A Personal View on Exercise Cals and Underfeeding
Replies
-
I should really add that while growing up I was taught the "food pyramid" of course at a basic public school principal...but that doesn't mean that I understood it. ESPECIALLY in the way that I am learning how nutrition works now, as an adult. To think that the last time I was taught nutrition was back in high school (really could've cared less back then) is sad to think. I was active in sports in HS, had a lean body so I didn't really care what I put in or out of it at the time so long as I performed well. It's nobody's fault but my own of course but after reflecting on my past, it's a wonder that nutrition isn't required even at a higher education level, being a Gen Ed for instance... looking back, I wish it were. Or at least emphasized more.0
-
I should really add that while growing up I was taught the "food pyramid" of course at a basic public school principal...but that doesn't mean that I understood it. ESPECIALLY in the way that I am learning how nutrition works now, as an adult. To think that the last time I was taught nutrition was back in high school (really could've cared less back then) is sad to think. I was active in sports in HS, had a lean body so I didn't really care what I put in or out of it at the time so long as I performed well. It's nobody's fault but my own of course but after reflecting on my past, it's a wonder that nutrition isn't required even at a higher education level, being a Gen Ed for instance... looking back, I wish it were. Or at least emphasized more.
It drives me CRAZY that nutrition isn't addressed better all throughout school. Besides the awful food in the cafeteria (although to be fair some schools are working on that), but like you, I think we had one or two short sections on the food pyramid - but no real significant education on how to apply even a basic pattern of healthy intake and exercise. I think the rapidity with which our lifestyles have changed (from manual labor and high activity levels with whole foods to a sedentary society with processed foods) has kind of left everyone at a loss as to how to compensate. Now whole generations are having to re-learn what health is and how to achieve it - and mostly on their own.
And that's great that you're working on the allergies. I know it's a long process, but hopefully it will make a huge difference in your daily life and overall health.0 -
Bump
0 -
Just wanted to say THANK YOU!!!
I am new to MFP as I just started two weeks ago. I have LOVED how easy it is to track the calories and exercise on this website, But have wondered about eating my work out calories. I just assumed that as long as I ate my 1200 Calories then the extra I was burning while exercising was like a bonus. However I am not noticing this bonus on the scale...I appreciate you putting your story, struggles and advise out there for all of us to read! And I am now going to eat my work out calories!!0 -
Just wanted to say THANK YOU!!!
I am new to MFP as I just started two weeks ago. I have LOVED how easy it is to track the calories and exercise on this website, But have wondered about eating my work out calories. I just assumed that as long as I ate my 1200 Calories then the extra I was burning while exercising was like a bonus. However I am not noticing this bonus on the scale...I appreciate you putting your story, struggles and advise out there for all of us to read! And I am now going to eat my work out calories!!
You're very welcome. Glad if it helps in any way. Don't be alarmed if you gain a couple of lbs at first - that's normal when you increase intake. May last a couple of weeks, and then the scale should start dropping again. Good luck to you! :flowerforyou:0 -
bump0
-
Thank you for such an honest account of your story. It is also nice to read a post on this topic that is "sane" - not over-dramatized or hyperbolic. Your story and mine are very similar, in the way that weight was gained. I never thought when I was a size 0 that I would be sitting where I am today, but I am trying to reverse the damage that I've done. Good luck in your journey, you should be incredibly proud of making the decision to choose health, and not illness.
Agreed! & same story here! Hard retraining ones-self to eat more then 900-1200 cals after years of bad under-eating habits but it is possible! good luck to you both!0 -
Thanks for the article! I'm on the sidelines myself because it's hard to eat more and eat back my exercise calories.
Has anyone seen better results by eating exercise calories back?
YES YES YES
Look at my ticker. We have the same stats. I am 5'2" as well.
I started here, ignorantly ate the 1200 they told me to eat and lost at first but then stopped. I only started to lose more when I started eating 1500 a day. Reached goal range 6 months ago and now I eat 1600-2200 a day depending on if I lounged around all day or was on my feet all day.
Always looking for smart people with similar stats to remind me why I need to push to eat more then 1200 cals a day! Thank you!0 -
On the standard 1200 that MFP likes to throw around, I was weak, tired, and cranky...
...(and as a reference point: I am 5'2" and weigh 104 lbs, so if 1200 is starving for ME, it is probably starving to 95% of people who read this, because the bigger you are the more you need to survive.)
I have been advising anyone who will listen that 1200 is too low and to eat more.
Okay, THANK YOU! I only joined MFP last weekend and when I put in my numbers and it spit back 1270 net calories for me (and that was for a more aggressive 2 lbs/week loss), I was floored. I am 5'9", in my late 20s, and active. My eyes got big as saucers and I realized that that wouldn't work for me at all. I changed my settings to 1 lb weight loss per week instead and that seems much more reasonable. However, I've been coming in under net calories by as many as 700+ a couple of days this week, and once I woke up an hour after I went to bed with a stomach that was screaming at me for more food. (Even though my dinner was quite satisfying earlier...it was the hour of bellydance class I did after that that put me way under calories again.)
In reading this wonderful post and some of your responses, I now have a better understanding of what my body is trying to tell me with regards to coming in so far under my caloric goals. I realize now that I could actually be sabotaging my efforts if I stay in this state of being-on-the-edge-of-hunger for most of the day.0 -
On the standard 1200 that MFP likes to throw around, I was weak, tired, and cranky...
...(and as a reference point: I am 5'2" and weigh 104 lbs, so if 1200 is starving for ME, it is probably starving to 95% of people who read this, because the bigger you are the more you need to survive.)
I have been advising anyone who will listen that 1200 is too low and to eat more.
Okay, THANK YOU! I only joined MFP last weekend and when I put in my numbers and it spit back 1270 net calories for me (and that was for a more aggressive 2 lbs/week loss), I was floored. I am 5'9", in my late 20s, and active. My eyes got big as saucers and I realized that that wouldn't work for me at all. I changed my settings to 1 lb weight loss per week instead and that seems much more reasonable. However, I've been coming in under net calories by as many as 700+ a couple of days this week, and once I woke up an hour after I went to bed with a stomach that was screaming at me for more food. (Even though my dinner was quite satisfying earlier...it was the hour of bellydance class I did after that that put me way under calories again.)
In reading this wonderful post and some of your responses, I now have a better understanding of what my body is trying to tell me with regards to coming in so far under my caloric goals. I realize now that I could actually be sabotaging my efforts if I stay in this state of being-on-the-edge-of-hunger for most of the day.
This is a very common mistake. When we sign up, we see the options and it's natural to think "Well, if 1 lb a week is good - 2 lbs per week is Great!" We'd all love the fastest results possible, but what appeals to us in that sense is often counter-productive. Good luck in reaching your goals!0 -
Bump...again.0
-
What about zig zagging calories- is that still a good thing or is that teaching your body to load up on carbs?
****.
maybe i should eat more
I'm still not sure if i'm buying it though. I usually average 1,100 - 1,000 cals a week-i binge maybe once a month and that's 2,000 calories tops! usually 1,600-1,800 would be my "binge"
am I in the wrong? This week I may try 1,200 cals average but I'm not going to lie I am still very hesitant.0 -
If zigzagging is done properly, no, it won't cause starvation mode. When it's done properly, you still average the amount of calories of your daily cal goal. And the higher days should not really have a higher ratio of carbs. The macro (protein/fat/carbs) ratios should generally be consistent on high and low days.
The amount of cals you need is dependent on height, weight, age, activity level, exercise.0 -
Hope I'm ok-My little brother had his communion and so I went out to lunch and had cake and ice-cream and ate candy with everyone. So i guess I binged. But it was a special occacion and very fun
so today I ate 500 calories-but If I go back to my goal of eating 1,200 calories-loosing a little less than a pound a week- I should be ok?-still loose a bit of weight / maintain (never become less than 17.5) ? I may be on the too thin side but I don't feel like I'm starving myself or setting myself up for disaster. ... but now I'm kind of worried-btw thanks for your reply!! 0 -
please keep bumping this!!0
-
Hope I'm ok-My little brother had his communion and so I went out to lunch and had cake and ice-cream and ate candy with everyone. So i guess I binged. But it was a special occacion and very fun so today I ate 500 calories-but If I go back to my goal of eating 1,200 calories-loosing a little less than a pound a week- I should be ok?-still loose a bit of weight / maintain (never become less than 17.5) ? I may be on the too thin side but I don't feel like I'm starving myself or setting myself up for disaster. ... but now I'm kind of worried-btw thanks for your reply!!
From what I can see of your stats (which is very little), you should not be trying to that much per week. That is far too aggressive for the stage you're at.
Again, I'd need more info (height, weight, age, activity level and exercise) to be able to give any kind of advice on what your cal goals should be.0 -
Hope I'm ok-My little brother had his communion and so I went out to lunch and had cake and ice-cream and ate candy with everyone. So i guess I binged. But it was a special occacion and very fun so today I ate 500 calories-but If I go back to my goal of eating 1,200 calories-loosing a little less than a pound a week- I should be ok?-still loose a bit of weight / maintain (never become less than 17.5) ? I may be on the too thin side but I don't feel like I'm starving myself or setting myself up for disaster. ... but now I'm kind of worried-btw thanks for your reply!!
From what I can see of your stats (which is very little), you should not be trying to that much per week. That is far too aggressive for the stage you're at.
Again, I'd need more info (height, weight, age, activity level and exercise) to be able to give any kind of advice on what your cal goals should be.
Feel free to send me a mail if you'd like to discuss it privately. :flowerforyou:0 -
Hope I'm ok-My little brother had his communion and so I went out to lunch and had cake and ice-cream and ate candy with everyone. So i guess I binged. But it was a special occacion and very fun so today I ate 500 calories-but If I go back to my goal of eating 1,200 calories-loosing a little less than a pound a week- I should be ok?-still loose a bit of weight / maintain (never become less than 17.5) ? I may be on the too thin side but I don't feel like I'm starving myself or setting myself up for disaster. ... but now I'm kind of worried-btw thanks for your reply!!
From what I can see of your stats (which is very little), you should not be trying to that much per week. That is far too aggressive for the stage you're at.
Again, I'd need more info (height, weight, age, activity level and exercise) to be able to give any kind of advice on what your cal goals should be.
I'm not really trying to loose-Mostly stay the same maybe loose a tiny tiny bit per week-I just don't want to gain. i'm 5'7'' and 117pounds right now (also just got my period :)so maybe more like 115pounds-I would like to know of other thin girls who eat 1,400 or so calories-I just don't believe its possible-kind of why i'm on/like this site0 -
Hope I'm ok-My little brother had his communion and so I went out to lunch and had cake and ice-cream and ate candy with everyone. So i guess I binged. But it was a special occacion and very fun so today I ate 500 calories-but If I go back to my goal of eating 1,200 calories-loosing a little less than a pound a week- I should be ok?-still loose a bit of weight / maintain (never become less than 17.5) ? I may be on the too thin side but I don't feel like I'm starving myself or setting myself up for disaster. ... but now I'm kind of worried-btw thanks for your reply!!
From what I can see of your stats (which is very little), you should not be trying to that much per week. That is far too aggressive for the stage you're at.
Again, I'd need more info (height, weight, age, activity level and exercise) to be able to give any kind of advice on what your cal goals should be.
I'm not really trying to loose-Mostly stay the same maybe loose a tiny tiny bit per week-I just don't want to gain. i'm 5'7'' and 117pounds right now (also just got my period :)so maybe more like 115pounds-I would like to know of other thin girls who eat 1,400 or so calories-I just don't believe its possible-kind of why i'm on/like this site
Well, first, I'm going to say that I think you're probably too thin. IMO, healthy is infinitely more attractive (and sustainable) than just thin. That's just my opinion, take it for what it's worth.
If you scroll back to page 3 and read Robin52077's posts, you can see she's much smaller than you and eats far more. If you send her a friend request or mail her, I'm sure she'd be happy to talk to you about it.
At 5'7", your BMR is about 1325. That is what you burn just being alive, as if in a coma. With just a sedentary activity level, your maintenance calories are about 1725. However, there's a good chance you've slowed your metabolism and would need to work up to that level to avoid gaining weight. If you begin adding about 50 cals a day, every 2 weeks or so, you shouldn't see a gain. And by doing that, you would increase your metabolism again, so that you wouldn't HAVE to eat so little to avoid gaining.0 -
What a great post and I eco what many other have said, well balanced, couragous, thoughtful and generous. Thank you.
I too was not educated in eating back exercise calories and confused when I got here and didn't want to do anything to impede my progress of compound the weight/health problems. I come from an athletic background and have never been one to starve myself or count calories until I got to MFP. I lean on my brother too who is a sucessful well trainer and WHEN I can get a hold of him he is tremendously supportive and helpful. I rejoice in eating my calories back since I love food - healthy food. Never been really into junk food. For me my problem was really lack of exersice and portion control as well as cutting back on decident glamerous foods. I feel like I'm on the "right" track and think I'm eating enough - hope I'm not over eating, but I guess we'll see. I bought a HRM which is helping me to see the picture clearer but I still know there is no "perfect" recording for me. I'm loosing and toning so again I think I'm on the right track.
I am looking for more MFP friends who have done some research and are finding solid information to back up their posts as well a finding success in their fitness/healthy nutrition journey. I'm certainly going to be friending several folks from this post as there are many who seem to have a balanced and knowledge based perspective.
Thanks again!0 -
thankyouthankyouthankyou
it's kinda nerve racking-i'm eating 1,200 this week-more than my usual then 1,300 next and then i'll see how I feel-one of my goals is more strength training and yoga because I don't feel toned at all
also my whole WHOLE family is overweight-so i'm terrified i'll end up like that-I love them but honestly-they are not taking care of themselves. I also wonder if their is such a thing as having a low metabolism/bmr or if that happens because one messes it up.
I know I know-so many questions sorry 0 -
thankyouthankyouthankyou
it's kinda nerve racking-i'm eating 1,200 this week-more than my usual then 1,300 next and then i'll see how I feel-one of my goals is more strength training and yoga because I don't feel toned at all
also my whole WHOLE family is overweight-so i'm terrified i'll end up like that-I love them but honestly-they are not taking care of themselves. I also wonder if their is such a thing as having a low metabolism/bmr or if that happens because one messes it up.
I know I know-so many questions sorry
Some strength training would do great things. Be aware that when starting strength training, you can have some water retention in the muscles as they repair - but DON'T let that dissuade you from doing it. A little bit of muscle also increases metabolism, so it will help you maintain your weight in the long run. And it looks nice.
There can certainly be a connection between genetics and being overweight. A slow metabolism can be connected to many things, such as genetics, medical conditions, medication, and underfeeding. However, that doesn't mean you're "destined" to be overweight. I would guess that if your metabolism is slowed, it's much more likely to be because of underfeeding. But even you have some genetic components that influence it, it's not something you can't overcome. You just have to experiment a bit to see what will work for YOUR body. But if you don't have any medical conditions, there shouldn't be any reason you can't get back to a reasonably normal intake without gaining. I know it's scary, but it's very worth it.0 -
WOW AMazing Thanks for posting this. At least I am not the only one in the same boat.0
-
I think for me the issue is that I have asked around about how many calories "a person like me" should have .. and it seems I get a lot of different answers. Now I know that when I've lifted weights often or done a lot of cardio, I should be more lenient with how much I eat. But no one can tell me what is appropriate, and I've gone back and forth .. . I've had male trainers tell me to eat a lot more, and I've gained weight. I've had times when I didn't count calories, and had trouble losing weight. Sometimes I lose weight (with a lot of exercise involved, not just diet) and then people tell me I should eat more. It's really hard to find out a definitive answer for "How many calories is appropriate for me and my level of activity?" .. . so confusing.0
-
I think for me the issue is that I have asked around about how many calories "a person like me" should have .. and it seems I get a lot of different answers. Now I know that when I've lifted weights often or done a lot of cardio, I should be more lenient with how much I eat. But no one can tell me what is appropriate, and I've gone back and forth .. . I've had male trainers tell me to eat a lot more, and I've gained weight. I've had times when I didn't count calories, and had trouble losing weight. Sometimes I lose weight (with a lot of exercise involved, not just diet) and then people tell me I should eat more. It's really hard to find out a definitive answer for "How many calories is appropriate for me and my level of activity?" .. . so confusing.
Well, the problem is that it revolves around basic math - BUT all of the numbers we use for energy expenditure and intake are estimates. And the math is based on averages. Each individual is different and there are a ton of factors than can influence what YOUR specific intake needs to be. Really it just takes a lot of experimenting. But in reality, very few people are so far outside the curve, or have a specific situation, that makes all of the numbers and formulas "not work." There may need to be adjustments, but the vast majority of people can use the basic formula to get a good starting point and will still be in the general neighborhood of what is recommended.
You may have some factors that put you slightly outside the curve, but unless you have some significant medical conditions (thyroid, PCOS, etc), there shouldn't be a huge difference.
Remember that a lot of trainers aren't certified, and even ones that are don't necessarily have a good background in nutrition.
But, once you've slowed your metabolism, it is normal and expected to see some weight gain if you suddenly start eating more. It can take a while to get things back to normal.0 -
This is pretty difficult for me. I never know how many calories I should be eating. I didn't buy the 1200 that MFP told me to eat so I did some research. I'm 5'7", work out 6 days a week. My BMR is 1493. According to my activity level, I should be eating 2314 calories/day in order to maintain my weight. In order to lose weight, I read I should create a calorie deficit of at least 500 calories, but nothing more than a 1000 calorie deficit. This is really hard! I've been averaging anywhere from 1200 - 1300 net calories and most times cannot push myself to get to the 1300 - 1800 range. I'm wondering if I can push for 1500 maybe I'll see more results? This is all a mind game! Sometimes I feel so full I feel fat and gross and get discouraged and I don't like feeling that way.
Thank you so much for your insight. I'm going to try and up my calories, but again it's all a mind game to me. Bottom line is I want to get healthy. It doesn't matter what my scale says. I want to tone up and feel good about myself again. And, I want my mommy tummy to go away. Lol!!0 -
I was just going to post a question in this direction. So glad you answered it.. Thanks!0
-
thanks for taking the time to write your novel (lol):laugh: seriously:indifferent: , i really enjoyed reading it and i know it must have been hard to share something personal. i hope others benefit from reading it as i have.0
-
This is pretty difficult for me. I never know how many calories I should be eating. I didn't buy the 1200 that MFP told me to eat so I did some research. I'm 5'7", work out 6 days a week. My BMR is 1493. According to my activity level, I should be eating 2314 calories/day in order to maintain my weight. In order to lose weight, I read I should create a calorie deficit of at least 500 calories, but nothing more than a 1000 calorie deficit. This is really hard! I've been averaging anywhere from 1200 - 1300 net calories and most times cannot push myself to get to the 1300 - 1800 range. I'm wondering if I can push for 1500 maybe I'll see more results? This is all a mind game! Sometimes I feel so full I feel fat and gross and get discouraged and I don't like feeling that way.
Thank you so much for your insight. I'm going to try and up my calories, but again it's all a mind game to me. Bottom line is I want to get healthy. It doesn't matter what my scale says. I want to tone up and feel good about myself again. And, I want my mommy tummy to go away. Lol!!
Sounds like you chose the 2 lb per week loss goal? Might be too high for what you have to lose. And if you're feeling deprived, by all means lower your loss per week goal. You need to find a plan that is sustainable for you. So even if it means slightly slower loss - that's better than feeling deprived and giving up.0 -
This was a courageous and thought provoking post. Bumping.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions