Carbs are making you fat
Replies
-
(PS. No it doesn't.)0 -
Sadly, I dont think the truth will ever be allowed out. Too many big industries (i.e. flour, sugar, pharmaceutical, supermarkets) are making too much money from the present "so called" healthy eating regime. No one can touch it. Whatever you believe, you should ask the question, why is obesity, heart disease and diabetes on the increase in such a huge scale?
Tell me in your own words how carbs make you fat?
No offense man, but I am not here to play gotcha game. I could throw this right back in your court and say tell me in your own words how fat makes you fat.
I am just posting a news report that I happen to agree with. Not you, but it seems many people get their panties all in a bunch if someone comes out against the typical standard nutritional diet. There is science to back up both theories. Are we that closed minded to fully shut out the whole low carb thing?
So in other words you have no idea how carbs supposedly make you fat, you're just jumping on the latest fear mongering bandwagon
Don't be too harsh on him as he obviously sounds like a low carb newbie. Once you get hooked believing the low carb spiel its hard to shake it and think objectively.
It was a simple question I posed to him, no reason to dodge it0 -
So all these carbs are making me gain weight?????? They are preventing me from losing the 80 pounds i lost while eating carbs? They prevented me from dropping my body fat% by 12%? are you sure?0
-
I've lost 40 pounds in 11 weeks following a basic low carb, high protein diet of 1200-ish calories a day and 5-6 days of exercise a week. Something is working. I think there is a lot of truth in the concept that processed carbs contribute to weight gain...and that all calories are not created equal. I guess as long as you do SOMETHING,rather than nothing, you can lose weight. This just happens to be working well for me.
A lot of people feel less hungry on low carb so you don't over-eat, create a caloric deficit and lose weight. Processed carbs may contribute to weight gain because for some they make you hungry, you over-eat, don't create a caloric deficit and gain weight.
I've seen a lot of low carbers, particularly those that are very over-weight lose weight initially but never get to goal.0 -
I've lost 40 pounds in 11 weeks following a basic low carb, high protein diet of 1200-ish calories a day and 5-6 days of exercise a week. Something is working. I think there is a lot of truth in the concept that processed carbs contribute to weight gain...and that all calories are not created equal. I guess as long as you do SOMETHING,rather than nothing, you can lose weight. This just happens to be working well for me.
Twinkie diet : http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html
Your caloric deficit makes you lose weight, and very well
Keep it up, but there is no magic, no banned food, and probably no "evil calorie vs good calorie", just a moderate, healthy caloric deficit 0 -
Carbs do not make you fat. Carbs may give you water retention, but like many things...it passes.
What makes you fat is eating a calorie surplus and sitting on the couch all day.0 -
Too many calories are making you fat.0
-
Marilyn Monroe credits her beautiful figure to pasta (AKA, carbs)
She so fat...
Umm, I don't know if you picked the best possible picture to illustrate your point...
Thought about it but couldnt be bothered with finding a photoshopped pic of her. She still looks drop dead gorgeous and very fit0 -
Oh my god! All this time carbs have been making me fat! I didn't even notice!
For the extremely dense: caloric surplus makes you fat. Carbs+suplus makes you fat faster.
You'll notice literally every one of the bodybuilder physique folks on here eats 300-400g carbs on a regular basis... hard to recover from serious weight training otherwise.
You'll also notice you don't see low-carbers who look like bodybuilders.
But I'm sure that's all just coincidence. Carry on!0 -
Sugar makes you fat, not carbs.0
-
its old news. Taubes has a new book out. I have Good Calories, Bad Calories it was okay for its time. A lot of low carbers have moved on since that.
Not arguing at all here -- what do you mean by "moved on?" Do you mean that they've gone on to other approaches completely (back to "high" carbs by a LC standard) or on to Paleo or something?
Also, what the hell happened to Jimmy Moore?!??! I clearly have not kept up with the old-school LC blogosphere.0 -
Carbs do not make you fat. Carbs may give you water retention, but like many things...it passes.
What makes you fat is eating a calorie surplus and sitting on the couch all day.
What if I skip the couch and just lay in bed all day? I won't get fat right?0 -
Sugar makes you fat, not carbs.
Not sure if srs0 -
Who you callin' fat?
I don't think so, sweetie-pie.0 -
Sadly, I dont think the truth will ever be allowed out. Too many big industries (i.e. flour, sugar, pharmaceutical, supermarkets) are making too much money from the present "so called" healthy eating regime. No one can touch it. Whatever you believe, you should ask the question, why is obesity, heart disease and diabetes on the increase in such a huge scale?
Tell me in your own words how carbs make you fat?
No offense man, but I am not here to play gotcha game. I could throw this right back in your court and say tell me in your own words how fat makes you fat.
I am just posting a news report that I happen to agree with. Not you, but it seems many people get their panties all in a bunch if someone comes out against the typical standard nutritional diet. There is science to back up both theories. Are we that closed minded to fully shut out the whole low carb thing?
So in other words you have no idea how carbs supposedly make you fat, you're just jumping on the latest fear mongering bandwagon
Don't be too harsh on him as he obviously sounds like a low carb newbie. Once you get hooked believing the low carb spiel its hard to shake it and think objectively.
It was a simple question I posed to him, no reason to dodge it
Also note, acg67 never said anything about fat making you fat. No one has.
So the OP should probably try a different tactic.0 -
You'll also notice you don't see low-carbers who look like bodybuilders.
Unless it's a night or two before a contest.
0 -
I've lost 40 pounds in 11 weeks following a basic low carb, high protein diet of 1200-ish calories a day and 5-6 days of exercise a week. Something is working. I think there is a lot of truth in the concept that processed carbs contribute to weight gain...and that all calories are not created equal. I guess as long as you do SOMETHING,rather than nothing, you can lose weight. This just happens to be working well for me.
something = calorie deficit0 -
Sadly, I dont think the truth will ever be allowed out. Too many big industries (i.e. flour, sugar, pharmaceutical, supermarkets) are making too much money from the present "so called" healthy eating regime. No one can touch it. Whatever you believe, you should ask the question, why is obesity, heart disease and diabetes on the increase in such a huge scale?
Tell me in your own words how carbs make you fat?
No offense man, but I am not here to play gotcha game. I could throw this right back in your court and say tell me in your own words how fat makes you fat.
I am just posting a news report that I happen to agree with. Not you, but it seems many people get their panties all in a bunch if someone comes out against the typical standard nutritional diet. There is science to back up both theories. Are we that closed minded to fully shut out the whole low carb thing?
So in other words you have no idea how carbs supposedly make you fat, you're just jumping on the latest fear mongering bandwagon
Don't be too harsh on him as he obviously sounds like a low carb newbie. Once you get hooked believing the low carb spiel its hard to shake it and think objectively.
It was a simple question I posed to him, no reason to dodge it
He probably doesn't know exactly!!! Has it something to do with insulin???0 -
I lost 83lb's on a very high carb diet to under 10 % BF. On the advice of some Paleo Wacko's at the gym I did try a low carb diet for a couple weeks and I felt like crap and weak and my workout's suffered. Never again, After all why sacrifice carbs when there is no need to do so.0
-
Sugar makes you fat, not carbs.
Have 80-100g of that most days too. Mmmm0 -
Sadly, I dont think the truth will ever be allowed out. Too many big industries (i.e. flour, sugar, pharmaceutical, supermarkets) are making too much money from the present "so called" healthy eating regime. No one can touch it. Whatever you believe, you should ask the question, why is obesity, heart disease and diabetes on the increase in such a huge scale?
Tell me in your own words how carbs make you fat?
No offense man, but I am not here to play gotcha game. I could throw this right back in your court and say tell me in your own words how fat makes you fat.
I am just posting a news report that I happen to agree with. Not you, but it seems many people get their panties all in a bunch if someone comes out against the typical standard nutritional diet. There is science to back up both theories. Are we that closed minded to fully shut out the whole low carb thing?
So in other words you have no idea how carbs supposedly make you fat, you're just jumping on the latest fear mongering bandwagon
Don't be too harsh on him as he obviously sounds like a low carb newbie. Once you get hooked believing the low carb spiel its hard to shake it and think objectively.
It was a simple question I posed to him, no reason to dodge it
He probably doesn't know exactly!!! Has it something to do with insulin???
That's right I forgot, eat carbs -> insulin spike -> get fat, duh0 -
Sugar makes you fat, not carbs.
0 -
0 -
I would like to hear OP answer the question also.It was a simple question I posed to him, no reason to dodge it0 -
SO WHAT! You aint GOD, nor are these "Gurus" who write this junk. If these people knew how to get us ALL Physically Healthy, they would come together and "tell us" and we would be a Country of Healthy people! I've read at least 50 Books on Wt.Loss, even more on Nutrition, tried at least 25 different "diets" AND NOTHING THEY recommended worked. But I've NOW lost over 100 lbs in 2 years...HOW, by reducing calories and eating well, moderate exercise, and MOST Importantly being CONSTANT (Sticking with MY PLAN, what works for Me!) AND you better understand also that Nothing stays the same over time, as you age adjustments must be made in nutrition and exercise. Everybody is looking for a quick fix or simple answer...There is NONE, ONE size does NOT fit all. Neither does blanket statements.0 -
Wow! Nice discussing things with you all. Take care.0
-
Calories in, calories out. That is all.0
-
I eat like 400 carbs a day... Do I look fat to you?0
-
Oh my god! All this time carbs have been making me fat! I didn't even notice!
For the extremely dense: caloric surplus makes you fat. Carbs+suplus makes you fat faster.
You'll notice literally every one of the bodybuilder physique folks on here eats 300-400g carbs on a regular basis... hard to recover from serious weight training otherwise.
You'll also notice you don't see low-carbers who look like bodybuilders.
But I'm sure that's all just coincidence. Carry on!
But Taubes is SO ripped!! Such a damn stud ;D
0 -
Wow! Nice discussing things with you all. Take care.
Have a nice day.
Oh and welcome to the forums.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions