Planet Fitness?
Replies
-
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
Stereotype much?
I didn't stereotype anyone. I described a behavior that is likely to be frowned upon at a Planet Fitness.0 -
Just FYI, Planet Fitness probably won't tolerate throwing/dropping weights and yelling as Crossfitters do. Might wanna read up on policy and stuff.0
-
SonicDeathMonkey80 wrote: »Just FYI, Planet Fitness probably won't tolerate throwing/dropping weights and yelling as Crossfitters do. Might wanna read up on policy and stuff.
no gym should allow that nonsense0 -
Dave198lbs wrote: »
no gym should allow that nonsense
That is what the rubber weights are for. Dropping.
0 -
If you read my post, I already have those things at the gym in my office. But what I need is an affordable place with heavier weights and real barbells. My options are NYSC ($100 a month) or PF ($10), and I'm trying to access from actual personal experiences if it would be worth it. The location isn't open yet, so I dont know yet what equipment they will havemojohowitz wrote: »Sweet Jesus. Here we go again... If all you need is an elliptical, treadmill and some light weights it's fine. If you need more, you should probably find a different place.
0 -
Trans3last wrote: »Just go where it works for you. Avoid the "go to a real gym" elitism. It's not a matter of "anyone letting you", it's a matter of what works for you. So don't be a troublemaker and join, and "being surprised" about the rules. All fitness centers have rules. People that act ignorant of the rules, and get "surprised" that they can't do "such and such" exercise" are trying to get attention, nothing else. Gym time is not a fashion show, and some females need to admit the need to wear a 5x.
strong newbie post. lol.0 -
VincitQuiSeVincit wrote: »If you read my post, I already have those things at the gym in my office. But what I need is an affordable place with heavier weights and real barbells. My options are NYSC ($100 a month) or PF ($10), and I'm trying to access from actual personal experiences if it would be worth it. The location isn't open yet, so I dont know yet what equipment they will have
go with nysc and avoid wasting time.0 -
I am also by NYC area, do you have Crunch by you? I like it a much better and it's a really good gym, it's about $70 a month if you only go to one location. The NYSC by my office is like $70 a month, the one by you is pretty expensive.. maybe their price will drop once PF opens. Good luck
btw, saw your pic and what great progress you have made! You look great! Wish I can do OHS, been dying to try that :-P0 -
Dave198lbs wrote: »
no gym should allow that nonsense
If you are exerting yourself to your limit, a grunt might happen. That doesn't mean I condone yelling at the top of your lungs, but it happens.
If you are looking to find your one rep max on a lift and you stacked too much weight, or you are having an off day, the only safe way to get out of it is to bail. That involves dropping the barbell. That's why there are rubber weights.0 -
I didn't stereotype anyone. I described a behavior that is likely to be frowned upon at a Planet Fitness.
Right, and that's what's stupid about it. If you have to drop a weight because you can't lift it, it's better to drop it than to hurt yourself. We all have off days.
And, your experience at your gym is not in line with what I have heard at others. My friend gut lunked for checking out her form in the mirror. She was mortified.0 -
I didn't stereotype anyone. I described a behavior that is likely to be frowned upon at a Planet Fitness.
Sorry, but the way it was stated looked like you were stereotyping those of us who workout hard as being disruptive. I can assure that this is not something you see a lot and is frowned upon by most other lifters as being rather comical at best and outright rude and annoying at worst.0 -
This is simply untrue of my PF. They do not police what you can lift. They have lots of mirrors specifically so you can check your form, and although they do have a dress code, it is not over-restrictive at all. Sleeveless seems to be completely acceptable, and hot pants are everywhere. If by "get into your workout", you mean loudly grunt like an animal and disrupt everyone else's workout, then you may have a case on that last point.
And, also, I'm giving her advice from one CrossFitter to another. It's an entirely different culture. If she's into the CrossFit culture, she will not like the PF culture. I can guarantee it.0 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
Sorry, but the way it was stated looked like you were stereotyping those of us who workout hard as being disruptive. I can assure that this is not something you see a lot and is frowned upon by most other lifters as being rather comical at best and outright rude and annoying at worst.
Comparing people who are working out hard to animals is pretty stereotypical and very much what I would expect from the PF culture.0 -
PF and their judgy judgemental lunk alarm doesn't allow anything hard being done.
I seriously do NOT grasp this line of "reasoning" from a fitness center! Seems weird and cult-like or something.0 -
yopeeps025 wrote: »
That is what the rubber weights are for. Dropping.
I'd love to be able to drop the weight down after a power clean to OHP. But gyms that allow that are pretty rare outside of hardcore and CF gyms.0 -
Comparing people who are working out hard to animals is pretty stereotypical and very much what I would expect from the PF culture.
True, I give the benefit of the doubt (i.e. most generous reading) and assume he was refering to people who are grunting in a loud and exagerated manner. It is; however, inappropriate to label lifters as animals and I'm hoping that's not what he actually meant. I will give him that benefit.0 -
JeffseekingV wrote: »
I'd love to be able to drop the weight down after a power clean to OHP. But gyms that allow that are pretty rare outside of hardcore and CF gyms.
The only time dropping of weights intentionally tends to be acceptable is when they are bumper plates on a platform and that usually means CF, Olympic lifting or powerlifting specific areas/gyms. Bailing on a lift; however, is acceptable for safety reasons but they might have a word with you if you are habitually bailing.
ETA my current gym only has one area like that and it for PT only...sometimes I hate my gym!0 -
VincitQuiSeVincit wrote: »If you read my post, I already have those things at the gym in my office. But what I need is an affordable place with heavier weights and real barbells. My options are NYSC ($100 a month) or PF ($10), and I'm trying to access from actual personal experiences if it would be worth it. The location isn't open yet, so I dont know yet what equipment they will have
I am currently at a gym that is $10.00 a month and have been at ones that were $100.00 plus a month. I too needed heavier weights and barbells. The $10.00 is way over crowded. Granted they have a lot of equipment and pretty big, but I want to kill someone when you cannot get a bench or machine for a while. You can only do so much standing around. I go to the gym after 8:30pm late and that kinda makes it better, but if I had the money I would go to the more expensive one. Luckily I go late so less crowed and only need 3 nights a week for the heavy lifting. Wait till March/April comes and everyone wants to get in shape for the summer.
Good luck!
0 -
yopeeps025 wrote: »
I had a membership like 4 years ago. It used to be a decent gym. Now I do not know what to call it. I'm almost at the point where I would wear some type of camera and have a visit/leg day session. I squat and deadlift heavy on leg days. See how many lunk alarms I get in one visit.
I'm sure none, as they advertise themselves as a "Judgment Free Zone."
0 -
I would just wait and check it out when it opens. Most of them are very limited as far as free weights go, but I hear sometimes about PFs with squat racks that don't discourage lifting. I think the franchises vary.0
-
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
The only time dropping of weights intentionally tends to be acceptable is when they are bumper plates on a platform and that usually means CF, Olympic lifting or powerlifting specific areas/gyms. Bailing on a lift; however, is acceptable for safety reasons but they might have a word with you if you are habitually bailing.
When I was powerlifting, the gym had a platform that we could drop a failed dead on but not from the OHP position. Platform was too small and there were too many others too close to the area.0 -
JeffseekingV wrote: »
I'd love to be able to drop the weight down after a power clean to OHP. But gyms that allow that are pretty rare outside of hardcore and CF gyms.
I remember those gyms. Guys using 130lb non rubber dumbells for chest etc. You really had to stay out of the way.
0 -
PF is not meant to be for heavy serious lifters. They don't try and hide that fact and in fact they promote that fact because they are geared to a different audience. Not sure why that is so hard to accept by so many people. it is a successful business and it is a cheap way for someone to get into going to a gym and getting some exercise.0
-
I have some friends that go to Crunch gym. They're pretty happy with it.0
-
I used them as a supplemental gym for awhile (because they were a mile from my office), and I didn't hate it. The corporate owner of a gym doesn't matter as much as the manager and the regulars, IMHO. I got really lucky and found one with a dedicated group of regulars who all lifted, so it wasn't too bad. I'd go check them out and try to get a feel for the environment.0
-
Dave198lbs wrote: »PF is not meant to be for heavy serious lifters. They don't try and hide that fact and in fact they promote that fact because they are geared to a different audience. Not sure why that is so hard to accept by so many people. it is a successful business and it is a cheap way for someone to get into going to a gym and getting some exercise.
I agree to an extent. What bothers me is their slogan of being a "Judgment Free Zone," but their commercials are extremely judgmental.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Depends on how closely the new location aligns its rules w/ PF Corporate's. Assuming you can sign up with no contract, give it a try. If it works, great...and if not, then no real loss.0
-
I agree to an extent. What bothers me is their slogan of being a "Judgment Free Zone," but their commercials are extremely judgmental.
Yep!0 -
JeffseekingV wrote: »
When I was powerlifting, the gym had a platform that we could drop a failed dead on but not from the OHP position. Platform was too small and there were too many others too close to the area.
I can see that, particuarlly for safety reason and, of course, there is no OHP in PL.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 428 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 15 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions