why don't the low carb folks believe in CICO?
Options
Replies
-
Liftng4Lis wrote: »Also, why do you insist people are "confused?" Keto food is generally more calorie dense, therefore lower volume, not the other way around. You need a lot of broccoli to match the calories in a filet with a pat of butter on top. People get to eat til they're full, that's the difference, it has nothing to do with volume. Higher fat with adequate protein makes someone feel full faster than higher carb.
So you're saying that I can eat 2000 calories worth of fish, fried in fat if I wanted to and I'll lose weight?
No, I'm saying you'd get full at 1400 and put the other 600 in the fridge (or possibly feed it to ducks, if it's from McDonald's)
OK, I haven't made it to the end of this thread yet, so others may have beat me to it, but I see what you did there
. I miss that thread!
0 -
I appreciate all the low carbers coming in here and validating that they agree with CICO ..this has been a great thread and not the dumpster fire that I thought it might be….
It has actually been a very informative thread. Thanks. I didn't have much hope for it when it started; I thought it would be closed pretty quickly.
0 -
I appreciate all the low carbers coming in here and validating that they agree with CICO ..this has been a great thread and not the dumpster fire that I thought it might be….
It has actually been a very informative thread. Thanks. I didn't have much hope for it when it started; I thought it would be closed pretty quickly.
IKR!! Look at everyone playing nicely. Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy. 0 -
Like, this is us!
0 -
billieljaime wrote: »so when I did low carb Atkins was all the rage and there were guidlines it did not mean i could eat a tub of lard because there was no lard....
seriously would you drink five liters of diet coke because there are no calories or six pots of coffee because there are no calories?
The simple answer is no because you would feel like crap and not meet your health goals
didn't some people take atkins to the extreme and start eating steak and bacon all day????
Years ago, probably 15 or so, I had to run to the store to pick up heavy cream because I was making shrimp Alfredo pasta for my mom visiting from out of town (her favorite meal). Standing in line at the checkout, I heard a guy behind me saying, "hey. Are you on Atkins? Hey... You on Atkins?" I didn't think he was talking to me but then he tapped me on the shoulder and asked again. "Are you on Atkins? It's awesome. I'm on it and I drink that stuff all the time and you can eat pork rinds and I've lost 25 lbs!" I said, "you eat pork rinds and drink heavy cream and you are bragging about that to strangers in public?" I wasn't even trying to be snarky. I was seriously dumbfounded.
In full disclosure it was at Walmart....
0 -
I do keto, and it truly is cico. Dont base an assumption on just one person. Also understand that maybe, from a scientific standpoint, that is what they can conclude. Use perspective analysis to understand what the other person is thinking. Maybe they are dumb to the notion (as in, they are uninformed) I know I was at some point...I still am on some topics. But I never ever say that keto is a magic bean to weight loss. I need to stay dedicated just like anyone else. It has its pros and cons, but it helps me in my progression.
Law of Conservation of Matter (coined by Lavoisier): matter is neither created nor destroyed...it is simply transferred. All matter has energy, and calories are a form energy takes. That is the TRUE definition of cico. Look it up.
If you burn more energy than you consume over a certain timeframe, you will have used what is called "stored energy." This holds true over the long term, as body weight fluctuates day to day for hundreds of reasons. It is not absolute...you use a combination of metabolic and stored energy all the time. But if you lose stored energy, you lose mass, and become smaller.
Diets are a tool. That is all, a tool that adheres to the Law of Conservation of Matter.0 -
I was diagnosed with IR and prediabetes about 9 years ago. Then I lost excess fat and added muscle mass with a barbell. My bloodwork (including A1C) is now awesome across the board and no signs of either of the above.IR and PCOS and Metabolic Syndrome are not curable, anymore than diabetes is. You can get rid of some or all of the symptoms if you eat correctly for your condition and keep the weight off. But if you go back to eating carbs, the symptoms come back.
I eat about 250g carbs a day, out of 2400, so about 40% of my calories. That includes stuff like candy bars and cookies when I feel like it, and I don't get the "food coma" I used to get before.
0 -
I do low carb - around 20g per day. But I keep within my calorie allowance, isn't that common sense? Maybe I'm doing it wrong lol0
-
It would be nice if some low carbers came in here and acutely refuted this…
I have gone through low carb phases in the past. In fact I'm currently on a PSFM cycle, just to see what it's like, so I guess technically I'm low carb right now, although I don't think of it in those terms.
There's no magic - it's just another tool to generate the CI I'm after.
0 -
One of the reasons this is a tetchy subject for me was I got into a rather large debate with the egg fast people re; cico.
Them
" Counting calories is unnecessary if you do low carb/keto. CICO doesn't work for everyone!!! "
Me
posted a link to a calorie calculator asking them to at least estimate their daily calorie intake.
Their response was
" Not interested "
So as per usual I left the conversation none the wiser....
0 -
billieljaime wrote: »so when I did low carb Atkins was all the rage and there were guidlines it did not mean i could eat a tub of lard because there was no lard....
seriously would you drink five liters of diet coke because there are no calories or six pots of coffee because there are no calories?
The simple answer is no because you would feel like crap and not meet your health goals
didn't some people take atkins to the extreme and start eating steak and bacon all day????
Years ago, probably 15 or so, I had to run to the store to pick up heavy cream because I was making shrimp Alfredo pasta for my mom visiting from out of town (her favorite meal). Standing in line at the checkout, I heard a guy behind me saying, "hey. Are you on Atkins? Hey... You on Atkins?" I didn't think he was talking to me but then he tapped me on the shoulder and asked again. "Are you on Atkins? It's awesome. I'm on it and I drink that stuff all the time and you can eat pork rinds and I've lost 25 lbs!" I said, "you eat pork rinds and drink heavy cream and you are bragging about that to strangers in public?" I wasn't even trying to be snarky. I was seriously dumbfounded.
In full disclosure it was at Walmart....
Whu, it's like cereal.0 -
people drink cream ? :shock:
bleurghh0 -
I think I mentioned it in another thread, don't know if its in the one you are referring to.
Low carbs or high carbs doesnt matter for weight loss, all that matters is CICO. Why some people are in denial regarding this I don't know...
Now, I consider myself a low-carber. For the past couple of weeks I've been eating consistently less than 50g of carbs per day but the only reason I do this, and found it through experimentation, is that most carbs (except maybe rice) don't satiate my hunger as much as protein and fat does. For me this is great because eating a couple of chicken breasts with a salad keep me full for longer than eating a plate of ravioli, so I'm less prone to overeating and binging. Now, I still eat under my TDEE, because CICO is the important thing for loosing weight, the high protein/low carb for me is just another tool to keep my hunger under control.
With that being said, I don't believe this helps an emotional eater for instance, because they eat not because they are hungry really but because they are stressed, depressed, etc... or maybe there is people were their bodies are used function different to mine and find a high-carb/lowish-protein meal more satiating, I don't know.0 -
I'm low carb (keto) and believe in cico. If I eat more than I should, I gain..just like everyone else.
Keto works better for me than calorie counting alone because I have reactive hypoglycemia.
0 -
do you mean like just butter .. or butter melted into hot toast .. because I know which one I could cope with0 -
do you mean like just butter .. or butter melted into hot toast .. because I know which one I could cope with
yes, there are people who EAT BUTTER.
i love me some butter, but please put it on or in something LOLOL
I think for MOST people (barring diabetes or other health concern) a normal diet, with the normal rec. amount of carbs is fine. of course CICO matters, some people (not all just some) are just... in denial? or maybe they are (coincidentally) eating at their number without meaning to.
cant be concerned too much about what other people are doing, i have my own fat to worry about LOLOLOL0 -
do you mean like just butter .. or butter melted into hot toast .. because I know which one I could cope with
Just butter. It comes up one of two ways. Often, new people get obsessed with hitting their exact macros. It takes them a while to learn that it's carbs as an upper limit, protein as a definite goal, and fat to satiety. They come in thinking they must eat all 140g or whatever of fat every day, and will do whatever they can to do it. If they've already had their carbs, and don't know about fat bombs, options seem limited.
Others are people who end up with a huge deficit (MFP yells at you kind of deficit) at the end of the day and need something quick to add another 500 calories or so.0 -
The low-carb people that do not believe in cico usually argue that insulin is the fat storing hormone and that it gives you a metabolic advantage because the body is used to burning fat instead of carbs. A lot of low carbers disagree that cico do not matter.
The "moderate" low carbers usually agree that the main advantage is reduce hunger.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 934 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions