How to calculate calorie goals according to NROLFW
Replies
-
bump for later....might need to revisit this now that I've added weights to my routine...0
-
bump. And I have the exact calculation as you. 131 pounds and 68 inches :P Made it easy haha0
-
bump0
-
Bumping for later0
-
bumping for later.
Thanks so much. Waiting for my paper copy of NROLFW to arrive0 -
No problem! I am not an expert and of course am only posting what the book says, but I truly believe that MFP should not be putting everyone and their brother at 1200 calories a day - unless you're very very short, it's really too little. It may seem excessive, but if everyone eats more they will still lose weight, will build muscle, and will be able to keep it going throughout their life without feeling like they are restricting themselves too much!
I ate at 1200 net for the first two months of my weight loss since January and while it worked fine, I'm a little ashamed because I should have done more research instead of just taking MFP's suggestions at face value. I don't believe that anyone should eat below 1400 net ever, and definitely even a little more than that usually. Especially if you're working out and want muscles to grow
How short is very, very short? MFP has my goal set at 1200. I am 61" tall, or 5'1"0 -
No problem! I am not an expert and of course am only posting what the book says, but I truly believe that MFP should not be putting everyone and their brother at 1200 calories a day - unless you're very very short, it's really too little. It may seem excessive, but if everyone eats more they will still lose weight, will build muscle, and will be able to keep it going throughout their life without feeling like they are restricting themselves too much!
I ate at 1200 net for the first two months of my weight loss since January and while it worked fine, I'm a little ashamed because I should have done more research instead of just taking MFP's suggestions at face value. I don't believe that anyone should eat below 1400 net ever, and definitely even a little more than that usually. Especially if you're working out and want muscles to grow
How short is very, very short? MFP has my goal set at 1200. I am 61" tall, or 5'1"
you are WAY to tall to be eating 1200 calories...please do the calculations that the OP gave you and see what you should be at...and eat a sandwich lol0 -
Bump0
-
BUMP!0
-
bump0
-
bump 4 l8r0
-
bump0
-
bump. And I have the exact calculation as you. 131 pounds and 68 inches :P Made it easy haha
Hah awesome0 -
How short is very, very short? MFP has my goal set at 1200. I am 61" tall, or 5'1"
you are WAY to tall to be eating 1200 calories...please do the calculations that the OP gave you and see what you should be at...and eat a sandwich lol
I've seen others who are very short, like 4'11 or less, on other posts claim that because they are so short they are ok eating that little. I personally don't believe this because every single person on the earth has the same cells and organs that need the same amount of calories to do their work. But, as I am not short, I can't really say if my instinct on the subject is true or not. I personally don't think anyone should eat less than 1400 calories for any purpose. And that is NOT including exercise calories burned. But, I'd say try doing the calculations and see how they work for you and if it isn't working out, change it up.0 -
Thanks for posting this!!! : )0
-
bump0
-
ARe these calculations only for those that lift weights? Also, does one eat back exercise calories on days of workouts?0
-
bump0
-
ARe these calculations only for those that lift weights? Also, does one eat back exercise calories on days of workouts?
i'd like to know this, also, please!0 -
another questionIf your BMI is 18-24.9:
Multiply X by:
On non-workout days: 1.6
On workout days: 1.8
If your BMI is >25
Multiply X by:
On non-workout days: 1.5
On workout days: 1.7
So for me, I'll do
Non-workout days: X = 1222.54 * 1.6 = 1956 calories
Workout days: X = 1222.54*1.8 = 2201 calories
do you memorize your "workout day" calories and just try to hit that on MFP (because, as far as i know, there is no way to have two different calorie goals on MFP).. AND are these net calories or just overall calories on workout days?0 -
Thank you for posting this. I just bought the kindle edition of this book, and started reading today, but had not hit any actual recommendations yet. E-books are a pain to flip back through, so I'm glad to have found this all laid out clearly!
There should be a way to set "bookmarks" on your Kindle - it's very useful for books like NROLFW with charts, etc. hope that helps.
Hey, I hope this helps... I have an older Kindle and I can set bookmarks. Here is how I do it. I just click the menu button when I'm on the page I want to bookmark. Then there is a "Add a bookmark" option. I just click it. Then, later, I can just open the book, click menu and click "View my notes and marks". It lists all of my notes and bookmarks, go to the one I want, click and it takes me there.0 -
Thanks..0
-
another questionIf your BMI is 18-24.9:
Multiply X by:
On non-workout days: 1.6
On workout days: 1.8
If your BMI is >25
Multiply X by:
On non-workout days: 1.5
On workout days: 1.7
So for me, I'll do
Non-workout days: X = 1222.54 * 1.6 = 1956 calories
Workout days: X = 1222.54*1.8 = 2201 calories
do you memorize your "workout day" calories and just try to hit that on MFP (because, as far as i know, there is no way to have two different calorie goals on MFP).. AND are these net calories or just overall calories on workout days?
In the past I would just change it every day. You could set your calories at the higher number and on your non workout days you'd be technically under.0 -
bump0
-
bump! thanks for this! I was thinking of buying the book but really wanted to know this part before I went to buy it. (some people were claiming it would tell me to eat a thousand cals more...) this seems more realistic. I'm in0
-
The very idea of eating more than 1600 calories is TERRIFYING!!!!0
-
bump0
-
The very idea of eating more than 1600 calories is TERRIFYING!!!!
i totally agree! according to this i need to eat over 2000 on workout days to maintain! i don't think i could ever make myself do that!0 -
bump0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions