Running. An avoidance behavior?
Replies
-
I'm sorry but this sounds stupid. IDK about other people... or mice... but withdrawal from running is not something I deal with. I don't run to get away from my problems. I don't lift to get away from my problems. Because no matter what I'm doing at the gym, when I come back, my problem will still be there. I have always been a no nonsense kidn of person. I was like that when I was fat and I'm still like that now that I am fitter. If I have a problem, I figure it out. Exercise is not going to make it all sunshine and rainbows. I'm not more assertive because I lift. I'm stronger because I lift but thats about it. I take care of the **** I need to take care of and then I go work out. I have one goal and one goal only when I'm running and lifting: to look hot. Everyone and everything else can kick rocks until I'm done taking care of my workout for the day.
Really really stupid post.
ETA: I don't need studies to back up my point because I am talking about my experience and my experience only. TBH the OP's post of journal articles means absolutely nothing to me becase I can't relate.
I agree. This post is stupid.
Thank you!
I thought that person posting was stupid as well.0 -
Homo erectus ran the equivalent of marathons to catch food. http://cavepeopleandstuff.wordpress.com/2013/05/16/running-is-bad-for-you-because-what/ the history (and pre-history) of long distance running goes back a couple of million years further than the event mentioned in the OP
a) we evolved to be long distance runners before we evolved the ability to use fire or haft stone blades onto sticks to make spears. Its in our genes. I don't see how long distance running can be bad for humans. This is not the only form of exercise human ancestors engaged in, but I don't see how it can be bad for us.
b) it's not running away from problems, it's running towards a solution, i.e. catching an animal so you can have something to eat. You get it in response to all kinds of strenuous exercise, and I'd rather be an exercise junkie than a couch potato.
c) the endorphin response is a good thing, it evolved to enable our bodies to cope with stressful physical activity, including but not limited to running long distances.
or catching a mate so you can procreate?0 -
I think 'real men' do plenty of things. But I would say that running certainly takes away someone's manlihood bit by bit.
Oh the silly things you read on the internet when opinions run rampant...
...I would say that running certainly adds to someone's manlihood, or womanhood, a lot by a lot.0 -
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
My favorite part. The idea of mice doing dead lifts and squats will probably keep me smiling like a dork for the rest of the day.0 -
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression-and-exercise/MH00043
summary: exercise can help with depression...the form of exercise is less important than just the fact that you moved...so lift, run, garden
http://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/help-information/mental-health-a-z/E/exercise-mental-health/
essentially says that exercise is important and that the type of exercise you do is best determine by what works for you, your goals, your family, what your enjoy and what you will keep doing....for some
3. Exercise Regularly
Thirty minutes of brisk aerobic exercising--such as running, swimming or bicycling--has been known to relieve most mild forms of depression. In the most immediate sense, it provides an outlet for negative emotions, allowing you to "burn off" feelings of anger or frustration in a positive way. On a more general level, it increases your energy and helps you to feel better about yourself. Studies have shown that regular exercise not only relieves mild symptoms of depression, but makes it less likely that they will come back. Regular exercise is less effective for relieving more serious forms of depression, but can still be helpful in conjunction with formal types of therapy.
Read more: http://www.livestrong.com/article/13224-relieve-depression/#ixzz2Tqt0IZQu
The point is, some people can relieve stress, depression etc by running. The fact that you feel that you are avoiding your problems is personal to you. I feel no extra personal strength from lifting. I feel more in touch with my spiritual side after a long run, and I have thought through my problems when I run. I find I cannot escapte from my life when I run but rather that I have to face it in my only peaceful time in my life. I do sometimes tune out. I do sometimes choose to focus on the silly songs on my playlist etc but if things are tough in my daily life running is when I sort it out. I do not have that same sense of focus when I lift or strength train, I am too busy counting reps, making sure my form is correct etc...focusing on differnt things so I do not face my issues in the same way.
To each thier own...it is ok if running is not the end all be all for you...and it is equally ok that I feel differently...exercise is the key.
Don't get me wrong. I'd much rather someone run than sit on the couch and eat Cheetos. I just think that society today has a very unhealthy addiction to it. Look at the Nike running ads! Look at running shoes! You don't see Nike commercials of people lifting up rocks or pushing cars or moving barrels of hay.
And just for the record if you think running is aiding your weight loss you're wrong!
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/most_recent/conditioning_is_a_sham
'Running 5 miles would be an example of a great way to avoid addressing the issue. '
So.....you're hurt Nike doesn't have commercials for weightlifters?
No I'm not hurt. I'm using it to illustrate a point. Nike doesn't have as many commercials for weight lifters because the truth is we have a healthy relationship with out sport. We're not fanatical about it. Runners see someone running and it's like a heroin addict watching someone cook up a batch of heroin. Therefore Nike makes more running commercials.0 -
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
My favorite part. The idea of mice doing dead lifts and squats will probably keep me smiling like a dork for the rest of the day.
And a scientist with a clipboard yelling "Lift, mice LIFT! There's a dude on an internet forum counting on you!!!"0 -
well if that's the case, here you go.http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression-and-exercise/MH00043
summary: exercise can help with depression...the form of exercise is less important than just the fact that you moved...so lift, run, garden
http://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/help-information/mental-health-a-z/E/exercise-mental-health/
essentially says that exercise is important and that the type of exercise you do is best determine by what works for you, your goals, your family, what your enjoy and what you will keep doing....for some
3. Exercise Regularly
Thirty minutes of brisk aerobic exercising--such as running, swimming or bicycling--has been known to relieve most mild forms of depression. In the most immediate sense, it provides an outlet for negative emotions, allowing you to "burn off" feelings of anger or frustration in a positive way. On a more general level, it increases your energy and helps you to feel better about yourself. Studies have shown that regular exercise not only relieves mild symptoms of depression, but makes it less likely that they will come back. Regular exercise is less effective for relieving more serious forms of depression, but can still be helpful in conjunction with formal types of therapy.
Read more: http://www.livestrong.com/article/13224-relieve-depression/#ixzz2Tqt0IZQu
The point is, some people can relieve stress, depression etc by running. The fact that you feel that you are avoiding your problems is personal to you. I feel no extra personal strength from lifting. I feel more in touch with my spiritual side after a long run, and I have thought through my problems when I run. I find I cannot escapte from my life when I run but rather that I have to face it in my only peaceful time in my life. I do sometimes tune out. I do sometimes choose to focus on the silly songs on my playlist etc but if things are tough in my daily life running is when I sort it out. I do not have that same sense of focus when I lift or strength train, I am too busy counting reps, making sure my form is correct etc...focusing on differnt things so I do not face my issues in the same way.
To each thier own...it is ok if running is not the end all be all for you...and it is equally ok that I feel differently...exercise is the key.
Don't get me wrong. I'd much rather someone run than sit on the couch and eat Cheetos. I just think that society today has a very unhealthy addiction to it. Look at the Nike running ads! Look at running shoes! You don't see Nike commercials of people lifting up rocks or pushing cars or moving barrels of hay.
And just for the record if you think running is aiding your weight loss you're wrong!
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/most_recent/conditioning_is_a_sham
'Running 5 miles would be an example of a great way to avoid addressing the issue. '
So.....you're hurt Nike doesn't have commercials for weightlifters?
0 -
I'm sorry but this sounds stupid. IDK about other people... or mice... but withdrawal from running is not something I deal with. I don't run to get away from my problems. I don't lift to get away from my problems. Because no matter what I'm doing at the gym, when I come back, my problem will still be there. I have always been a no nonsense kidn of person. I was like that when I was fat and I'm still like that now that I am fitter. If I have a problem, I figure it out. Exercise is not going to make it all sunshine and rainbows. I'm not more assertive because I lift. I'm stronger because I lift but thats about it. I take care of the **** I need to take care of and then I go work out. I have one goal and one goal only when I'm running and lifting: to look hot. Everyone and everything else can kick rocks until I'm done taking care of my workout for the day.
Really really stupid post.
ETA: I don't need studies to back up my point because I am talking about my experience and my experience only. TBH the OP's post of journal articles means absolutely nothing to me becase I can't relate.
I agree. This post is stupid.
Thank you!
I thought that person posting was stupid as well.
LOL. I'm obviously dealing with an OP who doesn't like to be told about him/herself. it wouldn't be MFP without at least one stupid post a day. thanks for filling the quota! have fun with your post. I'm gonna go for a run then lift :laugh:
0 -
I agree with tstancom, above. This is bad use of the science. The study was used to study withdrawal for animals that had both severe food restriction AND over-exercise. It was a study to determine causes of anorexia.
If you actually read the literature, and look at the charts, you'd see that the scientists did NOT find significant differences between the rates of withdrawal among active, regularly fed rats and inactive restrictive or regularly fed rats. If you look at this chart from the study, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2786257/figure/F2/, it says straight out "Total withdrawal scores following injections of 1.0 mg/kg/sc naloxone in active and inactive female rats given food for 24-hours or 1-hour per day or inactive female rats pair-fed to active food-restricted female rats. Withdrawal scores not sharing a common letter are significantly different from each other." What scores shared a common letter? Everything except the severe food restricted, active rats.
I was also going to post the study that tstancom posted, but she beat me to it.
Finding data that seems to back up your position and then cherry picking it instead of performing a thorough analysis based on an understanding of statistical evaluation and scientific research does not help you in any way. The best way to create a fully rounded, agile, lean, strong, and healthy body is a combination of weight training, HIIT, and cardio, with a balanced diet. ALL of the studies point to that.0 -
Homo erectus ran the equivalent of marathons to catch food. http://cavepeopleandstuff.wordpress.com/2013/05/16/running-is-bad-for-you-because-what/ the history (and pre-history) of long distance running goes back a couple of million years further than the event mentioned in the OP
a) we evolved to be long distance runners before we evolved the ability to use fire or haft stone blades onto sticks to make spears. Its in our genes. I don't see how long distance running can be bad for humans. This is not the only form of exercise human ancestors engaged in, but I don't see how it can be bad for us.
b) it's not running away from problems, it's running towards a solution, i.e. catching an animal so you can have something to eat. You get it in response to all kinds of strenuous exercise, and I'd rather be an exercise junkie than a couch potato.
c) the endorphin response is a good thing, it evolved to enable our bodies to cope with stressful physical activity, including but not limited to running long distances.
or catching a mate so you can procreate?
based on studies of modern humans and also of close extant relatives to humans (i.e. chimps and bonobos), coupled with the fact that our species couldn't even stick to its own species, i.e. interbreeding with neanderthals and denisovans (and probably a few other species of human they just haven't found the actual genes yet), I think early humans would not have had to chase each other to find mates..... (I'm not saying humans are easy or anything, but...)0 -
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression-and-exercise/MH00043
summary: exercise can help with depression...the form of exercise is less important than just the fact that you moved...so lift, run, garden
http://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/help-information/mental-health-a-z/E/exercise-mental-health/
essentially says that exercise is important and that the type of exercise you do is best determine by what works for you, your goals, your family, what your enjoy and what you will keep doing....for some
3. Exercise Regularly
Thirty minutes of brisk aerobic exercising--such as running, swimming or bicycling--has been known to relieve most mild forms of depression. In the most immediate sense, it provides an outlet for negative emotions, allowing you to "burn off" feelings of anger or frustration in a positive way. On a more general level, it increases your energy and helps you to feel better about yourself. Studies have shown that regular exercise not only relieves mild symptoms of depression, but makes it less likely that they will come back. Regular exercise is less effective for relieving more serious forms of depression, but can still be helpful in conjunction with formal types of therapy.
Read more: http://www.livestrong.com/article/13224-relieve-depression/#ixzz2Tqt0IZQu
The point is, some people can relieve stress, depression etc by running. The fact that you feel that you are avoiding your problems is personal to you. I feel no extra personal strength from lifting. I feel more in touch with my spiritual side after a long run, and I have thought through my problems when I run. I find I cannot escapte from my life when I run but rather that I have to face it in my only peaceful time in my life. I do sometimes tune out. I do sometimes choose to focus on the silly songs on my playlist etc but if things are tough in my daily life running is when I sort it out. I do not have that same sense of focus when I lift or strength train, I am too busy counting reps, making sure my form is correct etc...focusing on differnt things so I do not face my issues in the same way.
To each thier own...it is ok if running is not the end all be all for you...and it is equally ok that I feel differently...exercise is the key.
Don't get me wrong. I'd much rather someone run than sit on the couch and eat Cheetos. I just think that society today has a very unhealthy addiction to it. Look at the Nike running ads! Look at running shoes! You don't see Nike commercials of people lifting up rocks or pushing cars or moving barrels of hay.
And just for the record if you think running is aiding your weight loss you're wrong!
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/most_recent/conditioning_is_a_sham
'Running 5 miles would be an example of a great way to avoid addressing the issue. '
So.....you're hurt Nike doesn't have commercials for weightlifters?
No I'm not hurt. I'm using it to illustrate a point. Nike doesn't have as many commercials for weight lifters because the truth is we have a healthy relationship with out sport. We're not fanatical about it. Runners see someone running and it's like a heroin addict watching someone cook up a batch of heroin. Therefore Nike makes more running commercials.
Or runners go through more shoes? Possibly? And thus are targeted as a demographic more often?0 -
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression-and-exercise/MH00043
summary: exercise can help with depression...the form of exercise is less important than just the fact that you moved...so lift, run, garden
http://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/help-information/mental-health-a-z/E/exercise-mental-health/
essentially says that exercise is important and that the type of exercise you do is best determine by what works for you, your goals, your family, what your enjoy and what you will keep doing....for some
3. Exercise Regularly
Thirty minutes of brisk aerobic exercising--such as running, swimming or bicycling--has been known to relieve most mild forms of depression. In the most immediate sense, it provides an outlet for negative emotions, allowing you to "burn off" feelings of anger or frustration in a positive way. On a more general level, it increases your energy and helps you to feel better about yourself. Studies have shown that regular exercise not only relieves mild symptoms of depression, but makes it less likely that they will come back. Regular exercise is less effective for relieving more serious forms of depression, but can still be helpful in conjunction with formal types of therapy.
Read more: http://www.livestrong.com/article/13224-relieve-depression/#ixzz2Tqt0IZQu
The point is, some people can relieve stress, depression etc by running. The fact that you feel that you are avoiding your problems is personal to you. I feel no extra personal strength from lifting. I feel more in touch with my spiritual side after a long run, and I have thought through my problems when I run. I find I cannot escapte from my life when I run but rather that I have to face it in my only peaceful time in my life. I do sometimes tune out. I do sometimes choose to focus on the silly songs on my playlist etc but if things are tough in my daily life running is when I sort it out. I do not have that same sense of focus when I lift or strength train, I am too busy counting reps, making sure my form is correct etc...focusing on differnt things so I do not face my issues in the same way.
To each thier own...it is ok if running is not the end all be all for you...and it is equally ok that I feel differently...exercise is the key.
Don't get me wrong. I'd much rather someone run than sit on the couch and eat Cheetos. I just think that society today has a very unhealthy addiction to it. Look at the Nike running ads! Look at running shoes! You don't see Nike commercials of people lifting up rocks or pushing cars or moving barrels of hay.
And just for the record if you think running is aiding your weight loss you're wrong!
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/most_recent/conditioning_is_a_sham
'Running 5 miles would be an example of a great way to avoid addressing the issue. '
So.....you're hurt Nike doesn't have commercials for weightlifters?
No I'm not hurt. I'm using it to illustrate a point. Nike doesn't have as many commercials for weight lifters because the truth is we have a healthy relationship with out sport. We're not fanatical about it. Runners see someone running and it's like a heroin addict watching someone cook up a batch of heroin. Therefore Nike makes more running commercials.
Weight lifters never get fanatical about weight lifting? Uh huh.:huh:0 -
Running. I don't like conflict. lol0
-
But cherry picking was the only way OP could be right and attempt to belittle everyone else. Therefore, screw your facts from the same study! *eyeroll*I agree with tstancom, above. This is bad use of the science. The study was used to study withdrawal for animals that had both severe food restriction AND over-exercise. It was a study to determine causes of anorexia.
If you actually read the literature, and look at the charts, you'd see that the scientists did NOT find significant differences between the rates of withdrawal among active, regularly fed rats and inactive restrictive or regularly fed rats. If you look at this chart from the study, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2786257/figure/F2/, it says straight out "Total withdrawal scores following injections of 1.0 mg/kg/sc naloxone in active and inactive female rats given food for 24-hours or 1-hour per day or inactive female rats pair-fed to active food-restricted female rats. Withdrawal scores not sharing a common letter are significantly different from each other." What scores shared a common letter? Everything except the severe food restricted, active rats.
I was also going to post the study that tstancom posted, but she beat me to it.
Finding data that seems to back up your position and then cherry picking it instead of performing a thorough analysis based on an understanding of statistical evaluation and scientific research does not help you in any way. The best way to create a fully rounded, agile, lean, strong, and healthy body is a combination of weight training, HIIT, and cardio, with a balanced diet. ALL of the studies point to that.0 -
No I'm not hurt. I'm using it to illustrate a point. Nike doesn't have as many commercials for weight lifters because the truth is we have a healthy relationship with out sport. We're not fanatical about it. Runners see someone running and it's like a heroin addict watching someone cook up a batch of heroin. Therefore Nike makes more running commercials.
YES.
Heroin, powered by Nike.0 -
Irony at its finest.
Weight lifters never get fanatical about weight lifting? Uh huh.:huh:No I'm not hurt. I'm using it to illustrate a point. Nike doesn't have as many commercials for weight lifters because the truth is we have a healthy relationship with out sport. We're not fanatical about it. Runners see someone running and it's like a heroin addict watching someone cook up a batch of heroin. Therefore Nike makes more running commercials.0 -
Don't get me wrong. I love running. I used to run all the time. I was that guy that used to spend an hour on the treadmill everyday hoping to see results. But as I started lifting a realization occurred to me. Weightlifting puts you up close and gives the feeling of having personal close combat with your problems. Running on the other hand seems to be more about running away from your problems rather than facing them head on.
I mean look at marathon training for example. A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
The fact of the matter is that since I have started lifting I've been more focused and more determined to tackle my problems head on. I'm more assertive, more confident, and happier. In the past when I was really stressed out I would go for a run just to eliminate the stress but my problems were still there when I returned. Running was just a temporary escape from the problems of reality. Almost like how some would describe their drug use.
In fact did you know that studies have actually shown that running (particularly stationary running) causes withdrawal symptoms in mice?
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19634951
'There was a direct relationship between the intensity of running and the severity of withdrawal symptoms.'
'These findings support the hypothesis that exercise-induced increases in endogenous opioid peptides act in a manner similar to chronic administration of opiate drugs.'
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
Bottom line is that I would encourage each and every one of you to take a good long think about the person you want to become. Do you want to be the person that runs away from his/her problems or would you rather be the type of person that stands their ground and deals with their problems? I just can't support running on the hamster wheel and running outside is just a larger rat race because we always end up right back where we started and all our problems are still there waiting for us. We can be a hero like Hercules who faced his foes head on or we can be like Pheidippides and run away from our problems till it kills us.
The choice is yours . . .
Ankle biter. Dimming another's candle doesnt make yours any brighter.
I'm not trying to dim anyone's candle I'm just trying to get people to deal with their problems head on!
Instead of people having a calm and rational discussion everyone wants to attack me!0 -
Interesting you see it only as running away from problems, rather than running towards a solution.
Half empty/ Half full.
You have to look at the bias though and realize the OP prefers lifiting. Everything after that is justification.0 -
Were you streaking? At a game?I had a really, really good run yesterday.
From the cops.
i love this pic. my favorite part being how the "streaker's" toes are just. barely. making contact with the ground and yet his whole body is engaged in muscular effort. wonderful example of the human form in action. also love the facial expressions of everyone involved.0 -
i prefer to RUN towards my problems and tackle them just like i tackle an obstacle at the mud races I so enjoy doing - one at a time. The satisfaction i get from conquering an obstacle at a race (be it a ditch i must crawl through - afraid of the dark; or a 12 foot wall - afraid of heights) the satisfaction i get weight lifting. i am so glad i'm not a mouse.0
-
Maybe it has something to do with the fact that you picked out statements from a study to try and back a false claim that running is bad and essentially put down a lot of people here while ignoring the rest of the facts from the study you posted! Then when others refute you with accurate facts and statements, you have ignored them and only replied to the ones who are simply "attacking" you.Don't get me wrong. I love running. I used to run all the time. I was that guy that used to spend an hour on the treadmill everyday hoping to see results. But as I started lifting a realization occurred to me. Weightlifting puts you up close and gives the feeling of having personal close combat with your problems. Running on the other hand seems to be more about running away from your problems rather than facing them head on.
I mean look at marathon training for example. A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
The fact of the matter is that since I have started lifting I've been more focused and more determined to tackle my problems head on. I'm more assertive, more confident, and happier. In the past when I was really stressed out I would go for a run just to eliminate the stress but my problems were still there when I returned. Running was just a temporary escape from the problems of reality. Almost like how some would describe their drug use.
In fact did you know that studies have actually shown that running (particularly stationary running) causes withdrawal symptoms in mice?
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19634951
'There was a direct relationship between the intensity of running and the severity of withdrawal symptoms.'
'These findings support the hypothesis that exercise-induced increases in endogenous opioid peptides act in a manner similar to chronic administration of opiate drugs.'
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
Bottom line is that I would encourage each and every one of you to take a good long think about the person you want to become. Do you want to be the person that runs away from his/her problems or would you rather be the type of person that stands their ground and deals with their problems? I just can't support running on the hamster wheel and running outside is just a larger rat race because we always end up right back where we started and all our problems are still there waiting for us. We can be a hero like Hercules who faced his foes head on or we can be like Pheidippides and run away from our problems till it kills us.
The choice is yours . . .
Ankle biter. Dimming another's candle doesnt make yours any brighter.
I'm not trying to dim anyone's candle I'm just trying to get people to deal with their problems head on!
Instead of people having a calm and rational discussion everyone wants to attack me!
Just a possibility, but I run so I must have some sort of mental disability.0 -
Woah woah woah. Come on now, everybody. While I deeply disagree with the original poster's assertions, I would KILL OR DIE for his right to express them. Let's cool down all the censorship talk. This is a support website!0
-
For me, running gives me time to sort out solutions, when I run all things in my lift become managable and many of the answers I'm looking for come to light.
Lifting, on the other hand, helps to empower me and supports my self confidence.
They both give me something I need, and neither one is avoidance.0 -
Maybe it has something to do with the fact that you picked out statements from a study to try and back a false claim that running is bad and essentially put down a lot of people here while ignoring the rest of the facts from the study you posted! Then when others refute you with accurate facts and statements, you have ignored them and only replied to the ones who are simply "attacking" you.Don't get me wrong. I love running. I used to run all the time. I was that guy that used to spend an hour on the treadmill everyday hoping to see results. But as I started lifting a realization occurred to me. Weightlifting puts you up close and gives the feeling of having personal close combat with your problems. Running on the other hand seems to be more about running away from your problems rather than facing them head on.
I mean look at marathon training for example. A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
The fact of the matter is that since I have started lifting I've been more focused and more determined to tackle my problems head on. I'm more assertive, more confident, and happier. In the past when I was really stressed out I would go for a run just to eliminate the stress but my problems were still there when I returned. Running was just a temporary escape from the problems of reality. Almost like how some would describe their drug use.
In fact did you know that studies have actually shown that running (particularly stationary running) causes withdrawal symptoms in mice?
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19634951
'There was a direct relationship between the intensity of running and the severity of withdrawal symptoms.'
'These findings support the hypothesis that exercise-induced increases in endogenous opioid peptides act in a manner similar to chronic administration of opiate drugs.'
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
Bottom line is that I would encourage each and every one of you to take a good long think about the person you want to become. Do you want to be the person that runs away from his/her problems or would you rather be the type of person that stands their ground and deals with their problems? I just can't support running on the hamster wheel and running outside is just a larger rat race because we always end up right back where we started and all our problems are still there waiting for us. We can be a hero like Hercules who faced his foes head on or we can be like Pheidippides and run away from our problems till it kills us.
The choice is yours . . .
Ankle biter. Dimming another's candle doesnt make yours any brighter.
I'm not trying to dim anyone's candle I'm just trying to get people to deal with their problems head on!
Instead of people having a calm and rational discussion everyone wants to attack me!
Just a possibility, but I run so I must have some sort of mental disability.
The fact that you're comparing your addiction to a mental disability is the first step to recovery.
If you need help I'm here for you.0 -
0
-
Weakest argument against cardio ever.0
-
Your sarcasm meter's broken. You might want to get that looked at.
Maybe it has something to do with the fact that you picked out statements from a study to try and back a false claim that running is bad and essentially put down a lot of people here while ignoring the rest of the facts from the study you posted! Then when others refute you with accurate facts and statements, you have ignored them and only replied to the ones who are simply "attacking" you.Don't get me wrong. I love running. I used to run all the time. I was that guy that used to spend an hour on the treadmill everyday hoping to see results. But as I started lifting a realization occurred to me. Weightlifting puts you up close and gives the feeling of having personal close combat with your problems. Running on the other hand seems to be more about running away from your problems rather than facing them head on.
I mean look at marathon training for example. A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
The fact of the matter is that since I have started lifting I've been more focused and more determined to tackle my problems head on. I'm more assertive, more confident, and happier. In the past when I was really stressed out I would go for a run just to eliminate the stress but my problems were still there when I returned. Running was just a temporary escape from the problems of reality. Almost like how some would describe their drug use.
In fact did you know that studies have actually shown that running (particularly stationary running) causes withdrawal symptoms in mice?
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19634951
'There was a direct relationship between the intensity of running and the severity of withdrawal symptoms.'
'These findings support the hypothesis that exercise-induced increases in endogenous opioid peptides act in a manner similar to chronic administration of opiate drugs.'
They didn't do a study involving mice with weight lifting but I'm sure they would've seen different results.
Bottom line is that I would encourage each and every one of you to take a good long think about the person you want to become. Do you want to be the person that runs away from his/her problems or would you rather be the type of person that stands their ground and deals with their problems? I just can't support running on the hamster wheel and running outside is just a larger rat race because we always end up right back where we started and all our problems are still there waiting for us. We can be a hero like Hercules who faced his foes head on or we can be like Pheidippides and run away from our problems till it kills us.
The choice is yours . . .
Ankle biter. Dimming another's candle doesnt make yours any brighter.
I'm not trying to dim anyone's candle I'm just trying to get people to deal with their problems head on!
Instead of people having a calm and rational discussion everyone wants to attack me!
Just a possibility, but I run so I must have some sort of mental disability.
The fact that you're comparing your addiction to a mental disability is the first step to recovery.
If you need help I'm here for you.0 -
Woah woah woah. Come on now, everybody. While I deeply disagree with the original poster's assertions, I would KILL OR DIE for his right to express them. Let's cool down all the censorship talk. This is a support website!
I agree. People get mad whenever someone tells it like it is.0 -
I'm not trying to dim anyone's candle I'm just trying to get people to deal with their problems head on!
Instead of people having a calm and rational discussion everyone wants to attack me!
No-one's attacking you. They just don't agree with what you're saying, and I think this thread is quite calm and rational.
I don't even run. I lift weights. I just don't agree with what you're saying.0 -
There's always going to be a study and then theres always going to be study to contradict the first study.
To each their own...whatever makes you happy: DO IT. Not everyone likes to lift and not everyone likes to run. Find what you like and run with it. (No pun intended)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions