Polygamy, Your thoughts.
Replies
-
There are thousands of known polygamists in the state of Utah. Overwhelmingly Mormon/FLDS. Listen to some of the stories of kids (usually teenagers/young adults) trying to escape this lifestyle (which is made very, very difficult) and then think about it again. 90% of these people have been physically or sexually abused. Education is actively discouraged in these communities. Thousands and thousands of people in Utah alone. It isn't a few crazies living in a tent village in the desert.
It's about far more than 'what people do behind closed doors'.
This is why I can say I don't care about the *idea* of polygamy on paper and still also kind of not be comfortable with it in the real world.
On paper, if people are of age and want to do it, fine. But the reality is that there is a whole host of ethical issues associated with the practice in real life, just like you say.0 -
what is cracking me up here is everyone assuming the relationship would be one man with multiple wives. I have friends in my life where it is one woman and two men. It's not about the men sharing the woman. They all love (and enjoy) each other equally.
Took the words out of my mouth. I don't know anyone personally, but I think it's fuuny that we have the image of polygamy, as one man and many wives. This is how it usually is, but it's not the only way. I also wonder if any of the wives ever "hook" up, or fall in love.0 -
although personally, one significant other in my life is more than enough for me0
-
There are thousands of known polygamists in the state of Utah. Overwhelmingly Mormon/FLDS. Listen to some of the stories of kids (usually teenagers/young adults) trying to escape this lifestyle (which is made very, very difficult) and then think about it again. 90% of these people have been physically or sexually abused. Education is actively discouraged in these communities. Thousands and thousands of people in Utah alone. It isn't a few crazies living in a tent village in the desert.
It's about far more than 'what people do behind closed doors'.
Hmmm. I think you are connecting two things that don't neccessarily need to be connected. Polygamy can exist outside a cult setting in which child abuse happens.
Just like prostitution can exist outside of child prostitution. Prostitution is legal in one county in Nevada and brothels are up and running. Its definitely not the same as sex trafficking or child prostitution that is forced upon people against their will.
I think in both cases, the difference is one scenario is consenting adults (adult prostitution, adult polygamy) and the other is a situation of abuse/coercion/lack of consent. I agree with you that children should not be treated as you describe. But I don't think that really has anything to do with polygamy, per se.
The frame of reference for much of this discussion has been "Sister Wives" ... which is about a Mormon polygamist family. I did specify in my post that this is what I was referring to.0 -
I would love to have multiple husbands. As far as getting help around the house, I could afford that with a few extra incomes, but really for me I don't need another woman in the house. If my husband wanted to bring in another man, I'd be open to the discussion.
I don't tend to take well with the "women's role" in the house.0 -
your minds are really screwed up:indifferent:0
-
The frame of reference for much of this discussion has been "Sister Wives" ... which is about a Mormon polygamist family. I did specify in my post that this is what I was referring to.
I'm sorry. I didn't catch that. I don't watch TV much (that's a tv show right?)....
In which case, I think i agree with you!0 -
I feel lucky I was born in america, I feel lucky I was raised Wiccan and not brainwashed by a Christian family - there's many who don't agree with that. Everyone will never agree on everything.
So you were brainwashed by a Wiccan family instead.
This is another one I agree with you on!
I was raised christian, and I wouldn't say I was brainwashed.0 -
How about the flip side to this ? What if we women could marry more them 1 man? I would be open to that . But why do people look at it as nasty . Whats good 4 the goose is good 4 the gander RIGHT!0
-
im against gay marriage and polygomy on moral grounds. From legal grounds I think they all should be able to engage in a legal arrangement, (i.e.) a Civil Union, but let's not call it marriage, because that isnt what marriage is.
You're right, marriage at its creation was an exchange of property, typically a daughter for land or money. Sometimes livestock. Those are the only the government should recognize in your opinion?0 -
I did try and persuade my hubby to get a new wife - one who enjoyed the housework but he was not up for the idea.
What an awesome thought! I will have to discuss this with him..........I bet he will say it's not in our budget.............
Seriously though, I do not have an issue between consenting adults doing what is fine for them, I do have concerns about the young girls and what this says to them. If they are nothing but brood mares.........yeah, kinda have an issue with it. If this is many hands make light work.........sure whatever. Not for me though.........0 -
So if Romney had more than one wife, should anyone care?0
-
I can hardly keep up with my wife and her GF...I don't need another.....0
-
I personally couldn't be just another wife. lol But I was watching the show Sister Wives on Sunday and they were trying to get 4 home loans. What got me thinking is this.....3 of the wives had to apply for a loan as a SINGLE mother. I wonder how they like being called SINGLE mothers when in their eyes and their religion they are married.
That is why the laws need to change......so that they can apply as a five person family.....0 -
Honestly, I would welcome the extra help around the house. But, I wouldn't want to share my husband, therefore not an option for me.
AGREED!!!!! Absolutely!!!!!!!!!!!!!!0 -
It's their life. I wouldn't want my husband to have another wife and I definitely wouldn't share him with anyone else.0
-
i'm cool with polyamory but polygamy is so one-sided.0
-
I thinks its really no one business but the people invloved in the relationship as long as everyone is of age and truly wants the life style then go for it. Im not into that life style but I wouldnt stop those who are. life is about happines people what ever makes you happy :happy:0
-
as long as we don't all have to sleep in the same bed! crowded0
-
I feel lucky I was born in america, I feel lucky I was raised Wiccan and not brainwashed by a Christian family - there's many who don't agree with that. Everyone will never agree on everything.
So you were brainwashed by a Wiccan family instead.
This is another one I agree with you on!
I was raised christian, and I wouldn't say I was brainwashed.
I wouldn't say I was either. My parents shared their religion with me but didn't force me to do it. I was allowed to choose whether I went to church. And I didn't go for a few years. My parents didn't burn me at the stake or throw holy water at me...shocking, I know.0 -
So if Romney had more than one wife, should anyone care?
Good point!0 -
There are thousands of known polygamists in the state of Utah. Overwhelmingly Mormon/FLDS. Listen to some of the stories of kids (usually teenagers/young adults) trying to escape this lifestyle (which is made very, very difficult) and then think about it again. 90% of these people have been physically or sexually abused. Education is actively discouraged in these communities. Thousands and thousands of people in Utah alone. It isn't a few crazies living in a tent village in the desert.
It's about far more than 'what people do behind closed doors'.
Umm first thousands might be stretching it.
Second no Mormons have more than one wife. Sects that broke away from them allow it still like the FLDS, but that's like saying Jews take communion.
Third the educational discouragement, the entrapment of those seeking to get out, and the forceful removal of the "extra" males, are more a religious things than due to the fact that they have multiple wives.
Oh and no I'm not Mormon. I just know hundreds of em.0 -
If someone has multiple wives and children; can the male (and wives) in the house hold take care of all of them.
Do they get social aid?
If they divorce will he be able to pay child support and provide health care for the wives and children.
Are all the wives of leagal ages?
Which of the wives gets his social security? and retirement funds.
Too many unanswered questions for me.
...here is your answer... In South Africa, our president is the laughing stock of the 'civilised' world...
http://www.businessday.co.za/articles/Content.aspx?id=103788
http://www.iol.co.za/blogs/john-scott-1.2499/which-of-zuma-s-wives-will-pop-out-of-which-tunnel-first-1.1279770
...and WE as citizens pay for it!!!! So polygamy does not wash very well with me either....0 -
I don't understand the entire dynamic of polygamy, I see it as one sided the men are getting all of the satisfaction and the women are still treated like property. Again that is based on my very limited knowledge and observation. I could be way off base. As long as they are happy and it works for them why not. What's wrong with being able to marry and/or be in a relationship(s) that make us happy? We are born the way were are and we believe what we believe. Right or wrong we should all be able to be with the person(s) that make us happy. I will follow all of this up by saying as along are you are not a burden to society there's no issue, if you are a burden that's an issue.0
-
I don't understand the entire dynamic of polygamy, I see it as one sided the men are getting all of the satisfaction and the women are still treated like property. Again that is based on my very limited knowledge and observation. I could be way off base. As long as they are happy and it works for them why not. What's wrong with being able to marry and/or be in a relationship(s) that make us happy? We are born the way were are and we believe what we believe. Right or wrong we should all be able to be with the person(s) that make us happy. I will follow all of this up by saying as along are you are not a burden to society there's no issue, if you are a burden that's an issue.
i hear this. it should work with any gender. 4 men and 2 wives.0 -
Imagine having six wives, how bad that would make you feel, and how small and worthless
" How can you all have a headache at the same time" lol0 -
LOL I can tell you've put some serious thought on this Road Dog.Just my luck that I would get 4 women to go along with this idea and then their TOM didn't synch up. Every week there would be one woman p*ssed off.
0 -
I cant afford ONE wife, how could I afford multiples. Hey, if nobody is being coerced, have at it.0
-
I've starting feeling like, as long as people are happy and aren't causing harm to others, let them live their damn lives. Regardless if they're gay, polygamists, Mormons, whatever. People should be allowed to be happy - no one should infringe on that (as long as there's no harm being caused.)
Amen!!!0 -
As long as their human rights are not jepordised then I don't see an issue with it. Its not for me though.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions