1200 Calorie Diet???? Seriously???

Weight loss is trial & error as much as determination and will power. You can not tell me that a 17 stone 5"5 sedentarty woman should be eating the same as a 7 stone 5"5 highly active woman. That is the science fad diets are based on.

YES, YES you can! The 17 stone woman got to and maintained her weight eating WAY more calories than someone who weighs 140 lbs less than she does! It takes more calories just to maintain a bigger body. The point is that weight loss should not be about, hey, Mr. potential weight loser, you got fat. Now let's punish you by never having you eat whatever got you fat and you can only have chicken breasts and lettuce. The moderate deficit allows them to re-evaluate their food choices if need be, but they'd also be able to fit some of the items they like which got them to their current weight

It's one thing to say you can't be bothered to eat more, but giving a large person more calories to eat is EXCELLENT science!

It's about whatever approach helps you lose weight. Some people are more motivated by more rapid loss.

My daily goal is 1200 and I find it hard to get that many calories in daily! And I am not starving and I feel like I'm eating all the time. I don't eat back calories from walking 5 miles a day and/or the days I work out (3-4 times a week).

Someone should write a sticky for all these people. Seriously.

They'll be back on here years later saying they don't know what went wrong and gained the weight back and more.

I'm 5'4 and have just started on MFP. Beforehand I was eating around 900 cals a day, losing weight, but still feeling a little hungry.
Since starting, I've upped it to 1200, am still losing weight but more slowly (only have another 10lbs to lose though) and feel awesome.

I find it funny how taller, more active people are saying that those on a 1200 cal diet must be starving themselves because there's no way that can be healthy/fulfiling. Maybe YOU can't survive everyday on that amount, but I can, because we're different people with different requirements, heights, weights, gender etc.

I wish we could all bake a cake of smiles and rainbows and just be friends. But we cant. Because this is MFP. And as I've learnt thus far the only thing that everyone agrees on is that no one should agree on anything.....

I'm 5'4 and have just started on MFP. Beforehand I was eating around 900 cals a day, losing weight, but still feeling a little hungry.
Since starting, I've upped it to 1200, am still losing weight but more slowly (only have another 10lbs to lose though) and feel awesome.

I find it funny how taller, more active people are saying that those on a 1200 cal diet must be starving themselves because there's no way that can be healthy/fulfiling. Maybe YOU can't survive everyday on that amount, but I can, because we're different people with different requirements, heights, weights, gender etc.

I wish we could all bake a cake of smiles and rainbows and just be friends. But we cant. Because this is MFP. And as I've learnt thus far the only thing that everyone agrees on is that no one should agree on anything.....

Some of us are short petite females. Even at 1200 calories we lose less than a pound a week.

Based on the goal in your ticker, unless you told MFP more weight per week than your body weight can realistically lose (1.5 or 2 lbs for example), I would suspect that number could be higher

LiveLaughLoveEat1 wrote: »

ewarren1985 wrote: »

bygblu21 wrote: »

I'm fairly new to this forum and am really surprised at how many people on here are starving themselves to lose weight. Weight loss is not a sprint its a marathon. Its something that should happen over time, not within a few weeks. Weight loss is more than just limiting your caloric intake. Its a combination of eating clean and healthy ( I hate the word diet) and exercising on a daily basis. Starving yourself is not a healthy way to lose weight and by limiting your caloric intake to 1200 or so calories is doing just that. Not only is it unhealthy, but its a process that you will never stick to because its not natural and uncomfortable to do. So lets be serious and talk about how to lose weight realistically.

I would first ask yourself, "why do I want to lose weight?' Is it for appearance? Is it to be more healthy? Is it to be able to make it up that flight of steps without getting tired? Once you understand your own reasoning you can then move forward and begin your weight loss journey, because after all that's what it should be, a journey not a short trip. Once you've realized your goal and the reason for it you need to make the biggest decision of all, and that's to commit to yourself and commit to achieving your goal of losing weight and living a healthier lifestyle.

So now you've made the decision to put your health first; now what? Lets start with your eating habits. What do you eat? When do you eat it? and how often are you eating? Your body is a very complex machine but by following some simple rules about eating, you can have it running very efficiently. Follow these few simple rules and you'll see and feel the difference in your energy level.
-Start every day with an 8oz. glass of lemon water
-Monitor your portions- you should be eating small portion meals throughout the day rather than one, two or three large portioned meals a day
-Drink water, all day long
-Focus on lean proteins like chicken, turkey, salmon etc. and I don't mean processed cold-cuts...
-Focus on eating fresh vegetables, steamed when possible
-Limit unnecessary condiments i.e. mayonnaise, oils, salt etc.
-Limit, but don't restrict carbohydrates. Complex carbs are needed by your body
-Dairy is ok but in limited portions and should be kept to low fat dairy. Greek yogurt is a good choice.
-Fresh fruit should be kept to 1 or 2 pieces a day. Its high in sugar and you should be limiting your sugar

This si just a guide to go by. Your food intake should be directly related to your physical activity. Exercise is key but that's a whole other topic....

So... Funny thing that I found this today while utilizing MFP to log my progress on my weight loss journey!

I am currently under the care of weight loss doctor - a qualified medical professional - and was specifically instructed to limit my daily caloric intake to 1200 calories, as that is the medically recognized amount of calories needed for most women's weight loss (it is 1500 calories for men). I was also given the following instructions:

1. Eat breakfast, lunch, and dinner
2. Limit your daily calories (women 1200 men 1500)
3. Try to avoid excessive snacking between meals
4. Allow yourself to experience hunger between meals and small snacks. Feeling hungry during weight loss and everyday life/schedules is normal and healthy.
5. Limit carbohydrates to breakfast. The reason for this is that your body can easily burn the carbs off during the course of the day AND most of the reason that women retain "water weight" is because the carbohydrates stored in their bodies act like sponges and soak it all up.
6. If you need to snack, choose wisely (fruits, low fat yogurts, hard-boiled egg, small salad with dressing on the side)
7. Dinner should be your lightest meal of the day and breakfast your largest, but do what works for you
8. Find something other than food to soothe yourself
9. Make sure that meals are eaten at the table - not in front of the tv, in the bedroom, etc.
10. Use a Lean Cuisine for a meal if you are in a rush or too tired to cook

On top of that, I was given the advice that studies have shown that people who consume 25 grams of fiber on a daily basis, lose weight. You get 25 grams of fiber by consuming between 5 & 10 servings of fruits and vegetables throughout the day. Therefore, if you get hungry between meals, have a serving of fruit (banana, orange, handful of grapes, bing cherries, sliced apples, etc.)

Last tip he gave me: Learn to eat slowly so your body has time to catch up with your brain about when you are actually full/satisfied as opposed to "stuffed."

All in all, I'm FAR from being an expert on the subject (obviously evident by the fact that I went to a qualified medical professional that IS an expert on the subject), but I feel pretty confident in listening to what was conveyed to me above by my doctor.

In summary, what he tells hundreds of people everyday that leads to successful weight loss that doesn't come back completely contradicts the nonsense you listed! Also, I really feel that some of those choices and options differ depending on the person and their circumstances. At the end of the day, it's whatever works for you and keeps you strong enough to get where you want to be and stay there!

your doctor is I-N-S-A-N-E!!! I'm eating 1674 calories and I'm losing!!!!!

And no, your doctor IS NOT an expert on the subject. FIND A NEW DOCTOR!!!!!

limit my daily caloric intake to 1200 calories as that is the medically recognized amount of calories needed for most women's weight loss (it is 1500 calories for men).

WalkingAlong wrote: »

No one says it cant work for someone. They say it cant work for everyone. Hope this helps.

In this forum, the argument usually is stated in the opposite direction: that 1200 calories is too little for anyone. That's untrue and works to the detriment of many people.

I disagree with your analysis of how this is "usually" stated.

Y'know, I was afraid to open this thread because I thought for sure it was 90%+ people decrying the horrors of 1200 calorie starvation. So I was pleasantly surprised to see it's more like the other way! So I guess I agree with you both. Usually, or historically, this place has treated 1200 like it's anorexia. But people seem to have loosened up.

The part that burns me is it's usually men claiming the horrors of 1200. Men who don't need to worry about it because they have the BMR that they can lose 2 lbs/week and not get near it. A lot of us have to hover around 1200 to lose 1 lb/week. Which is not a bad thing, only when people act like we're crash dieting or idiots or something for daring to risk our precious LBM instead of spending six months losing 10 lbs. 'the healthy way', i.e., their way.