Treadmill vs street
Replies
-
Recommendation is 1-2% incline to make up for lack of wind resistance, etc.So, I dont have to walk at an incline or anything to get the same benefit as walking on a trail?
Recent study conducted by Running Times showed that there is no compensation necessary for wind resistance until you are running sub 6:00 miles.
Really? That is good to know because whenever I use the incline on a treadmill I have a harder time with shin splints and asthma.
I prefer outdoors but from about May to Mid-Sept use treadmill. Too hot on the surface of the sun and I can't get up at 4am to run.
Maybe that is why I was having shin splint problems... I was walking on a 3-5 incline.
Could be your shoes too. Make sure you have a good pair of running shoes that you get from a specialty running store. They will make sure you have the right shoe for your gait.
Thats another thing... My feet hurt like crazy after about 30 mins of just walking.0 -
You know, I ONLY used to run outside cause I lived next to a beautiful riverside trail that goes on and on for hours.
Then I moved and because of the hot weather I started running on the treadmill. It was so boring in the beginning.
Now I'm so used to running on it , because I watch shows while I'm at it.
BUT I DON'T KNOW!!! if i had a beautiful path and knew the area better I would probably try to run outside again. Or if I had a buddy to run with. But sadly, I don't anymore.
So if you can, I'd suggest running outside. But either way, it's running. I got a lot faster on the treadmill too, so if you're trying to work on your speed - it's good for that. To improve endurance, I find running outside better.0 -
I am canadian so treadmill....i do not run in snow. summer is different, then I hit the parks and trails. i love to groove to my tunes on the treadmill, outside i do not like music because i want to be aware of my surroundings.0
-
Removed quotes.Thanks! I don't currently have trail shoes - I just wear my regular running shoes when I hit the trails. Probably not a good plan for snow though.
If it's a fairly flat surface, with powdery snow, regular running shoes would work fine. If the snow get's really wet, it can compress and become a bit slippery. You just have to slow down, take smaller strides and take it all in.
What you didn't like 12,000 quotes in there? LOL.
Thanks for the advice! My trails are mostly flat - only about 3/4 of a mile section is hilly. Nicely paved bike trails but I doubt they'll ever be compressed since I don't think a lot of people use it in the winter. But I guess I'll find out! They were putting up cross country ski trail signs the other day...0 -
street! it is much more interesting. I live in the bronx and find my neighborhood is lovely at dawn!
plus i am afraid my cat will get hurt bu going on the tradmill while it is moving0 -
But what about when there is no sunshine
You make your own.
I don't feel safe running at night. Unless maybe at a well lit track. I have no sympathy for people who get mugged or knocked in the head running in dark desolate areas, especially in cities. You should know better.
I like to do intervals. I don't own a stop watch, so generally I do that on the treadmill. Longer runs for me are best outdoors, but again, but between the weather and limited daylight, I could never be an outdoors only runner.
Hubby is REALLY not happy about me running in the woods, alone at night. Only about the last 10 minutes of my runs are in the dark, but he's unimpressed. Hey, I have my LED running tights on!0 -
Removed quotes.Thanks! I don't currently have trail shoes - I just wear my regular running shoes when I hit the trails. Probably not a good plan for snow though.
If it's a fairly flat surface, with powdery snow, regular running shoes would work fine. If the snow get's really wet, it can compress and become a bit slippery. You just have to slow down, take smaller strides and take it all in.
What you didn't like 12,000 quotes in there? LOL.
Thanks for the advice! My trails are mostly flat - only about 3/4 of a mile section is hilly. Nicely paved bike trails but I doubt they'll ever be compressed since I don't think a lot of people use it in the winter. But I guess I'll find out! They were putting up cross country ski trail signs the other day...
Oh, don't run on the cross country ski trails. Those people spend hour upon hour grooming those trails. Walking and/or running on them destroys the trails for the skiers.0 -
I do both, but it depends on what I'm doing.
For my long, slower runs, I definitely prefer outside, as I get too bored on a treadmill even with my iPod.
For my sprints/interval training sessions, I prefer the treadmill because I find that I can push myself to go harder and faster because a treadmill will force me to keep my speed up.0 -
Get off the dreadmill and hit the pavement, trails or the track!
^^^ This !0 -
Neighborhood if the dogs are home. Treadmill if not and treadmill at night. We don't have street lamps and we have deer that tend to hang out at night, otherwise I would walk around the neighborhood at night.0
-
Maybe that is why I was having shin splint problems... I was walking on a 3-5 incline.
Could be your shoes too. Make sure you have a good pair of running shoes that you get from a specialty running store. They will make sure you have the right shoe for your gait.
I always know when my shoes are dead, shin splints. I never used to track miles but now I have an app for that.0 -
also - I NEED a good playlist when running outside. Music is what keeps me going.0
-
I prefer the treadmill. I lost all my weight from the treadmill and it broke because I wore it out! Now I have taken to the streets and I HATE it. I was use to walking/running on a 7 incline and now unless I go find an elevated ground area I am flat and I don't feel I am exerting myself like I did on the treadmill. I could burn way more calories on the treadmill using the incline than I do now. Now I have to stay out longer and go futher to compensate.0
-
Recommendation is 1-2% incline to make up for lack of wind resistance, etc.So, I dont have to walk at an incline or anything to get the same benefit as walking on a trail?
Recent study conducted by Running Times showed that there is no compensation necessary for wind resistance until you are running sub 6:00 miles.
Really? That is good to know because whenever I use the incline on a treadmill I have a harder time with shin splints and asthma.
I prefer outdoors but from about May to Mid-Sept use treadmill. Too hot on the surface of the sun and I can't get up at 4am to run.
Maybe that is why I was having shin splint problems... I was walking on a 3-5 incline.
Could be your shoes too. Make sure you have a good pair of running shoes that you get from a specialty running store. They will make sure you have the right shoe for your gait.
Never found the specialty shoes to be necessary. I run in $30 clearance rack cross trainers indoors, and work or hiking boots on trails (I dont run on the street .. where people can .. see)0 -
I always love when this topic pops up....me personally i can do both equally as well....todays run 89 mins ((no music)) treadmill....ppl always contend that treadmill running is so boring....well I run outside as well...beautiful 2.6 mile park....so unless you are running short distances to me I am still seeing the same old sites and sound... going around and around..to me thats boring as well...I run different places, same premise....it just require more focus especially if you are running longer...if you run a 10 min. mile treadmill or outside...same time...same sites....the 1 advantage I will give to the treadmill esp. long runs, my drinks in front of me....hate running outside carrying things....but the 1 advantage or disadvantage depending on your level of comfort abt outside is that you cannot deny the weather factor...that is huge...whichever you prefer Im all for it.....running is just the best feeling EVER.................enjoy it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!0
-
I prefer the treadmill. I lost all my weight from the treadmill and it broke because I wore it out! Now I have taken to the streets and I HATE it. I was use to walking/running on a 7 incline and now unless I go find an elevated ground area I am flat and I don't feel I am exerting myself like I did on the treadmill. I could burn way more calories on the treadmill using the incline than I do now. Now I have to stay out longer and go futher to compensate.
Congrats on your weight loss!!!!0 -
[/quote]
Crummy for me (although I'm not the person you're asking) is anything not between 45 and 65 degrees, any kind of precipitation, wind more than 10mph, snow/ice/mud on the roads, and/or the threat of any of the above during the time I expect to be outside. I hate nature-and i am outside more than in (although I don't have any of the normal resentful feelings towards my treadmill). I will say safety is a much bigger issue than weather where I am-and that will bring me inside faster than hurricane sandy did.
Guess I'm a bit of a princess...
[/quote]
I feel you on this. I live in New England and have had 3 serious ankle injuries in the last 5 years... not to mention I'm eternally clumsy and fearful of slipping when running with ice/snow. Crutches are the WORST.0 -
Not sure if this has been said or not, but I do a LOT of racing and let me tell you, if you ever want to race, then get out of the treadmill mentality, your joints will thank you come race day!
Your body needs to adapt to the different stress, otherwise you will just injure yourself
So true. It takes a few runs (and maybe some run/walks) to get used to running outdoors and learning to pace yourself. I couldn't imagine going straight from a treadmill to a race.0 -
Recommendation is 1-2% incline to make up for lack of wind resistance, etc.So, I dont have to walk at an incline or anything to get the same benefit as walking on a trail?
Recent study conducted by Running Times showed that there is no compensation necessary for wind resistance until you are running sub 6:00 miles.
Really? That is good to know because whenever I use the incline on a treadmill I have a harder time with shin splints and asthma.
I prefer outdoors but from about May to Mid-Sept use treadmill. Too hot on the surface of the sun and I can't get up at 4am to run.
Maybe that is why I was having shin splint problems... I was walking on a 3-5 incline.
Could be your shoes too. Make sure you have a good pair of running shoes that you get from a specialty running store. They will make sure you have the right shoe for your gait.
Never found the specialty shoes to be necessary. I run in $30 clearance rack cross trainers indoors, and work or hiking boots on trails (I dont run on the street .. where people can .. see)
You are in the very fortunate minority. I've seen many peoples' running pains go away from the right shoes.0 -
I prefer outdoors and here's why.....if I start walking on one of our many walking trails here and suddenly decide I'm over it and want to go home, I STILL have to walk home. Yes, maybe I can let myself cop out and do a slightly shorter distance than I had planned....but I don't have a choice but to walk back! If I'm on the treadmill and get it in my mind that I'm over it, I can be in my chair in 2 seconds flat! lol0
-
Never found the specialty shoes to be necessary. I run in $30 clearance rack cross trainers indoors, and work or hiking boots on trails (I dont run on the street .. where people can .. see)
A lot of people aren't as lucky.
I was in pain when I ran until I was fitted for the right kind of shoes. It made all the difference for me.0 -
I am stuck on the dreadmil! because it is dark when I am up and dark when I get home. Living in BFE with no street lights, sidewalks, and loose dogs. Makes it safer to be inside. I do better when I see where I am going, and if I can see those dogs coming so I can pay attention if I am going to get bit !! :ohwell: I prefer outside!!0
-
I always love when this topic pops up....me personally i can do both equally as well....todays run 89 mins ((no music)) treadmill....ppl always contend that treadmill running is so boring....well I run outside as well...beautiful 2.6 mile park....so unless you are running short distances to me I am still seeing the same old sites and sound... going around and around..to me thats boring as well...I run different places, same premise....it just require more focus especially if you are running longer...if you run a 10 min. mile treadmill or outside...same time...same sites....the 1 advantage I will give to the treadmill esp. long runs, my drinks in front of me....hate running outside carrying things....but the 1 advantage or disadvantage depending on your level of comfort abt outside is that you cannot deny the weather factor...that is huge...whichever you prefer Im all for it.....running is just the best feeling EVER.................enjoy it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
From Most to Least Boring: Track, Treadmill, Trail0 -
I used to love running on the street (I still do when the weather's beautiful), but it's a bit tough on my knees. I realized the treadmill is easier on my joints... so I've been running on the treadmill as of late. 0
-
Recommendation is 1-2% incline to make up for lack of wind resistance, etc.So, I dont have to walk at an incline or anything to get the same benefit as walking on a trail?
Recent study conducted by Running Times showed that there is no compensation necessary for wind resistance until you are running sub 6:00 miles.
Really? That is good to know because whenever I use the incline on a treadmill I have a harder time with shin splints and asthma.
I prefer outdoors but from about May to Mid-Sept use treadmill. Too hot on the surface of the sun and I can't get up at 4am to run.
I was sent to the surface of the sun on a business trip this summer. Lovely place-I enjoyed that it was nice and flat but good Christ it was hot. No reason for it to be almost 90 before the sun is up. And I had to be outside because work insisted we stay in a ghetto hotel that had no gym.
Oh man, that had to have been difficult. I want to try running outside this summer but am so nervous. I went a few times on what seemed like a nice September afternoon... I learned quickly that 98 is still just as hot as 115 when you run at 1 in the afternoon.0 -
I used to take my little ones to a playground and walk laps around the play area. Sure, it was kind of boring, but the kids were entertained, and we were all getting some exercise.0
-
double post0
-
Removed quotes.Really? That is good to know because whenever I use the incline on a treadmill I have a harder time with shin splints and asthma.
I prefer outdoors but from about May to Mid-Sept use treadmill. Too hot on the surface of the sun and I can't get up at 4am to run.
I was sent to the surface of the sun on a business trip this summer. Lovely place-I enjoyed that it was nice and flat but good Christ it was hot. No reason for it to be almost 90 before the sun is up. And I had to be outside because work insisted we stay in a ghetto hotel that had no gym.
Oh man, that had to have been difficult. I want to try running outside this summer but am so nervous. I went a few times on what seemed like a nice September afternoon... I learned quickly that 98 is still just as hot as 115 when you run at 1 in the afternoon.
Running in extreme heat conditions just requires adaptations. It takes about 3 weeks for your body to become acclimated to the heat. The first thing you have to do is slow way down. Then, after that acclimation period, you will find your pace naturally getting faster. Maybe not back to your pace at 45°F, but it will be faster than when you first started running in the heat. You will lose this adaptation over the winter and will need the same 3 week period to acclimate when summer rolls back around.
[/quote]0 -
I used to run on the treadmill and was fine with it, but after spending a few months over the summer running outside, I can't stand the treadmill anymore. I get bored out of my mind after like 10 minutes. So now if I'm stuck indoors, I just find different exercises to do instead.0
-
I like the treadmill because I know how hard i'm pushing myself. If I want to spring I know How fast I am going and for how long which means I don't get the chance to slow down at all.
Although I do like to run outside every once in a while, just for a change of scenery.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions