So can we put this topic to bed now?
Replies
-
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
But honey is a safe product? Even though it is made of one molecule of fructose and one molecule of glucose? The same as sucrose (table sugar)?0 -
A: Sugar would fail FDA tests.
B: What tests?
A: ALL TEH TESTZ!!1!eleven!!10 -
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded0 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
But honey is a safe product? Even though it is made of one molecule of fructose and one molecule of glucose? The same as sucrose (table sugar)?
Your science has no place in this debate.
NO PLACE!0 -
Rinse, lather, repeat.0
-
Please see the meme I posted earlier in this thread ref. the term "FDA approvals." It applies even more here than where I posted it.Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.0 -
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?0 -
I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.0 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
That doesn't answer my question at all. I'm asking what specifically is the danger that would cause it to fail the approval process. You must have one or more specific risks you've assessed to make this judgement.
What about new sugar products that come out and pass FDA approval? Agave nectar is relatively new. It goes through a chemical process very similar to the one used to make HFCS from corn. It's not JUST refined sugar, it's SUPER refined sugar, converted to about 90% fructose (whereas the HFCS in food products is only 55% fructose, table sugar is 50/50 glucose/fructose). How did that pass?0 -
I don't live in the States but I found this. It's not from sugar though.
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=134970 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
That doesn't answer my question at all. I'm asking what specifically is the danger that would cause it to fail the approval process. You must have one or more specific risks you've assessed to make this judgement.
What about new sugar products that come out and pass FDA approval? Agave nectar is relatively new. It goes through a chemical process very similar to the one used to make HFCS from corn. It's not JUST refined sugar, it's SUPER refined sugar, converted to about 90% fructose (whereas the HFCS in food products is only 55% fructose, table sugar is 50/50 glucose/fructose). How did that pass?
Foods don't have to pass FDA approval. Only drugs.0 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
:indifferent:0 -
I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
That must be what gives it its magical 'safe' properties.0 -
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
No, Jof. We are the only country that eats refined sugar. The rest of the world switched to sucrose about 15 years ago.0 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
So...
...how long ago did you personally cut out all sugar?0 -
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
No, Jof. We are the only country that eats refined sugar. The rest of the world switched to sucrose about 15 years ago.
But...
I mean...
But that's...
...uh...
Um...
(Man, I need to get out of the country more often...)0 -
In.0
-
It's like the dihydrogen monoxide thing all over again.My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. He teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
...
I can't even start with this
Because.....? If sugar was just found today and had to go through all the FDA approvals, it would fail. It is very bad for all of us.
What specific FDA approvals would it fail?
What ever tests a product has to go through to be approved for human consumption. Not a safe product.
Are you aware of the fact that the body has an entire organ that deals with balancing blood sugar levels, and carries around symbiotes inside each of your trillions of cells whose function is to oxidize sugar to provide energy?0 -
lol........I found this, it has a little more detail.
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
No, Jof. We are the only country that eats refined sugar. The rest of the world switched to sucrose about 15 years ago.
But...
I mean...
But that's...
...uh...
Um...
(Man, I need to get out of the country more often...)
http://www.annualreviews.org/eprint/iESYF775U2MwVfrxfAR2/full/10.1146/annurev-publhealth-031811-1246490 -
HONEY IS FOR BABY BEES!!!I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.0 -
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
That must be what gives it its magical 'safe' properties.
This exactly. Which is what has enabled penguins to flourish in Antarctica: regurgitating food for the chicks. This is why we humans fail.0 -
My daughter did not even taste sugar until she started kindergarten. The teacher called me one day and said, I think you better lighten up on the sugar scare. One of my daughter's classmates had a birthday and brought in cupcakes. I had told my daughter that sugar would rot your teeth. Well, it will. My daughter wouldn't eat the cupcakes. To this day, she is a size 2 and never a weight problem. :-)
How old is your perfect size two daughter?0 -
Oh look. There are crazy people on the Internet.0
-
HONEY IS FOR BABY BEES!!!I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
Well don't scream at me! I never touch the stuff!! Because...bee spit!!0 -
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
That must be what gives it its magical 'safe' properties.
This exactly. Which is what has enabled penguins to flourish in Antarctica: regurgitating food for the chicks. This is why we humans fail.
I choose failure.0 -
But there's like a thousand humans for every penguin. And we have pizza. If anyone's failing it's the penguins.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
That must be what gives it its magical 'safe' properties.
This exactly. Which is what has enabled penguins to flourish in Antarctica: regurgitating food for the chicks. This is why we humans fail.0 -
HONEY IS FOR BABY BEES!!!I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
*looks down at tea*
Buzz Buzz0 -
Well I hear so much of that regarding cows. But who's going to white knight for the bee?
HONEY IS FOR BABY BEES!!!I home cooked using honey. It's much better for you than white sugar or even brown sugar. But I also cut the sugar in 1/2 of what the recipe called for. Didn't use it very often either. Only on special occasions. Never missed it either.
Honey - honey is made of sugar. Didn't the bees tell you?
Regurgitated sugar at that.
Well don't scream at me! I never touch the stuff!! Because...bee spit!!0 -
lol........I found this, it has a little more detail.
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
No, Jof. We are the only country that eats refined sugar. The rest of the world switched to sucrose about 15 years ago.
But...
I mean...
But that's...
...uh...
Um...
(Man, I need to get out of the country more often...)
http://www.annualreviews.org/eprint/iESYF775U2MwVfrxfAR2/full/10.1146/annurev-publhealth-031811-124649
Interesting hypotheses of causality. Sounds almost political even.
ETA: Above thought based on a remarkably quick skim of the link.0 -
Yeah, that must be it.
lol........I found this, it has a little more detail.
All Countries life expectancy went up just not the US.........lately though the US's world ranking has dropped from if I remember correctly, 11th place not too many years ago to 42 or around there.......basically not good comparatively speaking.This is EXACTLY why our life expectancy dropped when we discovered how to refine sugar.
When did that happen?
See. All the info proving the point I was trying to make. None of the work.
Though I'm pretty sure we were refining sugar before the US was founded
Any chance this is caused by obesity from excess consumption > activity?
No, Jof. We are the only country that eats refined sugar. The rest of the world switched to sucrose about 15 years ago.
But...
I mean...
But that's...
...uh...
Um...
(Man, I need to get out of the country more often...)
http://www.annualreviews.org/eprint/iESYF775U2MwVfrxfAR2/full/10.1146/annurev-publhealth-031811-124649
Interesting hypotheses of causality. Sounds almost political even.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions