of pop tarts correct? Ive also read enough books and articles from experts to understand the benefits and pitfalls of eating certain ways.
JORDAN! stop trying to make everyone eat only poptarts. How many time do we have to say it. Jeez0 -
there is no way you are real life. i hope your a troll. you apparently dont know what a troll is either, im not making fun of you
i also told you to PM me if you wanted to argue so we didnt spam up this thread. i guess you didnt read that either.
good luck with your carbophobic nutrition goals of 2011
Why is there no way I am real life????
I am not a troll, far from it. Being the fact that you just joined this site and I have been here for much longer I have people to back me up to know I am NOT an internet troll.
I am not carbophobic. I eat plenty of carbs in the form of VEGETABLES and minimal fruit. Like I told you, you go eat your bread and pop tarts while contributing to future inflammation in your body and I will continue with my ANTI-inflammatory eating plan.
I educate people on holistic eating, so your mindset is no where near where mine is at.0 -
PM methere is no way you are real life. i hope your a troll. you apparently dont know what a troll is either, im not making fun of you
i also told you to PM me if you wanted to argue so we didnt spam up this thread. i guess you didnt read that either.
good luck with your carbophobic nutrition goals of 2011
Why is there no way I am real life????
I am not a troll, far from it. Being the fact that you just joined this site and I have been here for much longer I have people to back me up to know I am NOT an internet troll.
I am not carbophobic. I eat plenty of carbs in the form of VEGETABLES and minimal fruit. Like I told you, you go eat your bread and pop tarts while contributing to future inflammation in your body and I will continue with my ANTI-inflammatory eating plan.
I educate people on holistic eating, so your mindset is no where near where mine is at.
PM me
maybe if i say it twice youl understand0 -
The government lies about EVERYTHING, including saying we need carbs when we don't. We don't need grains, carbs,etc.......... They have the majority of people brainwashed to think we need carbs for brain function so they can push Monsanto GMO grains along with Kelloggs and General Mills grain foods on you all as healthy.
There is actually a lot of truth to this. If the world finally realized what grains, specifically corn, does to the body, what would we have left to export?0 -
why would the government lie about that?lol there is no way you believe that. you are a very good trollI had an entire reply typed out to Jordan, but i'm not going to bother. Anyone who tells someone else that it's okay to eat pop tarts everyday like he has in a previous post dosen't have the slightest clue about nutrition.
of course you can eat pop tarts. your body breaks food down into its smallest parts it doesnt recognize that this is pop tarts, its not good for, so it turns to fat.
that was worded awkwardly but you know what i mean.
im going to use another example that everyone has side stepped so far.
if you need 2000 calories to just maintain your body ( not adding or taking away any muscle, fat etc) and you ate 1800 cals of pop tarts what would happen to your weight?
also same scenario with 2200 of lettuce, what would happen?
tomorrow on this website go to your foods for the day and put pop tarts in for everything until you reach your caloric goal. tell me what it says will happen to your weight. if you dont understand energy in vs energy out theres no reason for me to argue with you.
im trying to make your goals easier to attain. if you want to be scared of bread for the rest of your life go ahead but im going to have bread and get the same results as you
Once again, you are not understanding it is not about the QUANTITY.....it is about QUALITY.
Its not as simple as energy in, energy out as the government leads you to believe.
How about this. You do you and I will keep doing me. Sound fair, good luck with the inflammation cuased by grains in your future.
The government lies about EVERYTHING, including saying we need carbs when we don't. We don't need grains, carbs,etc.......... They have the majority of people brainwashed to think we need carbs for brain function so they can push Monsanto GMO grains along with Kelloggs and General Mills grain foods on you all as healthy.
For your information, the brain runs on fatty acids, which is derived from FAT, not carbs.
There is enough scientific evidence to back up everything I say and I am in NO way a troll.
Before you resort to name calling GO READ and RESEARCH everything that we have all said. You fill find yourself VERY, VERY WRONG.
I am done with you. Don't say anything else to me.
We don't "need" protein either. People do live without it.0 -
gtfo you werent even here at the beginning of this thread. you havent read any of the links i posted. quit acting like you know what youre talking aboutJust end the thread, it's pointless. High carb proponents will find research to denounce low carb proponents will find research to support low carb, and jordan will continue to spout nonsense.
he s pretty right on on that one0 -
We don't "need" protein either. People do live without it.
This is a joke right? Protein breaks down into amino acids. Amino acids are the bodies building blocks. Without protein, the body would break itself down (catabolic).
People can live long HEALTHY lives without grains of any kind.0 -
that is why low carb diets work. thank you so much. you now understand.
when you dont eat as many carbs protein and fat intake must increase. protein and fat make you feel full and satisfied which prevents you from eating more and helps prevent extra snacking,
>less calories
> weight loss
im not trying to saw low carb diets dont work, im saying carbs arent bad for you nor do they make you fat.
this is not true atleast for me, i can eat the same calorie amount in a day. if i was to do that with mfp suggested carb amount i will gain, i know this I did, if i eat that exact same amount of cals with under 25 grams of carbs i will lose.
same amount of calories diffrent results0 -
this is not true atleast for me, i can eat the same calorie amount in a day. if i was to do that with mfp suggested carb amount i will gain, i know this I did, if i eat that exact same amount of cals with under 25 grams of carbs i will lose.
same amount of calories diffrent results
It's because your carbs weren't from pop tarts.0 -
i dont mean to spam your thread but these people are being so closeminded. i just want them to understandI'm going to quote myself because I think it is worth repeating:And as I predicted when this post first popped up, this has become a pissing contest. Both low carb and low fat diets have been around for a very long time. Neither of them are fads at this point, IMO. Some people like to eat their bread, others enjoy full fats. Really, both can work, and it pretty much comes down to preference. My mom prefers low fat and she follows WW. I prefer Atkins. We are both losing weight.
OP, if you really don't think you can live a low carb lifestyle for the long run, then maybe a different appraoch is best for you. But, from what you have described, all your symptoms are completely normal for starting out low carb. For some people it takes a few weeks to overcome. Good luck with your decision, whatever that may be.
pot meet kettle0 -
this is not true atleast for me, i can eat the same calorie amount in a day. if i was to do that with mfp suggested carb amount i will gain, i know this I did, if i eat that exact same amount of cals with under 25 grams of carbs i will lose.
same amount of calories diffrent results
It's because your carbs weren't from pop tarts.
your right i will have to try that pop tart diet ,0 -
why would the government lie about that?lol there is no way you believe that. you are a very good trollI had an entire reply typed out to Jordan, but i'm not going to bother. Anyone who tells someone else that it's okay to eat pop tarts everyday like he has in a previous post dosen't have the slightest clue about nutrition.
of course you can eat pop tarts. your body breaks food down into its smallest parts it doesnt recognize that this is pop tarts, its not good for, so it turns to fat.
that was worded awkwardly but you know what i mean.
im going to use another example that everyone has side stepped so far.
if you need 2000 calories to just maintain your body ( not adding or taking away any muscle, fat etc) and you ate 1800 cals of pop tarts what would happen to your weight?
also same scenario with 2200 of lettuce, what would happen?
tomorrow on this website go to your foods for the day and put pop tarts in for everything until you reach your caloric goal. tell me what it says will happen to your weight. if you dont understand energy in vs energy out theres no reason for me to argue with you.
im trying to make your goals easier to attain. if you want to be scared of bread for the rest of your life go ahead but im going to have bread and get the same results as you
Once again, you are not understanding it is not about the QUANTITY.....it is about QUALITY.
Its not as simple as energy in, energy out as the government leads you to believe.
How about this. You do you and I will keep doing me. Sound fair, good luck with the inflammation cuased by grains in your future.
The government lies about EVERYTHING, including saying we need carbs when we don't. We don't need grains, carbs,etc.......... They have the majority of people brainwashed to think we need carbs for brain function so they can push Monsanto GMO grains along with Kelloggs and General Mills grain foods on you all as healthy.
For your information, the brain runs on fatty acids, which is derived from FAT, not carbs.
There is enough scientific evidence to back up everything I say and I am in NO way a troll.
Before you resort to name calling GO READ and RESEARCH everything that we have all said. You fill find yourself VERY, VERY WRONG.
I am done with you. Don't say anything else to me.
We don't "need" protein either. People do live without it.
You can live without protein if you want to eat your muscles and ruin your organs.
However, you can live HEALTHFULLY without carbs.0 -
I have to say from a personal point i have done a no carb diet and felt rotten very tired and mood swings from hell.... NEVER again!!!!0
-
Just end the thread. Again, there is good and bad from both lifestyles, high-carb/low fat and high-fat / low carb. Just eat however makes you happy and what works to meet your fitness and health needs. There is good and bad in both.0
-
well . . . in my opinion (I know -- who cares, right?!), low/no carb eating is a silly fad that is unsustainable as a lifestyle, and is detrimental to those who exercise, as well as those who like to have energy.
EAT YOUR CARBS!
blessings.
Sorry, but low carb eating is not a silly fad. Please read William Banting's Letter of Corpulence, he is considered to be the Father of low carb and this was written in the 1800's.
Low Carb eating is about eating CLEAN, WHOLE foods such as fats, meats and primarily vegetables with some fruits added in. Where is this a fad and where is not not sustainable???
I started Atkins in 2003 when I was diagnosed with T2 Diabetes. I lost 100 pounds in 6 months and kept that weight off for 8 years until 2008 when I had a near fatal car accident and then I gained a lot of weight due to hospital food, my hubby not being a great cook and not really knowing how to shop and the fact that I couldn't exercise for a long time.
It is an excuse to eat cake, cookies and ice cream to say that low carb is not sustainable.
No offense intended, if it works for you, great. However, I have been an athlete my entire life and I have maintained a heatlhy and athletic weight and body fat percentage with the exception of pregnancies for my entire life as well. Even at my highest weight of 142 lbs. I was still within the healthy range for my height and maintained a 20-21% body fat. As an athlete, I know carbs are necessary, and I wouldn't undertake an endurance event (or daily life) without them.
Bread and rice have long sustained humans on this earth, and have been a staple of all societies since man came out of the caves. Barring the massive weight gain and explosion of obesity experienced by the western world (primarily America and Australia) over the past 35 years, you can look across the human race and see that carbs do not make people fat.
That being said, anything in excess (such as McDonalds, corn syrup and partially hydrogenated oils -- coincidentally having been injected at an alarming rate into western society's diet over the past 35 years) will make you fat.
I don't think anyone has become fat solely due to the inclusion of carbs in their diet, nor do I believe that they will become sustainably thin and healthy due to excluding carbs from their diet.
Again, no offense intended. Eat as you will.
carry on.
blessings.
blessings.0 -
its temporary gain in water weight which is normal when increasing carbsthat is why low carb diets work. thank you so much. you now understand.
when you dont eat as many carbs protein and fat intake must increase. protein and fat make you feel full and satisfied which prevents you from eating more and helps prevent extra snacking,
>less calories
> weight loss
im not trying to saw low carb diets dont work, im saying carbs arent bad for you nor do they make you fat.
this is not true atleast for me, i can eat the same calorie amount in a day. if i was to do that with mfp suggested carb amount i will gain, i know this I did, if i eat that exact same amount of cals with under 25 grams of carbs i will lose.
same amount of calories diffrent results0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions