Nagging about saving money for IVF

11314161819

Replies

  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...

    Too many people living outside their means these days. :(

    Yes, yes they are... but that is a separate subject

    It is, and it isn't, all at once.... OP is trying to gather money she doesn't have for this IVF procedure; and it's been suggested they take out loans, put it on credit.... Awful idea
  • melinda200208
    melinda200208 Posts: 525 Member
    Why aren't you considering adoption? Why force your body to do something it's not naturally inclined to do in your case?
    Plus, IVF isn't guaranteed. You could end up with 5 babies, or worse, have to "selectively abort" some until you have the choice amount. I all smacks of a puppy mill to me, to be honest.
    There are children already existing out there that need you, don't understand why people have to force their hands with this, taking drugs and going into a lab for impregnation (shudder). And before you say "I want my OWN child", I have a little girl that I adopted when she was 8 months old that couldn't be more MINE if I had carried her myself. We have the closest, best bond and I couldn't love her an iota more than I already do.

    In my previous posts, i mentioned adoption is my second option if IVF doesn't work. My body IS naturally inclined to have a baby. My husband is having issues with his semen. NO, I WONT end up with 5 babies. They select how many eggs they want to give me. One or two is usually the option. Which in my case, I would opt for 2. They WOULD NOT put 5 eggs back in me. That would just be silly and dangerous for me and the children. Yes, I am willing to go through all the drugs, injections, ect. to try to carry my OWN child. We want our OWN child. If it doesn't happen with IVF (we have 3 tries and get our money back if it doesn't work) then we will look into adoption. Yes, if I adopted a child, that child would be my OWN child regardless of weather I carried him/her or not. Just because we are having trouble getting pregnant doesn't mean we dont have the right to use the medical field to assist us.
  • laynerich15
    laynerich15 Posts: 1,918 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...

    Too many people living outside their means these days. :(

    Yes, yes they are... but that is a separate subject

    It is, and it isn't, all at once.... OP is trying to gather money she doesn't have for this IVF procedure; and it's been suggested they take out loans, put it on credit.... Awful idea

    Agreed, sorry missed the point it the first post.

    Its been a long day
  • DSTMT
    DSTMT Posts: 417 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member

    I also went through adoption training classes in MN through Children's Home Society. Each class I got more and more scared. A panel of parents who had already adopted through the program came to talk. Afterwards, about half the class was even more excited to adopt and half wanted to run away screaming. Some were dealing with multiple 3 letter diagnoses that were not disclosed until after adoption - ADD, ODD, RAD - you name it. You fill out a questionnaire describing what behaviors you could deal with and what you couldn't. Would it be ok if they had a history of fire-setting? Abuse of animals? Food hoarding?

    The best part was that you can look through websites of waiting children, go through all the training and a homestudy, and not until nearly the very end of the process are you allowed to see their files or hear anything about their past. I went in with the best of intentions and abandoned ship near the end of the process. I cannot emphasize enough how much I respect those parents who were able to provide a home to a child, but anyone who thinks adoption would be "less stress" than IVF is sorely misinformed.

    wow I didn't know you could figure out if you're precious kidlet could be ADD pre-birth!!!! That's awesome!!! Good to know.
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.
    wow I didn't even know that could be done- but I'm totally right there with you.
    The lengths people go through to have children is so weird to me... it just proves how selfish people are honestly.
    There isn't a logical reason to have children- much less multiple children at this point- so the only real reason is it's because it's something YOU want to do. Which is fine- but let's not get crazy with expenses and irrational justifications for having kids, it's a self serving choice and that's it.
  • PurringMyrrh
    PurringMyrrh Posts: 5,276 Member
    Why aren't you considering adoption? Why force your body to do something it's not naturally inclined to do in your case?
    Plus, IVF isn't guaranteed. You could end up with 5 babies, or worse, have to "selectively abort" some until you have the choice amount. I all smacks of a puppy mill to me, to be honest.
    There are children already existing out there that need you, don't understand why people have to force their hands with this, taking drugs and going into a lab for impregnation (shudder). And before you say "I want my OWN child", I have a little girl that I adopted when she was 8 months old that couldn't be more MINE if I had carried her myself. We have the closest, best bond and I couldn't love her an iota more than I already do.

    In my previous posts, i mentioned adoption is my second option if IVF doesn't work. My body IS naturally inclined to have a baby. My husband is having issues with his semen. NO, I WONT end up with 5 babies. They select how many eggs they want to give me. One or two is usually the option. Which in my case, I would opt for 2. They WOULD NOT put 5 eggs back in me. That would just be silly and dangerous for me and the children. Yes, I am willing to go through all the drugs, injections, ect. to try to carry my OWN child. We want our OWN child. If it doesn't happen with IVF (we have 3 tries and get our money back if it doesn't work) then we will look into adoption. Yes, if I adopted a child, that child would be my OWN child regardless of weather I carried him/her or not. Just because we are having trouble getting pregnant doesn't mean we dont have the right to use the medical field to assist us.
    So you want to have your OWN child, yet would also consider an adopted child your OWN? Why not just take the step now and save a life?
  • melinda200208
    melinda200208 Posts: 525 Member
    not judging, just throwing this out there based my personal experience....

    Infertility is a bi#ch and IVF is physically and emotionally draining. The financial drain with potentially no child at the end is a bitter pill to swallow too. I was deeply entrenched in infertility hell when a friend said this to me:

    So do you want to be pregnant, or do you want to be a mother?

    I am mom to two daughters adopted internationally, and I have never looked back.
    Bravo.
    I want to be Pregnant AND be a MOTHER.! Is that selfish of me? I dont think so at all!
  • BusyRaeNOTBusty
    BusyRaeNOTBusty Posts: 7,166 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...

    Too many people living outside their means these days. :(

    Yes, yes they are... but that is a separate subject

    It is, and it isn't, all at once.... OP is trying to gather money she doesn't have for this IVF procedure; and it's been suggested they take out loans, put it on credit.... Awful idea

    And you've never bought a car with a loan? Having a loan with a small manageable payment is not that bad of an idea.
  • laynerich15
    laynerich15 Posts: 1,918 Member
    How about taking that 21k and putting it into shares or real-estate, you can bet that neither of those things will never throw up on you or tell you how much of a S***ty parent you have been.
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    over spending money and having problems with his semen?

    Are you SUuuuuuuureeeeeee you both want kids?
  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.

    Not true at all. I question anyone who has a child; fertile or through medical assistance.... I also question who anyone would support and buy an animal like a dog or cat from a breeder. My thought is, if you want a child, or a pet... Don't have one created when there are so many out there already in need of a loving home. We need to stop bringing more unnecessary life into this world and take better care of the lives already existing.
  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...

    Too many people living outside their means these days. :(

    Yes, yes they are... but that is a separate subject

    It is, and it isn't, all at once.... OP is trying to gather money she doesn't have for this IVF procedure; and it's been suggested they take out loans, put it on credit.... Awful idea

    And you've never bought a car with a loan? Having a loan with a small manageable payment is not that bad of an idea.

    No, actually I haven't. I've saved and bought my cars outright, in cash.
  • bugaboo_sue
    bugaboo_sue Posts: 552 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...

    Too many people living outside their means these days. :(

    Yes, yes they are... but that is a separate subject

    It is, and it isn't, all at once.... OP is trying to gather money she doesn't have for this IVF procedure; and it's been suggested they take out loans, put it on credit.... Awful idea

    And you've never bought a car with a loan? Having a loan with a small manageable payment is not that bad of an idea.

    How can she afford a "small manageable payment" when her husband doesn't want to save money for the IVF in the first place? Couple that with the expenses of having a child and that just equals disaster.

    ETA: Not everyone takes loans out to buy a car. Every car I have owned I paid cash for.
  • Laurenloveswaffles
    Laurenloveswaffles Posts: 535 Member
    How about taking that 21k and putting it into shares or real-estate, you can bet that neither of those things will never throw up on you or tell you how much of a S***ty parent you have been.

    How about leaving this thread now? You have done nothing but give sh*tty responses the entire thread.
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    not judging, just throwing this out there based my personal experience....

    Infertility is a bi#ch and IVF is physically and emotionally draining. The financial drain with potentially no child at the end is a bitter pill to swallow too. I was deeply entrenched in infertility hell when a friend said this to me:

    So do you want to be pregnant, or do you want to be a mother?

    I am mom to two daughters adopted internationally, and I have never looked back.
    Bravo.
    I want to be Pregnant AND be a MOTHER.! Is that selfish of me? I dont think so at all!

    it is.

    and you have to be okay with that.

    I'm selfish- I don't want kids. But I know I'm selfishly choosing ME over a child. Sometimes it's okay to be selfish- you just have to be okay with knowing that's exactly what you want.
  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    not judging, just throwing this out there based my personal experience....

    Infertility is a bi#ch and IVF is physically and emotionally draining. The financial drain with potentially no child at the end is a bitter pill to swallow too. I was deeply entrenched in infertility hell when a friend said this to me:

    So do you want to be pregnant, or do you want to be a mother?

    I am mom to two daughters adopted internationally, and I have never looked back.
    Bravo.
    I want to be Pregnant AND be a MOTHER.! Is that selfish of me? I dont think so at all!

    So, adopt a child to call your own, and offer to be a surrogate mother for someone else? You get to have the pregnancy experience, a child of your own, and you don't have to spend 21k to do it
  • likitisplit
    likitisplit Posts: 9,420 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    What do you mean by "allow"?
  • laynerich15
    laynerich15 Posts: 1,918 Member
    How about taking that 21k and putting it into shares or real-estate, you can bet that neither of those things will never throw up on you or tell you how much of a S***ty parent you have been.

    How about leaving this thread now? You have done nothing but give sh*tty responses the entire thread.

    How is that a ****ty response?

    Welcome to the world of the internet
  • melinda200208
    melinda200208 Posts: 525 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...
    LOL! Exactly. I can't be in debt to have a baby!? But people can for cars, toys, t.v., fancy phones?! Pretty sure 95% of everyone in the world is in debt. Unless you own every single thing you have, more power to ya then!
  • VeryKatie
    VeryKatie Posts: 5,961 Member
    Have you considered trying to earn extra money as opposed to just saving the money you currently earn? There are a lot of little ways you can earn extra money. It might sound juvenile, but babysitting/nanny-ing in your spare time could be an option. Maybe dog sitting/walking? Plus, keeping busy might help keep you from obsessing about the issue of fertility.

    Have you checked into HSA's (health savings accounts)? From what I understand, if you use the money for approved procedures it's not taxed.

    There is some help here! Another option might be to "rent" out your basement or a room to a college student for the 8 months? It's coming up on that time.
  • PurringMyrrh
    PurringMyrrh Posts: 5,276 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.
    So adopting a child isn't rescuing them from the burdens and heartache of a parentless and loveless life? Saving them from foster care, the streets, and helping to instill family values and bonding?

    How motherly of you to pass on all the lemons because you want a "regular" life.
  • TAsunder
    TAsunder Posts: 423 Member
    Unbelievably, the trolling has grown even stronger in this thread since I last read it.
  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    Have you considered trying to earn extra money as opposed to just saving the money you currently earn? There are a lot of little ways you can earn extra money. It might sound juvenile, but babysitting/nanny-ing in your spare time could be an option. Maybe dog sitting/walking? Plus, keeping busy might help keep you from obsessing about the issue of fertility.

    Have you checked into HSA's (health savings accounts)? From what I understand, if you use the money for approved procedures it's not taxed.

    There is some help here! Another option might be to "rent" out your basement or a room to a college student for the 8 months? It's coming up on that time.

    SOLID IDEA!
  • UsedToBeHusky
    UsedToBeHusky Posts: 15,228 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.

    Not true at all. I question anyone who has a child; fertile or through medical assistance.... I also question who anyone would support and buy an animal like a dog or cat from a breeder. My thought is, if you want a child, or a pet... Don't have one created when there are so many out there already in need of a loving home. We need to stop bringing more unnecessary life into this world and take better care of the lives already existing.

    Generally, it's human instinct to want to procreate. Just because you had some ****ed up childhood where you were an unwanted child in an unloving home and has caused you to have some pessimistic, narrow-minded view of the world doesn't mean that is true of everyone. You have established that you think OP should adopt. You can move on now.
  • laynerich15
    laynerich15 Posts: 1,918 Member
    Unbelievably, the trolling has grown even stronger in this thread since I last read it.

    What are you talking about?

    There is nothing but genuine conversations happening in here
  • bugaboo_sue
    bugaboo_sue Posts: 552 Member
    I had IVF so let me put in my two cents. Don't stress, it's not gonna help. Put it on a credit card, once you give birth, you can claim your child tax credit then pay off your CC. That's what we did. My son is almost 2 and he's paid off Yaay! :drinker:

    Oh and my husband only gets $20/week and no gas money :glasses:
    A child tax credit is to invest in your kid's future, not pay off his creation. It is absolutely despicable that people are allowed to go into debt to procreate.

    Right. People should only go into debt for new cars and clothes and T.V.s...
    LOL! Exactly. I can't be in debt to have a baby!? But people can for cars, toys, t.v., fancy phones?! Pretty sure 95% of everyone in the world is in debt. Unless you own every single thing you have, more power to ya then!

    So then just put on your credit card and pay it off.
  • PurringMyrrh
    PurringMyrrh Posts: 5,276 Member
    not judging, just throwing this out there based my personal experience....

    Infertility is a bi#ch and IVF is physically and emotionally draining. The financial drain with potentially no child at the end is a bitter pill to swallow too. I was deeply entrenched in infertility hell when a friend said this to me:

    So do you want to be pregnant, or do you want to be a mother?

    I am mom to two daughters adopted internationally, and I have never looked back.
    Bravo.
    I want to be Pregnant AND be a MOTHER.! Is that selfish of me? I dont think so at all!

    So, adopt a child to call your own, and offer to be a surrogate mother for someone else? You get to have the pregnancy experience, a child of your own, and you don't have to spend 21k to do it
    Hey now, not a shabby idea. Save a life, and help someone else in the process.
  • AtmaKing
    AtmaKing Posts: 145 Member
    There could be any number of reasons that he is spending money that have absolutely nothing to do with his desire to have the IVF procedure. Your answer actually ISN'T the only right answer. And I don't see at all where the OP has stated that she plans to ignore the advice to talk to her husband. Not once anywhere has she stated that she doesn't want to have a discussion with him about it. Not once did she say that all she wanted was a way to manipulate her husband in wanting what she wants.

    She actually agreed to talk to her husband and others went on to give her suggestions on how to save money and/or other alternatives to IVF. I'm not sure how any of that would give you the impression that she only cares about what she wants. But if you honestly think after 15 pages (or wherever it was that you eventually showed up in this thread) that the OP somehow missed that communicating with her husband was the FIRST step to solving the problem, well then you are either ignorant or you just came in here to pick a fight.

    So which is it? Ignorant or bitter?

    She doesn’t have to state it. Although I'm pretty sure she finally understands now what I was trying to get her to see. But the first 14 pages where the advice was given to "speak to your husband" was truly the only advice that was given that needed to be taken. I didn't even come up with it first. I like on many threads, read it saw she got the answer that I would have given and moved on. However when the thread is going to roll and has been going on for 14 pages after the answer to her question was given on page 1, I had to say something in a manner that may have be “extreme” to some because there are people who can’t see things any other way. So to answer your question, yes I came to pick a fight, because sometimes picking a fight with someone is the only way they know how to actually see advice.

    The suggestions on how to save money start by sticking to a budget established between her and her husband. That starts with a conversation with her husband. The fact she continued to show up and ask, then defend him (which is good, she is a good woman) means she missed the fact she should talk with him. The issue isn’t money coming in it’s the money going out. They presented each other with a plan and agreed upon it. The issue isn’t the money or the flying over seas or IVF at all, the issue is her husband is currently not respecting her by his actions. Until she can see that and until she can get with him and help him fix that. No advice outside of “speak with your husband” applies anymore. If he needs help with his spending because he lacks self control that is on him, she can help him get that help but its ultimately on him.

    Ignorant? Nope. Bitter? Not at all. Trying to help someone see the problem at its core? Sure. Taking unorthodox outside the box approaches to it? Sure. Bitter and ignorant? Not in the least.

    Okay... so let's just say she had the CORE solution to her problem back on page 2. Once he answers that basic question about whether or not he really wants to do the IVF, she would have to know where she wants to take the conversation from there, hence the suggestions about saving money and alternatives to the IVF.

    Furthermore, once she started this thread, she had no control over what people do with it. Sure, she came back and responded here and there, but only to the suggestions that others had posted.

    I'm still really baffled why you needed to take an EXTREME approach to tell her what she already knows must happen. I mean, she can't stop the thread from rolling. She can't stop people from posting. And she has learned some things that will help her in the future, no matter what her and her husband decide.

    Why do you need to expend the energy? What cause are you fighting for?

    It’s the actions of the situation. Not once has she responded with “I talked to him, This is what he said”. There is no action from him in saving for the IVF, and there is no action from her in actually talking to him about the saving. The "extreme" approach was to try and get her to do something she already knows. Get her to take action. Kind of like someone going to the Dr. and the Dr. going well you're going to have to take these meds now. Those people some of them not all tend to take some action because they don’t want to be on meds. Sometimes the approach nobody wants is the approach some people need.

    I'm not fighting anymore, again like I said I think she understands now and I have a feeling she may actually do something now. Only time will tell.

    I wish her luck, I think overall she is a good woman. Especially since she is here trying to get the answer to the real question of “How can I make my Husband stand up and be a Man?”
  • melinda200208
    melinda200208 Posts: 525 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.
    Well said !! THank You!
  • warriorprincessdi
    warriorprincessdi Posts: 617 Member
    To all those that have adopted: Thank you for taking an emotional and financial risk to rescue a pre-existing child that desperately needed a loving home. You saved and enriched a life and had yours enriched in the process.

    This sort of mentality really bugs me too, adoption isn't "rescuing" a kid like they're a stray dog. I wanted to adopt because we wanted a child, I wasn't doing it to be heroic, but there were a million roadblocks and it's not as black and white as everyone seems to think.

    Yes it's true there are no guarantees either way, but at least if a person is able to conceive and carry a child they can do their best to take care of themselves before the baby is born, and then to raise them well. There's always a chance of health problems, but what I'm saying is when I went to adopt through CAS they said we were literally almost 100% sure to get a child with not one but several serious problems. We just wanted to have a regular family like other people have, like all our friends were starting to have, we weren't ready to take that on.

    The thing that I find very frustrating is people seem to think that infertile people have to bear the burden of society's unwanted children, and to do anything other than that is somehow selfish or greedy or whatever. If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first.

    Not true at all. I question anyone who has a child; fertile or through medical assistance.... I also question who anyone would support and buy an animal like a dog or cat from a breeder. My thought is, if you want a child, or a pet... Don't have one created when there are so many out there already in need of a loving home. We need to stop bringing more unnecessary life into this world and take better care of the lives already existing.

    Generally, it's human instinct to want to procreate. Just because you had some ****ed up childhood where you were an unwanted child in an unloving home and has caused you to have some pessimistic, narrow-minded view of the world doesn't mean that is true of everyone. You have established that you think OP should adopt. You can move on now.


    Actually that was in response the this comment : "If fertile people want kids, they have a kid and don't think twice about it, no one is looking at them going "well why didn't you adopt instead of trying at all?" It would never even be a question, but the second someone has trouble conceiving and has to seek medical help, suddenly they're terrible people if they don't want to adopt before trying anything else first."

    I'm just saying, I don't judge infertile people for choosing to go the medical route and ignore those that conceive naturally. I was saying I feel the same regardless of the situation that brought that child into someone's life. Why bring more life into a crowded world when so many already exist needing care?