Starvation Mode is Real, and ugly
Replies
-
This is a very informative post...
It's just shook me out of feeling sorry for myself, for only losing 1 lb this week.... and made me realise that I just should be happy that I'm still losing....
plus I'm replying, so I can share this with a friend who is slowly coming to terms with what the negative effects are from eating too little calories....
Thanks...0 -
Thank you so much for this!0
-
I think MFP is a great tool. I love the site. I don't think their formula is the wisest.
http://www.bmi-calculator.net/bmr-calculator/
I got my current information here. I'm now making a slight deficit-- my body right now supposedly needs 2500 for my activity level, et cetera-- and I'm eating 2100-2200. Much better than the 1200 calorie deficit I was putting my body through.
No freaking wonder my body rebelled.
Curious what MFP's maintenance was for you - with an active or very active setting? 9 kids alone has to put you there. :laugh:
At 164, it would have me at 2220 for maintenance, 2470 right now at 200 pounds.
I never had myself at a very active setting, though, because I have a typing job and spend a portion of my day on my fanny. I'm seeing your point, whether you meant it or not, that MFP's settings might be more accurate than I thought-- I just didn't have myself at the right activity level.0 -
I'm sorry to hear you have worked so hard, only to discover you were starving yourself :frown: I really think you will turn it around though! You seem like the type who has the willpower, that's for sure. Good luck! I hope your body gives ya break and your metabolism returns to normal very soon. BTW, very well written post
thank you!0 -
This is a very informative post...
It's just shook me out of feeling sorry for myself, for only losing 1 lb this week.... and made me realise that I just should be happy that I'm still losing....
plus I'm replying, so I can share this with a friend who is slowly coming to terms with what the negative effects are from eating too little calories....
Thanks...
Yes, please share it-- there is so much misinformation out there, and people not eating enough. I know it goes against the grain of what we always have thought was proper, but again, I'm living proof that what we have thought was right, isn't.0 -
Major victory at the moment-- I have never been able to run in the sunlight since beginning my weight loss journey.
I got to thinking the other day that perhaps the reason I wilt so flippin' fast in the sun, no matter the temperature, is because I haven't been receiving the proper nutrition.
I just ran 2 and a quarter miles, bright blue sky, bright sun shining. 45 degrees. Light jacket. (I'd rather hoped the run was longer-- I was a bit discouraged when I mapped it upon my return-- but, oh well-- )
Last year I would have wilted. My friends all know I "can't" run in the daylight.
I did it!!! And I came home and had a protein shake to replenish.
There's something to this proper nutrition stuff-- woo-hoooooo!!!!!!!0 -
I think MFP is a great tool. I love the site. I don't think their formula is the wisest.
http://www.bmi-calculator.net/bmr-calculator/
I got my current information here. I'm now making a slight deficit-- my body right now supposedly needs 2500 for my activity level, et cetera-- and I'm eating 2100-2200. Much better than the 1200 calorie deficit I was putting my body through.
No freaking wonder my body rebelled.
Curious what MFP's maintenance was for you - with an active or very active setting? 9 kids alone has to put you there. :laugh:
At 164, it would have me at 2220 for maintenance, 2470 right now at 200 pounds.
I never had myself at a very active setting, though, because I have a typing job and spend a portion of my day on my fanny. I'm seeing your point, whether you meant it or not, that MFP's settings might be more accurate than I thought-- I just didn't have myself at the right activity level.
Yeah, I understand activity level can be tricky. But honestly, even with a typing job, I really would think that the activity with the kids (I only have one and he wears me the hell out lol), and the running you do, would be at least active. Because even though you enter exercise separately, it seems to me that some women in your circumstances (with several kids and a high exercise level) often underestimate what they actually do on a daily basis (modesty is a virtue, but can be a problem in this case
)
I don't recall seeing it in the thread anywhere - have you thought about having BMR tested? I would think that could be really helpful for you. For you, at least, BMR and where your settings are at could be particularly problematic. You have several things going on that could either lower or raise BMR - and finding out which end of the scale you're on could at least get the basics on point. I don't know that it's important for a lot of people, but in your situation, it could be. Just a thought.0 -
So proud of you! Running in the daytime is a HUGE victory for you!0
-
Thank you so much for sharing this! A lot really thonk fewer calories is better but your story tells them the truth0
-
I think MFP is a great tool. I love the site. I don't think their formula is the wisest.
http://www.bmi-calculator.net/bmr-calculator/
I got my current information here. I'm now making a slight deficit-- my body right now supposedly needs 2500 for my activity level, et cetera-- and I'm eating 2100-2200. Much better than the 1200 calorie deficit I was putting my body through.
No freaking wonder my body rebelled.
Curious what MFP's maintenance was for you - with an active or very active setting? 9 kids alone has to put you there. :laugh:
At 164, it would have me at 2220 for maintenance, 2470 right now at 200 pounds.
I never had myself at a very active setting, though, because I have a typing job and spend a portion of my day on my fanny. I'm seeing your point, whether you meant it or not, that MFP's settings might be more accurate than I thought-- I just didn't have myself at the right activity level.
Yeah, I understand activity level can be tricky. But honestly, even with a typing job, I really would think that the activity with the kids (I only have one and he wears me the hell out lol), and the running you do, would be at least active. Because even though you enter exercise separately, it seems to me that some women in your circumstances (with several kids and a high exercise level) often underestimate what they actually do on a daily basis (modesty is a virtue, but can be a problem in this case )
I don't recall seeing it in the thread anywhere - have you thought about having BMR tested? I would think that could be really helpful for you. For you, at least, BMR and where your settings are at could be particularly problematic. You have several things going on that could either lower or raise BMR - and finding out which end of the scale you're on could at least get the basics on point. I don't know that it's important for a lot of people, but in your situation, it could be. Just a thought.
Yes, modesty in this case can be a problem-- I always had myself at "moderate."
I don't know how to have BMR tested. 'splain.0 -
So proud of you! Running in the daytime is a HUGE victory for you!
I Know!! Thanks, Sara-- I'm stoked right now!!!0 -
Yes, modesty in this case can be a problem-- I always had myself at "moderate."
I don't know how to have BMR tested. 'splain.
They often offer RMR (similar to BMR) testing at gyms (don't usually have to be a member), or you can check with your doc. Basically just gives you a much more accurate estimate of your BMR. In your situation, you may not be "average" - so you might be outside the curve that most BMR calculators cover. I think it usually costs around $100. If you do a search on "RMR test" for your area, you could probably find some places that do it.0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:0
-
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Yeah, I would assume most RDs have the capability.0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Actually, I think I heard of one in the Bahamas!!! Whaddyasay?0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Actually, I think I heard of one in the Bahamas!!! Whaddyasay?
marla pm me the town you live in in PA, I'll look up bod pods and hydrostatic testing for you. they aren't super expensive (usually fifty bucks or so), and you'll get your body fat, TDEE, and a few other very useful numbers from them.0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Actually, I think I heard of one in the Bahamas!!! Whaddyasay?
marla pm me the town you live in in PA, I'll look up bod pods and hydrostatic testing for you. they aren't super expensive (usually fifty bucks or so), and you'll get your body fat, TDEE, and a few other very useful numbers from them.
Done--
Thanks!0 -
Major victory at the moment-- I have never been able to run in the sunlight since beginning my weight loss journey.
I got to thinking the other day that perhaps the reason I wilt so flippin' fast in the sun, no matter the temperature, is because I haven't been receiving the proper nutrition.
I just ran 2 and a quarter miles, bright blue sky, bright sun shining. 45 degrees. Light jacket. (I'd rather hoped the run was longer-- I was a bit discouraged when I mapped it upon my return-- but, oh well-- )
Last year I would have wilted. My friends all know I "can't" run in the daylight.
I did it!!! And I came home and had a protein shake to replenish.
There's something to this proper nutrition stuff-- woo-hoooooo!!!!!!!
Holy crap - starvation mode turned you into a vampire? Now I have heard it all....
Where you supplementing to any degree while on your low cal / high exercise binge? Perhaps a multivitamin?
If not it could be a magnesium deficiency leading to light sensitivity which has now been remedied through diet. Where you having headaches as well?0 -
Major victory at the moment-- I have never been able to run in the sunlight since beginning my weight loss journey.
I got to thinking the other day that perhaps the reason I wilt so flippin' fast in the sun, no matter the temperature, is because I haven't been receiving the proper nutrition.
I just ran 2 and a quarter miles, bright blue sky, bright sun shining. 45 degrees. Light jacket. (I'd rather hoped the run was longer-- I was a bit discouraged when I mapped it upon my return-- but, oh well-- )
Last year I would have wilted. My friends all know I "can't" run in the daylight.
I did it!!! And I came home and had a protein shake to replenish.
There's something to this proper nutrition stuff-- woo-hoooooo!!!!!!!
Holy crap - starvation mode turned you into a vampire? Now I have heard it all....
Where you supplementing to any degree while on your low cal / high exercise binge? Perhaps a multivitamin?
If not it could be a magnesium deficiency leading to light sensitivity which has now been remedied through diet. Where you having headaches as well?
A vampire?? maybe that's why I hate garlic!
Actually the issue was basically just overheating. I'd get one mile into a run, and just die. I could run at dusk, as the sun was setting. But, anything when the sun was casting a shadow would just totally wipe me out. I couldn't run another step.
Multi-vite? Much to my husband's frustration, not with any responsible regularity. He gets so mad at me.
No headaches.0 -
Major victory at the moment-- I have never been able to run in the sunlight since beginning my weight loss journey.
I got to thinking the other day that perhaps the reason I wilt so flippin' fast in the sun, no matter the temperature, is because I haven't been receiving the proper nutrition.
I just ran 2 and a quarter miles, bright blue sky, bright sun shining. 45 degrees. Light jacket. (I'd rather hoped the run was longer-- I was a bit discouraged when I mapped it upon my return-- but, oh well-- )
Last year I would have wilted. My friends all know I "can't" run in the daylight.
I did it!!! And I came home and had a protein shake to replenish.
There's something to this proper nutrition stuff-- woo-hoooooo!!!!!!!
Holy crap - starvation mode turned you into a vampire? Now I have heard it all....
Where you supplementing to any degree while on your low cal / high exercise binge? Perhaps a multivitamin?
If not it could be a magnesium deficiency leading to light sensitivity which has now been remedied through diet. Where you having headaches as well?
OK...the vampire thing had me cracking up!! But seriously Marla, CONGRATULATIONS!!! God always takes our sufferings and uses them! He is certainly using this really difficult situation for you and blessing so many other people! Huge thumbs up!!
Donna0 -
A vampire?? maybe that's why I hate garlic!
Actually the issue was basically just overheating. I'd get one mile into a run, and just die. I could run at dusk, as the sun was setting. But, anything when the sun was casting a shadow would just totally wipe me out. I couldn't run another step.
Multi-vite? Much to my husband's frustration, not with any responsible regularity. He gets so mad at me.
No headaches.
You hate garlic? Damn, my life wouldn't be worth living without it but then I am more wolf than bat
Well I am glad a) that it isn't a magnesium deficiency and b) you get to experience the pleasure of running outside with the sun in your face and the wind in your hair. The world is a wonderous place and over and above the way we look experiencing things like that make life such a joy.
Re: a mult vitamin. It's a good insurance policy but I don't think strictly necessary. If you eat a good, healthy diet then you will probably have the bases covered already.0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Actually, I think I heard of one in the Bahamas!!! Whaddyasay?
marla pm me the town you live in in PA, I'll look up bod pods and hydrostatic testing for you. they aren't super expensive (usually fifty bucks or so), and you'll get your body fat, TDEE, and a few other very useful numbers from them.
Done--
Thanks!
You promised me Bahamas! :sad:0 -
I've seen other people talk about it on here & if memory serves correctly, Registered Dieticians can also test for it. I'd like to look into it for myself, actually. Wanna go together, Marla? :drinker: Find some place in PA. :laugh:
Actually, I think I heard of one in the Bahamas!!! Whaddyasay?
marla pm me the town you live in in PA, I'll look up bod pods and hydrostatic testing for you. they aren't super expensive (usually fifty bucks or so), and you'll get your body fat, TDEE, and a few other very useful numbers from them.
Done--
Thanks!
You promised me Bahamas! :sad:
Uh, I mean--
0 -
:laugh: I like the hug, but I'm confused by the physical abuse. You never cease to amaze me, Marla. Have a great night! 0
-
:laugh: I like the hug, but I'm confused by the physical abuse. You never cease to amaze me, Marla. Have a great night!
I'm a riddle wrapped in an enigma.
maybe that's why I'm so fat??0 -
wow...thanks for the info!0
-
Don't make me come over there, young lady! *hugs*0
-
Really, really struggling today-- have no idea what's going on.
No change in weight, but the bloating is unbelievably out of control. I can't fit into any of my pants. Every cell seems to be positively overloaded with water and fat--
It always seems worse the days after I exercise-- anybody have thoughts on that? I'm looking positively, woefully rotund today in my stretchy pants and all-covering hoody.
Very sad in New Jersey this day-- can't look in the mirror without sobbing. I need to get a grip.
I've worked so hard. I've never stopped. I've done all the "right" things. This just freaking sucks.0 -
BUMP ! .. this brought me back to my senses ..I wish you all the best hun, hope you get back to your healthy self0
-
this is what i keep telling people. dont sweat it if you go over on a few days so long as when you switch the setting to maintenance level you have not gone over that you wont put on weight, but if you eat to few calories you will store what little you do eat. to many people get obsessed with "oh no i cant have' AND DOING TOO MUCH EXCERCISE AND NOT EATING THE BURNED CALORIES WILL MAKE YOU GO INTO STARVATION MODE.. slow and steady keep it off, is the best way, we didn get big overnight no way we will lose it that way0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions