Viewing the message boards in:

Sugar is killing you.

Options
1235

Replies

  • Posts: 29,136 Member

    I see a lot of people on this site posting that, and it doesn't make any sense at all. Do you think that the second you eat something that it's instantly converted down to it's base molecules?

    do you really think your body distinguishes between types of sugar? Do you really think it is possible to say that one is addicted to "added sugar" but that same "addict" can then eat 20 ounces of fruit a day?
  • Posts: 7,436 Member
    Sugar is keeping me alive

    glucose is a sugar

    in every cell in my body, glucose is being broken down, with the help of oxygen, to release energy which my cells are using to do all the things they need to do to keep me alive.

    I :heart: sugar
  • Posts: 1,690 Member

    The alarming rise in diabetes and obesity is closely linked to overeating. Period.

    And would eating a diet filled with refined sugar perhaps be more likely to lead to overeating then a diet filled with whole foods? Of course it would for normal people who don't weigh and log every single piece of food they eat.
  • Posts: 1,690 Member

    do you really think your body distinguishes between types of sugar? Do you really think it is possible to say that one is addicted to "added sugar" but that same "addict" can then eat 20 ounces of fruit a day?

    Don't change the subject. Sure, a molecule of fructose may be a molecule of fructose. But that's neither here nor there when discussing a complex system. Foods have to be processed by your body BEFORE they turn into base molecules.

    So while there is no difference b/w two solitary fructose molecules from different sources, there is a big difference in the metabolic response b/w eating an apple and eating an equivalent caloric amount of HFCS.

    In regard to "sugar addiction," it makes perfect sense that foods that taste better would more addictive.
  • Posts: 16,913 Member

    And would eating a diet filled with refined sugar perhaps be more likely to lead to overeating then a diet filled with whole foods? Of course it would for normal people who don't weigh and log every single piece of food they eat.

    I got fat (200+ pounds) on a diet of whole, healthy, minimally processed food. Wasn't even hard. I just...you know. Ate a lot.
  • Posts: 29,136 Member

    Don't change the subject. Sure, a molecule of fructose may be a molecule of fructose. But that's neither here nor there when discussing a complex system. Foods have to be processed by your body BEFORE they turn into base molecules.

    So while there is no difference b/w two solitary fructose molecules from different sources, there is a big difference in the metabolic response b/w eating an apple and eating an equivalent caloric amount of HFCS.

    In regard to "sugar addiction," it makes perfect sense that foods that taste better would more addictive.
    interesting concept ..so by your logic, I can be addicted to crack-cocaine, but not powder cocaine....
  • Posts: 1,690 Member

    I got fat (200+ pounds) on a diet of whole, healthy, minimally processed food. Wasn't even hard. I just...you know. Ate a lot.

    I never said it was impossible to gain weight eating whole foods! It's definitely doable. Although I still have to ask. Did this "diet of whole, healthy, minimally processed food" include lots of bread, pasta, or rice?
  • Posts: 1,690 Member
    interesting concept ..so by your logic, I can be addicted to crack-cocaine, but not powder cocaine....

    You can become addicted to either one. But which one is known to be more addictive?
  • Posts: 16,913 Member

    I never said it was impossible to gain weight eating whole foods! It's definitely doable. Although I still have to ask. Did this "diet of whole, healthy, minimally processed food" include lots of bread, pasta, or rice?

    Do you consider bread and pasta minimally processed? Because you'd be the first person I've seen to say so.

    Or do you think I don't know what minimally processed means?

    Either way, no, it didn't. As a teenager I ate how my mother cooked, with was a mostly meat and veggie based diet (probably why I don't eat vegetables now. I've had enough to last a lifetime) and while she did occasionally make bread and pasta herself it was more of a special occasion thing than a daily/frequent occurrence. She didn't buy sugary snacks, soda, or any of the other supposed evils people quake in fear of.

    Thankfully she's since become a real person and keeps a pantry full of oreos and coco puffs, which means I don't cringe at the thought of visiting anymore.
  • Posts: 1,690 Member
    Do you consider bread and pasta minimally processed? Because you'd be the first person I've seen to say so.

    Or do you think I don't know what minimally processed means?

    Hey, just said I had to ask, that's all!
    Either way, no, it didn't. As a teenager I ate how my mother cooked, with was a mostly meat and veggie based diet (probably why I don't eat vegetables now. I've had enough to last a lifetime) and while she did occasionally make bread and pasta herself it was more of a special occasion thing than a daily/frequent occurrence. She didn't buy sugary snacks, soda, or any of the other supposed evils people quake in fear of.

    Thankfully she's since become a real person and keeps a pantry full of oreos and coco puffs, which means I don't cringe at the thought of visiting anymore.

    Well I hope you learn to like vegetables again someday. When I was a teenager I only ate one meal per day that my mom cooked. My breakfast and school lunch were both highly processed and low in nutrients. So I'm still a little skeptical that you were really eating what sounds almost like a paleo diet, but you can gain weight on anything if you overeat of course.
  • Posts: 1,184 Member
    I feel like we literally just finished an occasionally nasty thread on this exact same topic which resulted in nobody on either side budging one millimeter from the opinion they held coming into the thread.

    I think I am a seer. Give me offerings.
  • Posts: 16,913 Member

    Hey, just said I had to ask, that's all!

    Well I hope you learn to like vegetables again someday. When I was a teenager I only ate one meal per day that my mom cooked. My breakfast and school lunch were both highly processed and low in nutrients. So I'm still a little skeptical that you were really eating what sounds almost like a paleo diet, but you can gain weight on anything if you overeat of course.

    I ate breakfast at home and did not eat school lunch (I wouldn't eat that junk even now and I'll try almost anything.) I usually took some fruit and occasionally a sandwich is there was bread around and meat left over from dinner. Even now I'm 'not a three meal a day eater'. I usually have some yogurt, fruit, and a sandwich around noon, and then dinner around 6 then dessert, as opposed to high school being Breakfast->Fruit->Dinner(and then seconds and then thirds after my mom was asleep)

    My stepdad did make pancakes every Sunday, so I suppose there is that. It was probably the pancakes that got me.
  • Posts: 29,136 Member

    You can become addicted to either one. But which one is known to be more addictive?

    I don't know any crack heads that are not addicted to cocaine...
  • Posts: 29,136 Member
    I feel like we literally just finished an occasionally nasty thread on this exact same topic which resulted in nobody on either side budging one millimeter from the opinion they held coming into the thread.

    I think I am a seer. Give me offerings.

    probably because this one comes up at least once a week with zero resolution ...
  • Posts: 445 Member
    Aren't we all just slowly dying anyways? Eat a little sugar. Don't eat enough to make you a fatty. No biggy.
  • Posts: 7,001 Member

    probably because this one comes up at least once a week with zero resolution ...

    The department of redundancy department.
  • Posts: 1,690 Member

    I don't know any crack heads that are not addicted to cocaine...

    I really don't know where this analogy came from. But sugar addiction is more likely 2/2 to the taste and our brain's reward center, not individual molecules. Since fruit and cupcakes taste a lot different I'm not sure why you would think addiction would to either would cross over.
  • Posts: 1,217 Member

    Phew, good thing I live in Nebraska. No sugar here, just corn and cows. And corn..... oh, and cows.....
    corn.

    lmfao
  • Posts: 7,001 Member

    I really don't know where this analogy came from. But sugar addiction is more likely 2/2 to the taste and our brain's reward center, not individual molecules. Since fruit and cupcakes taste a lot different I'm not sure why you would think addiction would to either would cross over.

    There's this salty taste I'm addicted to... but I've heard it's actually made up of mostly sugar.
  • Posts: 34,415 Member

    I really don't know where this analogy came from. But sugar addiction is more likely 2/2 to the taste and our brain's reward center, not individual molecules. Since fruit and cupcakes taste a lot different I'm not sure why you would think addiction would to either would cross over.

    Are we all still in agreement that sugar " addiction" is a real thing? And that it is exclusive to "processed" sugars? Because fiber (or some other explanation)?
  • Posts: 7,001 Member

    Are we all still in agreement that sugar " addiction" is a real thing? And that it is exclusive to "processed" sugars? Because bacon

    FIFY
  • Posts: 29,136 Member

    Are we all still in agreement that sugar " addiction" is a real thing? And that it is exclusive to "processed" sugars? Because fiber (or some other explanation)?

    yes, that appears to be the case...
  • Posts: 447 Member
    lol
  • Posts: 3,498 Member

    OK, now I'm curious. Let's ignore people that have compulsive disorders and the like - I agree they're going to need help with food issues. But for the normal person who just loves to eat cookies, cakes, and drink soda ... what skill\s do they lack that they can't put down or not buy one (or even part of one) of the cookies, cake and soda?

    The skill to distinguish natural satiety from the mind's desire to over eat and act on it.

    Some people can regulate their weight and appetite quite naturally and stop when they've had enough as they have internalised this skill unconsciously. Some people need to work on it consciously.

    Will elaborate tomorrow. I am out and posting from my phone is just painful...
  • Posts: 1,319 Member
    <-- Was eating peanut M&Ms while reading this.
  • Posts: 1,256 Member
    Let's talk statistics here. What are the top 10 countries that consume the most sugar in the world? Well if you don't know here they are:

    Macedonia 73.8
    Belize 65.5
    Swaziland 56.9
    Cuba 56.6
    Trinidad & Tobago 55.3
    Barbados 52.7
    Brazil 51.7
    Costa Rica 50.6
    New Zealand 49.2
    St. Kitt & Nevis 49.0

    WHAT? The US didn't make the top 10?

    Now let's check the obesity rates of these countries.

    Macedonia- Est. 298,512 Population 2,040,085
    Belize- 39,938 272,945
    Swaziland- 171,087 1,169,241
    Cuba- 2,310,000 11,000,000
    Trinidad/Tobago- 399,000 1,330,000
    Barbados- 283,221 195,422
    Brazil- 26,938,323 184,101,109
    Costa Rica- 1,440,000 4,800,000
    New Zealand- 1,373,333 4,443,000
    St. Kitt and Nevis


    http://www.rightdiagnosis.com/o/obesity/stats-country.htm

    So with this info, you'd think they would be the most obese nations in the world too, but they aren't.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
    It's cause the fatties are dying young...from y'know...the sugar ;)
  • Posts: 271 Member

    There's this salty taste I'm addicted to... but I've heard it's actually made up of mostly sugar.

    ^^^^^^Seriously?!? How did you all miss this?? LOL
  • Posts: 570 Member
    twinkie-funeral.jpg

    Then I shall die happy.
  • Posts: 100 Member
    HI OP - I just read your opening statement. If you are going to try to tell me that eating fruit (eating a fresh orange or apple) is going to make me fat, then I reject your opening statement.

    I will eat an orange and an apple and a banana and watermelon and cherries and ugli fruit over cookies, cakes, ice cream, brownies, etc, not only because there are many nutrients in fruit (vitamins, fiber, juice, refreshment and sweetness), and also because they really taste good and satisfy my sweet tooth without having to eat processed sugary snacks for that reason.

    I think you misread or misunderstood my opening statement. A) I do not believe sugar is going to kill you. The title was meant in jest as it is the title of the article quoted and B) I was saying that I understand your body cannot differentiate between sources of sugar. It will process sugar from a soda the same way it will process sugar from a juice. Neither is necessarily harmful.

    I eat a TON of sugar and have no plans on stopping any time soon.
  • Posts: 100 Member

    In the single human study I’m aware of that linked fructose to a greater next-day appetite in a subset of the subjects, 30% of total daily energy intake was in the form of free fructose [12]. This amounts to 135 grams, which is the equivalent of 6-7 nondiet soft drinks. Is it really that groundbreaking to think that polishing off a half-dozen soft drinks per day is not a good idea? Demonizing fructose without mentioning the dose-dependent nature of its effects is intellectually dishonest. Like anything else, fructose consumed in gross chronic excess can lead to problems, while moderate amounts are neutral, and in some cases beneficial [13-15].

    Thanks, this is the kind of response I was hoping for!
This discussion has been closed.