SUGAR SuGAr SuGAr!!!
Replies
-
nvsmomketo wrote: »nvsmomketo wrote: »
There have been numerous threads that have popped up basically saying "sugar is the devil" and it should be avoided.
That being said, if someone is craving something sweet, I fully believe in trying to incorporate into the diet some how rather than making it a restriction. (pending medical conditions of course)
To be honest, I believe people's health would be better off without any added sugar in their lives, and by eating lower carbs, but people are going to do what they want. Many people do not become ill from sugar, but many do.
I ate sugar until it became the devil for me. LOL If it hadn't become a health issue (prediabetes and exacerbating autoimmune issues), I would still be drinking my colas and saving a few calories for candy.
Same here. Sugar is not not the problem, overeating and a sedentary lifestyle is...nvsmomketo wrote: »nvsmomketo wrote: »
There have been numerous threads that have popped up basically saying "sugar is the devil" and it should be avoided.
That being said, if someone is craving something sweet, I fully believe in trying to incorporate into the diet some how rather than making it a restriction. (pending medical conditions of course)
To be honest, I believe people's health would be better off without any added sugar in their lives, and by eating lower carbs, but people are going to do what they want. Many people do not become ill from sugar, but many do.
I ate sugar until it became the devil for me. LOL If it hadn't become a health issue (prediabetes and exacerbating autoimmune issues), I would still be drinking my colas and saving a few calories for candy.
funny I eat added sugar and carbs and my blood work is nearly perfect and I maintain anywhere from 12 to 15% body fat...0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I feel like the cookie monster - after a full day of working out and eating healthy vegetables, proteins, and fruits, all I want is sugary snacks!
What do you guys use when you crave sugar, and are there any healthy ways to fight off cravings that don't involve eating more fruit?
You may me low in chrome this can cause sugar cravings I take a supplement and it works for me I get very bad cravings when I am due on my period
) 0 -
The Truth About Sugar
thetruthaboutsugar.org/
Sugar: The Bitter Truth – Robert Lustig. Comprehensive and scientific explanation of why sugar is a toxic drug from Robert H. Lustig, MD, UCSF Professor of ...0 -
Lustig is a quack. A theatre major in College, he does have a flair for the dramatic. But his position is nonsense...cathode1977 wrote: »The Truth About Sugar
thetruthaboutsugar.org/
Sugar: The Bitter Truth – Robert Lustig. Comprehensive and scientific explanation of why sugar is a toxic drug from Robert H. Lustig, MD, UCSF Professor of ...0 -
This content has been removed.
-
cathode1977 wrote: »The Truth About Sugar
thetruthaboutsugar.org/
Sugar: The Bitter Truth – Robert Lustig. Comprehensive and scientific explanation of why sugar is a toxic drug from Robert H. Lustig, MD, UCSF Professor of ...
Bahahahaha0 -
Sorry, you said cookie monster.
0 -
cathode1977 wrote: »The Truth About Sugar
thetruthaboutsugar.org/
Sugar: The Bitter Truth – Robert Lustig. Comprehensive and scientific explanation of why sugar is a toxic drug from Robert H. Lustig, MD, UCSF Professor of ...
Ummm, no. Let me just leave you with this...
http://www.alanaragonblog.com/2010/01/29/the-bitter-truth-about-fructose-alarmism/
0 -
1- The OP didn't say they had an addiction, they said they had cravings.nvsmomketo wrote: »
B- if someone had a legitimate addiction, why would they expect a public nutrition forum to be of any use in dealing with their addiction?
0 -
I don't have a sweet tooth. It occurred to me that my defining moment was when I was diagnosed insulin resistant many years ago and I started diarizing, checking my blood sugars. I swiftly learned which foods spiked my sugar levels, and I began to associate that yuckky feeling two hours afterwards, to the over-consumption of sugar. All of a sudden that thick slice of cake with 1/2 inch of frosting did not appeal. After diarizing the results, I associated such foods with ick. They subsequently slid out of my diet. I'll still have a little sweet here and there, but it's much smaller. Like a spoonful of hubby's ice cream. I prefer vegetables and salads over fruits, even though I include fruit daily. And I never bother with sugar sodas.
Keep in mind that I got my blood sugar under control but I continued to gain weight until I reduced my daily calorie load overall.0 -
Here's a podcast that I recommend checking out if you like podcasts. I don't agree with everything they say, but I enjoy it.
http://www.evilsugarradio.com/0 -
OP, if you are looking to fit in a daily treat, at 1400 calories, I would suggest loosely following this breakdown:
Breakfast=300 calories
Lunch=350
Snack=200
Dinner=350
Treat=200
There aren't any rules, but if you know you're going to want it, find a way to budget your calories so you're left with a decent amount for anything you want.
Thanks, this will be really helpful! I didn't mean to start a sugar war - this was my first post and I had no idea it was such a touchy subject! Thanks for all your input, FP community!
0 -
Lasmartchika wrote: »I was craving a donut... and I bought one, enjoyed it, logged it, and kept living life.
I don't think you should deprive yourself of what you crave. Just make it fit into your day.
As for the sugar "addiction"... I don't have the need to go down pounds of sugar (or any other sugar laden food for that matter) after having said donut. It was A donut, not drugs. You can have a drug addiction. You go to rehab for a drug addiction. I have never heard anybody go to rehab for a sugar addiction. :huh:
No, they go to a Curves, Nutrisystem, or a Registered Dietician.
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
You craved a donut, you ate a donut, so you (in theory) got your fix, and life goes on. The smoker craves a cigarette, smokes a cigarette, and since they got their fix, life goes on.
Sugar may not be a traditional addiction as we have come to label them, but the triggers and symptoms are eerily similar to one, and the neuropathways for sugar satisfaction are the same as drug satisfaction: they induce similar hormones. Science is new because we are just barely developing the technology to measure activity in the brain, and society's eyes are just barely opening to see what different foods do to us physiologically.
If we work in absolutes, science takes the hit, because new discoveries get delayed. What if we asked the question: how do we measure with accuracy whether sugar is an addiction to a human or not? Are we biased to believe a certain thing, mainly because we (as a whole) believe sugar is good and addiction is bad? Could there be a conflict of interest?
These are the questions we should be asking instead of telling the unknown person digitally next to us that they are absolutely, without a doubt wrong and demanding digital "evidence" by people more educated than us.
Personally, I dont know. I look at empirical evidence: myself. I hit some green , but I dont feel a [need] to hit some again. I have smoked cigarettes since I was 13. Quitting at 26 was the hardest thing I ever had to do in my entire life. I am no longer addicted to cigarettes. And sugar...well, it's somewhere in the middle. Sometimes I can smell a cake baking, and want no part of it. Other times, I eat it to satiety.
I wonder if it has to do with a neurological or biological balance or imbalance, these variable triggers. The senses are involved, and sensory signals can be very psychosomatic. So, I really don't know.0 -
Too much "you're wrong and I am right" here.
Whatever side of the fence you are on...just know this conversation is irrational because opinions wont change no matter what you present to the other side. Rational thinkers are always open to new ways of thinking, new ways that something coukd happen, and every absolute idea they have is completely fluid, no matter how concrete the idea. Remember...human civilization dates over 10,000 years back, but only in the last 350 years or so did we accept the fact that the Earth is not the center of the universe, even though the idea was evident for centuries.0 -
Great podcast!lemurcat12 wrote: »Here's a podcast that I recommend checking out if you like podcasts. I don't agree with everything they say, but I enjoy it.
http://www.evilsugarradio.com/
0 -
I have no issue with sugar either way, I find it impossible to stay under mfp's goals on a daily basis, and am often far above it.
I do have a question though... When these sugar threads pop up, it's always the same people who jump on the pro-sugar bandwagon. I'm wondering how many of these people are under the age of say, 50 and have yet to deal with any health issues?
Just curious, is all.0 -
christinev297 wrote: »I have no issue with sugar either way, I find it impossible to stay under mfp's goals on a daily basis, and am often far above it.
I do have a question though... When these sugar threads pop up, it's always the same people who jump on the pro-sugar bandwagon. I'm wondering how many of these people are under the age of say, 50 and have yet to deal with any health issues?
Just curious, is all.
what does that have to do with anything????????0 -
Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...0 -
christinev297 wrote: »I have no issue with sugar either way, I find it impossible to stay under mfp's goals on a daily basis, and am often far above it.
I do have a question though... When these sugar threads pop up, it's always the same people who jump on the pro-sugar bandwagon. I'm wondering how many of these people are under the age of say, 50 and have yet to deal with any health issues?
Just curious, is all.
Again, we are not pro-sugar. We are pro science. None of us are advocating diets laden with added sugar. What we are saying, is that you can eat a nutritious diet and still incorporate sugar. I frequently eat 100 - 120g of sugar, but that is mainly from fruit. I generally get 30 - 40g of added sugar, but I also hit 2500 calories (small weight loss), 150g of protein (a little more than 1g per lb of lean body mass), 80 to 90g of fat (.3 to .35g /lb of lbm) and 230 - 250g of carbs. All of this with a variety of foods to ensure I get plenty of nutrients. And just in case I am short, I do a men's one a day and I do naturemade fish oil (never can have enough omega-3s) and on top of that I work out 6-7 hours a week which consist of 4 hours of lifting, 1.5 of cardio and .5-1.5 of yoga/flexibility training.
So are you honestly telling me, that this is a bad plan? That genetics, long term body composition, and lifestyle have less of an impact than the amount of added sugar you eat? And not even considering, that many of us aim to get 80 to 90% of our foods from whole sources? I think the bigger problem is, many people miss context.0 -
As per the bolded, who is advocating this?christinev297 wrote: »Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...
0 -
christinev297 wrote: »I have no issue with sugar either way, I find it impossible to stay under mfp's goals on a daily basis, and am often far above it.
I do have a question though... When these sugar threads pop up, it's always the same people who jump on the pro-sugar bandwagon. I'm wondering how many of these people are under the age of say, 50 and have yet to deal with any health issues?
Just curious, is all.
I've wondered it also.
I'm also still not sure if the whole 'new products' thread is a joke or not.
0 -
As per the bolded, who is advocating this?christinev297 wrote: »Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...
I'm not saying anyone here is advocating this. I just know I care a lot more about what I put in my body now then I did when I was in my 20's and 30's.
Like I said, I have nothing against sugar. It's just the people who advocate for sugar, aspartame etc. etc. are usually in the younger subset, or in denial
Jk Jk
0 -
So you are saying people who do not advocate the removal of added sugar do not care what they put into their bodies?christinev297 wrote: »
As per the bolded, who is advocating this?christinev297 wrote: »Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...
I'm not saying anyone here is advocating this. I just know I care a lot more about what I put in my body now then I did when I was in my 20's and 30's.
Like I said, I have nothing against sugar. It's just the people who advocate for sugar, aspartame etc. etc. are usually in the younger subset, or in denial Jk Jk
0 -
So you are saying people who do not advocate the removal of added sugar do not care what they put into their bodies?christinev297 wrote: »
As per the bolded, who is advocating this?christinev297 wrote: »Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...
I'm not saying anyone here is advocating this. I just know I care a lot more about what I put in my body now then I did when I was in my 20's and 30's.
Like I said, I have nothing against sugar. It's just the people who advocate for sugar, aspartame etc. etc. are usually in the younger subset, or in denial Jk Jk
I don't know, do they?
0 -
Sure seems like you are infering that. But i know i cared about my body in the 20s. After graduation, i changed the way i ate.christinev297 wrote: »
So you are saying people who do not advocate the removal of added sugar do not care what they put into their bodies?christinev297 wrote: »
As per the bolded, who is advocating this?christinev297 wrote: »Because when we're young we can bombard our bodies with pretty much anything. It's years later when these things catch up with us...
There's also the attitude of I'm young and invincible, and don't have to worry too much about my health just yet...
I'm not saying anyone here is advocating this. I just know I care a lot more about what I put in my body now then I did when I was in my 20's and 30's.
Like I said, I have nothing against sugar. It's just the people who advocate for sugar, aspartame etc. etc. are usually in the younger subset, or in denial Jk Jk
I don't know, do they?
0 -
I can only comment on my own experience. I never worried about calories, micros and macros etc etc until I came here nearly a year ago.
In essence i was pretty late to the health care party.
I think we all know younger people who say "I'll worry about that when I'm older". I know I did.0 -
am sure I will be "attacked" by this but added sugar is not good for you.
https://blog.myfitnesspal.com/the-surprising-benefits-of-cutting-back-on-sugar/?utm_source=mfp&utm_medium=Facebook0 -
Also, some people have their ideas and viewpoints set in stone, and no amount of debate or studies will ever change that.
This is why I very rarely participate in sugar or carb et al threads. Because there is always 2 sides, and neither party will budge. It's pretty much just pointless, argumentative banter.0 -
I feel like the cookie monster - after a full day of working out and eating healthy vegetables, proteins, and fruits, all I want is sugary snacks!
What do you guys use when you crave sugar, and are there any healthy ways to fight off cravings that don't involve eating more fruit?
My cravings were bad in the beginning but I just chose to ignore them and eat something healthy like nuts or greek yogurt with fruit and it would go away. Now I hardly ever crave it.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions