Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Is verbal harassment common at the gym? And do women or men catch more of it?
Options
Replies
-
There is one man who followed me around the gym 4-5 times over a few months. He would use the machines next to me or just generally be close by way too often to be normal and is the only person so far at that gym to interrupt my sets to ask stupid questions (my answers got shorter and less polite every time). I do consider it harassment and it did affect how safe and confident I felt but I didn't want to be told by the gym employees that I'm overreacting, or worse, that he would know I had reported him and become a different kind of harasser. So I just dealt with it and texted my sister every time I saw him there.
Haven't seen him in a while, it's nice not to be on the lookout for him.19 -
I met my husband at the gym.
He harassed but after I was done working out. He wasn't disgusting but he made me laugh. We have been married for 21 years.10 -
I've been to a few different gyms over many, many years and I've never seen it. I'm sure it happens from time to time just about anywhere you can imagine. I've been harassed many times on the street, though.1
-
-
I just remembered an article from a few years ago. Does anyone remember that nasty woman who took nude photos of overweight women in the gym changerooms and posted them online, ridiculing them? It's not common, but this is a horrific example of harassment.5
-
I just remembered an article from a few years ago. Does anyone remember that nasty woman who took nude photos of overweight women in the gym changerooms and posted them online, ridiculing them? It's not common, but this is a horrific example of harassment.
An extreme version, and probably rare. She faced legal issues for that.5 -
I just remembered an article from a few years ago. Does anyone remember that nasty woman who took nude photos of overweight women in the gym changerooms and posted them online, ridiculing them? It's not common, but this is a horrific example of harassment.
An extreme version, and probably rare. She faced legal issues for that.
This reminds me of the only time I can remember when I was confrontational with someone at the gym. I was in the locker room, changing -- i.e., naked -- and these girls who looked to be 12 to 14 years old were taking selfies in front of the mirror. I had no way to know whether they were catching my reflection, but I told them firmly that they needed to stop and that it was incredibly rude to take pictures in a locker room.
But on the original question, no, in nearly 40 years of using university gyms, free or cheap county rec department gyms, cheap for-profit gyms, not-so-cheap gyms, gyms in hotels when traveling, and women-only gyms, I have never felt harassed myself, and the only incidents I can remember seeing where I felt like someone was bordering on verbally abusive were people who clearly knew each other.
I never had anyone, male or female, staff or customer, say, imply, or look at me in a way that made me feel like I was unwelcome because of my gender or current body size.
A couple of times in 40 years I've run into instructors who seemed reluctant to have me join their class because I was new, and they seemed to have the odd notion that their classes -- part of what the gym membership was supposed to pay for -- were only for people whom they already knew and already knew how to do what they were supposedly teaching. One of them turned out to be great once I made it clear I wasn't leaving. The other was still a jerk, but one session of her yoga class in a windowless concrete slab room covered in wrestling mats had me looking for a real yoga studio with light and soft music, anyway. I guess it's kind of understandable she had lost the namaste concept, having to work under those conditions.
When I was younger, I would occasionally catch guys in gyms looking, but they pretty much always looked away, embarrassed to be caught looking. Occasionally they would flash a chagrined smile. Neither of those situations felt like harassment to me. Occasionally people -- usually men -- will offer unsolicited advice. It's annoying when they don't know what they're talking about, but it's not harassment.
I've never experienced harassment out running, "power" walking, or biking, but I think it's because I mostly do that in suburban, rural, or vacation areas. I've been verbally harassed, followed, had my path blocked, had guys expose themselves or *kitten* in front of me, and been touched inappropriately walking in cities, on college campuses (heck, in my elementary school classroom as an 11-year-old and walking home from the school at about the same age), on public transit, at non-gym swimming pools, and in almost every other venue I've ever been in. Libraries. Banks. Pizza joints. Bars, of course. You name it.
So I'd have to say that gyms are among the safest spaces I know of for being allowed to just get on with your life and not have to smile and talk to strangers because somebody will you a *kitten* if you don't.
11 -
I’ve noticed some of the people walking by the yoga classroom sometimes staring a little....but thirty middle aged and older ladies all in down dog position rear ends facing the window would be a sight, I suppose. Harassment? Never. And a few of those starers have come and joined us.1
-
I’ve noticed some of the people walking by the yoga classroom sometimes staring a little....but thirty middle aged and older ladies all in down dog position rear ends facing the window would be a sight, I suppose. Harassment? Never. And a few of those starers have come and joined us.
2 -
Fortunately - I’ve personally never seen that or experienced it. Ive been a member of my gym for about 10 years. I find MFP forums to be much more hostile than any person I’ve run into at my gym!3
-
I was a lifeguard at a gym so I got to hear and see lots of stuff all the time... one guy was banned for comments he made to women, but after a month or so he was allowed back in for reasons I don’t understand. He would make comments to us female lifeguards when we were working and it made our shifts really uncomfortable.
I definitely prefer running in the great out doors, it’s a very safe community, even early in the morning I see many officers out on patrol on my running route and I don’t feel scared and no one bothers me.0 -
-
I've going to gyms in the US and then in Europe for years and never experience any problems either. They always feel like very accepting environments where everyone is there to do their own thing. The problems have been outside in the "real world" where I've had people yell or honk from cars when I'm riding my bike slowly up big hills. I just wave back and smile. I might be struggling, but I'm getting more exercise than they are in the car so who cares?2
-
At my gym I was never really harassed, but what made me quit was the owner making a comment about complaints about my body odeur. Note this was a woman's only gym and there were a number of ladies that saw the gym mostly as a social thing vs really workout area.
I was one of the few that I actually worked hard at the gym and did not participate much in the banter and I don't wear those artificial perfumes that most ladies in that gym wore.
I sweat when I work out hard and yes that smells like sweat I am sorry I thought this was a GYM? I know who did the complaining She was always complaining about body odeur hating around in after a hard workout session in the class before us. Unfortunately she is also a very loyal, socially very central customer and mother of one of the trainers and the gym was struggling.
Anyway I asked around in my social circle and everybody was stunned about the comment. I am not a smelly cat at all. Just like to work out and sweat out my stress.3 -
no. thirty years ago women were really not welcome and men were very verbal about it....not now.
Agreed - had this happen in my Student Union gym 25-30 years ago - 2 guys came in as I was leaving & I was told 'This is for men only' by one. The other guy questioned him ('is that right?' & he replied 'No, but we don't want them in here do we?') no staff around to report it to - I regret not engaging now, and in fact I just never went back there.
That's the single, only time it has happened to me though - fast-forward a few decades and several gyms and all have been fine. A combination of context and lack of staffing meaning that sweetie thinking he could get away with trying (well succeeding really!) to intimidate3 -
Wow! I'm sorry to hear men were saying that. We have a a super enthusiastic gym owner who greets everyone by their full name (usually yelling from across the gym if he's not at reception). Also calls out when you leave, and has run outside to protect women being harassed by a meth head down the road. Very welcoming gym!1
-
I've always felt very welcoming and not experienced harassment.
I've been in different gyms in several countries over the years.
I might get the occasional stare from men but I either ignore them or give them a stern look and that's normally enough to mind their own business.0 -
VanVanDiane wrote: »no. thirty years ago women were really not welcome and men were very verbal about it....not now.
Agreed - had this happen in my Student Union gym 25-30 years ago - 2 guys came in as I was leaving & I was told 'This is for men only' by one. The other guy questioned him ('is that right?' & he replied 'No, but we don't want them in here do we?') no staff around to report it to - I regret not engaging now, and in fact I just never went back there.
That's the single, only time it has happened to me though - fast-forward a few decades and several gyms and all have been fine. A combination of context and lack of staffing meaning that sweetie thinking he could get away with trying (well succeeding really!) to intimidate
If it only happened once, it seems unfair to agree with the generalization women weren't welcome and men were very verbal about it.
Also, it's likely that the culture at all gyms were not identical.
I used university gyms 30-ish to 40-ish years ago (undergrad and grad school, both at large-ish state universities). I would say commercial gyms today feel more welcoming than uni gyms did, probably both because of a desire to maximize their customer pool and because there are just more women in them.
I think the fact that my roommate and I could walk into a uni gym in the early 80s and be the only women there, and a few men might look surprised, and maybe even a couple might make it pretty clear they weren't happy about letting us work in (but maybe they treated other guys that way too?) and nobody was walking up and saying "Oh, it's so great you're here. Please feel right at home" didn't necessarily mean the guys were to blame for our discomfort.
Yeah, in a perfect world, we would all be kind and thoughtful to each other and go out of our way to make people feel welcome, but laying the blame on an entire gender, or at least all the members of that gender who use gyms or who used gyms 30 years ago because of a single comment by one guy (whose friend apparently called him on it) seems like too much to me.5 -
This is a pretty easy one -
Have you ever witnessed, participated in, or been a victim of, verbal harassment at a gym? How often - frequently, sometimes, occasionally, almost never?
If yes, what type? Sexual harassment, verbal intimidation, insults or derogatory comments, something else?
And, was the victim of said harassment a man or a woman (or someone who reads as a man or woman)?
And if anyone wishes, bonus question: are you a man or woman (or read like one) - just to see if we pay more attention to when people within our own perceived group are harassed, vs. other groups.
Bonus bonus question: if this is something you see sometimes or frequently, do you do anything about it when you see it? Or what do you think should be done about it, if anything?
i've never personally experienced verbal harassment or seen/heard it in person. but up until recently there was a guy who constantly tries to intimidate me by trying to one-up every exercise i do. on the days i do squats, he would stop his workout, loads up the same amount of weight i'm using on the power rack next to mines without warming up, then he gets under the bar and starts grunting loudly, like he didn't even unrack the bar off the rack, he's just standing under it. from the mirror in front of me, i see him staring directly at me and grunting loudly. he would not shut up and start his set until i look at him. everytime the timer on my phone goes off, i get under the bar and he stands there to watch me squat, once my set is done i sit on the floor, start the timer, and read the news on my phone app, then he goes back under the bar and starts grunting again while waiting for me to watch him squat, and he would do this continuously. on the days i really don't want to deal with him, i would just turn my head over to pretend like i looked, and then he starts doing his quarter squats. i've reported him, to a different manager and they had him banned.
this one guy who would purposely wait until i unrack the barbell to start bench press or squats and he will come over to grab weights just to spite me or something. like i walk out for squats, i take a huge breathe in, brace my core, and just when i am about to break my hips and knees to start the first rep for the set, the guy will come rushing over, squeezing/dodging between the barbells, trying to get to the back to get weights by the mirrors in front of me, and then i'm just standing there with over 255 lbs sitting on my traps/scapulas, i'm standing there waiting for him to get out, but he would just stand around to fiddling with the 5 lbs and 10 lbs. for bench press the guy would wait until i unracked the bar and moved it above my shoulders, then he would come swooping in, acting like he's grabbing weights beside me with his side of the body almost bumping into the barbell, it's so scary and i'm just holding the bar up until he leaves because with his body there, i can't even put the barbell back on the hooks. the gym only have 2 types of plates, the metal ones and the rubber ones, same color and brands, they're hanging on all the smith machines, squat racks, deadlifts platforms, bench press, they're just all over the entire gym, but he would purposely come over to where i'm trying to start my set, to come over to grab weights. on some days when i'm not in a good mood, feeling annoyed/frustrated, i really just want to smash his face with a plate.
there are many other things, like i literally have a fan club at gym. i always have a bunch of dudes following me around the gym and they just straight up stare at me while i'm lifting. no matter where i moved to in the gym, they will always show up near me within 60 seconds. they just stand or sit on a machine close to where i am and they just stare without ever doing any exercises themselves.9 -
lynn_glenmont wrote: »VanVanDiane wrote: »no. thirty years ago women were really not welcome and men were very verbal about it....not now.
Agreed - had this happen in my Student Union gym 25-30 years ago - 2 guys came in as I was leaving & I was told 'This is for men only' by one. The other guy questioned him ('is that right?' & he replied 'No, but we don't want them in here do we?') no staff around to report it to - I regret not engaging now, and in fact I just never went back there.
That's the single, only time it has happened to me though - fast-forward a few decades and several gyms and all have been fine. A combination of context and lack of staffing meaning that sweetie thinking he could get away with trying (well succeeding really!) to intimidate
If it only happened once, it seems unfair to agree with the generalization women weren't welcome and men were very verbal about it.
Also, it's likely that the culture at all gyms were not identical.
What I was agreeing with is that it doesn't happen now. I also agree that all gyms are not identical.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.4K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 984 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions