Running. An avoidance behavior?
Replies
-
Well only one is going to help you if you are trying to get away from zombies
Or if you get into a little trouble
Or time traveling
well maybe if you need to bust up a chair, then weight lifting would help.
0 -
Thanks for your comment, I just join the gym and I've been doing more weight lifting and its more challenging to me but, I love it.0
-
The study has to do with withdrawal symptoms for activity-based anorexia. It's not saying that running is bad for everyone. It has to do specifically with rats that were withheld food and their reactions.
I'm not saying lifting is bad either. I'm in the camp that cardio and strength should not be mutually exclusive. I think they are both very important.0 -
As contrarian mentioned, I am both a runner and a lifter. Thus, I could beat you up. Or, if I find I could not, I can run away.
And you say it causes withdrawal symptoms. You know what else causes withdrawal symptoms? YOUR MOM.
Or you could run fast enough to catch him...and then beat him up?
0 -
Last I checked, my problems are still there after I lift heavy things and put them down, too.
Exercise isn't necessarily about tackling problems. For me, it's to be healthy and feel good about myself, and I actually actively meet and tackle running problems while running. Some days every step is a problem I have to fight with. I don't use it to cope with life issues, and running doesn't mean i'm running away from anything. I don't feel any more cowardly for having started it, just like the messenger from Marathon wasn't a coward for following his commander's orders and delivering his message.
I think you've got the wrong idea. But, different strokes for different folks.0 -
I run because I love it, I lift to get stronger, I sit down and actually work on my problems to fix them.0
-
i'll have to take a look at this later...
and.....having with withdrawal, you can get that from anything....0 -
Wait, Pheidippides was a coward and a failure? He completed his assigned mission before he died.0
-
I'll be the first to be eaten by zombies, as I can't outrun them or kick their *kitten*.
That is all.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Well, the study to end all studies is the one that proves stronger people are harder to kill. It's not just common sense; it's science.Muscular strength is inversely and independently associated with death from all causes and cancer in men, even after adjusting for cardiorespiratory fitness and other potential confounders.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2453303/0 -
I'll be the first to be eaten by zombies, as I can't outrun them or kick their *kitten*.
That is all.
You can be my Otis, honey.0 -
I run so I can drink more beer. The end.
FTW!!! :drinker:
I'm worried that you're using one addiction to fuel another.0 -
Calling lungs courageous is poetic, but dumb.
I still have yet to see anything but pretty words from people who disagree with this post. No studies yet. Funny, that...
Fine if I have to be the guy that puts up for all the runner's out there, there is one peer reviewed and Journal-published piece of work[1]. They SPECIFICALLY mention jogging about five times in the four page paper.
[1]: http://www.lhj.com/health/fitness/whats-so-great-about-cardio/0 -
I see nothing wrong with running. I feel free whenever I can do it. Not free from my problems or battle but just from the shackles of life. It's something I miss terribly. I've never thought of it as running FROM something but more like running TOWARDS something. There's something so mind numbing and zen about the footfalls repeating over and over, and something empowering about the fact that I can do it with just my body, no props, machines, or anything. I think it's a freedom lovers endeavor and nothing less.
I think strength training with weights has it's obvious advantages too, but I think neither is mutually exclusive. Unless you have a rival like a sancho or something who is a runner, i'm not sure why you'd feel the need to bash running in order to embrace lifting?
Love this quote. I just took up running (C25K) and this quote says it all.
Calling lungs courageous is poetic, but dumb.
I still have yet to see anything but pretty words from people who disagree with this post. No studies yet. Funny, that...
what should the study be about? that lifting causes the same problem. or negating his study's results about running being addictive? that study by the way didn't really mean much to me since....rats, and mice. I'm not sure how they'd get the little dumbbells and other weights in their tiny hands...anyway?0 -
I'll be the first to be eaten by zombies, as I can't outrun them or kick their *kitten*.
That is all.
You can be my Otis, honey.
*SWOON*0 -
I've always been one that believes everyone should have a right to their own beliefs. I also believe that this community has done a great job of being supportive. My thought is that coming and making a post that you knowingly would inflammatory is very small minded or if you didn't think this would stir up a pot then perhaps you should start working out the muscle between your ears a bit.
Secondly you should brush up a bit on your greek mythology, Pheidippides was actually sent 1st to get help from sparta and ran over 140 miles. He died AFTER the battle at Marathon running back to announce the victory at Marathon.
While I may not have any studies that say "nuh uh" I love to run perhaps as much as you love to lift. I think any behavior could be used as an avoidance vehicle, why is going to the gym and tuning out the world any different than those that run to tune out the world. I've gone from 265lbs to 185 now lifting AND running and I am more social now than ever.
PS as soon as I start getting my mice to do some deadlifts and curls I will send you the study results0 -
A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
dude, learn your history... he ran a hell of a lot more than that, and wasn't "running away from the battle" and was NOT labelled a failure and a coward.
http://www.lakepowell.net/marathon.html
The Role of Phidippides
The Athens, vastly outnumbered, desperately needed the help of Sparta's military base to help fend off the attack. Time was short, so the Athenian generals send Phidippides (or Philippides) a professional runner to Sparta to ask for help. The 140 mile course was very mountainous and rugged. Phidippides ran the course in about 36 hours. Sparta agreed to help but said they would not take the field until the moon was full due to religious laws. This would leave the Athenians alone to fight the Persian Army. Phidippides ran back to Athens (another 140 miles!) with the disappointing news. Immediately, the small Athenian Army (including Phidippedes) marched to the plains of Marathon to prepare for battle.
The Battle of Marathon
The Athenian Army was outnumbered 4 to 1 but they launched a surprise offensive thrust which at the time appeared suicidal. But by day's end, 6400 Persian bodies lay dead on the field while only 192 Athenians had been killed. The surviving Persians fled to sea and headed south to Athens where they hoped to attack the city before the Greek Army could re-assemble there.
Phidippides was again called upon to run to Athens (26 miles away) to carry the news of the victory and the warning about the approaching Persian ships. Despite his fatigue after his recent run to Sparta and back and having fought all morning in heavy armor, Phidippides rose to the challenge. Pushing himself past normal limits of human endurance, the reached Athens in perhaps 3 hours, delivered his message and then died shortly thereafter from exhaustion.
Ok. Perhaps he wasn't a failure but he still had to be the one to run and find 'real men' to be able to fight his battles.0 -
Most runners are not heroine-addicted, anorexic mice.
Some Buddhists (and others) meditate to clear their heads, some people exercise, some people use anti-depressants or anti-anxiety meds, some people watch TV, some people listen to music, some people look at flowing water, some people watch washing machines, some people garden, some people have sex, some people go shopping, some people play computer games, ad infinitum.
But of course, no scientists have decided to pump people with opiates to see if planting tulips increases withdrawal symptoms compared to lying on a sofa... probably an ethics thing.0 -
But of course, no scientists have decided to pump people with opiates to see if planting tulips increases withdrawal symptoms compared to lying on a sofa... probably an ethics thing.
Uhm, is this study seeking volunteers?0 -
I run so I can drink more beer. The end.
FTW!!! :drinker:
I'm worried that you're using one addiction to fuel another.
Nah...I don't even run. I was just excited about beer.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Calling lungs courageous is poetic, but dumb.
I still have yet to see anything but pretty words from people who disagree with this post. No studies yet. Funny, that...
Fine if I have to be the guy that puts up for all the runner's out there, there is one peer reviewed and Journal-published piece of work[1]. They SPECIFICALLY mention jogging about five times in the four page paper.
[1]: http://www.lhj.com/health/fitness/whats-so-great-about-cardio/
When a woman can walk briskly for half an hour+, she has achieved cardio fitness?
huh.0 -
I would say you are projecting, and overthinking it.
I run because I need to burn more calories, enjoy getting outdoors in the summer, or on the treadmill to burn calories and watch something I was going to watch anyways. And it makes me feel freakin fantastic afterwards.
I lift because I like muscles and the sense of accomplishment from getting stronger.
Nothing more complex than that.0 -
Most runners are not heroine-addicted, anorexic mice.
Some Buddhists (and others) meditate to clear their heads, some people exercise, some people use anti-depressants or anti-anxiety meds, some people watch TV, some people listen to music, some people look at flowing water, some people watch washing machines, some people garden, some people have sex, some people go shopping, some people play computer games, ad infinitum.
But of course, no scientists have decided to pump people with opiates to see if planting tulips increases withdrawal symptoms compared to lying on a sofa... probably an ethics thing.
I highly doubt meditation, washing machines, and flowing water induce withdrawal symptoms.0 -
I'm failing to see how time spent running or lifting weights has any effect on finding solutions to our 'problems', (apart from fitness). And if it does then that is a bonus.
I do lots of different types of exercise, including running, and the one factor I like about all of them is the challenge - to lift a heavier weight, do more reps, increase flexibility and balance, go further or faster. Therefore, I run because I like the challenge aspect.
You disregard the fact that not everyone uses exercise to try and tackle unspecified problems, and that you can continually challenge yourself in all forms of exercise. That's how I see it anyway.
Just because you like weight lifting does not make running suddenly inferior. It's simply different. People run for different reasons and will find it effects them differently.
I guess for some people who use it as quiet time, or alone time to sort through their problems. I tend to workout with friends so I guess sometimes the chit chatting if I'm only walking achieves that. I wouldn't really say I did that while running, but I could see how others might? The second bolded part is true for me. I don't see it as a problem solving endeavor per se. Just as a way to burn cals or build muscle. Depending on the activity and intensity. Sometimes even as a way to relax plain and simple. It's just certain workouts I do have built in rewards like getting to the top of a rock to see the view, or etc. To me it's not that big of a deal. If my workouts work for me, why should I care how other's use theirs. Now if my husband took up running and he started to behave like an addict, having mantrum's when he didnt get to do it, then I'd see the sense in posting this. IF something similar is happening in OP's life and its affecting him, then I understand, so far I don't yet. Except to open discourse on the much debated cardio VERSUS lifting debate. Which plenty of people have chimed in doesn't have to be an either or proposition.0 -
OK, the study that the OP refers to is talking about EXERCISE ADDICTION in which the subject is over-exercising to produce a chemical effect from endorphins and dopamine. The only reason why it refers to running is because the study uses rats, so it is easier for scientists to stick them on a hamster-wheel than to get them to repeatedly lift heavy objects. Anybody here know any weight-lifting rats? Anybody? Anybody? No, but that doesn't mean we don't know PEOPLE that over-exercise in the weight room (or on the track, or in the dance studio, or the pool etc.) Please take your time to read a little more critically. <shakes head>
Now, for all you "show me the study!" people, here's a similar study that talks about how over-exercising - any form of overexercising, including weight lifting - causes an "opiate-like effect" such as that described in the study of the OP. Just to be clear - ANY type of over-exercising causes withdrawal symptoms, not just running.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3210598/
So, folks, go out and run or go out and lift, or go out and dance or do log-rolls or whatever the eff it is that helps you to work though your problems. Just become wary when WHATEVER form of exercise you are using becomes a way to escape your problems entirely instead of facing them.0 -
When it comes to health benefits of certain activities, you can pretty much always find studies and articles for and against. Just because there's a study doesn't mean it's the end-all be-all truth.I still have yet to see anything but pretty words from people who disagree with this post. No studies yet. Funny, that...
http://med.stanford.edu/news_releases/2008/august/running.html
http://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/bhcv2/bhcarticles.nsf/pages/Running_and_jogging
http://www.vanderbilt.edu/AnS/psychology/health_psychology/running.html
http://www.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/seniors-runners.html
http://med.stanford.edu/ism/2011/june/mcconnell.html
http://www.sgsd.k12.wi.us/homework/smurawas/benefits_of_running.htm
http://healthresearch.lbl.gov/
Again, I'm not against lifting. I'm for cardio + strength.0 -
A marathon was started because some French aristocrat wanted to celebrate a Greek messenger named Pheidippides. So basically, rather than celebrating the actual soldiers for fighting in The Battle of Marathon they celebrate some messenger who runs 28 miles away from the battle only to collapse and die a failure and a coward.
dude, learn your history... he ran a hell of a lot more than that, and wasn't "running away from the battle" and was NOT labelled a failure and a coward.
http://www.lakepowell.net/marathon.html
The Role of Phidippides
The Athens, vastly outnumbered, desperately needed the help of Sparta's military base to help fend off the attack. Time was short, so the Athenian generals send Phidippides (or Philippides) a professional runner to Sparta to ask for help. The 140 mile course was very mountainous and rugged. Phidippides ran the course in about 36 hours. Sparta agreed to help but said they would not take the field until the moon was full due to religious laws. This would leave the Athenians alone to fight the Persian Army. Phidippides ran back to Athens (another 140 miles!) with the disappointing news. Immediately, the small Athenian Army (including Phidippedes) marched to the plains of Marathon to prepare for battle.
The Battle of Marathon
The Athenian Army was outnumbered 4 to 1 but they launched a surprise offensive thrust which at the time appeared suicidal. But by day's end, 6400 Persian bodies lay dead on the field while only 192 Athenians had been killed. The surviving Persians fled to sea and headed south to Athens where they hoped to attack the city before the Greek Army could re-assemble there.
Phidippides was again called upon to run to Athens (26 miles away) to carry the news of the victory and the warning about the approaching Persian ships. Despite his fatigue after his recent run to Sparta and back and having fought all morning in heavy armor, Phidippides rose to the challenge. Pushing himself past normal limits of human endurance, the reached Athens in perhaps 3 hours, delivered his message and then died shortly thereafter from exhaustion.
Ok. Perhaps he wasn't a failure but he still had to be the one to run and find 'real men' to be able to fight his battles.
Have you actually RAN a marathon distance before? You make it sound like the dude was sitting on a couch eating chips and calling in the professionals via text message.0 -
i'll have to take a look at this later...
and.....having with withdrawal, you can get that from anything....
like....... even........MFP?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions