Gaining muscle
Replies
-
OP, are you actually a new lifter? How long have you been lifting?
Off and on again my whole adult life, actually. Sometimes I get quite discouraged, even though I am very strong, because of the stereotypes of fat women. Though I will readily admit that the men in my local gym are really awesome and nice to me. They are very supportive. The women, erh... depends on the woman. But the men generally accept me when I show up.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
yopeeps025 wrote: »
I will guess you mean maintain mass because plenty of people increase in strength on a deficit.
At least in my legs.
I am also not opposed to the idea of losing the fat and then regaining the strength if I need to do it that way. But damn, it sounds an awful lot like men are suggesting women just can't possibly be smaller and strong.
Nobody suggested that, but if you want to play the off in left field game, go for it. Only makes you look more reasonable.
Here is what I asked:
Can I lose the fat and still keep the muscle - or gain muscle.
-
Everybody - NO THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE.
Well, that's a somewhat short-sighted answer, isn't it? We know that many women at smaller weights are extraordinarily strong. It's not like it would be IMPOSSIBLE for me to get there, but the route may be circuitous at best.
you are confusing muscle with strength...they are not the same...
You may well be right. I would appreciate people sharing their knowledge on the differences. It is my strength that I value.
muscle gain is the process of building new muscle, which is accomplished by eating in a calorie surplus and lifting heavier and heavier weights.
Strength is the process of training your muscles to work more efficiently. Example - while eating in a calorie deficit I increase my deadlift from 250#to 275#; I have not added any new muscle, I have just training the existing muscle to perform the lift more efficiently. Essentially this is making your muscles more productive aka do more with less, or more with the same...
does that help?0 -
Calls people bullies and in the same breath shoots insults. Only one person doing that in this thread.I think some people are both cognitively challenged along with being just generally mean. I don't give a crumb if losing the fat means I automatically become less strong - it would be MY CHOICE then to maintain the muscle OVER WEIGHT LOSS. Derpy der kids, try and keep up.
your original post said you wanted to build muscle and lose fat ..it was not until like page two that you clarified you meant maintain strength and lose fat...
so while some may need reading comprehension, others may need writing comprehension...
I already apologized for misleading the peanut gallery.
So polite, I'm amazed more aren't lining up to help you with commentary like that.
Oh my goodness, if you don't like it then use all your thinky skills to navigate away.
The most amusing parts is.........claiming abnormally strong female strength because, Nordic.........spends the whole thread complaining about mean people.
Shhh, must use thinkies.0 -
You can still lift to retain the muscle you have. When you reach goal, then you can focus on getting cut and strong on a surplus while still keeping the fat off. I don't think you should give it up altogether. It still burns calories and it will still work to keep what you have.0
-
and also, I have never really 1. tried to lose weight or 2. kept track of my diet/nutrition before... and I never researched lifting or anything... I have always been kind of on the sidelines, mainly because of my own issues.0
-
Calls people bullies and in the same breath shoots insults. Only one person doing that in this thread.
The most amusing parts is.........claiming abnormally strong female strength because, Nordic.........spends the whole thread complaining about mean people.
lol I'm not abnormally strong for a Nordic lass.0 -
HerbertNenenger wrote: »You can still lift to retain the muscle you have. When you reach goal, then you can focus on getting cut and strong on a surplus while still keeping the fat off. I don't think you should give it up altogether. It still burns calories and it will still work to keep what you have.
Thank you.0 -
muscle gain is the process of building new muscle, which is accomplished by eating in a calorie surplus and lifting heavier and heavier weights.
Strength is the process of training your muscles to work more efficiently. Example - while eating in a calorie deficit I increase my deadlift from 250#to 275#; I have not added any new muscle, I have just training the existing muscle to perform the lift more efficiently. Essentially this is making your muscles more productive aka do more with less, or more with the same...
does that help?
Yes, thank you.
So can I maintain (or increase) my strength while on a calorie deficit/losing fat?0 -
No one said it can't be done, but is that you? Because the person in that video looks very well trained.
Oh, wait, this is the OP?
I don't see 280 pounds on that frame.
I'm pretty sure it's not. I'm just confused as to what was the purpose of posting the video.
Of course it isn't, there's no purpose to the video other than to show that a woman can lift something heavy. Ok, numerous powerlifting records show that. It was a logical fallacy and deflection on her part. Essentially a composition fallacy.0 -
Of course it isn't, there's no purpose to the video other than to show that a woman can lift something heavy. Ok, numerous powerlifting records show that. It was a logical fallacy and deflection on her part. Essentially a composition fallacy.
I like the word fallacy.
Someone said "try it and get back to us" as though it were impossible. Obviously not impossible.0 -
muscle gain is the process of building new muscle, which is accomplished by eating in a calorie surplus and lifting heavier and heavier weights.
Strength is the process of training your muscles to work more efficiently. Example - while eating in a calorie deficit I increase my deadlift from 250#to 275#; I have not added any new muscle, I have just training the existing muscle to perform the lift more efficiently. Essentially this is making your muscles more productive aka do more with less, or more with the same...
does that help?
Yes, thank you.
So can I maintain (or increase) my strength while on a calorie deficit/losing fat?
Lots of programs on Google to increase strength while in calorie deficit.
0 -
As has been said multiple times.
muscle gain is the process of building new muscle, which is accomplished by eating in a calorie surplus and lifting heavier and heavier weights.
Strength is the process of training your muscles to work more efficiently. Example - while eating in a calorie deficit I increase my deadlift from 250#to 275#; I have not added any new muscle, I have just training the existing muscle to perform the lift more efficiently. Essentially this is making your muscles more productive aka do more with less, or more with the same...
does that help?
Yes, thank you.
So can I maintain (or increase) my strength while on a calorie deficit/losing fat?
Yes. Although more accurately would be: maybe.
It depends on a lot of factors. Commitment, consistency, proper intake, proper output.
You can half *kitten* it and wave a bunch of iron around and probably get some results. OR. You can gather data, work in a reasonable programming schedule, analyze said data and adjust as needed.
Based on your posting history, I think your previous statement of getting a trainer is probably an excellent one.
0 -
I guess it depends on what you mean by "off and on," but I doubt you're going to be seeing any noob gains if you're not a beginner.OP, are you actually a new lifter? How long have you been lifting?
Off and on again my whole adult life, actually. Sometimes I get quite discouraged, even though I am very strong, because of the stereotypes of fat women. Though I will readily admit that the men in my local gym are really awesome and nice to me. They are very supportive. The women, erh... depends on the woman. But the men generally accept me when I show up.
I seems like you're really sweating the small stuff and it's getting you off track. You need to figure out what your primary goal is right now, then people here can help you get there.
Do you want to lose weight? Or, do you just want to focus on lifting more weight to the exclusion of all else?
Focus on the results -- if you are able to progressively increase your lifts, even slowly, who cares if it's because you're actually making more muscle fibers or if it's because your body is lifting more efficiently? If your goal is to lose some weight while still staying strong, it doesn't matter. The way you get there is to eat at a small deficit and keep lifting.
0 -
Of course it isn't, there's no purpose to the video other than to show that a woman can lift something heavy. Ok, numerous powerlifting records show that. It was a logical fallacy and deflection on her part. Essentially a composition fallacy.
I like the word fallacy.
Someone said "try it and get back to us" as though it were impossible. Obviously not impossible.
You're projecting.
It was said, try it and report back. As that's the only way you'll know. If you won't try it, then obviously it's completely impossible for you.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
muscle gain is the process of building new muscle, which is accomplished by eating in a calorie surplus and lifting heavier and heavier weights.
Strength is the process of training your muscles to work more efficiently. Example - while eating in a calorie deficit I increase my deadlift from 250#to 275#; I have not added any new muscle, I have just training the existing muscle to perform the lift more efficiently. Essentially this is making your muscles more productive aka do more with less, or more with the same...
does that help?
Yes, thank you.
So can I maintain (or increase) my strength while on a calorie deficit/losing fat?
yes, but like others have said it is going to be dependent on a lot of factors..
I know that when I do a aggressive cut, say 500 calorie deficit, that after about three to four months my lifts start feeling like sh** and I can tell that my strength is starting to suffer a little....usually at that point I up calories to say a 250 calorie deficit..
which is why you should try with a 250 calorie deficit and go on a heavy lifting program and see how it goes...0 -
I guess it depends on what you mean by "off and on," but I doubt you're going to be seeing any noob gains if you're not a beginner.
I seems like you're really sweating the small stuff and it's getting you off track. You need to figure out what your primary goal is right now, then people here can help you get there.
Do you want to lose weight? Or, do you just want to focus on lifting more weight to the exclusion of all else?
Focus on the results -- if you are able to progressively increase your lifts, even slowly, who cares if it's because you're actually making more muscle fibers or if it's because your body is lifting more efficiently? If your goal is to lose some weight while still staying strong, it doesn't matter. The way you get there is to eat at a small deficit and keep lifting.
I want to lose fat. But I do not want to lose my strength.
Also, thank you for the reasonable response.
0 -
No one said it's not possible. The phrase try it and get back to us is directed at you personally, "You, try it and get back to us". No one said it can't be done. Most of us here know at least 1 or 2 females that put up numbers like that. But the thing is, no one is talking about the people we know, or the girls in the video. Instead it's about you.
Of course it isn't, there's no purpose to the video other than to show that a woman can lift something heavy. Ok, numerous powerlifting records show that. It was a logical fallacy and deflection on her part. Essentially a composition fallacy.
I like the word fallacy.
Someone said "try it and get back to us" as though it were impossible. Obviously not impossible.
Yes, we are talking about me and how I can get there.0 -
you've been shown how. You'll either do it, or you won't.0
-
yes, but like others have said it is going to be dependent on a lot of factors..
I know that when I do a aggressive cut, say 500 calorie deficit, that after about three to four months my lifts start feeling like sh** and I can tell that my strength is starting to suffer a little....usually at that point I up calories to say a 250 calorie deficit..
which is why you should try with a 250 calorie deficit and go on a heavy lifting program and see how it goes...
Thank you very much.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Well, the guys here were telling you the truth -- lifting at 280 is different from lifting at 140 (I don't know if that's your goal, so I'm just making up numbers). You may not be able to hold on to 100% of your strength, because nobody just loses fat when you lose weight. You can hold onto a lot of your strength, though, and you can build more muscle after you lose weight. It just may need to be a multi-step process and you may not be able to reach all your goals at the same time.
I guess it depends on what you mean by "off and on," but I doubt you're going to be seeing any noob gains if you're not a beginner.
I seems like you're really sweating the small stuff and it's getting you off track. You need to figure out what your primary goal is right now, then people here can help you get there.
Do you want to lose weight? Or, do you just want to focus on lifting more weight to the exclusion of all else?
Focus on the results -- if you are able to progressively increase your lifts, even slowly, who cares if it's because you're actually making more muscle fibers or if it's because your body is lifting more efficiently? If your goal is to lose some weight while still staying strong, it doesn't matter. The way you get there is to eat at a small deficit and keep lifting.
I want to lose fat. But I do not want to lose my strength.
Also, thank you for the reasonable response.
This is an extreme example, but it might help: at your weight, you could go balls-out on the deficit and try to lose 4 pounds per week, and you'll lose weight quickly, but you'll probably lose a lot of strength at the same time. Or, you can try to lose 0.5 pounds per week and keep most of your strength, but it'll take a really long time to lose weight. You get to decide how to set your goals, and you'll have to put up with some trade-offs, but you can stay strong and lose weight.
0 -
Well, the guys here were telling you the truth -- lifting at 280 is different from lifting at 140 (I don't know if that's your goal, so I'm just making up numbers). You may not be able to hold on to 100% of your strength, because nobody just loses fat when you lose weight. You can hold onto a lot of your strength, though, and you can build more muscle after you lose weight. It just may need to be a multi-step process and you may not be able to reach all your goals at the same time.
This is an extreme example, but it might help: at your weight, you could go balls-out on the deficit and try to lose 4 pounds per week, and you'll lose weight quickly, but you'll probably lose a lot of strength at the same time. Or, you can try to lose 0.5 pounds per week and keep most of your strength, but it'll take a really long time to lose weight. You get to decide how to set your goals, and you'll have to put up with some trade-offs, but you can stay strong and lose weight.
I figured it would be different.
My goal is between 180 and 190.
I am not losing weight super fast, somewhere between a pound and two pounds per week.0 -
No time to read the thread so I'm sorry if this has been said. Keep up the weight training -- it can help you retain the muscle you have while losing fat. It's also good for bone health. It also helps make you strong and therefore badass.
0 -
Ok, then I'll break it down to small terms for ya.
1a. Eat at a deficit. A range of 250-500 might be effective, try it and find out.
1b. Ensure that you are eating an appropriate mix of macros.
2. Commit to a consistent workout regimen with progressive loading. You're a new lifter, so you'll experience some linear gains, then you'll have to grind out more after that stops.
3. Gather detailed qualitative and quantitative data regarding your intake, output, performance, etc.
4. Analyze said data, and adjust based on goals.
5. Reassess total performance every quarter.
There you go, roadmap.0 -
Unfortunately, each person is different. It's quite possible that during your weight loss journey that you will plateau or even possibly, lose strength, but none of us have a crystal ball to be able to tell you exactly how this will work out. All you can do is start to lose weight with a moderate to small deficit and do a progressive weight lifting program. If you only care about the numbers you lift, then do a program like strong lift 5x5 or starting strength 5x5. There are plenty of different programs that focus on strength, hypertrophy or endurance. Depending on your preference, depends which one you do. I tend to mix all three... some tend to only do strength..
0 -
bump.0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Za22mICcREo
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions