CrossFit Put To The Test, Comes Out On Top: Study
Replies
-
I'm pretty sure if you do any form of exercise consistently you will burn calories.0
-
Or Pin about, or Facebook about.........gets old!
To be clear, I wasn't hating at all. I don't do Crossfit but know many that do with great enjoyment and success. Too each their own.
It's funny regardless though cause it's so true.0 -
0 -
Awesome kitty! Give him the nip!0 -
“This is not the workout for a 45-year-old person with multiple cardiovascular risk factors. People absolutely need to be properly screened before beginning CrossFit.”
Translation - CrossFit is great for people who already have a high degree of cardiovascular fitness.0 -
Crossfit is a dangerous cult.
Don't be bitter just cause you're a bottom...
It was only a matter of time before the CF haters showed up
Let me know when they do!0 -
Or Pin about, or Facebook about.........gets old!
To be clear, I wasn't hating at all. I don't do Crossfit but know many that do with great enjoyment and success. Too each their own.
It's funny regardless though cause it's so true.
I thought it was funny and I do CF. This made me think about the preCF days.
My wife's friends were always talking about it. I thought they were crack pots.0 -
There's no point in "hating" on CF. It's at its peak popularity right now, three years from now half the studios will be closed as the exercise world moves on to the next big thing.
Meantime, those who enjoy should keep enjoying it! Any exercise is better than no exercise, in my book.
0 -
I've been CrossFitting for almost 2 months now...am down nearly 25 lbs when nothing else had worked in the past. I'm a firm believer! Eating a paleo lifestyle has also made a HUGE difference! Interesting articles though! Thanks for posting...it serves as an extra added bonus and confirmation that I am doing the right thing FOR ME and for MY BODY! (Other stuff could work for other people, I've tried it all and CrossFit has made the biggest impact in my life!) I say if you haven't tried it, you can't and shouldn't criticize it - different things work* for difference people and for different reasons. Try it and you'll be hooked!
0 -
when i see people doing crossfit stuff at my gym i get so mad......i cant really explain why i get mad...i just do0
-
There's no point in "hating" on CF. It's at its peak popularity right now, three years from now half the studios will be closed as the exercise world moves on to the next big thing.
Meantime, those who enjoy should keep enjoying it! Any exercise is better than no exercise, in my book.
:flowerforyou:0 -
[
How come you said cross fit came out on top when the study didn't have the subjects do anything but crossfit workouts?
That was the title of the article in the Huffington post.
Well, consider the source … ?
THANK YOU! Clearly everyone is failing to remember this flawless public health study is brought to us by none other than The Huffington Post... who also reported that Romney won the last presidential election, among thousands of other completely fallacious articles! Whenever Huffington Post is the top reference on an article, it's tough to believe anything it says!
That being said, I have nothing against CrossFit, except those I know who do it tend to be obnoxious, shoving it down the rest of our throats on their facebook page in "I know how to workout better than you"-esque posts. I completely believe it is a valid and worthy form of exercise and I myself do many similar exercises... yet having a Master's Degree in Public Health and knowing the Huffington Post to be the most horrid example of awful reporting - I can't take this article seriously!0 -
Crossfit is awesome. IMHO, it's far better than the hand full of regular gyms I've ever been to and the level of instruction blows away any regular gym's personal trainers that I've seen.
Again, just my 2 cents based on what I've seen. No offense to actual personal trainers who don't spend the whole session texting and chatting when your client isn't even breaking a sweat. But I sure have seen a lot of that going on.
Go crossfit !!!
I think my head would explode if I paid someone to stand around and text by me.0 -
“This is not the workout for a 45-year-old person with multiple cardiovascular risk factors. People absolutely need to be properly screened before beginning CrossFit.”
Translation - CrossFit is great for people who already have a high degree of cardiovascular fitness.
Just a disclaimer, this guy is just warning you that you are going to some hard work and you may die if you don't regulate your workout. Just like anything else. Don't let it scare you.0 -
[
How come you said cross fit came out on top when the study didn't have the subjects do anything but crossfit workouts?
That was the title of the article in the Huffington post.
Well, consider the source … ?
THANK YOU! Clearly everyone is failing to remember this flawless public health study is brought to us by none other than The Huffington Post... who also reported that Romney won the last presidential election, among thousands of other completely fallacious articles! Whenever Huffington Post is the top reference on an article, it's tough to believe anything it says!
That being said, I have nothing against CrossFit, except those I know who do it tend to be obnoxious, shoving it down the rest of our throats on their facebook page in "I know how to workout better than you"-esque posts. I completely believe it is a valid and worthy form of exercise and I myself do many similar exercises... yet having a Master's Degree in Public Health and knowing the Huffington Post to be the most horrid example of awful reporting - I can't take this article seriously!
Huffington is re posting someone else's article (American Council on Exercise). Agree that their some of their original reporting is suspect. See the negative articles published on crossfit by one of their so called medical hacks( see Crossfits dirty Secret also posted on the HP).0 -
I tried it and stopped after a few sessions. I was already pretty fit when I started, so it wasn't a matter of it being too hard. My issue with it was that the only thing they cared about was speed. Zero interest in form. As long as you were more or less throwing the kettle bell around in the right general direction, or jumping up and then laying on the floor repeatedly fast enough, that's all that mattered. I'm not hating on it, just throwing my 2 cents in FWIW. I'm glad it works for so many folks, but it's not the right program for me.0
-
Well, thats a bunch of misleading baloney and non-science. Statements about this study are all BS, all the study shows is elevated HR and increased calorie burning after two different Crossfit routines, only, thats it and for added effect: durrr? What would you expect after exercise...? And you cant say it "comes out on top" when you compared to nothing. Crossfit is great if you dont take it to extremes...as is any other exercise program really.
I'll do an equally valid claim as your study now, to show how ridiculous it is: My lunch comes out on top! Because well...it was comprised of calories and my hunger went down and well... its what I ate...0 -
[
How come you said cross fit came out on top when the study didn't have the subjects do anything but crossfit workouts?
That was the title of the article in the Huffington post.
Well, consider the source … ?
THANK YOU! Clearly everyone is failing to remember this flawless public health study is brought to us by none other than The Huffington Post... who also reported that Romney won the last presidential election, among thousands of other completely fallacious articles! Whenever Huffington Post is the top reference on an article, it's tough to believe anything it says!
That being said, I have nothing against CrossFit, except those I know who do it tend to be obnoxious, shoving it down the rest of our throats on their facebook page in "I know how to workout better than you"-esque posts. I completely believe it is a valid and worthy form of exercise and I myself do many similar exercises... yet having a Master's Degree in Public Health and knowing the Huffington Post to be the most horrid example of awful reporting - I can't take this article seriously!
The original study was done by the American Council on Exercise
https://www.acefitness.org/prosourcearticle/3542/crossfit-sup-tm-sup-new-research-puts-popular/0 -
if something works (for you) you don't have to try and proclaim it as king. Just let it work for you and others will catch on if it really is that good.0
-
Well, thats a bunch of misleading baloney and non-science. Statements about this study are all BS, all the study shows is elevated HR and increased calorie burning after two different Crossfit routines, only, thats it and for added effect: durrr? What would you expect after exercise...? And you cant say it "comes out on top" when you compared to nothing. Crossfit is great if you dont take it to extremes...as is any other exercise program really.
I'll do an equally valid claim as your study now, to show how ridiculous it is: My lunch comes out on top! Because well...it was comprised of calories and my hunger went down and well... its what I ate...
