Blood Type Diet Buddies?
stjohn8us
Posts: 12 Member
Hi! I'm blood type A and have been following the BTD for several years. It's the times when I get lazy and/or sloppy and eat "avoid" foods that I gain weight, become sluggish, sick, etc. I have lots of great recipes and good info on the Blood Type Diet. Looking for buddies to share with.
1
Replies
-
The blood type diet is complete woo. If you like the recipes that's great, but diet itself is based on a premise that has been totally debunked.23
-
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?1
-
"Woo" is the word many people here use to describe junk-science and mythology about many foods and diets. Just about anything touted by Dr. Oz, for example. Sometimes it's harmless, sometimes it's a ploy to sell something, sometimes it's an outright scam.
The blood type fad diet has been around since '97 and is touted by a naturopath. He even got it promoted on Dr. Oz at one point. The premise sounds "sciency" enough, but the diet plan works only when people end up eating less than they burn. My favorite anecdote about this diet was a person who lost weight and was thrilled, until he found out he had a different blood type than he thought and was eating the "wrong" plan.
And what if you were a vegan and you had blood type O? Would you throw your ethics out the window because a diet book told you to?
But don't just take my word for it. The University of Toronto did a pretty good study of it. Their conclusion:Adherence to certain ‘Blood-Type’ diets is associated with favorable effects on some cardiometabolic risk factors, but these associations were independent of an individual's ABO genotype, so the findings do not support the ‘Blood-Type’ diet hypothesis.
http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0084749
https://media.utoronto.ca/media-releases/health-medicine/theory-behind-popular-blood-type-diet-debunked/
Again, if you enjoy the structure and recipes, that's great. As long as you maintain a calorie deficit, you'll lose weight. But the premise of the diet is false, and we shouldn't encourage people to enrich the quacks who peddle woo like this.
23 -
Hm. I'd never heard of it but an interesting concept!1
-
"Woo" is the word many people here use to describe junk-science and mythology about many foods and diets. Just about anything touted by Dr. Oz, for example. Sometimes it's harmless, sometimes it's a ploy to sell something, sometimes it's an outright scam.
The blood type fad diet has been around since '97 and is touted by a naturopath. He even got it promoted on Dr. Oz at one point. The premise sounds "sciency" enough, but the diet plan works only when people end up eating less than they burn. My favorite anecdote about this diet was a person who lost weight and was thrilled, until he found out he had a different blood type than he thought and was eating the "wrong" plan.
And what if you were a vegan and you had blood type O? Would you throw your ethics out the window because a diet book told you to?
But don't just take my word for it. The University of Toronto did a pretty good study of it. Their conclusion:Adherence to certain ‘Blood-Type’ diets is associated with favorable effects on some cardiometabolic risk factors, but these associations were independent of an individual's ABO genotype, so the findings do not support the ‘Blood-Type’ diet hypothesis.
http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0084749
https://media.utoronto.ca/media-releases/health-medicine/theory-behind-popular-blood-type-diet-debunked/
Again, if you enjoy the structure and recipes, that's great. As long as you maintain a calorie deficit, you'll lose weight. But the premise of the diet is false, and we shouldn't encourage people to enrich the quacks who peddle woo like this.
This. So very true.
According to my blood type I should be eating a low carb high fat type diet......errrr, no thanks! That would actually cause me great grief (lots of intense stomach cramps, plus many more disturbing symptoms).
I remember reading about someone looking into the blood type diet for gits and shiggles. The diet recommended wheat. They have celiac......13 -
OP, I have the same blood type as you and I feel best when I eat a lot of meat.
As to your question for why else would some people do better on some diets than others, the answer is "pretty much any other reason than because of their blood type."12 -
I just looked up the lists for my blood type (AB+). I would be utterly miserable on that diet.8
-
EricaCraigie wrote: »Hm. I'd never heard of it but an interesting concept!
I mean really, how much money can they really make if they just tell people to eat less than they burn? ALL DIETS revolve around that. They just sprinkle it with other "woo" to make it sound super scientific when it's not.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
15 -
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
Genuinely curious - I'm type A and you can pry bacon from my cold, dead hands! I would be miserable and very cross as a vegetarian, even a "near" vegetarian. I actually lose weight better on a high protein (meat. not nuts!!) diet. How do you explain that one if the BTD makes sense?11 -
Looks like I should be trying an essentially paleo eating plan - not going to happen. The only thing interesting was that this type of diet says my blood type leads to hypothyroidism which I do have, unfortunately in the same paragraph it says potatoes will give me arthritis.4
-
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
I'm O neg and was vegan for most of my life. I hate red meat and eat mainly salmon now. Just because a friend follows that trend and enjoys meat doesn't make it fact for all. =/ There's too much information that proves it's all a lie. It would be like saying all horoscopes are true because during December you were concerned about money, but we all know they're just vague and they most likely wrote that because everyone is concerned about money around xmas time.
The only truth to the diet is that genetics can play part in what you can and can't eat. My parents both have issues with milk, I also have issue with milk but that doesn't mean their blood types are the cause.
http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0084749
https://www.utoronto.ca/news/popular-diet-theory-debunked
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/01/140115172246.htm
However if you're doing a diet you enjoy, then keep doing it.
3 -
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
She likes beef.
You like vegetables.
4 -
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
People fail on a particular diet because it does not fit their preferences, personality, hunger responses...etc. It's simply because people are different, and it has little to do with their blood type. I'm a type O and I very rarely eat beef because I don't like most kinds of meat. I like vegetables, grains, legumes and most things on the "not allowed" list and I hate most things on the "allowed" list. I have lost more than 100 pounds so far on a diet that leans heavily towards a vegetarian diet because that's what I like.
Any diet that restricts variety has a potential to restrict calories and that's why weight loss happens. If you are happy eating the way you are currently eating then great! It's just good to know that if you ever feel like having something from the "not allowed" list, you can. You just need to make sure the calories add up to a number than is lower than what your body burned that day.3 -
If it works for you,carry on!2
-
comptonelizabeth wrote: »If it works for you,carry on!
I agree that the OP should definitely carry on eating the way she's eating if it works for her.
But know that it has absolutely *nothing* to do with blood type, and everything to do with eating less than you burn in a day.
Whatever you choose to eat.9 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »comptonelizabeth wrote: »If it works for you,carry on!
I agree that the OP should definitely carry on eating the way she's eating if it works for her.
But know that it has absolutely *nothing* to do with blood type, and everything to do with eating less than you burn in a day.
Whatever you choose to eat.
Yup,agreed1 -
I've lost around 50lbs and I don't even know what my blood type is
OP the others are right-this is just another fad diet gimmick, and if you're losing weight then it's because you're eating at a calorie deficit and not because of what kinds of foods you're eating/not eating.6 -
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
We have the same blood type. I could never go without meat. There just isn't correlation between blood type and dietary preference. Now, if you want to follow it, by all means, but it has nothing to do with blood type but rather the foods described are foods you enjoy.3 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »comptonelizabeth wrote: »If it works for you,carry on!
I agree that the OP should definitely carry on eating the way she's eating if it works for her.
But know that it has absolutely *nothing* to do with blood type, and everything to do with eating less than you burn in a day.
Whatever you choose to eat.
This exactly.
Also, OP, food type does not make a person gain weight unless you exceed your total daily energy expenditure on a pretty consistent basis.4 -
Wow! Cool down! I'm simply asking if someone wants to buddy-up with me on the BTD.5
-
Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?Hey you, what's a woo? :-) The BTD makes perfect sense. Why else would some people fail on a particular diet while others succeed? My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock). In the end, b, it's what works for you, yes?
Woo = nonsense.
I love chicken! But according to the "blood type diet" I am supposed to avoid it. For every single person that matches the type of food they are supposed to eat....there is at least one person that doesn't match.
The fact that you and your friend "match" is total coincidence.0 -
-
Why do folks think everyone is getting out of control upset/heated when they're simply trying to help? Is it because it goes against what they want to hear?13
-
Blood Type Diet! Never heard such total baloney (excuse the meat-related pun) I'm an A- blood type and eat any lean meat as part of my diet. Lost 11lbs in the last five weeks on a lowish carb higher protein regime, but eat almost everything...1
-
Just going to leave this here and tiptoe my type-A-meat-eating-self right outta here:
http://www.webmd.com/diet/a-z/blood-type-diet
In summary:
If the Blood Type Diet intrigues you, consider this: The science is stacked behind traditional recommendations for healthy eating for weight loss -- not restrictions based on the type of your blood.2 -
serindipte wrote: »Just going to leave this here and tiptoe my type-A-meat-eating-self right outta here:
http://www.webmd.com/diet/a-z/blood-type-diet
In summary:
If the Blood Type Diet intrigues you, consider this: The science is stacked behind traditional recommendations for healthy eating for weight loss -- not restrictions based on the type of your blood.
Also from your link: "The diet may quickly become expensive, too, since the author recommends you buy organics as well as his own line of supplements"
14 -
Wow! Cool down! I'm simply asking if someone wants to buddy-up with me on the BTD.
No one is getting heated in this post. All I see are very honest and open answers. No anger, no dumpster fire. It's all good.
FYI, it's a good idea to stop deriving emotion from internet posts as it is impossible unless emojis are involved13 -
It's all cool!
Glad the diet is working for you, OP, but it's simply because you're eating fewer calories than you burn. If you actually like/want the things you've cut out, you can still have those as long as you keep your total intake below what your body uses in a day.2 -
Alatariel75 wrote: »I just looked up the lists for my blood type (AB+). I would be utterly miserable on that diet.
AB- here and boy do I agree! The stupid thing about this idea is that in diverse populations blood type is basically random chance so genetic disposition to food sensitivities based on blood type wouldn't apply.3 -
If OP stands for Old(er) Person, then that's me! I'm 65. I’m not new to this field. I was a chubby baby and a pleasingly plump child, according to my mother. My weight fluctuated during my teens—mostly up. I used the Grapefruit Diet and the Cottage Cheese Diet among many other ancient weight-loss schemes.
After I had the first of my 3 children (1971) my doctor told me if I’d just eat less than 1000 calories per day, I’d lose weight. It didn’t matter what you ate, he said. You can eat ice cream all day if you want, and if it’s less than 1000 calories, you’ll lose weight, he said. And that’s what I did. Sometimes I’d save my whole day’s calories just to have some gooey, high-cal ice cream concoction. I lost the baby weight and then some within three months. I used the same method after the birth of babies 2 and 3. In between, not so good. I wasn’t out of my 30s yet.
But I was just using the fewer-calories-in-than-expended method (CICO), which was not based on good nutrition. During my 30s and 40s the “science” said high-fat diets were bad, so we all ate no-fat cookies, nonfat ice cream and no-fat cake and wondered why we were expanding still. Especially our waists. By the time I got to 50, carbs were deemed bad. Now, of course, it’s sugar. By the way, also by the time I reached 50 I had passed 200 pounds on my bathroom scale.
Over the years I’ve done Jane Fonda’s No Pain No Gain aerobics, step aerobics, meditation, acupuncture, yoga, Pilates (my fav), swimming, amphetamines, Fen-phen …all of it. You name it, I’ve done it.
My health was bad—partly because of poor diet choices; partly because of genes. At 50 I had severe asthma, arthritis, stomach ulcers, heartburn/GERD and IBS, hypoglycemia, hypothyroidism, psoriasis, allergies, constipation big-time, idiopathic peripheral neuropathy, severe fatigue, etc., etc., etc. You get the picture.
I lost 70 pounds 15 years ago using first the Ornish Diet, which in the beginning banned nearly all carbohydrates, and then the South Beach Diet, which fit my hypoglycemia well and kept me from fainting. Somewhere in there people began to understand that 1000 calories was way too low for the average person, and that any way of eating that had the word Diet in it was an artificial way of eating. Also, that eating almost exclusively protein can wreck your kidneys. I lost the weight over a two-year period by eating 1200-1500 cal per day, depending on how active I was, eating nutritious food, and exercising in any way I could.
Now I’m 65, as I said. Fifteen years have passed since I lost the weight. And I’ve kept that weight off, within 5 pounds or so, up or down. But my health problems remained, for the most part. I’ve read more books on nutrition than I can count. I’ve looked at the science, the case studies. I did the research. I came across the Blood Type Diet about 10 years ago. Back then D’Adamo didn’t sell any products except for the book. First came the people and then the products, not the other way around. Just like the South Beach Diet, Atkins, etc., products became a big deal later on. And damn near everyone’s been on Dr. Oz. Guilt by association hardly seems fair, guys.
I said, “My roommate can't go a few days without beef. I'm nearly a vegetarian. Turns out her blood is type O (eat meat! eat meat!) and mine is type A (vegetarians rock).” Perhaps some in this group missed the point. I had become a near vegetarian because I couldn’t digest red meat and heavy, greasy chicken/turkey, yet I kept trying to keep protein in my life. Eggs and cheese get old. But a steak or hamburger would lie like dead weight in my stomach for days. My whole body ached from top to bottom. When I saw the profile of Type A, it was a huge relief to know I wasn’t crazy, that I really couldn’t digest red meat well, but at the same time I surely didn’t want to go vegetarian at all! Nothing happens overnight. I have worked at this all for years.
My roommate is much younger and newer at this than I. She has consistently carried 30+ excess pounds around and never been able to lose much weight—especially off her middle. She felt tremendous guilt eating red meat and eschewing “diet foods.” She tried just like I did to fit herself into something that was failing her. I’ve known her for 5 years and this is the first time I’ve ever seen her actually excited about eating well. And that’s what this is: eating well. It’s not dieting, or restricting, or denying oneself. It’s knowing that potatoes cause my arthritis to flare (and oranges too). It’s knowing that food is my friend and can make me feel oh so much better.
My asthma has virtually gone away. My stomach is finally right. No more gas, belching, bloating. No more constipation. My fatigue has lessened considerably. I can move again! So, bottom line: I didn’t come here to lose weight. I came to record what I eat and how I move to help myself be the best I can be. I use MyFitnessPal to be sure I’m getting all the nutrients I need and using all the tools available to me to live a happy, healthy life. The BTD way of eating fits my lifestyle.
So, again, here’s my OP: Hi! I'm blood type A and have been following the BTD for several years. It's the times when I get lazy and/or sloppy and eat "avoid" foods that I gain weight, become sluggish, sick, etc. I have lots of great recipes and good info on the Blood Type Diet. Looking for buddies to share with.
8
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions