Body Positive or Promoting an unhealthy lifestyle

1568101114

Replies

  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    I see this thread has now degenerated into a debate on how obese people really are just as healthy as the non obese...

    LOL interesting...

    not one person is saying that.

    oh really? Then why a few pages back are people making claims about obese people being as healthy, if not healthier, than non obese????????????????????
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    oh god.

    So much special snowflake. Definitely promoting unhealthiness. I'd also say promoting an unhealthy mental condition too. I'm not sure if it's ignorance or insanity that equates being happy with being morbidly obese, and "bucking beauty standards"
  • Lourdesong
    Lourdesong Posts: 1,492 Member
    edited January 2015
    Lourdesong wrote: »
    Lourdesong wrote: »

    The "fat" are "pitiable"?
    Really, you went there?

    Read the whole conversation. I am among this pitiable group that needs a self-esteem boost so is being encouraged to boast about qualities I do not possess.

    So only the fat that don't have self esteem are pitiable?
    And it's ok to call them that if you belong to them. Got it.

    You don't 'get' anything. You clearly aren't following along and don't understand what my argument even was.


    So who are the pitiable then?


    The group being condescended to, the group encouraged to boast when others who are conventionally beautiful are discouraged to boast. If you were following along, you'd know that I found this condescending and that I felt I and other fat people are being pitied.
    Spell it slow, I'm not only not following along, I'm kinda dense.

    You said it.

  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    Zaftique wrote: »
    My god, I want her hair. o_O And her chin! I'm several sizes smaller than her, yet I have the most frustrating double chin that will not go away, HOW DOES SHE DO..

    Face tattoos (both tats of faces and tats on the face) aren't my cup of tea, but confidence is always sexy. ;D
    Photoshop.
    Pose.
  • daw0518
    daw0518 Posts: 459 Member
    I think you should be happy in your skin no matter what size you are. When I was fat, I had sex, dressed nicely, went to events/etc. I mean, life wasnt over just because I was overweight. Now I am thin, and I still do all those things. I think its unhealthy to wait to live your life until your body meets a certain standard.

    I had different priorities when I was big, and I figure other large people similarly have other aspects of their lives they are focusing on, and arent bothered by their weight.

    This this this. Life does not stop just because you're fat. You still have to go to work, to school, run errands, etc. You still have friends & romantic relationships. You're allowed to be overweight and still make an effort with your appearance via nice clothes, hair, and makeup if you so choose. Fat people aren't relegated to hoodies, sweatpants, & a sad look on their face at all times. Life still happens.

    It honestly just amazes me how many people here act like weight loss and self-acceptance is this easy thing, as if we didn't all struggle with it at some point. We especially have first hand experience telling us that it isn't easy. It takes a lot of work and soul-searching to get there. Some of us stayed fat well into our 20s, 30s, 40s - even AFTER doctors and friends/family might have told us we were dangerously unhealthy. Seriously, WHO ARE WE to go around acting like we're heroes because we, by some miracle, saw the light and decided to (and were able to) make a change for the better. Of course we should be proud, but damn. Some of you forget awful quick what it was like to be on that side of the fence and have no empathy at all.

  • veganbettie
    veganbettie Posts: 701 Member
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.
  • veganbettie
    veganbettie Posts: 701 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    well of course, but when people get them, you automatically become "alternative" (kinda, not so much anymore). And alternative isn't necessarily what society deems attractive, so people want to be accepted for that.

    The tattoos and piercing things is pretty silly, but that's sort of the way of thought in those communities.....

    "Accept me even though i'm heavily tattooed!!!" "Business people can have tattoos!!!" "I'm not a delinquent because i'm pierced up!!!" ----that sort of thing.

    Anyways, the campaign was built to give confidence to anyone that is "different".
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    daw0518 wrote: »
    I think you should be happy in your skin no matter what size you are. When I was fat, I had sex, dressed nicely, went to events/etc. I mean, life wasnt over just because I was overweight. Now I am thin, and I still do all those things. I think its unhealthy to wait to live your life until your body meets a certain standard.

    I had different priorities when I was big, and I figure other large people similarly have other aspects of their lives they are focusing on, and arent bothered by their weight.

    This this this. Life does not stop just because you're fat. You still have to go to work, to school, run errands, etc. You still have friends & romantic relationships. You're allowed to be overweight and still make an effort with your appearance via nice clothes, hair, and makeup if you so choose. Fat people aren't relegated to hoodies, sweatpants, & a sad look on their face at all times. Life still happens.

    It honestly just amazes me how many people here act like weight loss and self-acceptance is this easy thing, as if we didn't all struggle with it at some point. We especially have first hand experience telling us that it isn't easy. It takes a lot of work and soul-searching to get there. Some of us stayed fat well into our 20s, 30s, 40s - even AFTER doctors and friends/family might have told us we were dangerously unhealthy. Seriously, WHO ARE WE to go around acting like we're heroes because we, by some miracle, saw the light and decided to (and were able to) make a change for the better. Of course we should be proud, but damn. Some of you forget awful quick what it was like to be on that side of the fence and have no empathy at all.

    I haven't forgotten how it felt to be big. I wasn't even that big, and I just felt fat and unattractive. Is that really shocking that I find women even bigger than I was fat and unattractive? Call it lack of empathy if you wish, but I don't see why I should apply different standards to people other than myself. I've never claimed to be a hero. Heck my friends here know by now that there isn't a week that goes by without me binging and I can't say for certain how long I'll be able to keep my 'new lifestyle'. But I sure wasn't showing off my fat rolls when I was obese either.

    Although yes, she has a very pretty face. But it makes me sad. Loving oneself is one thing, but frankly it's borderline self-destructive at this point, IMO, because she clearly isn't doing anything to fix it ('but she works out 4x a week with a trainer!'. Because we all know that exercise without diet works so well). But I guess she's 22...
  • farfromthetree
    farfromthetree Posts: 982 Member
    edited January 2015
    daw0518 wrote: »
    I think you should be happy in your skin no matter what size you are. When I was fat, I had sex, dressed nicely, went to events/etc. I mean, life wasnt over just because I was overweight. Now I am thin, and I still do all those things. I think its unhealthy to wait to live your life until your body meets a certain standard.

    I had different priorities when I was big, and I figure other large people similarly have other aspects of their lives they are focusing on, and arent bothered by their weight.

    This this this. Life does not stop just because you're fat. You still have to go to work, to school, run errands, etc. You still have friends & romantic relationships. You're allowed to be overweight and still make an effort with your appearance via nice clothes, hair, and makeup if you so choose. Fat people aren't relegated to hoodies, sweatpants, & a sad look on their face at all times. Life still happens.

    It honestly just amazes me how many people here act like weight loss and self-acceptance is this easy thing, as if we didn't all struggle with it at some point. We especially have first hand experience telling us that it isn't easy. It takes a lot of work and soul-searching to get there. Some of us stayed fat well into our 20s, 30s, 40s - even AFTER doctors and friends/family might have told us we were dangerously unhealthy. Seriously, WHO ARE WE to go around acting like we're heroes because we, by some miracle, saw the light and decided to (and were able to) make a change for the better. Of course we should be proud, but damn. Some of you forget awful quick what it was like to be on that side of the fence and have no empathy at all.

    My goodness...maybe I missed it but I didn't see any comments implying that overweight people should stick to hoodies, and sweatpants. In fact, the majority of people are on her side with a few people saying either a.) they do not find it attractive or b.) It is an unhealthy weight
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    well of course, but when people get them, you automatically become "alternative" (kinda, not so much anymore). And alternative isn't necessarily what society deems attractive, so people want to be accepted for that.

    The tattoos and piercing things is pretty silly, but that's sort of the way of thought in those communities.....

    "Accept me even though i'm heavily tattooed!!!" "Business people can have tattoos!!!" "I'm not a delinquent because i'm pierced up!!!" ----that sort of thing.

    Anyways, the campaign was built to give confidence to anyone that is "different".

    meh, everyone gets judged by their actions. this really just seems silly to me. if you need an acceptance movement for tattoos and you really truly care that society accepts you for who you are, don't get the dumb tattoos.
  • MireyGal76
    MireyGal76 Posts: 7,334 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    hairstyles aren't a choice? body hair isn't a choice? weight isn't a choice?

    In the grand scheme of things, many (if not all) of the items in the movement are choices. And the whole idea of "acceptance" is to say that "I" still have value even if "you" do not agree with my choices.

    Beauty is not about body. A person's worth, their inherent beauty, is so much more than the skin sack they occupy. When we only accept a person as "beautiful" who fits into our acceptable mold, then we are the ones who are wrong. Not them.

    I have my own personal preferences as to what attracts me, to what appeals to me. But I will not say someone is not worthy of being respected if they don't fit that mold. I was never physically fat. EVER. But I was mentally fat. And I struggled with esteem issues (still do).. But more than anything, I am learning to love myself. And with that, I am finding it extends to all people a lot more readily.

    Sorry, I digress.
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    edited January 2015
    MireyGal76 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    hairstyles aren't a choice? body hair isn't a choice? weight isn't a choice?

    In the grand scheme of things, many (if not all) of the items in the movement are choices. And the whole idea of "acceptance" is to say that "I" still have value even if "you" do not agree with my choices.

    Beauty is not about body. A person's worth, their inherent beauty, is so much more than the skin sack they occupy. When we only accept a person as "beautiful" who fits into our acceptable mold, then we are the ones who are wrong. Not them.

    I have my own personal preferences as to what attracts me, to what appeals to me. But I will not say someone is not worthy of being respected if they don't fit that mold. I was never physically fat. EVER. But I was mentally fat. And I struggled with esteem issues (still do).. But more than anything, I am learning to love myself. And with that, I am finding it extends to all people a lot more readily.

    Sorry, I digress.

    sure, what you eat is a choice, but it's much harder to get thin than to not get a tattoo. different levels of judging. i'll judge overweight people too, just not as harshly as the tattoo people. tattoos are stupid.

    will judge those who choose not to remove body hair too. women with hairy legs are gross.
  • veganbettie
    veganbettie Posts: 701 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    well of course, but when people get them, you automatically become "alternative" (kinda, not so much anymore). And alternative isn't necessarily what society deems attractive, so people want to be accepted for that.

    The tattoos and piercing things is pretty silly, but that's sort of the way of thought in those communities.....

    "Accept me even though i'm heavily tattooed!!!" "Business people can have tattoos!!!" "I'm not a delinquent because i'm pierced up!!!" ----that sort of thing.

    Anyways, the campaign was built to give confidence to anyone that is "different".

    meh, everyone gets judged by their actions. this really just seems silly to me. if you need an acceptance movement for tattoos and you really truly care that society accepts you for who you are, don't get the dumb tattoos.

    well i think it's more of, you need to just accept people as they are not not judge on appearances, because that generally doesn't give you a good idea of what a person is about.
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    well of course, but when people get them, you automatically become "alternative" (kinda, not so much anymore). And alternative isn't necessarily what society deems attractive, so people want to be accepted for that.

    The tattoos and piercing things is pretty silly, but that's sort of the way of thought in those communities.....

    "Accept me even though i'm heavily tattooed!!!" "Business people can have tattoos!!!" "I'm not a delinquent because i'm pierced up!!!" ----that sort of thing.

    Anyways, the campaign was built to give confidence to anyone that is "different".

    meh, everyone gets judged by their actions. this really just seems silly to me. if you need an acceptance movement for tattoos and you really truly care that society accepts you for who you are, don't get the dumb tattoos.

    well i think it's more of, you need to just accept people as they are not not judge on appearances, because that generally doesn't give you a good idea of what a person is about.

    if you don't know a person well, that is going to be the first thing you judge them on. just a fact of life. if they don't like the judgments made based on something as easy to avoid as a tattoo, they shouldn't get one.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    MireyGal76 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    hairstyles aren't a choice? body hair isn't a choice? weight isn't a choice?

    In the grand scheme of things, many (if not all) of the items in the movement are choices. And the whole idea of "acceptance" is to say that "I" still have value even if "you" do not agree with my choices.

    Beauty is not about body. A person's worth, their inherent beauty, is so much more than the skin sack they occupy. When we only accept a person as "beautiful" who fits into our acceptable mold, then we are the ones who are wrong. Not them.

    I have my own personal preferences as to what attracts me, to what appeals to me. But I will not say someone is not worthy of being respected if they don't fit that mold. I was never physically fat. EVER. But I was mentally fat. And I struggled with esteem issues (still do).. But more than anything, I am learning to love myself. And with that, I am finding it extends to all people a lot more readily.

    Sorry, I digress.

    I'm sorry but where did anyone say that obese people don't have value? Just because I don't find someone beautiful doesn't mean I won't like their personality or that I find them worthless. Yikes. Talk about jumping to conclusions.
  • veganbettie
    veganbettie Posts: 701 Member
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    Aviva92 wrote: »
    i love her, and i think she is gorgeous.

    But I don't think the modeling agency got her because they want her to display clothing for the larger crowd...

    I think they got her for exactly what we've given them and her, publicity.

    Now they have their token gorgeous fat girl.

    Also the eff your beauty standards campaign is not just for overweight people. Its motivation for people to brush off and try not to care about what society deems attractive.

    If you go to that hash tag on instagram you'll see a lot of different looking people....yes mostly overweight and or obese people, but there are also thin different looking people, people with tattoos, people with piercings, women with body hair....i think the aim is for more than just weight acceptance, it's mostly going that way because we have a lot of overweight people that need more self love and confidence to get through their day because they have lived their whole life with fat shaming.

    This is a super multifaceted topic, and it's interesting to read everyone's take on it.

    hmmmm, tattoos and piercings seem like a stupid thing to have an acceptance movement for. those are clearly a choice.

    well of course, but when people get them, you automatically become "alternative" (kinda, not so much anymore). And alternative isn't necessarily what society deems attractive, so people want to be accepted for that.

    The tattoos and piercing things is pretty silly, but that's sort of the way of thought in those communities.....

    "Accept me even though i'm heavily tattooed!!!" "Business people can have tattoos!!!" "I'm not a delinquent because i'm pierced up!!!" ----that sort of thing.

    Anyways, the campaign was built to give confidence to anyone that is "different".

    meh, everyone gets judged by their actions. this really just seems silly to me. if you need an acceptance movement for tattoos and you really truly care that society accepts you for who you are, don't get the dumb tattoos.

    well i think it's more of, you need to just accept people as they are not not judge on appearances, because that generally doesn't give you a good idea of what a person is about.

    if you don't know a person well, that is going to be the first thing you judge them on. just a fact of life. if they don't like the judgments made based on something as easy to avoid as a tattoo, they shouldn't get one.

    true. you can't avoid judging. And I mostly agree with you. I'm just going on about what the campaign is about.

    Personally i don't mind being judged because i seldom fit what the person thinks of me, and it generally gives me an advantage, especially in my line of work. Granted there are negatives too.
  • EvgeniZyntx
    EvgeniZyntx Posts: 24,208 Member
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    I see this thread has now degenerated into a debate on how obese people really are just as healthy as the non obese...

    LOL interesting...

    not one person is saying that.

    oh really? Then why a few pages back are people making claims about obese people being as healthy, if not healthier, than non obese????????????????????

    I believe I made the claim of an ex-Olympian, who happens to be overweight and also happens to be healthy. No one is saying that obese people are just as healthy - just that some obese people are healthy.

    There's a subtle difference.

    In fact, at least some research shows has shown - (quoted above) - In the absence of negative health markers, obesity is apparently not as large a risk fact in and of itself.

  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    edited January 2015
    promoting health is not typically what models do. unless they work for shakeology or shape- or fitUstoday.com or whatever.

    she's paid to sell what her manager books her gigs for and take pictures for an owner/marketer who wants her body type/face/style/image to represent their product.

    That doesn't mean she loves her body.
    That doesn't mean she hates her body.

    Those two things are not connected.

    Personally- I think people need to understand that loving yourself is not an excuse to stay the same. You don't need self hate to want to change.

    you don't need to hate yourself if you think you need to change. You can want to change- and pursue changes without hating yourself.

    it's okay to love your body even when it's less than what you think is ideal- it doesn't have to be your be all end all self esteem like people make it out to be.
  • Unknown
    edited January 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    So, wonder what else they plan with Token?
  • rosebette
    rosebette Posts: 1,660 Member
    We must keep in mind, she is a "plus size" model. Plus size clothes are above a size 16. Typically, plus size models are an 8 to 12 and they pin the clothes tight in discreet places so they fit properly. My daughter, who is 5'10" and around a size 12 would be a "plus size" model (she's an actress and has gone to a few auditions/gigs). However, a size 12 on a medium to large framed woman that height is perfectly normal, not "plus size." So why not have a real plus size woman model plus size clothes and celebrate herself?
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    rosebette wrote: »
    We must keep in mind, she is a "plus size" model. Plus size clothes are above a size 16. Typically, plus size models are an 8 to 12 and they pin the clothes tight in discreet places so they fit properly. My daughter, who is 5'10" and around a size 12 would be a "plus size" model (she's an actress and has gone to a few auditions/gigs). However, a size 12 on a medium to large framed woman that height is perfectly normal, not "plus size." So why not have a real plus size woman model plus size clothes and celebrate herself?

    I don't think most of us who don't like it are against the fact that she's modeling plus size clothes, but that she's so vocal about the fact that it's perfectly fine to be obese.
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    Francl27 wrote: »
    rosebette wrote: »
    We must keep in mind, she is a "plus size" model. Plus size clothes are above a size 16. Typically, plus size models are an 8 to 12 and they pin the clothes tight in discreet places so they fit properly. My daughter, who is 5'10" and around a size 12 would be a "plus size" model (she's an actress and has gone to a few auditions/gigs). However, a size 12 on a medium to large framed woman that height is perfectly normal, not "plus size." So why not have a real plus size woman model plus size clothes and celebrate herself?

    I don't think most of us who don't like it are against the fact that she's modeling plus size clothes, but that she's so vocal about the fact that it's perfectly fine to be obese.
    Which to me it is fine.

    If I were a cannibal and she were my feed cattle.
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    rosebette wrote: »
    We must keep in mind, she is a "plus size" model. Plus size clothes are above a size 16. Typically, plus size models are an 8 to 12 and they pin the clothes tight in discreet places so they fit properly. My daughter, who is 5'10" and around a size 12 would be a "plus size" model (she's an actress and has gone to a few auditions/gigs). However, a size 12 on a medium to large framed woman that height is perfectly normal, not "plus size." So why not have a real plus size woman model plus size clothes and celebrate herself?

    for regular sizes, the models don't accurately reflect the body of the average person either. why can't we celebrate average too? we should celebrate everyone. yay!
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    we need body positive models for those of us who aren't obese or even overweight, but are kinda flat chested and have big thighs for our overall figure and hips that are too wide. where are these positive models for ME exactly?
  • carrieous
    carrieous Posts: 1,024 Member
    glorified obesity. not good.
  • Bry_Fitness70
    Bry_Fitness70 Posts: 2,480 Member
    If we diminish the stigma on being overweight, and celebrate people with unhealthy bodies, is that really helpful? I'm not suggesting shaming anyone, but rather refraining from glorifying an unhealthy condition.
  • DeWoSa
    DeWoSa Posts: 496 Member
    I think she's promoting a healthy lifestyle -- she works with a trainer 4 times a week. That's four times more than I work with a trainer.

    Then there's that picture of her eating a corn dog. IIFYM!
  • Aviva92
    Aviva92 Posts: 2,333 Member
    edited January 2015
    I think she's promoting a healthy lifestyle -- she works with a trainer 4 times a week. That's four times more than I work with a trainer.

    Then there's that picture of her eating a corn dog. IIFYM!

    her body tells me otherwise. she can claim whatever she wants. i'm gonna claim that i'm the queen of england.
This discussion has been closed.