It's just a study reproving that HIT is effective and CF is HIT. There's many studies on HIT.0 -
I say if you haven't tried it, you can't and shouldn't criticize it
Off topic, but this is way annoying. I have not eating a dog poop sandwich, but I can and should criticize it. This should read: If you don't know the research behind it/what goes on during it/etc you can't and shouldn't criticize it0 -
I tried it and stopped after a few sessions. I was already pretty fit when I started, so it wasn't a matter of it being too hard. My issue with it was that the only thing they cared about was speed. Zero interest in form. As long as you were more or less throwing the kettle bell around in the right general direction, or jumping up and then laying on the floor repeatedly fast enough, that's all that mattered. I'm not hating on it, just throwing my 2 cents in FWIW. I'm glad it works for so many folks, but it's not the right program for me.
Sounds like bad coaching, which you can get anywhere, in any sport. Maybe you'd like it if you try another box.1 -
So you are saying HIT does not work?
The post you are replying to didn't say anything even remotely like that.0 -
Better than what? I'm not going to "knock" CF because if you have a good coach it's just fine. It's no worse than clueless idiots that attempt to lift weights at a regular gym. I'm saying that as somebody that has no interest in CF. Bottom line, why care about calorie burn? Most of your weight/fat loss is going to come from a healthy calorie deficit so in other words, your diet. If your diet sucks then it doesn't matter how many calories you burn while exercising. Too many calories and you can put on weight, too few calories and you'll burn yourself out and you won't be exercising anymore. Pick the type of exercise you enjoy that helps you meet your fitness goals and stop worrying about crap like calorie burn. The whole CF versus PL versus marathon running, versus exercise calories burned from vacuuming your floors is just stupid.0
-
Better than what? I'm not going to "knock" CF because if you have a good coach it's just fine. It's no worse than clueless idiots that attempt to lift weights at a regular gym. I'm saying that as somebody that has no interest in CF. Bottom line, why care about calorie burn? Most of your weight/fat loss is going to come from a healthy calorie deficit so in other words, your diet. If your diet sucks then it doesn't matter how many calories you burn while exercising. Too many calories and you can put on weight, too few calories and you'll burn yourself out and you won't be exercising anymore. Pick the type of exercise you enjoy that helps you meet your fitness goals and stop worrying about crap like calorie burn. The whole CF versus PL versus marathon running, versus exercise calories burned from vacuuming your floors is just stupid.
Amen!0 -
0 -
Nah, light cleaning and dog walking is where it's at.0
-
0 -
On top for rotator cuff injuries0
-
Well, thats a bunch of misleading baloney and non-science. Statements about this study are all BS, all the study shows is elevated HR and increased calorie burning after two different Crossfit routines, only, thats it and for added effect: durrr? What would you expect after exercise...? And you cant say it "comes out on top" when you compared to nothing. Crossfit is great if you dont take it to extremes...as is any other exercise program really.
I'll do an equally valid claim as your study now, to show how ridiculous it is: My lunch comes out on top! Because well...it was comprised of calories and my hunger went down and well... its what I ate...
So you are saying HIT does not work? It's just a study reproving that HIT is effective and CF is HIT. There's many studies on HIT.
No, thats not what I said, and its also not what the "study" said. All the "study" says is Crossfit elevates calorie burning and elevates HR. My issue is with making these very poorly done studies of a tiny group of samples into something they arent and basically lying with titles of articles about them. Its bad for real science. Its bad for what you are falsely promoting. And its not true. So, yes Crossfit can work great for you, it does elevate calorie burning and HR. Is it "shown to come out on top"? Not in any way. It just makes me annoyed at Crossfit and tend to think "what other misinformation is being promoted?".
For something to be "on top" it must be compared to other things. You might be able to say one of those routines is "on top" of the other, but since nothing else was compared, thats all you can say. So Crossfit is on top of itself is all you could claim.
Sitting upright in the couch is on top of other forms of sitting because I measured calorie burns of laying in the couch vs sitting upright! Now I want to post "Sitting Upright Comes Out on Top, Study Shows!" in an article.
My study showed that my lunch provided calories, and I was hungry, now I'm not (measure of provided calories) so my lunch was on top of all other lunches! Also equally as valid. Now don't these two claims seem pretty ridiculous to say?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions