How Long Before Someone Noticed Your Loss??

it took over 2 months and 25lbs before anyone commented

This is exactly what I was going to quote. It really helps put it perspective.

Sound about right. 14 lbs lost and about 4 months after starting my journey before someone at work notices it.

This is a topic that really bothers me too!! I have lost almost 20 pounds and only my husband has said anything. In fact he asked me just this morning if anyone else has said anything and I regretfully told him no.

The last time I made a comment along the lines of 'you look nice today, have you lost weight?' it turned out they had a medical issue. It was not a happy weight loss. So now I just say 'that's a great color for you' or 'you look happy', but I never ask about physical changes. So please don't let my silence undermine your goals or lessen your accomplishments! And by the way, you ALWAYS look great.

I think it depends on your height how much it shows. I'm 5'2 and 25 lb was a pretty dramatic change. Most people have noticed. I look forward to Easter when people who haven't seen me since Christmas will be surprised. I keep putting on clothes, and not seeing much of a difference myself, but then if I put on an old shirt, I'm shocked how baggy it is, and remember how much I filled it.
Looking at my 25 lb before and after pic is really motivating for me to get off the next 25!

And yes, it seems to also be directly related to body % lost too. Someone must do a study and come up with a calculation based on ratio to height % of body weight!

At about 20 lbs lost is when one of my husbands crew man thought my husband was talking to another woman and when my husband told him it was his wife the guy was shock and said I looked totally different I guess everyone is different but it really feels good when they notice.

I want this poster!

I have lost 11 lbs. so far and some people have noticed. I have noticed that I have been getting a few more compliments about my hair, makeup, clothing and etc. and I truly believe it is because they know something is different but not sure exactly what. So take those compliments as a job well done!! Good luck with your weight loss!

I am down 8lbs in 8 weeks of trying. Started at 236lb and i'm 5'9" This past weekend when I was with friends one of them asked if I had lost some weight. Which was nice. I have asked my husband if he noticed but he tells me since he sees me on a daily basis its harder for him to tell. Personally i feel better since I have been seeing some of the weight drop off.
My real test will be Easter next month. I will see a lot of family and they aren't shy about saying did you loose/gain some weight. I hope to be down about 15lbs by then. So far family wise only my mother knows i'm trying to loose and she keeps going how much are you down now? Which is nice having her encouragement as well

It's so funny that I saw this post. The first person (co-worker) noticed today. I have gone from 155 to 140... so 15 lbs. I think that people notice but don't always say it. Working with 99% women I find myself not sure if I should comment on weight loss. Sometimes it can be a sensative subject. I think some people feel the same way. Don't worry, Im sure you and your clothes notice.

6 weeks and 16 lbs..my boss was the first to comment..and she did so yesterday felt great!

This is EXACTLY what I was looking for! Thanks for posting!!

This is a hard-to-determine one for me...

I've had a lot of comments, where the passive aggressive ones I wish would stop...

Weight loss, particularly a significant amount, can be intimidating and cause those that also need to lose weight to secretly or overtly resent your success.

What's a great response? "You look great", or, "Great job on your weight loss"... Funny though, I often hear, "Wow, how much weight have you lost?", or, "Man, you're waisting away to nothing."

All of this has taught me that weight mastery should contain a lot of personal and intrinsic benefits that are just for you... e.g. longer life, great example for your kids, gift back to your spouse, self esteem, courage to attempt other life change, etc. Another good one is new clothes. But the list is important for at some point, we may become comfortable with our weight loss and succumb to the temptation to put it all back on. If your list of benefits is lengthy, it can keep you on the right path... Conversely, if you're only goal is to hear the compliments or to turn the eye of that special person, you might run out of motivation to keep the weight off...

I find it's almost as meaningful when someone who hasn't ever seen me (like an online buddy who exchanges long emails & has known me for awhile) manages to convey some sense of happiness for me ("that's amazing. That's a lot of pounds") but, I've had no feedback yet , even though my total weight loss before I found MFP and the loss shown in my official ticker comes to more than 10% of my starting weight (38 pounds starting from 320).Could it be because I'm a hermit and go for days and weeks without seeing anyone, so that nobody who actually knows me has seen me in MONTHS, other than my neighbors catching a glimpse of me running between car & house when I'm forced to go out. Maybe when I'm really lookin' good, I'll even feel like staying OUTside and spending time with someone human.

I'm down about 10% of my body weight and nobody has said anything. But this is good for me because in the past if someone noticed I stopped losing weight. This time I'm doing it for health, and I can sure tell.

THIS - yes - in the past getting too much attention for weight loss has spelled disaster for me. I think I got cocky and let myself go, because I felt like "well done, Carole...have some ice cream." and it was all downhill from there. Even after I had dropped from 350 to 185, I caved as soon as my head started to swell.