1200 calories, exercise, but no weight loss!!
Replies
-
You do weigh some foods on a scale, but you should weight everything.
Weigh out those chips instead of counting 14 of them to eat.
Put your bread on the scale, Tare to 0, then add the mayo or peanut butter, and weight it.
Weigh the teaspoon' of sugar.
Most nutrition labels have both the volume (cup, teaspoon) and the weight for the serving. Use the weight information.
And have a check up with your doctor if you haven,t recently, just in case it is a thyroid or other issue.
I am sure that works great for those that have the time and desire, but I just don't see myself weighing a spoonful of peanut butter or a tsp of sugar. If the calories listed on food packages is that far off, how do I know I can trust my scale? Or how do I know if the weight of that particular food is really the calories the package says? I guess I just don't believe that getting that obsessed about what the exact calories were in my portion is necessary. If it was 10 calories more....oh well. Maybe it was 12 calories less...It just seems that it would all come out in the wash. I feel that my calorie intake is low enough that even if I added in that bite of cake and it was 200 calories (it's not), I should still be losing something. And no disrespect to those of you that do weigh everything. I admire you, but it's just not something I will ever do.
There is your answer, you NEED TO WEIGH EVERYTHING!!!
You came here to get help, people are telling you that you need to weigh your food and you keep making excuses!!! :frown:
As long as you don't weigh your food, you will continue not losing. Good luck with that!! :ohwell:
I weigh everything, I eat and I am losing!! See ticker below. JS :bigsmile:0 -
In hopes of helping the OP, and sorry if it's been said, but my 2 cents... Whether you're logging and burning 1200 calories a day or 2100, if you're weight isn't changing you're logging what you're burning on average. If you want to lose you need to take less in or burn more. If your food log totals while eating less put you in an uncomfortable place in order to do that (under 1200), then take your concerns to a doctor, along with your food log.
I don't mean to sound accusatory but my first suspicion would be measurement error in food logging. It's just so common. None of us thinks we do it but studies show we virtually all do, to some extent. Even if the past week of logging has been perfect, if the paper journal was 20% off that would explain the lack of losses.0 -
In a nutshell, it seems that the majority of people responding to my post feel that I am eating a lot more calories than what I am logging. I am logging everything and I don't think it would be healthy for me to eat less than what I am eating now. So, basically I have learned that I should eat more, I should eat less, I should work out more, I should work out less, I am paranoid, I may have an ED, I need to change what I am doing, I need to stick to what I am doing, etc. I am more confused now than I was when I originally posted this! Ha Ha!!! To those of you that are truly here to help....THANK YOU!! And to those of you that find joy in being rude and sarcastic and have no desire to be helpful, get a life!
Crikey. Keep logging like you have been, and cut more calories. Simple. If your food measurements are off, cutting more will solve that issue (by bringing you to a true deficit). Don't need to change HOW you have been measuring, just eat less. **Eating less food always works to lose fat. Try it for a couple weeks and see what the results are.
Sounds like you are working out, so as long as you get at least 0.8 grams of protein per lb that you weigh, you should be able to sustain or gain muscle (despite what people may think) while you lose fat.
**If you have more than the essential body fat levels of 10% - 13% (for a woman), cutting below 1200 is not a problem. You will continue to function doing your daily routine because your body converts body fat (stored energy) to do this. If it did not, we would pass out when we were out of food, and we would not wake up. Thankfully, our bodies magically do this for us, so losing fat is really a simple math problem. Calories in/calories out.
Thank you! Makes sense to me.0 -
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!0 -
prolly bc you aren't eating enough. man am i tired of these threads i need to just hang around the recipe ones0
-
In a nutshell, it seems that the majority of people responding to my post feel that I am eating a lot more calories than what I am logging. I am logging everything and I don't think it would be healthy for me to eat less than what I am eating now. So, basically I have learned that I should eat more, I should eat less, I should work out more, I should work out less, I am paranoid, I may have an ED, I need to change what I am doing, I need to stick to what I am doing, etc. I am more confused now than I was when I originally posted this! Ha Ha!!! To those of you that are truly here to help....THANK YOU!! And to those of you that find joy in being rude and sarcastic and have no desire to be helpful, get a life!
Crikey. Keep logging like you have been, and cut more calories. Simple. If your food measurements are off, cutting more will solve that issue (by bringing you to a true deficit). Don't need to change HOW you have been measuring, just eat less. **Eating less food always works to lose fat. Try it for a couple weeks and see what the results are.
Sounds like you are working out, so as long as you get at least 0.8 grams of protein per lb that you weigh, you should be able to sustain or gain muscle (despite what people may think) while you lose fat.
**If you have more than the essential body fat levels of 10% - 13% (for a woman), cutting below 1200 is not a problem. You will continue to function doing your daily routine because your body converts body fat (stored energy) to do this. If it did not, we would pass out when we were out of food, and we would not wake up. Thankfully, our bodies magically do this for us, so losing fat is really a simple math problem. Calories in/calories out.
Thank you! Makes sense to me.
No matter how much protein you take in, you're not going to gain any muscle mass with how little you say you eat plus it would take some serious heavy lifting.0 -
The best advice has already been said. Nothing else to say.
-Measure your food better.
-Go to a doctor or dietician. If you're convinced you should be losing more, and you're as vigilant as you've said, than perhaps there's an issue.0 -
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.0 -
You're not alone... It's very easy to "forget" to log a snack here and there or "guestimate" low on portion sizes. On the other end, is the OP using a heart rate monitor to track actual cals burnt or just picking out of preloaded (always high) search options for exersize?I expect you're eating more than you think you are. Are you logging every single thing you eat, including snacks, drinks, condiments, etc.?0 -
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!
Absolutely true! Well said.0 -
EAT MOAR0
-
see below0
-
How is any of this thread negative or mean? 90% of the posters, including myself, Jonnythan and Sarauk2sf (who runs the best and most informative group on here, that helps thousands of people, and who has written nearly 20,000 posts to help people asking for health and fitness advice) all said you may be overestimating your intake and advised you to weigh your food. Yet, you won't give that advice a moments consideration. THAT'S why people may be sounding like they are frustrated with you.In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!0 -
BS... if you are truly eating 1200 calories and exercising you will lose weight. If you are not losing weight.. u are not eating 1200 calories. End of story. Also if you are 164 lbs at 5'4... there is no change of starvation mode. When your bodyfat hits 10% or so.. there is a chance of starvation mode then.
At a deficit you will ALWAYS lose weight.
No that is BS- Are you serious, the body can go into starvation mode at a deficit such as she is eating if it is used to getting more and it needs more to run on than 100 a day! GTFOOHWT- Having been to numerious nutrionist I can say that with pretty much absolute certainty. Stop giving BAD advice for something you obviously know nothing about!
Sorry about the repost but I meant to quote an earlier msg.0 -
BS... if you are truly eating 1200 calories and exercising you will lose weight. If you are not losing weight.. u are not eating 1200 calories. End of story. Also if you are 164 lbs at 5'4... there is no change of starvation mode. When your bodyfat hits 10% or so.. there is a chance of starvation mode then.
At a deficit you will ALWAYS lose weight.
No that is BS- Are you serious, the body can go into starvation mode at a deficit such as she is eating if it is used to getting more and it needs more to run on than 100 a day! GTFOOHWT- Having been to numerious nutrionist I can say that with pretty much absolute certainty. Stop giving BAD advice for something you obviously know nothing about!
Sorry about the repost but I meant to quote an earlier msg.
The ironic part is that you told someone to stop giving bad advice about something they "obviously" know nothing about, yet believe that eating 1200 calories will out someone into the mythical Starvation Mode.
Starvation mode. Makes you wonder how anorexics get skinny instead of fat, eh?0 -
In a nutshell, it seems that the majority of people responding to my post feel that I am eating a lot more calories than what I am logging. I am logging everything and I don't think it would be healthy for me to eat less than what I am eating now. So, basically I have learned that I should eat more, I should eat less, I should work out more, I should work out less, I am paranoid, I may have an ED, I need to change what I am doing, I need to stick to what I am doing, etc. I am more confused now than I was when I originally posted this! Ha Ha!!! To those of you that are truly here to help....THANK YOU!! And to those of you that find joy in being rude and sarcastic and have no desire to be helpful, get a life!
Crikey. Keep logging like you have been, and cut more calories. Simple. If your food measurements are off, cutting more will solve that issue (by bringing you to a true deficit). Don't need to change HOW you have been measuring, just eat less. **Eating less food always works to lose fat. Try it for a couple weeks and see what the results are.
Sounds like you are working out, so as long as you get at least 0.8 grams of protein per lb that you weigh, you should be able to sustain or gain muscle (despite what people may think) while you lose fat.
**If you have more than the essential body fat levels of 10% - 13% (for a woman), cutting below 1200 is not a problem. You will continue to function doing your daily routine because your body converts body fat (stored energy) to do this. If it did not, we would pass out when we were out of food, and we would not wake up. Thankfully, our bodies magically do this for us, so losing fat is really a simple math problem. Calories in/calories out.
Thank you! Makes sense to me.
No matter how much protein you take in, you're not going to gain any muscle mass with how little you say you eat plus it would take some serious heavy lifting.
Yeah, you do not gain muscle mass while eating at a deficit through diet alone. And when eating a large deficit, protein is converted into glucose through glucogenesis (I may have butchered the spelling).0 -
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.
OP~THIS!!!! ^^^^^^^
Just in case you missed it.0 -
BS... if you are truly eating 1200 calories and exercising you will lose weight. If you are not losing weight.. u are not eating 1200 calories. End of story. Also if you are 164 lbs at 5'4... there is no change of starvation mode. When your bodyfat hits 10% or so.. there is a chance of starvation mode then.
At a deficit you will ALWAYS lose weight.
No that is BS- Are you serious, the body can go into starvation mode at a deficit such as she is eating if it is used to getting more and it needs more to run on than 100 a day! GTFOOHWT- Having been to numerious nutrionist I can say that with pretty much absolute certainty. Stop giving BAD advice for something you obviously know nothing about!
Sorry about the repost but I meant to quote an earlier msg.
NO!!!0 -
Paging special snowflakes.0
-
I haven't read through 12 pages of responses so maybe this has been asked....are you drinking enough water? I find that when I become lax with my water intake, that my weight loss slows down.0
-
No that is BS- Are you serious, the body can go into starvation mode at a deficit such as she is eating if it is used to getting more and it needs more to run on than 100 a day! GTFOOHWT- Having been to numerious nutrionist I can say that with pretty much absolute certainty. Stop giving BAD advice for something you obviously know nothing about!
Sorry about the repost but I meant to quote an earlier msg.
Oh good lord.
0 -
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.
I dragged this thread on?? You have basically hijacked this thread!! And don't use quotation marks to say I said something that I didn't! I appreciate 90% of the responses. You are one of the few that I find to be negative, rude, and sarcastic. I don't like my words being twisted. Please, go away. I will pm some of the sensible, level-headed members here and avoid public message boards. I hope you don't do this to every thread! Yikes!0 -
When it comes to weight loss its less about the number of calories and more about the quality of calories and how they affect your hormones. So eat more protein and fat and less carbs and you can eat easily 1700 calories and lose weight. Counting calories is not effective at all. and when people do lose weight by cutting calories it is usually at the expense of muscle mass. Clean out your diet - ditch the gluten, sugar, processed foods, soy and dairy.0
-
I tried changing the composition of my diet and stopped eating gluten (mostly bread and pasta/pizza, that I am not fond of it actually, but in this country I moved in is all they eat basically and I got weight even eating same amount of calories, but going from rice/salad/beans/cooked potatoes/protein to pasta/pizza/bread, even wholegrain ones). I changed my diet to the one in my old country and I lost some weight and cms already IN 1-2 months. calories restriction only didnt work for me. I feel bloated when I eat bread or pasta frequently.0
-
When it comes to weight loss its less about the number of calories and more about the quality of calories and how they affect your hormones. So eat more protein and fat and less carbs and you can eat easily 1700 calories and lose weight. Counting calories is not effective at all. and when people do lose weight by cutting calories it is usually at the expense of muscle mass. Clean out your diet - ditch the gluten, sugar, processed foods, soy and dairy.
I guess all the people who didn't do this and have maintained an excellent physique are medical anomalies.0 -
go see a doctor... maybe you aren't eating enough, maybe you are exercising too much, maybe you are eating more than you think you are eating, maybe you aren't exercising enough... however you play it, you are not providing your body with enough energy to actually survive (well below your BMR) and that is silly0
-
In for the ragequit because OP didn't get the answer she wanted.
What answer did she want? She doesn't seem to want the "eat less" or the "eat more" or anything lose in between.
I'm not sure. Maybe "oh you poor thing you can't help it"? I have no idea.
How sad. Most people on MFP seem to genuinely care and want to help. But, unfortunately, it only takes 1 or 2 (or 3 or 4) to take an innocent question and turn it into such a negative experience. Wonder how many folks have left MFP just because of the rudeness? If someone knows what the answer was that I wanted...please share. I don't want to eat less as it doesn't seem healthy to do so. I am concerned about eating more as I will gain. I am not asking for anyone's sympathy and am shocked at how a few can be so mean. Life is so much better when you are positive! You should try it!
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.
I dragged this thread on?? You have basically hijacked this thread!! And don't use quotation marks to say I said something that I didn't! I appreciate 90% of the responses. You are one of the few that I find to be negative, rude, and sarcastic. I don't like my words being twisted. Please, go away. I will pm some of the sensible, level-headed members here and avoid public message boards. I hope you don't do this to every thread! Yikes!
I wonder what solution you expect to get via PM you didn't get already.0 -
For your own sake, please don't PM the sensible level headed members who have suggested it was starvation mode, sugar, processed food, lack of water, gluten or muscle gain...,,....
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.
I dragged this thread on?? You have basically hijacked this thread!! And don't use quotation marks to say I said something that I didn't! I appreciate 90% of the responses. You are one of the few that I find to be negative, rude, and sarcastic. I don't like my words being twisted. Please, go away. I will pm some of the sensible, level-headed members here and avoid public message boards. I hope you don't do this to every thread! Yikes!0 -
I knew this thread was going places on page one.0
-
For your own sake, please don't PM the sensible level headed members who have suggested it was starvation mode, sugar, processed food, lack of water, gluten or muscle gain...,,....
You dragged this thread on for 10 pages and finally concluded with "screw it all, I refuse to weigh food!" to a thread full of extremely helpful, successful people who weigh food.
"The answer" is that you're eating much more than you think you are, and the reason you're eating more than you think you are is because you don't properly measure portions.
You can either fix that, and succeed, or you can continue to fail and whine. It's really your choice.
Is that mean? Maybe. But it's the truth.
I dragged this thread on?? You have basically hijacked this thread!! And don't use quotation marks to say I said something that I didn't! I appreciate 90% of the responses. You are one of the few that I find to be negative, rude, and sarcastic. I don't like my words being twisted. Please, go away. I will pm some of the sensible, level-headed members here and avoid public message boards. I hope you don't do this to every thread! Yikes!
Note that sensible and level headed does not imply smart, knowledgeable, or experienced.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions