Since thick is in, should I stay at 145 on my 5'2 frame
Replies
-
westcoastgrl21 wrote: »PikaKnight wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »PikaKnight wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »
angellll12 wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »I'm extremely confident weighing 174# at 5'1". Thanks to strength training. #thickchick
Do you have pictures? I'd like to see how that looks .
See, I like the way your waist is small and your hips and butt pop. You don't even look 175, esp being only 5'1. Good work.
I'm going to waist train, this belly ruins everything.
Waist train???
Yeah apparently it works I was skeptical but a lot of girls are getting results.
I want a belly gone, and just tone up my arms. I like everything else.
You can't spot reduce, just a heads up. I don't think the girls are getting results in the way you think. You're talking about corsets, right? That's a temporary thing and if done excessively, can lead to a lot of problems.
Yes, she's talking about using a corset. Modern-day women are using corsets and calling it "waist training". It does work, surprisingly, to lessen the circumference of your waist and give that hourglass shape (only so long as you keep using the corset fairly regularly). There are some slight risks to it, but women have been using corsets for centuries without perishing. It's a little hard to wrap your head around it at first, but I guess it's not particularly strange when you think of all the shapewear that's in vogue now like spanx etc. And, no, I do not practice waist training, I just am familiar with it.
Personally I'm waiting for Chinese foot-binding to come back in vogue.0 -
christinev297 wrote: »LOl i wasn't fishing for compliments, but thank you.
well since we're all being honest, i've creeped on your profile a couple times before; just didnt have any context to say it till now LOL
creepy? whatever >.>0 -
If you are comfortable at that weight than why not? Im 5'5 and 175 ans my goal is 165. When i get to 165 i will see how i feel.0
-
angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?0 -
tryingtogetbigger2015 wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »LOl i wasn't fishing for compliments, but thank you.
well since we're all being honest, i've creeped on your profile a couple times before; just didnt have any context to say it till now LOL
creepy? whatever >.>
No worries, all good
0 -
TheVirgoddess wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?
Inb4 people try and say that "the opinion that small breasts is unfeminine" is the same as saying someone "matter-of-factly has too much body fat".0 -
rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
Right? I have 32 B's, basically the same cup size as a 34 A...and I still think I'm womanly. You bet.0 -
FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »almostplenty wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »almostplenty wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »almostplenty wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »I'm extremely confident weighing 174# at 5'1". Thanks to strength training. #thickchick
Do you have pictures? I'd like to see how that looks .
I still think you look overweight, too much body fat.
@almostplenty Excuse you? Who are YOU to tell someone they have too much body fat?
There's this saying….. If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.
I don't know why people are getting offended to an objective observation. You're the one adding the emotional connotation to terms relative to weight and body fat. It's like saying someone's hair looks brown, not blonde.
It's common sense that you don't flat-out call someone overweight. Have some couth, please.
*shrug* It's a medical term. Would you be offended if stated your blood pressure, thinking it was normal, and someone told you that it was actually hypertensive?
Don't even try to compare body weight and blood pressure. Body weight is a sensitive subject in the medical field.
You are still missing the point that she didn't ask for anyone's opinion on her photo.
Just a heads up- you won't last here if you continue to go around calling people overweight/overfat/obese. Also, abusing the flagging system isn't taken kindly here either.
LOL I didn't flag anybody. If my comments inspire randoms on the internet to jump down my throat, oh well. And I am in the medical field, working with cardiac and renal patients, I talk to others about their body weight on the reg. Unfortunately most people don't want to hear the truth, because they think it's normal to be the size they are.0 -
arditarose wrote: »rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
Right? I have 32 B's, basically the same cup size as a 34 A...and I still think I'm womanly. You bet.
Same size here! Sometimes i wear a 30C because the straps fit better but 99% of stores dont carry a band that small. 0 -
TheVirgoddess wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?
C'mon now, this thread is going to turn into a sh*tstorm at this rate
Personally i'm loving the honesty
0 -
rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
What do you think about yourself?
0 -
emilypink573 wrote: »If you are comfortable at that weight than why not? Im 5'5 and 175 ans my goal is 165. When i get to 165 i will see how i feel.
I am 5'5" too and have btdt. I thought I would stop at 180, 170, 165, 155, 150, 140, 135. I finally have decided to stop at 133 (BMI 22.1) and start work recomping. Every time I met my 'end' goal, I realized I had further to go than I thought to have the body I wanted.0 -
rainbowbow wrote: »arditarose wrote: »rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
Right? I have 32 B's, basically the same cup size as a 34 A...and I still think I'm womanly. You bet.
Same size here! Sometimes i wear a 30C because the straps fit better but 99% of stores dont carry a band that small.
Yeah, I can measure about a 30 band size as well but 30 C is rare. I'm interested to see how it looks on me though because sometimes the B cup looks funny.0 -
CrabNebula wrote: »emilypink573 wrote: »If you are comfortable at that weight than why not? Im 5'5 and 175 ans my goal is 165. When i get to 165 i will see how i feel.
I am 5'5" too and have btdt. I thought I would stop at 180, 170, 165, 155, 150, 140, 135. I finally have decided to stop at 133 (BMI 22.1) and start work recomping. Every time I met my 'end' goal, I realized I had further to go than I thought to have the body I wanted.
Same here. 5'4" and my goals were 150, 145, 140 and then I thought my absolute low would be 130...but now I'm at 133 and see that I might want to get into the 120s.0 -
almostplenty wrote: »westcoastgrl21 wrote: »PikaKnight wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »PikaKnight wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »MissKriss3 wrote: »I'm extremely confident weighing 174# at 5'1". Thanks to strength training. #thickchick
Do you have pictures? I'd like to see how that looks .
See, I like the way your waist is small and your hips and butt pop. You don't even look 175, esp being only 5'1. Good work.
I'm going to waist train, this belly ruins everything.
Waist train???
Yeah apparently it works I was skeptical but a lot of girls are getting results.
I want a belly gone, and just tone up my arms. I like everything else.
You can't spot reduce, just a heads up. I don't think the girls are getting results in the way you think. You're talking about corsets, right? That's a temporary thing and if done excessively, can lead to a lot of problems.
Yes, she's talking about using a corset. Modern-day women are using corsets and calling it "waist training". It does work, surprisingly, to lessen the circumference of your waist and give that hourglass shape (only so long as you keep using the corset fairly regularly). There are some slight risks to it, but women have been using corsets for centuries without perishing. It's a little hard to wrap your head around it at first, but I guess it's not particularly strange when you think of all the shapewear that's in vogue now like spanx etc. And, no, I do not practice waist training, I just am familiar with it.
Personally I'm waiting for Chinese foot-binding to come back in vogue.
LOL
0 -
christinev297 wrote: »TheVirgoddess wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?
C'mon now, this thread is going to turn into a sh*tstorm at this rate
Personally i'm loving the honesty
If someone asks for opinions on their body, I'm ALL for honesty - it's great.
When people comment on a photo of someone's body with no prompt - it's rude. It's like walking up to someone in person and telling them they're fat. That would be frowned upon, but for some reason people think it's okay on the 'net. It's gross.
Also, me commenting on crappy posts doesn't turn threads into shitstorms. The crappy posts do.0 -
Just because ur stomach is flat doesn't automatically mean you're hot.
If I was a guy sex wouldn't be fun with someone with a boy body type, I'd want my hands filled with boobs, *kitten* to grab, thighs to squeeze, I wouldn't want to feel Boney hip bones. Small tummy though.-2 -
hm new game...i have a feeling one of the posters in this thread seems like the type of person who would get mad if we didnt call this skim milk, can you guess who?? winner gets one internet
0 -
rainbowbow wrote: »arditarose wrote: »rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
Right? I have 32 B's, basically the same cup size as a 34 A...and I still think I'm womanly. You bet.
Same size here! Sometimes i wear a 30C because the straps fit better but 99% of stores dont carry a band that small.
I have big boobs. It's just the thought of that making me "womanly" is kinda ew. I'm pretty sure that woman card came with my uterus.0 -
Well maybe instead of weight loss, try changing your weight composition? Eat at maintenance calories. And workout with squats, deadlifts, and other strength training. It should burn off some fat, while keeping muscle, maybe building a tiny bit of muscle. It might let you keep your boobs and *kitten*, while still losing some belly fat along with fat elsewhere0
-
angellll12 wrote: »Just because ur stomach is flat doesn't automatically mean you're hot.
If I was a guy sex wouldn't be fun with someone with a boy body type, I'd want my hands filled with boobs, *kitten* to grab, thighs to squeeze, I wouldn't want to feel Boney hip bones. Small tummy though.
Yeah me too
0 -
angellll12 wrote: »rainbowbow wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
TIL- I am not womanly.
What do you think about yourself?
I recognize that no amount of dedication, hard work, sweat and tears in the gym, eating right or taking care of my body can change the size of my breasts. So i accept them.
It's not the same as losing weight, which can be changed. It's not the same as booty which can be built.
Breasts are made of fatty tissue, which i cannot magically grow.
I see no issue whatsoever like i said earlier on in women who chose to get breast implants. But for myself, i like the fact that my chest is perky, small, proportionate to my body, and never inhibits me from certain exercise or movements. I also don't have to worry about sagging later on in life.
0 -
Well maybe instead of weight loss, try changing your weight composition? Eat at maintenance calories. And workout with squats, deadlifts, and other strength training. It should burn off some fat, while keeping muscle, maybe building a tiny bit of muscle. It might let you keep your boobs and *kitten*, while still losing some belly fat along with fat elsewhere
I'm going to go down to 130 pounds and start doing all those things you listed.
That's the goal for now.
0 -
Then again, she presented herself as being at a healthy weight and posted her photo to encourage someone else to remain at a high-ish BMI...TheVirgoddess wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »TheVirgoddess wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?
C'mon now, this thread is going to turn into a sh*tstorm at this rate
Personally i'm loving the honesty
If someone asks for opinions on their body, I'm ALL for honesty - it's great.
When people comment on a photo of someone's body with no prompt - it's rude. It's like walking up to someone in person and telling them they're fat. That would be frowned upon, but for some reason people think it's okay on the 'net. It's gross.
Also, me commenting on crappy posts doesn't turn threads into shitstorms. The crappy posts do.
In this context, I think it's legit.0 -
forget weight and bmi and all that. if you somehow cant decide for yourself whether or not you like what you see in the mirror, then see if people crack fat jokes around you. if they do, you've won lol0
-
I read the first page and then jumped to the last......going back to page 20
-
Then again, she presented herself as being at a healthy weight and posted her photo to encourage someone else to remain at a high-ish BMI...TheVirgoddess wrote: »christinev297 wrote: »TheVirgoddess wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »I rather have some fat then be skinny with small breast, it's not womanly since we're being honest. I don't mind a little stomach, I'll probably go down to 130 and stop there and just workout to maintain and be healthy, I can look hot still without looking like I try so hard at the gym.
Um what? Having small breasts is not womanly?
C'mon now, this thread is going to turn into a sh*tstorm at this rate
Personally i'm loving the honesty
If someone asks for opinions on their body, I'm ALL for honesty - it's great.
When people comment on a photo of someone's body with no prompt - it's rude. It's like walking up to someone in person and telling them they're fat. That would be frowned upon, but for some reason people think it's okay on the 'net. It's gross.
Also, me commenting on crappy posts doesn't turn threads into shitstorms. The crappy posts do.
In this context, I think it's legit.
Fair point. It just makes me really uncomfortable to see, so I wanted to speak up. Personal issue I guess.0 -
tryingtogetbigger2015 wrote: »forget weight and bmi and all that. if you somehow cant decide for yourself whether or not you like what you see in the mirror, then see if people crack fat jokes around you. if they do, you've won lol
That works, too.
0 -
-
angellll12 wrote: »Just because ur stomach is flat doesn't automatically mean you're hot.
If I was a guy sex wouldn't be fun with someone with a boy body type, I'd want my hands filled with boobs, *kitten* to grab, thighs to squeeze, I wouldn't want to feel Boney hip bones. Small tummy though.
Most outrageous comment of the thread so far.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions