Stop eating breakfast. Here's why.
Replies
-
i'm pretty sure not eating is called anorexia. thanks, but i'd like the keep my heart muscle in tact and not lose 100 lbs in a year and go into cardiac arrest.
this post is wrong, biologically. you DO need breakfast for energy. without carbohydrates, your cells do not make energy (read: atp). without atp, your cells cannot perform their normal actions like cell and DNA replication (to up-keep your tissues (heart, liver, kidneys, stomach lining, blood etc etc)), waste disposal (to keep you from experiencing toxicity and the like of substance build up), and other important functions.
i didn't click through to the link, but from the bull you're spilling, the person who wrote these articles you covet is a hack. sorry, you've been brainwashed.
*shrug*
this is one of the most ignorant things i've read in a while. please explain how ketogenic diets work or why PSMF's are prescribed by docs for the morbidly obese?
also how is not eating breakfast anorexic? you'll lose 100lbs in a yr by skipping breakfast?
This!0 -
Seriously, this is a great thread and exactly what forums are for! Healthy debating! Back and forth!
I think if the OP had just called it "Why breakfast may harm weight loss", it wouldn't be nearly as entertaining! I'm loving reading this point/counterpoint between all the big hitters.
Personally if i eat breakfast, no matter how small, i just feel like crap for about an hour. If i skip it i feel great. No idea why, don't really care why. But i can't back it up with studies, so i'll bow out now, and enjoy the more educated butting nutritional/biological horns!:drinker:
Also, hi mods! I'm sure this thread is being monitored!0 -
I didn't read through the whole thread, but I will give my anecdote. I was 230 (now 200, working towards 165), and my Dr. told me to not eat breakfast! Got your attention? It wasn't exactly what he said. He said if I am not hungry when I wake up, to not eat. Breakfast right away is for skinny people. He said if I can wait a couple of hours or so, then eat 1/4 cup or so of nuts or maybe some egg whites and/or whole grains (bulger, etc.) to get by until lunch.
You must remember this is a Dr. talking to a fat guy who was facing serious health issues if something didn't change. He wanted me to do a 1500cal low fat, whole grain diet. If you are eating normal calories, you can alter this. I actually decided to use medifast to kick start my weight loss and teaching myself to log everything I put in my mouth.
This is just another data point. Skipping breakfast or not skipping breakfast is not an absolute. Just eat when your hungry, and don't eat more than you need. Moderation is the key to most things in life.0 -
I didn't read through the whole thread...
If you got time, you should! Thread of the year imo
0 -
-Good thread going on in here-
Ok, fact, your body needs something to do something. You sleep all night, and your body goes into overdrive to repair cells from the day, and all that jazz.
You wake up, you got nothing. I don't eat right away, myself, because like any average adult- I grab the coffee (I'm glugging like 1-2 cups most now, and half-caf, because well, I don't want to explode before 12). Anyhow, I grab that. Yes, sugar and milk. And the milk tends to work its magic to curb my hunger, a long with the natural appetite suppressant that coffee actually does. For better or worse, its a habit I can't break.
But then it rolls a few hours later, and I nibble. I havn't ahd a 'big breakfast' in almost a year now. And if I do, its like rare.
I tried skipping before, and I get the shakes. I feel like crap, and by the time lunch rolls around, I can't hold my food down because my stomach is so upset.
And HEYO- Hypoglycemia anyone?0 -
I disagree, if I dont eat breakfast then I tend to eat way more during the day, and they usually are not good options Im eating.
Ditto! I am use to eating small meals throughout the day, skipping meals is bad news. One of the reasons I am where I am, you need to eat to lose, but eat the right things. Also, not good if you're diabetic.0 -
I disagree, if I dont eat breakfast then I tend to eat way more during the day, and they usually are not good options Im eating.
One of the reasons I am where I am, you need to eat to lose, but eat the right things.
If you want to get healthy, sure.
If you just want to get healthier and lose weight, then doesnt matter what you eat, just keep that calorie deficit.0 -
i'm pretty sure not eating is called anorexia. thanks, but i'd like the keep my heart muscle in tact and not lose 100 lbs in a year and go into cardiac arrest.
this post is wrong, biologically. you DO need breakfast for energy. without carbohydrates, your cells do not make energy (read: atp). without atp, your cells cannot perform their normal actions like cell and DNA replication (to up-keep your tissues (heart, liver, kidneys, stomach lining, blood etc etc)), waste disposal (to keep you from experiencing toxicity and the like of substance build up), and other important functions.
i didn't click through to the link, but from the bull you're spilling, the person who wrote these articles you covet is a hack. sorry, you've been brainwashed.
*shrug*
Wow. Just wow. I'll just say this and let it be;
The whole point of eating less than you burn is so that your body does NOT have the energy it needs, and is forced to use the stored energy, i.e. fat.
But I understand why you won't click the link. If you do you may be forced to confront the fact that you have no effing clue what you're talking about.0 -
sorry! cant give up my rice krispies, milk and chocolate chips each morning. I would have a blood sugar crash (not diabetic) before I could eat and would feel sick so gotta nix the no breakfast idea.
Oh yeah, I'm sure chocolate chips are totally keeping your blood sugar even and helping you avoid crashing.0 -
I disagree, if I dont eat breakfast then I tend to eat way more during the day, and they usually are not good options Im eating.
Ditto! I am use to eating small meals throughout the day, skipping meals is bad news. One of the reasons I am where I am, you need to eat to lose, but eat the right things. Also, not good if you're diabetic.
Completely agree that this isn't for diabetics.
Also, many have had great success with small meals, including breakfast, and if people find a method that helps them find success, then I'm all for it! I've used it myself, but I'm a man of extremes, which is why I like intermittent fasting so much. I'd rather have times of not eating and times of eating enough to avoid hunger entirely, instead of being a little hungry all the time. That's also why I like my diet. How else can someone hit up a pizza buffet once a week and STILL lose weight. Better yet, how else can someone actually lose MORE weight by hitting up the pizza buffet?0 -
Yay! I reached the end of the thread!
Having read the link, what it seems to say is:
1) Our bodies are designed to demand/require breakfast (the hormones described make you hungry, right? Grehlin or whatever it was called).
2) While in that natural state, if we eat, our bodies will prefer to store some fat, if possible.
3) We can prevent this by ignoring all the signals to eat from our bodies and delaying eating for a couple of hours.
As I am not attempting to lose fat right now, I'll just stick to letting my body tell me that I need breakfast. When losing weight in the past, I often split breakfas in two, which seemed very effective, but next time (hopefully having gained baby weight) I may just delay the whole thing a bit.
Thank you for the info. Our bodies really don't want us to lose too much fat, so if we want to, tricking them this way makes some sense.0 -
bump0
-
I've found, if I don't eat breakfast, I can easily go until 3 or 4 pm without feeling hungry at all, but if I eat breakfast, I will be starving all day long...I prefer to skip breakfast and keep all my calories in a 6-8 hr window in the afternoon....It's worked for me I've been consistently losing weight *well lately just inches b/c I've been building muscle* for the past 5 months. 0
-
If you are skipping bfast and lunch, then you must be consuming all your calories in one meal??? And exercise in the evening?
I, too have to disagree......never once have I skipped any one of my 6 meals a day in the past year, and I have very successfully lost over 100 pounds 0 -
If you are skipping bfast and lunch, then you must be consuming all your calories in one meal??? And exercise in the evening?
I, too have to disagree......never once have I skipped any one of my 6 meals a day in the past year, and I have very successfully lost over 100 pounds
No not one meal.....You have 6-8 hrs to eat in still---they are just from say 4PM to 12PM or 2PM to 10PM....I normally have one meal and two snacks in that time period....And you don't have to work out in the evening---A big part of IF is training while fasting.
I beleive either method works honestly....For me, it's easier to do what I'm doing now...It's all about making changes that you can keep forever right?? Well, I can skip breakfast and lunch way easier than I can plan out 5-6 small meals throughout my hectic day.0 -
If you are skipping bfast and lunch, then you must be consuming all your calories in one meal??? And exercise in the evening?
I, too have to disagree......never once have I skipped any one of my 6 meals a day in the past year, and I have very successfully lost over 100 pounds
That's awesome! Welcome to the 100lb club!
No, I'm definitely not eating all my calories in one meal. I'm not sure why people keep saying that. Today I ate very little, just 3 hamburger patties with cheese and a bowl of raw broccoli covered in a little cheese and dipped in a little ranch, but I ate throughout the day once I got off work (each burger was 500 calories, so I still had plenty of cals). I had a hamburger pattie at 3:30, then lifted (I squatted 315x4 and 135x50 today. Obviously I'm really week from this low carb diet), then had the other two hamburgers and broccoli spread throughout the rest of the evening.
One of my favorite fast breaking meals after I get off work is an omelet with 4 eggs, 4 strips of bacon, 1/2 cup of sausage crumbles and 1/4 cup of shredded cheese. This all works out to about 500-600 calories with only about 7g of carbs and leaves me STUFFED for hours.0 -
One of my favorite fast breaking meals after I get off work is an omelet with 4 eggs, 4 strips of bacon, 1/2 cup of sausage crumbles and 1/4 cup of shredded cheese. This all works out to about 500-600 calories with only about 7g of carbs and leaves me STUFFED for hours.
Stop....you had me at bacon....0 -
If you are skipping bfast and lunch, then you must be consuming all your calories in one meal??? And exercise in the evening?
I, too have to disagree......never once have I skipped any one of my 6 meals a day in the past year, and I have very successfully lost over 100 pounds
No not one meal.....You have 6-8 hrs to eat in still---they are just from say 4PM to 12PM or 2PM to 10PM....I normally have one meal and two snacks in that time period....And you don't have to work out in the evening---A big part of IF is training while fasting.
I beleive either method works honestly....For me, it's easier to do what I'm doing now...It's all about making changes that you can keep forever right?? Well, I can skip breakfast and lunch way easier than I can plan out 5-6 small meals throughout my hectic day.
i personally found IF is just more convenient and satiating for me, i usually have 1 smallish meal, 1 big meal and 1 dessert in my eating window. Normally i'll go 7ish hrs from waking to my first meal0 -
wow, this has been an interesting read. It's 1:30pm here and I haven't eaten breakfast yet. Oh ****...
To those who aren't willing to give up their eggs/bacon/oats whatever. You can actually eat these at any time of the day
To those who said they will make bad food choices if they don't eat breakfast, well that's just a lack of will power. And if you're under your TDEE and still getting adequate protein and fats then I don't see an issue.
To those that say they will be too hungry if they don't eat breakfast: that is because that is what you're body is used to. http://lmgtfy.com/?q=ghrelin+&+leptin
It's also very easy to see the amount of people that have replied to this thread after reading the title and not the article.0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
Dear TateFTW,
I disagree. This is what you do when you purge your body of the nutrients it needs to continue to function. You must have read the following:
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/diet_and_fitness/article578724.ece
Next thing we know people will say that anorexia and bulimia aren't medical conditions but, instead, are actually healthy for us. Really?0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
Dear TateFTW,
I disagree. This is what you do when you purge your body of the nutrients it needs to continue to function. You must have read the following:
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/diet_and_fitness/article578724.ece
Next thing we know people will say that anorexia and bulimia aren't medical conditions but, instead, are actually healthy for us. Really?
really? how is skipping breakfast purging your body of nutrients?
and the article you listed the author stated she couldn't skip breakfast and feels terrible when doing so, she doesn't present any actual research against skipping breakfast
and did you just bring up eating disorders? and somehow that is even relevant to this conversation? if you eat the same amount of cals, when you eat them or how many meals you eat them in makes zero difference0 -
It was just last night I was reading about intermittent method/training/nutrition. From what I gathered there's a feeding stage and a healing/recovery stage. During the feeding stage you simply eat all of your calories for the day. A feeding stage lasts for like 8 hours. So 4 meals spaced out every 2 hours. Your first meal being your largest one and your last being the smallest. Call it not eating breakfast, but if you count ahead 8 hours using this method, If you eat breakfast at 6 am, you should be finished eating for the day by 2pm. If breakfast is at 10, then you'd be done eating by 6. Simply adjust based on your individual schedule.
I don't do the above, but I don't think it's unhealthy. I do think that marketing messes with people more than they realize. Just like making you think there's something wrong with you by saying you're an "overpronater" so here buy these special shoes that will cure your problem. When I first started in a natural running form, I ditched my heavy duty brooks beasts for a pair of saucony kinvara's and haven't looked back. I run farther and faster with zero aches / pains. The mind!
There's an article out there to support whatever you believe. Just do what works for you.0 -
Despite proof from your article, there is also an abundance of research that proves breakfast is key to weight loss. I suppose there is no conclusion when it comes to this topic; it depends on the individual.
Weight-loss is actually quite simple. You need to burn more calories than you eat. (And consume healthy calories) Unless I'm wrong, I don't think what you eat at what the time of the day is a significant issue when it comes to weight-loss.0 -
I feel like I just wasted half an hour of my life reading this entire thread.
Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are culturally created concepts. Who says you have to eat at a certain time of the day? Who says you have to eat bacon and eggs or cereal for breakfast? Just listen to your body and do what feels right. For me, eating breakfast feels right because I'm hungry after 8 hours of sleep. If I wasn't hungry when I woke up I probably wouldn't be eating until I felt hungry.
And can't we all just get along?
Began to type a post then saw this. Just sums up what I think!
Circadian Rhythm.0 -
HEY guys!!! i have a belly button!!
Holy ****! I do too!!!! :noway:0 -
i usually wake up hungry, and i'm a total ***** when i'm hungry (and, thankfully, ONLY when i'm hungry!), so i think it's in the best interest of those who have to deal with me that i continue to eat breakfast!
Same here...I can only imagine how many people will be killed if I didn't eat until 3pm. *shudder*0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
Dear TateFTW,
I disagree. This is what you do when you purge your body of the nutrients it needs to continue to function. You must have read the following:
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/diet_and_fitness/article578724.ece
Next thing we know people will say that anorexia and bulimia aren't medical conditions but, instead, are actually healthy for us. Really?
really? how is skipping breakfast purging your body of nutrients?
and the article you listed the author stated she couldn't skip breakfast and feels terrible when doing so, she doesn't present any actual research against skipping breakfast
and did you just bring up eating disorders? and somehow that is even relevant to this conversation? if you eat the same amount of cals, when you eat them or how many meals you eat them in makes zero difference
You're entitled to your opinion, I'm entitled to mine. If you disagree with what I say then I'm happy for ya'. Doesn't change my mind about the thread and the information within the thread.0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
In addition, the starter of this thread clearly indicated that he "started skipping breakfast and even lunch" and he started losing weight on demand. He made no mention that he was eating the "recommended caloric goal" for the day for his particular body. If I starved myself I'd lose weight quickly myself, I'm sure I'd also gain it back since I've tried that route before. The mention about anorexia and bulimia was not referencing that's what he's doing. I was cross-referencing that, in my opinion, saying that skipping meals and not making up the calorie count your body needs for proper nutrients is ok, is the same as saying that anorexia and bulimia are not medical conditions and are perfectly ok. I DID NOT say that the thread owner had anorexia or bulimia or was bound to end up with either conditions.0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
Dear TateFTW,
I disagree. This is what you do when you purge your body of the nutrients it needs to continue to function. You must have read the following:
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/diet_and_fitness/article578724.ece
Next thing we know people will say that anorexia and bulimia aren't medical conditions but, instead, are actually healthy for us. Really?
How is it purging your body of nutrients if you're getting your daily caloric requirements? Simple question here..0 -
Ok, have I got your attention now? For a long time we've been fed the idea that breakfast is important. In fact, people call it the most important meal of the day (mostly cereal companies. . .jk). I started to learn about a year ago that this wasn't true. The more I researched and read, the more I realised that we were getting bad info. I started skipping breakfast and even lunch, not eating until I got off work around 3, and I started losing weight on demand and felt great once I got used to it. There are programs that make use of this idea, such as intermittent fasting, which I've used with success.
I posted another article from this author the other day, but I just found this one and again feel the need to let everyone else read this. I believe strongly in the things this author believes in and they have all worked for me. Yes, he does have programs he's designed, but I'm not trying to sell anything. I just want everyone to have this information.
http://articles.elitefts.com/articles/nutrition/logic-does-not-apply-part-2-breakfast/
Dear TateFTW,
I disagree. This is what you do when you purge your body of the nutrients it needs to continue to function. You must have read the following:
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/diet_and_fitness/article578724.ece
Next thing we know people will say that anorexia and bulimia aren't medical conditions but, instead, are actually healthy for us. Really?
really? how is skipping breakfast purging your body of nutrients?
and the article you listed the author stated she couldn't skip breakfast and feels terrible when doing so, she doesn't present any actual research against skipping breakfast
and did you just bring up eating disorders? and somehow that is even relevant to this conversation? if you eat the same amount of cals, when you eat them or how many meals you eat them in makes zero difference
You're entitled to your opinion, I'm entitled to mine. If you disagree with what I say then I'm happy for ya'. Doesn't change my mind about the thread and the information within the thread.
i'm not trying to change your opinion but i fail to see how eating disorders even come up in the topic of skipping breakfast and instead adding those calories into other meals0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions