Just watched Forks Over Knives...

245

Replies

  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    This topic seems like it could be divisive......just sayin'

    Apparently so, but I did not intend for it to be. I have tried vegetarianism before, I'm not a big meat eater, and dairy makes me sick. I also found the video to be interesting (just as I found Campbell's book), and it sparked a desire to get back into eating more healthfully. I was wondering if anyone else has seen it, and/or interesting in the same thing. That is all.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    Can I have your meat? lol

    Funny, and sure
  • gettingfitkit
    gettingfitkit Posts: 2 Member
    I am new in my journey, but am on day 29 meat free. have still been eating some cheese, yogurt, and coffee creamer. planning on cutting out all dairy starting Friday. A year ago I read A world without cancer, the story of B17 and it really got me on a path to seeking out truth in our food sources, non gmo foods, and looking for free range meats/ dairy for my family....I got an amazon prime subscription for Christmas and watched forks over knives, food inc, and vegecated. They all blew my mind & we decided as a family to eat more meat free meals together. You can do it!
  • gettingfitkit
    gettingfitkit Posts: 2 Member
    I agree, the movies are just to help us be more educated, like books, ect. Of course there are opinions all over the place....But I believe If you eat to live and want to live a clean life, then you will search out the clean sources or eliminate these items all together. More whole foods and less processed foods is the key... more home cooking and less convenience food full of chemicals. I am choosing to live a plant based life, but understand if it is not for everyone.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    I have been thinking the same thing. I watched that movie and the movie "Food Matters" and think a lot about cutting out dairy. I keep hearing so much evidence out there about how harmful it can be to your body. I also have an auto-immune disorder (rheumatoid arthritis) and have heard about people being cured by cutting out certain inflammatory foods. I think everyone is different and for some people dairy is just fine. I don't know why people get so bent out of shape though when others mention it. Nobody is going to take away your meat or cheese, settle down! Exploring the health benefits of multiple styles of eating is not a bad thing.

    I haven't seen that movie, but I might check it out. I also have health problems that dairy severely aggravates, and I can't even have regular milk products without getting sick (though it is oh so hard to give up cheese!). Idk why people get bent out of shape either, or assume because you mention it that you haven't done any research, let a movie/documentary dictate your diet (I mean that was just ignorant), or that you have to eat meat/dairy to be healthy, or happy. I'm glad you are looking into it for your health, and I wish you much success.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    Be very careful just watching documentaries like these and taking them on face value.

    They are not neutral investigations, they have a conclusion already and then show you want they want to fit that conclusion.

    There are a lot of write-ups on the net showing the flaws in this movie (and it is a movie, not a documentary) if you use Google.

    Here's one if you cant be bothered:

    http://yourdoctorsorders.com/2012/05/forks-over-knives/

    And another more well known one:

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/



    You can pick holes in either side I guess, but Forks Over Knives is giving you one opinion and interpretation of data only. You should always see other interpretations and even research stuff yourself and learn rather than believe anything you see on tv or in the media.

    Thanks for the info. I will look into it.
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Be very careful just watching documentaries like these and taking them on face value.

    They are not neutral investigations, they have a conclusion already and then show you want they want to fit that conclusion.

    There are a lot of write-ups on the net showing the flaws in this movie (and it is a movie, not a documentary) if you use Google.

    Here's one if you cant be bothered:

    http://yourdoctorsorders.com/2012/05/forks-over-knives/

    And another more well known one:

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/



    You can pick holes in either side I guess, but Forks Over Knives is giving you one opinion and interpretation of data only. You should always see other interpretations and even research stuff yourself and learn rather than believe anything you see on tv or in the media.

    Thanks for the info. I will look into it.

    Please do. I'm all for people becoming vegetarians/vegans for ethical reasons but don't let things like forks over knives, or the china study, convince you of things.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    Glad you're getting such useful advice, OP!

    Don't let this crap bother you. There are a group of folks on this board who love to be divisive and rude just for the fun of it. It's pretty sad. However, there's a lot of good info in a recent thread called 'Why should I go Vegan?' - check it out. And glad you watched it. Quite a powerful documentary.

    Thanks. Yeah, the advice really helps. Guess I won't get any more dietary advice from movies, ignore the fact that dairy products make me sick, and that I'm not a big meat eater....Oh well, my life will be happier with digestive problems and rash from dairy and beef. Gotta love it.

    I will check out the thread. Thanks again.
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    Be very careful just watching documentaries like these and taking them on face value.

    They are not neutral investigations, they have a conclusion already and then show you want they want to fit that conclusion.

    There are a lot of write-ups on the net showing the flaws in this movie (and it is a movie, not a documentary) if you use Google.

    Here's one if you cant be bothered:

    http://yourdoctorsorders.com/2012/05/forks-over-knives/

    And another more well known one:

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/



    You can pick holes in either side I guess, but Forks Over Knives is giving you one opinion and interpretation of data only. You should always see other interpretations and even research stuff yourself and learn rather than believe anything you see on tv or in the media.

    Thanks for the info. I will look into it.

    Please do. I'm all for people becoming vegetarians/vegans for ethical reasons but don't let things like forks over knives, or the china study, convince you of things.

    I'd actually like any info you have about why the china study is so horribly flawed. genuinely curious.
  • Topher1978
    Topher1978 Posts: 975 Member
    I actually watched that yesterday. Interesting film, though not exactly new information. There is medical evidence that too much meat, especially red meat, can increase risk of disease. And the reversal of disease experienced by the study participants was impressive, but it's not as if the only change to their diet was the eilimination of meat. A control group that made the switch to a whole food plant based diet but also included meat would have been helpful to show how much of a role the elimination of meat played.
    ^^^ No doubt!
  • greenmeena
    greenmeena Posts: 118 Member
    People aren't going to stop eating meat. I would rather people support local farms, and grass-fed/ humanely raised animals. I'm speaking as a vet, too!! People love their meat, our bodies love meat- so rather than black and white, all or nothing, educating folk and encouraging people to eat local is really the way to go. I was vegan and/or vegetarian for a long time and had lots of GI issues which pretty much went away when I began to eat meat again. I eat consciously, locally- it's expensive but I vote with my dollars. Support local farms, happy local animals (who you can see and visit!) and decentralize large factory farms- whether you're an omnivore or vegetarian.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    I watched that movie too. But MOVIES are just another way media tries to shake us and change our way of thinking and in this case eating. I'd research a bit more before cutting out the deliciousness of dairy (I'm already a vegetarian haha) it has so many benefits and is delicious!

    So, I take it you are a Lacto-Ovo Vegetarian? I have done research before, but my issue is that dairy makes me sick. The benefits don't outweigh the problems for me. However, I do agree with you about the deliciousness of it (well, as far as cheese goes, because I haven't been able to drink milk in years).
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    Happy Herbavores is a great group here on MFP. We share lots of recipes and there are tons of us new(er) vegans to support each other.
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/forums/show/62-happy-herbivores

    Thanks!
  • EvgeniZyntx
    EvgeniZyntx Posts: 24,208 Member
    Be very careful just watching documentaries like these and taking them on face value.

    They are not neutral investigations, they have a conclusion already and then show you want they want to fit that conclusion.

    There are a lot of write-ups on the net showing the flaws in this movie (and it is a movie, not a documentary) if you use Google.

    Here's one if you cant be bothered:

    http://yourdoctorsorders.com/2012/05/forks-over-knives/

    And another more well known one:

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/



    You can pick holes in either side I guess, but Forks Over Knives is giving you one opinion and interpretation of data only. You should always see other interpretations and even research stuff yourself and learn rather than believe anything you see on tv or in the media.

    Thanks for the info. I will look into it.

    Please do. I'm all for people becoming vegetarians/vegans for ethical reasons but don't let things like forks over knives, or the china study, convince you of things.

    I'd actually like any info you have about why the china study is so horribly flawed. genuinely curious.

    There is a good summary here: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/the-china-study-revisited/
  • greenmeena
    greenmeena Posts: 118 Member
    Also- research showing meat making people sick is skewed. All the meat researched is from factory farmed animals who are fed large amounts of corn (etc) and not eating a natural diet they were evolved to eat. Cows fed corn and silage have an imbalanced fatty acid profile, favoring Omega 6 over Omega 3- increasing inflammatory mediators in the body. Same goes for chickens, and farmed salmon (incredibly inflammatory!!!). Increasing inflammatory mediators in the body is what encourages heart disease, not the meat itself. Vilifying meat this way is short sighted. Grass fed beef is actually quite high in Omega 3s. Just like venison- some of the healthiest meats out there!

    And there is a lot to be said for moderation. No one needs a 16 oz steak, really.
  • Topher1978
    Topher1978 Posts: 975 Member
    Now, why would meat and dairy be bad for an animal that evolved to eat meat and dairy and is designed to eat meat and dairy?
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    Also- research showing meat making people sick is skewed. All the meat researched is from factory farmed animals who are fed large amounts of corn (etc) and not eating a natural diet they were evolved to eat. Cows fed corn and silage have an imbalanced fatty acid profile, favoring Omega 6 over Omega 3- increasing inflammatory mediators in the body. Same goes for chickens, and farmed salmon (incredibly inflammatory!!!). Increasing inflammatory mediators in the body is what encourages heart disease, not the meat itself. Vilifying meat this way is short sighted. Grass fed beef is actually quite high in Omega 3s. Just like venison- some of the healthiest meats out there!

    And there is a lot to be said for moderation. No one needs a 16 oz steak, really.

    right - but the point is that the majority of americans aren't eating grass-fed beef. they're eating the cheapest stuff available, which is also the crappiest.

    (i do agree with every bit of your first post)
  • yourenotmine
    yourenotmine Posts: 645 Member
    My thoughts on the Vegan/Vegetarian thing is this: If it's something that you want to do for yourself, do it. If you feel your health will benefit and you want to do it go for it. Don't do it because some video/person/book/website/etc... told you it was the best way to live your life. The best way to live your life is the way you want to. If what you are doing right now is making you healthy and happy and you don't feel you need to change then don't. Only make the change if it's what you feel is best for you.

    That's just my 2 cents.

    What if I want to live my life smoking crack. Is that the best for me?

    Dude, that's your business. Just don't have babies or kill anyone.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    My thoughts on the Vegan/Vegetarian thing is this: If it's something that you want to do for yourself, do it. If you feel your health will benefit and you want to do it go for it. Don't do it because some video/person/book/website/etc... told you it was the best way to live your life. The best way to live your life is the way you want to. If what you are doing right now is making you healthy and happy and you don't feel you need to change then don't. Only make the change if it's what you feel is best for you.

    That's just my 2 cents.

    Thanks for your 2 cents! I completely agree, and I apparently gave the wrong impression with my post. I am not doing it, or thinking about doing it, because of the movie. The movie made me rethink what I have been eating, what I like to eat, how my body reacts to certain foods, and how I can improve on my previous attempt at vegetarianism. It is not for everyone to do, and I can respect that. I'm glad you do as well.
  • queenbelove
    queenbelove Posts: 33 Member
    I was all for it too when I watched it. Then I did some research of my own and found out that there is some seriously flawed data in that movie. Check out this review. It's probably the world's longest movie review but it explains the errors in detail.

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/

    Thanks. I will check it out.
  • moustache_flavored_lube
    moustache_flavored_lube Posts: 849 Member
    Eat whole foods, not to much, mostly plants

    Meat and dairy are good for you. Most bioligists / nutritionist agree on this.

    My advice would be to work hard to improve your diet to include a greater variety of healthy vegetables. Vegitarian cookbooks are a great place to get ideas.

    Fish
    eggs
    chicken breast
    turkey breast
    greek yogurt

    Have a place in a healthy diet
  • ashleyking3194
    ashleyking3194 Posts: 6 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.

    :drinker: this!!
  • moustache_flavored_lube
    moustache_flavored_lube Posts: 849 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.

    Yes please keep an open mind

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/07/07/the-china-study-fact-or-fallac/

    http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/the-china-study-revisited/

    If a vegan diet works for you, and you feel healthier because of it. Fine. (I think it is far better than the average American's diet)

    This movie / book is not scientific proof that meat and dairy are responsible for degenerative disease
  • EvanKeel
    EvanKeel Posts: 1,904 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.

    And other people have posted links to criticisms of the research in a non-rude and dismissive manner. It looks as if you have a strong desire to research. As proponent of one side of the discussion, I'm curious what your reasoned response is to the criticism.
  • angelams1019
    angelams1019 Posts: 1,102 Member
    I watched Forks Over Knives yesterday and took EVERYTHING from it EXCEPT "Stop eating meat and you won't die!!" I'm just not willing to give it up! :drinker:
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.

    And other people have posted links to criticisms of the research in a non-rude and dismissive manner. It looks as if you have a strong desire to research. As proponent of one side of the discussion, I'm curious what your reasoned response is to the criticism.

    where has this been posted? would love to see it. already asked once.
  • EvanKeel
    EvanKeel Posts: 1,904 Member
    Try reading the book, The China Study (the movie was based off some of the research found in this book). My family (in-laws and husband's extended family) follow this way of eating for health reasons as well as many of my friends. It is an amazing lifestyle. I strongly recommend checking it out if you were impressed by this movie. After that, make small changes at a time. Don't do it all at once. And even then, 80/20 is a good rule of thumb... eating this way 80 percent of the time and allowing yourself some dietary freedom 20 percent of the time.

    Also, it is a shame so many on here are insulting and rude and are dismissing this lifestyle right off the bat without understanding the mounds of documented research that supports this way of life. Right down to showing links to breast cancer and liver cancer. Anyhow, I applaud your open minded attitude toward pursuing health.

    And other people have posted links to criticisms of the research in a non-rude and dismissive manner. It looks as if you have a strong desire to research. As proponent of one side of the discussion, I'm curious what your reasoned response is to the criticism.

    where has this been posted? would love to see it. already asked once.

    And someone answered you on page 2. I believe someone also posted something on page 3, though perhaps before you asked a second time. But here's the previous response:
    Be very careful just watching documentaries like these and taking them on face value.

    They are not neutral investigations, they have a conclusion already and then show you want they want to fit that conclusion.

    There are a lot of write-ups on the net showing the flaws in this movie (and it is a movie, not a documentary) if you use Google.

    Here's one if you cant be bothered:

    http://yourdoctorsorders.com/2012/05/forks-over-knives/

    And another more well known one:

    http://rawfoodsos.com/2011/09/22/forks-over-knives-is-the-science-legit-a-review-and-critique/



    You can pick holes in either side I guess, but Forks Over Knives is giving you one opinion and interpretation of data only. You should always see other interpretations and even research stuff yourself and learn rather than believe anything you see on tv or in the media.

    Thanks for the info. I will look into it.

    Please do. I'm all for people becoming vegetarians/vegans for ethical reasons but don't let things like forks over knives, or the china study, convince you of things.

    I'd actually like any info you have about why the china study is so horribly flawed. genuinely curious.

    There is a good summary here: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/the-china-study-revisited/
  • Vercell
    Vercell Posts: 437 Member
    i just watched epic meal time and now im thinking about eating bacon and drinking copious amounts of alcohol
  • moustache_flavored_lube
    moustache_flavored_lube Posts: 849 Member


    where has this been posted? would love to see it. already asked once.
    32864367.jpg
This discussion has been closed.

Categories