carbs...are they the enemy?
Options
Replies
-
High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance21
-
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
Okay, enough is enough. You keep posting this is multiple threads. Eating carbs does NOT stall weight loss. Period. Stop trying to sell your Keto consultation services.
12 -
cwolfman13 wrote: »No, carbs aren't the enemy...there are all kinds of highly nutritious carbohydrates...veggies are carbs, fruit is carbs, beans and lentils are carbs, potatoes and sweet potatoes and other starchy root vegetables are carbs...etc, etc, etc...Carlos_421 wrote: »Weight gain is caused by an excess of calories. How many of those calories come from carbs is irrelevant.
I beg to differ. If you take two people and put them on a 2000 calorie diet. One eats high carb low fat moderate protein. The other eats high protein moderate fat and low carbs. I guarantee the diet with low carb will not only produce better weight loss, the person will also have more stable blood glucose and will also have more mental focus and a much better mood.27 -
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
So much no.5 -
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
First off, Sources please?? Second, stop spamming this like it's the hardcore truth.10 -
MCummings720 wrote: »cwolfman13 wrote: »No, carbs aren't the enemy...there are all kinds of highly nutritious carbohydrates...veggies are carbs, fruit is carbs, beans and lentils are carbs, potatoes and sweet potatoes and other starchy root vegetables are carbs...etc, etc, etc...Carlos_421 wrote: »Weight gain is caused by an excess of calories. How many of those calories come from carbs is irrelevant.
I beg to differ. If you take two people and put them on a 2000 calorie diet. One eats high carb low fat moderate protein. The other eats high protein moderate fat and low carbs. I guarantee the diet with low carb will not only produce better weight loss, the person will also have more stable blood glucose and will also have more mental focus and a much better mood.
Science begs to differ with your beliefs and I tend to stick with what science tells me over woo.8 -
,.. just passing through!6
-
MCummings720 wrote: »cwolfman13 wrote: »No, carbs aren't the enemy...there are all kinds of highly nutritious carbohydrates...veggies are carbs, fruit is carbs, beans and lentils are carbs, potatoes and sweet potatoes and other starchy root vegetables are carbs...etc, etc, etc...Carlos_421 wrote: »Weight gain is caused by an excess of calories. How many of those calories come from carbs is irrelevant.
I beg to differ. If you take two people and put them on a 2000 calorie diet. One eats high carb low fat moderate protein. The other eats high protein moderate fat and low carbs. I guarantee the diet with low carb will not only produce better weight loss, the person will also have more stable blood glucose and will also have more mental focus and a much better mood.
Are they eating at the exact same deficit? If so, the only difference in weight loss is that the one eating low carb will lose more water weight, but the same amount of fat as the high carb person.10 -
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
This has been studied. Over the longer term, there is no advantage to limiting carbs.10 -
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
When I had gestational diabetes, and my fasting blood draw was through the roof, my dietitian was very adamant about me eating a certain number of carbs, for my health and my baby. Through the course of the day I was to consume 200 grams of carbs total to regulate my blood sugar. I lost a little weight at the end of my pregnancy because I was eating healthier, and my full term baby was 7 lbs. Carbs are our friends. Consuming excess calories is not.
6 -
Carbs are a frienemy.2
-
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
All my vegan friends from the yoga center were thinner than I was. Perhaps JivanMukti Yoga has some magical anti-fat storage properties that Kripalu Yoga lacks?8 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Meh. You lose about 30-40% of the vitamin C boiling peeled potatoes. If you eat a varied diet, you can get plenty of vitamin C from other sources.
I find boiled potatoes to be one of the most satiating foods I can eat. I'll continue to boil them.
I tend to boil mine early in the day to save time later, and there's an argument to be made that in doing that and reheating them that I'm creating resistant starch, which is all kinds of good for my gut bacteria.
Another reason to not peel potatoes...3 -
I've lost more than 60 pounds eating 50-60% of my intake as carbs. They are my friend: confidently and securely so.
I would be sooooo miserable eating low carb.5 -
The answer to OP is no. While preference and health status are individual, carb intake does not affect weight loss in any meaningful way beyond calorie intake. I have lost 120 lbs averaging over 250 grams of carbs a day. No magical physics-defying insulin response prevented me from losing weight and they actually improve my mood and are much better at controlling my hunger than fats, which helps me stick to my calories and lose weight. Just log accurately and eat in a way that feels most natural and comfortable to you and you should be better primed for weight loss than forcing yourself to eat a certain way and finding stressful.5
-
I am diabetic so I do need to watch my carbs - however, they are definitely not the enemy. In fact they will help you power through workouts. Having a blood glucose meter has helped me see the direct result of putting food into my body and exercising: food is fuel!
Whole fruits contain fiber, vitamins, and other micronutrients as well as carbs. They are good for you and delicious. Even for a diabetic like me, the fiber in whole fruit slows digestion enough that a reasonable serving of fruit doesn't spike my blood glucose, and for a healthy person like you, there is no reason in the world not to eat fruit. Eating a high carb diet does not lead to weight gain - weight gain is about calories, not carbs.3 -
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
^ Keto woo. Not a single bit of that is true. There is ZERO net fat storage while in a caloric deficit. That is a scientific fact. Very basic physiology.8 -
Carbs are the only macro I sometimes exceed target on. (I'm an ovo-lacto vegetarian. Most of my protein has carbs in it.) As I type this, I'm enjoying some homemade peach sorbet (peaches, sugar, water, and lemon juice). Over 77 lbs lost in 9 months. No hint of a stall.3
-
MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
I've lost over 130lbs with my carb intake making up 50-60% of my daily calories. I must be an alien or an escaped lab experiment. Oh my...5 -
Wynterbourne wrote: »MCummings720 wrote: »High carbs will absolutely stall weight loss. As soon as carbs are ingested insulin is released. Insulin is a fat storage hormone. When your body needs fuel and uses glycogen (carbs) and it doesn't use them all that you have ingested then the excess is converted to fat. Instead look into a Keto diet. I am here to help if you need any assistance
I've lost over 130lbs with my carb intake making up 50-60% of my daily calories. I must be an alien or an escaped lab experiment. Oh my...
70 lbs. (and about 20% bodyfat) lost here, my carbs are set at 40% of my daily intake. And I eat grains, sugars and processed carbs on a fairly regular basis <gasp!>5
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 398 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 976 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions