Lose weight or no wedding--- is this right?

From not knowing the OP and her situation personally, my answer would be that gut reaction of "NO, it's not right!"

I care more about losing weight for my wedding than my fiancé does and that's what a healthy relationship feels/seems like to me. I wanted the wedding to be this October and then pushed it to May next year because I'm really wanting to enter the marriage as a healthier, happier version of myself & my fiancé still thinks I should have the fall wedding I've always wanted because he doesn't care about my dress size. I'm about 209 pounds right now and want to be 125-130 for my wedding. This is purely about my own insecurities in my body--my fiancé would marry me today in the clothes I'm wearing.

This is someone I've been with for over two years & OP, you've been with yours for about three times as long. He has seen the best and worst of you. He knows your struggles, dreams, triumphs. And yet he is holding a marriage license over your head until you meet a standard he set for you, using your desires and struggles with weight loss against you. There is no room for manipulation in love. It would be one thing if he knew your goal weight and said "we can put off the wedding until you feel you've reached a comfortable weight for YOU, but I love you and I'd marry you as-is right now, so don't think you need to reach a certain number before we can set the date," but he did the exact opposite!

What will he do if you get pregnant? If you get old and sedentary and put some weight on? If you have an accident or need surgery and gain weight in recovery?

Whatever happened to in sickness and in health? Those aren't vows he seems to be willing to make. His vows would be more like "As long as you're always a healthy weight."

With the weight fluctuations during the course of the relationship, I wonder if he's remained completely faithful to you. I wouldn't trust someone so focused on my physical appearance to never stray when he decided I'd gotten "too fat" for him.

For me, this would be the end of the relationship.

Emotionally I'm shot, and the extra stress from my relationship is not helping at all. I feel that my plateau is emotional and I'm not sure if I should leave him and move back home or if I should set aside my emotions and just keep trying to lose the weight for the sake of my relationship. Someone please give me some advice... I don't know who to ask anymore!

***An extra foot note: home is Puerto Rico and I live in Florida on my own, my boyfriend does not live with me.***
[/quote]

Maybe not a good time for you to be making BIG decisions when you are "Emotionally shot." Step back and re-think. Maybe find a counselor to help you manage your feelings, losses and help you make some sound decisions. You're life needs to get straightened out before you add another person to it. Marriage is not to be taken lightly. Maybe your man in your relationship can not deal with all the issues right now either. An honest man will always get a bad rap. It gets very messy if you decide to separate/divorce. VERY messy! Take care of YOU first. A happy you makes a happy life and a happy wife, no matter who your marry.

Girl, you are worth more than a man who doesn't love you for the way you are. Period. If he wants a skinny mini girl who weighs 130, then that's who he should be with. What, is he going to divorce you when you gain weight after reaching that goal and getting married. It just doesn't sound like a good relationship in the first place.

Don't mean to sound judgy or mean. I spent way too much of my life not valuing the person I am or letting myself have the things I deserved. I married a stupid man because I thought "no one else will ever love me" and that was a huge mistake. I figured out that I deserve more than that and divorced him a year later. I am now in a relationship with a new guy who is amazing.

Live your life for you and the right man will come along eventually and walk beside you. Good luck.

I was in an emotionally abusive relationship at one point, and my partner was talking about marriage. He didn't actually propose, but he made it clear that I would need to lose weight for marriage to happen. It escalated quickly into him controlling/wanting to control many other aspects of my life. Ending the relationship was hard, but I am a much, much happier person now and am engaged to a very wonderful man who thinks I am beautiful no matter what I weigh.

The thing that helped me?

I wrote out a list of what was bad in my abusive relationship. Everything. Then I wrote out a list of what was good. There was only one thing on the second list, and even then, it wasn't great. I'd recommend you do so too. Because you are beautiful, even if you aren't 130 pounds. And the man you are going to marry should tell you that on a daily basis.

Bless you and congrats on your happiness. You are totally right. OP, please do not hang all of your happiness on this man; find the real man that loves you for all of you. Trust me, they exist and they're fabulous.

There is so much to consider here. By what you wrote here, if you were my daughter I would tell you to dump him like a rock in the deep blue sea. Never to be seen again. One thing you have to consider is this his way of truly trying to help you even though the approach is still all wrong. You know your relationship, so be honest with yourself. you know the man he is. You are the one wanting to marry him. Marriage is truly about an unconditional comittment. there is no way of knowing what the future may bring. It truly is for better or worst. Now as for as your wieght gain, I do believe its about something emotional. You need to find a way to figure out what it is and address the issue. Be willing to speak with those who can truly be honest with you and not just tell you what they feel you want to hear. Also maybe speaking with a professional would be good. there is no shame in asking for help. It's you taking control of your life and being responsible to yourself. Best of luck to you and may God bless you and look over you at this time.

I'm sorry you're being treated in this way and no one deserves this "demand". Once you reach the magic number, I have a feeling there will be some other new demand. Start your weight loss by returning the ring (if there is one) and move on. Not easy, I know, but the added stress to lose like this can hold you back and this most likely isn't a healthy relationship. Decide why YOU want to lose weight and put your energy into that and I have a feeling good things will happen in time. Good luck to you. You are not defined by someone else's opinion of you...but by your own self-worth. Work toward that.

The dude put a number on your weight as a condition for him to marry you? And you agreed to this? I don't usually say this in relationship threads, but just break up and move on. Fix you for you and then find someone who loves you for being you and you love for being them.

this..get rid of him,fix yourself for YOU,and the right guy will come along,,who knows,it may be someone you already know and they are just waiting for you to get your head on straight and dump the jerk!

He doesn't want to get married. Cut your losses and move on. When you find the man you are to marry, he will do anything possible to marry you. Look for THAT guy. This one you have has been stringing you along long enough.

^^^^ THIS!! ^^^^

I have a feeling this was already said but I think both of you need to go to a counselor. Then you can get an outside persons opinion who is qualified and has experience in this type of thing. If he outright refuses to do that then I would say cut your losses and get on with your life. No one should make you feel bad about how you feel. He should also not mandate that you be a certain weight before you get married. That is no kind of relationship. What about your future when you get pregnant or anything else? He doesn't seem to respect you or at least that is my opinion for what little you have told. I am not a qualified professional just another female who is offering her opinion. Best of luck!

If someone truly loved you, they wouldn't insist you have to lose weight before they marry you.