Be Smart... don't fall for Fads and scams :)

11012141516

Replies

  • JennaD075
    JennaD075 Posts: 43 Member
    ^^^^ Kale Candy Bars PEOPLE! Lets argue about that too! ;) This is almost fun.

    Clearly... I have NO Idea what I'm talking about. My body must show for it along with my clients.

    Anyone that wants to have an adult debate with me can send me a message and I will start to be serious about this and give my insights and actually listen to yours. Right now all I hear is blah blah blah since so many of you are arguing and knit picking every little thing.

    Ohhh I get it... YOU all are the experts... OOPS My bad lol. :::eye roll:::

    Kale Candy Kale Candy!

    <hate that I have to stoop this low, but I think its the only way some of you can understand>

    I could be wrong because there are a lot of post's on here and I might not remember all of them but from what I CAN remember you are the only one that claimed to be an expert.
  • That's how I feel about all the "teatoxes" everyone is posting about lately. My friend ordered one and her excuse was "it helps flush out your system and get rid of bloating" .....yeah, so does eating healthy.

    Yes that true too! As well as various cleanses making claims to get rid of bloating. Good point :)
  • diannethegeek
    diannethegeek Posts: 14,776 Member
    P.S. Dark chocolate bars help me hit my iron needs.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,268 Member
    ^^^^ Kale Candy Bars PEOPLE! Lets argue about that too! ;) This is almost fun.

    Clearly... I have NO Idea what I'm talking about. My body must show for it along with my clients.

    Anyone that wants to have an adult debate with me can send me a message and I will start to be serious about this and give my insights and actually listen to yours. Right now all I hear is blah blah blah since so many of you are arguing and knit picking every little thing.

    Ohhh I get it... YOU all are the experts... OOPS My bad lol. :::eye roll:::

    Kale Candy Kale Candy!

    <hate that I have to stoop this low, but I think its the only way some of you can understand>

    See this is the thing my sisters body looks like yours...she takes green coffee bean extract, raspberry ketones, "eats clean" and does tonnes of cardio...she doesn't know what she is talking about most of the time either so apparently the presence of low body fat means about as much as your OP....
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,268 Member
    Do you really listen/read what some of you are writing? One of you went on to say "Yeah pizza is better than chicken" and "Ohhh well it can be if its made with this and this" PEOPLE... its a basic comparison of typical pizza and typical chicken. We could literally argue about EVERYTHING if you go that route. I mean really??? YES OBVIOUSLY someone can make their own version of healthy pizza... but I'm saying for purpose of message boards... IN GENERAL CHICKEN IS HEALTHIER THAN PIZZA! oh my goodness LOL I'm literally shocked right now how some of you are SO QUICK to try and prove me wrong that you literally are fighting every point I make- when you know very well that if you ask just about ANYONE they would agree.

    This is exactly the point I was trying to make when I said that pizza can be healthier than chicken. I'm not trying to jump on you or prove you wrong. I read everything that I write and I like to believe that I understand it, even if the point doesn't always come across like I think it will. I also did you the favor of not once shouting at you in this thread, so your choice to do so is unappreciated.

    You never replied to my earlier post about food fear on these boards, so I don't know if you read it or not. I'll revisit it quickly. There are a lot of people who become obsessed with only eating the healthiest diet possible. When we make false comparisons like this it hurts those lurking who have this sort of mindset. I say that chicken is not necessarily healthier than pizza because it's not. Let me shout that because it bears repeating: CHICKEN IS NOT NECESSARILY HEALTHIER THAN PIZZA.

    The general idea that I'm trying to get across is that literally nothing is healthier than anything else unless you look at it in the context of someone's diet. A diet is healthy or unhealthy. A food by itself is neither. Pizza has veggies, crust, cheese, and meat (in most cases). It's a full meal. One could live on pizza and have a relatively decent diet. Even take-out pizza. A chicken breast is just meat. It's mostly just a good source of protein. It's not something that you'd want to live on by itself for the rest of your life. That doesn't make pizza healthier. That doesn't make chicken breast healthier.

    Drop the comparisons. Drop the labels. Talk to people instead of yelling at them and insinuating that they're uneducated or just trying to pick a fight. It really will help you out in the long run.

    This all of this...in a much nicer way than I would say it.
  • BombshellPhoenix
    BombshellPhoenix Posts: 1,693 Member
    Did you know there are people who have your body eating all kinds of foods in moderation and claiming that you have this body you must know what your talking about is kind of a silly claim.
  • SLLRunner
    SLLRunner Posts: 12,942 Member
    I'm curious, not bashing just genuinely curious. You have stated over and over that people keep bringing up that you used "clean" when that wasn't even what your post was about. You said it though and it was part of your post. Why wouldn't people harp on that if it is something that they find offense with? Also I'm curious why you felt the need to come on here and post your public service announcement? Do you honestly think that people don't know about these scams already? The people that would buy into them aren't people that would listen to your warning anyways. It looks like this was one of your first post's ever on this forum what prompted you to do this today? I'm honestly just wondering your thought process. Not in a bad way just wanting to find out where you are coming from on this.

    (As in saying I said they MUST ONLY eat clean foods... and never eat unhealthy foods. Which I clearly CLEARLY stated that I eat them too). :angry:

    You did it again. You're killing me, Smalls.

    Did what? Read carefully what I wrote... that was about what others said, not myself.

    Man, harsh group towards someone just trying to warn people about health/fitness scams that I see daily. Isn't this a Heath and fitness forum to share tips, advice, etc? I'll say it again... MYYYYY BADDDD for using a common word. My Baddd that it got taken in the wrong context. MY BAD for wishing you all a healthy journey. I mean clearly I don't know what I'm talking about :huh:
    To those who sent me private messages supporting my post. Thank you :) Glad I could help. I have no regrets about what I said other than using a word that basically took all meaning away from what I was actually getting at. :laugh:
    You can't suggest eating healthy food around here without sending the yahoos into a tizzy.

    They like their junk food and they don't want to hear that it might not be healthy.

    They cannot be convinced that such a thing as junk food exists, much less hat it might be bad for them.

    It was nice of you to try to help people. :). But, some people cannot be helped. There are none so blind.

    Leave them be.
    There you go pontificating again and making sweeping generalization. This is senseless banter.
  • ^^^^ Kale Candy Bars PEOPLE! Lets argue about that too! ;) This is almost fun.

    Clearly... I have NO Idea what I'm talking about. My body must show for it along with my clients.

    Anyone that wants to have an adult debate with me can send me a message and I will start to be serious about this and give my insights and actually listen to yours. Right now all I hear is blah blah blah since so many of you are arguing and knit picking every little thing.

    Ohhh I get it... YOU all are the experts... OOPS My bad lol. :::eye roll:::

    Kale Candy Kale Candy!

    <hate that I have to stoop this low, but I think its the only way some of you can understand>

    See this is the thing my sisters body looks like yours...she takes green coffee bean extract, raspberry ketones, "eats clean" and does tonnes of cardio...she doesn't know what she is talking about most of the time either so apparently the presence of low body fat means about as much as your OP....

    People on this board can think ANYTHING they want about me. They can think like you and compare me to your sister who does Tons of cardio of which I do not. I do however have a great workout routine (that works for ME) and a suitable nutrition plan that also works for ME. I also train and coach many people who are also doing great. (Each client is on a different program that fits their needs... so no nutrition plan or diet is exactly the same). Whether you believe it or not is your choice. I've had great experience, recommendations, and I LOVE what I do. Making judgements on a message board will not take any of that away from me.
  • Kalikel
    Kalikel Posts: 9,603 Member
    And yes I believe pizza is as good as lean chicken..maybe more so as it has more macros than chicken and hits lots of micros...esp if it's delux with veggies and cheese and meats.
    Deluxe pizza is more healthy than lean chicken.

    You can't make this stuff up.
  • s_pekz
    s_pekz Posts: 340 Member
    in for later
  • bethlaf
    bethlaf Posts: 954 Member
    i eat clean ALL THE TIME- i wash my hands and i can say that i have not eaten dirt since i was 2 or 3 and in four decades i have been clean!!

    Detox - no thanks i have a liver and kidneys, but nice try.
    wraps, yeah they did those in the 70s.
    eliminate this or that foodgroup... um, no thanks , i kind like meat and carbs are good grains not evil nobodies..

    the only things you should limit is the amounts.
    will you feel better on brown rice and broccoli.
    thank burger king and dunkin donuts..
    most likely long term , but that doesnt mean i wouldnt eat them..
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    CASE IN POINT - DONT JUDGE!!!

    come on i had awesome "fast food" last night from Bojangles,2 pieces of chicken and dirty rice. you know why . cuz it was free, as part of signing up for the bone marrow donor registry... and my kids did too ... then we went roller skating for 2 1/2hours and came home and had wild picked blackberries(picked them that morning) with vanilla protein shake poured over as "cream"
    which one was healthier??? i dunno , both were delicious!!!
  • BombshellPhoenix
    BombshellPhoenix Posts: 1,693 Member
    Gonna catch me eating dirty

    2qjc6d5.gif
  • maidentl
    maidentl Posts: 3,203 Member
    and some are empty calories that get stored as fat!

    But they don't though. Calories only get stored as fat if they're in surplus.
  • JennaD075
    JennaD075 Posts: 43 Member
    :laugh:
  • i eat clean ALL THE TIME- i wash my hands and i can say that i have not eaten dirt since i was 2 or 3 and in four decades i have been clean!!

    Detox - no thanks i have a liver and kidneys, but nice try.
    wraps, yeah they did those in the 70s.
    eliminate this or that foodgroup... um, no thanks , i kind like meat and carbs are good grains not evil nobodies..

    the only things you should limit is the amounts.
    will you feel better on brown rice and broccoli.
    thank burger king and dunkin donuts..
    most likely long term , but that doesnt mean i wouldnt eat them..
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    CASE IN POINT - DONT JUDGE!!!

    come on i had awesome "fast food" last night from Bojangles,2 pieces of chicken and dirty rice. you know why . cuz it was free, as part of signing up for the bone marrow donor registry... and my kids did too ... then we went roller skating for 2 1/2hours and came home and had wild picked blackberries(picked them that morning) with vanilla protein shake poured over as "cream"
    which one was healthier??? i dunno , both were delicious!!!

    I have no issues with anything you said. Good points were made and I definitely understand about the Bojangles. :wink:
  • SLLRunner
    SLLRunner Posts: 12,942 Member
    wow...just wow...

    OP you don't get it do you...wondering if I should try one more time....hmm sure I am a sucker for punishment

    Clean eating is a fad and until you say something a long the lines of this

    "you guys I stand corrected, I should not have used the phrase "clean eating" as a thing to do to lose weight while my post was about scams and fads to avoid that are all over the weight loss industry because "clean eating" is the new "buzz word" fad weight loss gimmick.

    What I did was create an oxymoron of a post with that phrase and if I could go back and edit it with" nutrient dense" or "follow the 80/20 rule" I would but now I can't because I was too busy debating that I was right to use that word and calling you all naysayers and laughing at you and dropping the bully bomb, my bad"

    *isn't gonna hold my breath for this but at least I tried.

    :noway: hmm... maybe you should go read a couple posts above where I DID talk about the buzzwords and said I didn't realize it was one and now I do so I will be more careful with it. Reading helps :ohwell:

    you mean this
    We will have to agree to disagree on the bullying. I don't care about it hence why I haven't left yet, but some of the snobbish attacks were unwarranted. Someone could easily say that the term is confusing to many and gave their explanation and that would be that. I understand now that it is a sensitive word. I will be more careful with it in the future... but the way some people handled it was ridiculous.
    <snip>

    Yes I read that part and that was the part that made me post what I did...being disagreed with repeated by the majority <> bullying and you wouldn't have been disagreed with if 6 pages ago you would have just "GOT IT" because you didn't "READ" what we were saying.

    YOu were so intent on being right you missed the forest for the trees and now unfortuanately because you took 6 pages to acknowledge that it is a FAD instead of doing research prior to posting it period...most of what you will post in the future will be scoffed at by those here who saw this and see what you are about.

    And even now you are putting the blame on "us" saying we are bullies, naysayers etc...

    So take this for what it's worth after you have read it a couple times...don't be careful with the words "clean eating" just don't use them they are a fad and a scam...kk :flowerforyou:

    :noway: That was not the post I was referring to... it was before that. But thank you for the lecture. :drinker:

    And again... this is a message board and I take it as such. I am NOT worried about being "Scoffed at by those who saw this and see what you are about" I have legitimate tips and advice regarding fitness and health. I have made other comments on other posts and have had no negativity yet (Though I'm sure some of you are jumping at the chance :laugh: ). As I stated in a previous post. I had NO IDEA that "clean" was a buzzword. I have never heard that before until I came on here. I also stated above that I won't use it and be more careful which terms I use to make a point (even if that was NOT the point in the first place).
    "Clean eating" is not a buzzword, it's a fad and a scam, and your post is about avoiding scams.

    Nobody has been bullying you.
  • Laurenloveswaffles
    Laurenloveswaffles Posts: 535 Member
    So I look forward to speaking with some of you about living a healthy lifestyle.
    Legit question here. What exactly makes a person healthy? Perfect results coming back from blood work? The ability to run a mile in 7 minutes? Not having an eating disorder? Please explain...

    If you're going to post advice on living a "healthy lifestyle" then please inform the readers on what exactly a healthy lifestyle is.
  • MscGray
    MscGray Posts: 304 Member
    I skimmed and skipped....and I have a headache now. Thanks!
  • marie3221
    marie3221 Posts: 77 Member
    Yep, I agree with the message as well until the "clean" came out. You can't claim to not fall for fads and then say you must eat "clean" (which is just another fad term).

    and how is "paleo", "low-carb", etc.. not "fad" terms? Most ppl on here are on a "fad"- like diet.
  • kgeyser
    kgeyser Posts: 22,505 Member

    :noway: That was not the post I was referring to... it was before that. But thank you for the lecture. :drinker:

    And again... this is a message board and I take it as such. I am NOT worried about being "Scoffed at by those who saw this and see what you are about" I have legitimate tips and advice regarding fitness and health. I have made other comments on other posts and have had no negativity yet (Though I'm sure some of you are jumping at the chance :laugh: ). As I stated in a previous post. I had NO IDEA that "clean" was a buzzword. I have never heard that before until I came on here. I also stated above that I won't use it and be more careful which terms I use to make a point (even if that was NOT the point in the first place).

    Your welcome, I typically pull out my mom voice when running into people who are acting like teenagers who have read the book of all...can't help it I have one at home.

    As for your others posts do you mean on your "other" profile because on this profile you have 2 posts...this one you started and one you commented on about how people lose weight differently in which you didn't spout nonsense.
    That is the point I was trying to make. It is a simple word that SOME people use to generally mean healthy food. The word "healthy" can ALSO have multiple meanings since healthy means different things to different people. It's just a simple word to use to describe natural foods. It does NOT mean that all unnatural foods are dirty or unhealthy. Thank you for reading the post the way it was meant and not reading into something I never intended to. Unfortunately, reading things on the internet can easily be misconstrued and for that I do not blame others for disagreeing with that term. I do however disagree with those who got rude about it though to try and make a point... when we were pretty much saying the same thing. Once I explained that I did not mean it as a 100% thing, I would have thought they would back off. Persistence is key I guess. Thanks for your reply!

    As for this...then that's the point you should have made...I read the words and take them for their meaning in context. We can't read minds and know what you "intended" we can only go by what is typed out and that doesn't mean it was misconstrued...

    because even now you are spouting about "eating clean" even if it's 80% of the time which is well...what you just aren't getting.

    There is no clean or dirty, no natural or unnatural food...it's all fuel and can be used for various things. Pizza is a good fuel, lean chicken breast is good fuel, heck a donut is good fuel and the fiber1 peanut butter brownie I am about to eat is good fuel...

    So since persistence is key get this...clean eating and exercise is not the key to weight loss, eating in a calorie deficit is, eating nutrient dense foods and exercise is for health and you can still be fat eating "clean" and "exercising" if you are not in a calorie deficit

    Well... sorry but I am going to completely disagree with you. I agree that I should have been more cautious with the chosen word and described myself better. So in that aspect you are right. But if you honestly tell me that health and losing weight is ONLY about being in a calorie deficit and you basically stated that ALL calories are created equal then I COMPLETELY utterly disagree. That is like telling people they can eat 2 donuts a day but since they are under their calorie amount they will lose weight. :noway: Anorexics lose weight because they obviously are in a calorie deficit. Does that make them healthy? Healthy does NOT always mean being in a calorie deficit. And YES a calorie is a calorie and to lose weight one must burn 3500. I get it. But some calories are "empty" and pose no nutritional value to help the cells in your body burn fat, metabolize food, and maintain muscle. Do you honestly believe that a slice of pizza is as healthy as a chicken breast? Is pizza a demon? NO... and people should be able to ENJOY pizza. But if your sake of argument is that to be healthy and lose weight, a person only has to eat less calories... then you are way off base.

    Yes, a person can eat two donuts a day, be healthy, and lose weight if they are in a calorie deficit. Some people can even do it while also hitting their RDA for micronutrients and manage to hit all their macros. It all depends on your TDEE.

    ETA: Take a look at the diet of Olympic athletes. Michael Phelps had an extremely high calorie requirement, openly admitted to eating fast food regularly, and he won how many medals? Are we going to call him unhealthy?