If it fits in my daily calories...
Replies
-
Oh look............ It's this again..............
I am not doing this for you. I am not doing this for approval. I am not doing this to be a role model. I am doing this for me. If I want a burger, I am gonna eat a burger. I would hope that me eating a cheeseburger does not cause YOU to stress. I eat fairly healthfully the majority of the time. But sometimes, I just want food that is considered "*kitten*" by some self righteous groups of people. There is no point in me being thin and miserable.
My feelings exactly....0 -
I think it sets a bad example for those starting out. It is one thing to make that decision once you've gotten a hold of what you are doing with your weight loss. But for those who haven't found that happy medium, it gives them the wrong impression. Do what you need to do but I don't think it needs to be bragged about.
The flip side of that coin is that not everyone can start out eating whole quality foods if they are used to eating junk food. Sometimes staying under your calories while continuing to eat what you're used to is the starting point, not making huge changes all at once. Too many people fail at weight loss because they think they have to be deprived of things they like and must eat stuff they hate to be "healthy." Weight loss is hard enough. Stop trying to make it harder by imposing rules that aren't necessary.
This! :flowerforyou:0 -
I think it sets a bad example for those starting out. It is one thing to make that decision once you've gotten a hold of what you are doing with your weight loss. But for those who haven't found that happy medium, it gives them the wrong impression. Do what you need to do but I don't think it needs to be bragged about.
I disagree, I think it sets a GOOD example for people who are starting out. Starting out is hard enough, without taking away EVERYTHING you enjoy to eat. If people see that you can eat a double cheeseburger or a big mac (gasp!) and still have results, than it may make them think this is not impossible!
I have been on MFP for 70 days, I have lost 13.6. yes, it may be going slow, but it's going. It's going because I still eat Mcdonalds and Burger King. It's going because if I want ice cream, I eat it. it's going because it's possible to eat that food and still loose weight, as long as you balance your life out. THAT it what this is all about.0 -
why must everyone get into a heated arguement? i eat what i want, i dont care what other people eat and i dont care what anyone has to say about me eating what i want. everyone has their own methods.0
-
As long as you hit the macros it's all good IMO.0
-
hmm, I just have to wonder, how exactly does what other people are doing affect you and your journey? You should see my diary and then my progress pictures. You would be amazed at the transformation I made eating what I've eaten.
Agreed! And check her pics out-she does amazing!0 -
If you don't want comments from people on what you eat, then why are you posting it on a public website?0
-
I think it sets a bad example for those starting out. It is one thing to make that decision once you've gotten a hold of what you are doing with your weight loss. But for those who haven't found that happy medium, it gives them the wrong impression. Do what you need to do but I don't think it needs to be bragged about.
I actually think it gives a great impression...the impression that weight loss is attainable and maintainable by eating normal foods (in moderation) and that it is ok if you eat a cheeseburger or a slice of pizza. You don't have to quit your weightloss journey just because you indulge in some old favorites. You have to remember most people starting out are eating nothing BUT junk food, and to ask them to give it all up at once...I wouldn't do it!! that's for sure!
However, I commend you for your healthy journey and choices.
I think people refering to fast food and junk food as "normal food" bothers me just as much. It gives the impression that a good home cooked meal of fresh foods is somehow not "normal".0 -
I don't hate when people eat things that fit into their calories...I think the bigger issue is when people fit things like cheeseburgers into their calories, but complain they are not making the same progress that you are. Being mad at someone who has success and eats whatever they want is just plain jealousy.
One of my best friends eats roughly 3-4k calories a day, and he couldn't gain weight if he was getting paid to. He is extremely tall and it takes more for his body to stay balanced. I am not going to let his food choices bother me, all I am going to do, is continue with my goals and make sure that I am doing what is right to head down the path of health.
Even if you are fitting those types of foods into your calories and having success, it doesn't mean you are doing good things for your body. All of the negative effects of those foods will still add up over time, even if they don't show up on the scale. I say for argument's sake, just worry about your own path, and don't worry about your friend's menu. They will realize soon enough that those things aren't going to work for them...or they will fall of the wagon. Either way, not your concern.
Definitely not worth the stress either...stress adds pounds. :-)0 -
0 -
Why is it all or none with some people? "You eat cheeseburgers every day, so you're unhealthy and doing badly." It's like because we eat foods that aren't good for us, there's no hope. We should stop counting calories and just binge all day and gain 80 pounds, I guess.
The main reason I dislike many clean eaters (not clean eating) is because a lot of them get pretty snobby. Your way isn't the best, or most realistic way for a lot of us.0 -
I got the mental image of the toe nails EEEEKKKK
0 -
I'll take two0 -
Please point me to said 400 calorie double cheeseburger. Thanks
**waits**
McDonalds Double Cheeseburger=440 calories (maybe not the best example of a double cheeseburger but there it is)!!!
0 -
They can eat what they want, I'm sure they exercise or something to fit it into their calorie range. As long as they hit their macros and don't go overboard with the saturated fat or sugar then there shouldn't be any "health issues" either.0
-
I think it sets a bad example for those starting out. It is one thing to make that decision once you've gotten a hold of what you are doing with your weight loss. But for those who haven't found that happy medium, it gives them the wrong impression. Do what you need to do but I don't think it needs to be bragged about.
You know that works both ways right? You're "bragging" about doing it the 'right' way = your way. There is no difference.
I don't see people 'bragging', but sharing their experiences and saying there are all types of ways to lose weight and find one that will work for you long term.
The post I see aren't saying "I'm your example to follow!" they've saying "if it works for you, be happy and do it". How is that a bad example?0 -
Not sure why this bothers me but it every time I read someone posting something about how that 400 calorie Double Cheeseburger or Bucket of fried food fits into my daily calories, so I'm going to eat it!!. It is one thing if it's a special occasion but if this is a daily or weekly occurrence, you are only lying to yourself and making it that much harder to get to that goal you've been reaching for. Calories aren't the enemy, it is what those calories are made up with that count.
I used to agree with this without question. But, now that I have 3000 calories to eat every day I cannot possibly fill them with vegetables and whole grains only. That's just too much volume and I don't have the time to eat that much during the day. So, most days I eat some Oreos with a glass of milk after my kids go to bed. I'm breastfeeding, so I also need a lot of extra sugar. Even with that indulgence and lots of baked pasta I still have a hard time meeting my calorie goal.0 -
Why is it all or none with some people? "You eat cheeseburgers every day, so you're unhealthy and doing badly." It's like because we eat foods that aren't good for us, there's no hope. We should stop counting calories and just binge all day and gain 80 pounds, I guess.
The main reason I dislike many clean eaters (not clean eating) is because a lot of them get pretty snobby. Your way isn't the best, or most realistic way for a lot of us.
On the other hand, there are some people who take the statement "it's not good to eat cheeseburgers every day" to mean "CLEAN EATING ALL DAY EVERY DAY FOREVER"0 -
Agreed. I hate when i read that because it's not as simple as calories in vs calories out - although that's what I see a lot on here. You have to feed your body properly. And eating crap on a daily basis is NOT feeding your body properly.
I don't eat fast food (it upsets my tummy really bad), but I do eat cookies, cake, etc on a daily basis. I've had all kinds of blood work done along with other tests - everything is "excellent" or "text book perfect". From my cholesterol to my EKG to blood pressure - PERFECT. I don't eat perfectly and considering I've lost weight AND I am healthy (with the test results to back it up), this is what I will continue to do. It is sustainable to me for the rest of my life. Considering my doctors are thrilled that I have held off some of the nasty heart issues that plague my family in their early to mid 30's by losing weight, doing cardio and eating better? I couldn't care less what someone else thinks of me.0 -
You don't need to give up everything to lose weight, or adopt a completely "healthy foods only" diet, so I don't see what the problem is honestly. I also don't think it is as "unhealthy" as you are claiming it do be. If these hypothetical people are eating nothing but a cheeseburger and fries for every single meal then maybe can we begin to claim they are lacking nutrients and hurting their health in some way, but I doubt this is the case with anyone on here. But fitting a cheeseburger or fries into an already well planned balanced day? I say that sounds normal and frankly, healthy!
Touche! and fully agree. Several years ago I had counted calories and included things like a sundae for a dessert in the evening, a beer, wings, etc - if it fit into my daily calorie count. In that time (I had less to lose then), I was successful in taking off about 12 pounds in about 2 months to reach my goal. I kept that weight off for about 5 years - eating as I chose and exercising daily. Once I retired from the Air Force and stopped exercising and watching what I ate - I gained to where I was about a month ago. I don't think you can be successful in the long term through deprivation. If you like something - burgers, beer, wine, etc - EAT IT!! It doesn't mean you should do so daily - but there is nothing wrong with what someone else referred to a "Burger and Fries Friday!"0 -
Personally, I don't have an issue with it, but I do take issue with people who do that and then complain because they are not losing. If you can eat it and lose, great! But if you aren't losing and wonder why, that is an excellent place to start.0
-
Not sure why this bothers me but it every time I read someone posting something about how that 400 calorie Double Cheeseburger or Bucket of fried food fits into my daily calories, so I'm going to eat it!!. It is one thing if it's a special occasion but if this is a daily or weekly occurrence, you are only lying to yourself and making it that much harder to get to that goal you've been reaching for. Calories aren't the enemy, it is what those calories are made up with that count.
You're right. How dare people eat the food they enjoy, in proper proportions! And in no way can people losing massive amounts of weight become any healthier! Simply not being obese any more is not healthy! Who are they kidding?!
Oh, wait. That was supposed to be written in the sarcasm font. My bad.0 -
Why is it all or none with some people? "You eat cheeseburgers every day, so you're unhealthy and doing badly." It's like because we eat foods that aren't good for us, there's no hope. We should stop counting calories and just binge all day and gain 80 pounds, I guess.
The main reason I dislike many clean eaters (not clean eating) is because a lot of them get pretty snobby. Your way isn't the best, or most realistic way for a lot of us.
Not all cheeseburgers are that unhealthy. You can make them at home and they're just fine.0 -
If you don't want comments from people on what you eat, then why are you posting it on a public website?
personally, I don't get bothered. My friends actually applaud that I'm a real person and eat real (fake, processed, bad, whatever) food every now and again. Generally, I eat clean and train dirty, but eh, every once in a while I prefer a coke or beer over water or a burger rather than baked chicken or tilapia. Meh, I'm not worried, so I don't see why anyone else should be worried about me, either.0 -
I think it sets a bad example for those starting out. It is one thing to make that decision once you've gotten a hold of what you are doing with your weight loss. But for those who haven't found that happy medium, it gives them the wrong impression. Do what you need to do but I don't think it needs to be bragged about.
That's all well and good if someone starts dieting with the idea of being a role model for others. Most people I know are doing it for themselves and need to do what works best for them. I, personally, consider what I'm doing not a diet but a lifestyle change. I'm not going to give up cheese and chocolate cake for the rest of my life, so as long as it fits in my calories and I REALLY want it, I'm going to eat it! I just make sure it fits in my calories for the day or I burn it off in my workout later. And if I go over on my calories periodically, it isn't the end of the world as long as I get back on the right track the next day.0 -
No where did I say I ate "clean" or that I drank diet coke wtf?. Maybe my idea of healthy and getting fit isn't the same as yours. If you're having a "cheat" day more days than you are not, its not a cheat day.. it's part of your diet. For me, a cheat meal is an exception to the rule, not the rule. I have found my balance. My point was a fast food cheeseburger isn't the best option to meet your caloric goals for the day! Now if you're used to eating Four Cheeseburgers and your cutting it down to two, then that is great and it's a step in the right direction.
This is not the sentiment you expressed in the beginning. You're getting defensive because the conversation isn't going the direction you want it to go. In the beginning, you expressed the sentiment that we should NOT adopt the "if it fits in my daily calories..." mentality. I understood you to be saying that we should NOT eat cheeseburgers or cakes or cookies even if we can fit them into our calorie budget.
Now, I actually agree with the comment you made above. Yes, if you're cheating more days than not, you're not going to lose weight because a cheat day is almost always going to bring you above maintenance with your calorie count... but that's not how you started your tread. You weren't talking about balance, you were talking about abstaining from foods you considered 'unhealthy' even if you could eat those foods while practicing calorie restriction.0 -
If it fits in my calories for the day then that is really all that matters...we're only here (on Earth) for a short time and I plan on enjoying it as much as I can. And to me enjoying it means cupcakes, ice cream, M&M's, a double cheeseburge if the urge hits. Yes I want to lose weight, I've lost 7pounds in 2 months and plan on losing more...but I'm not going to be one of those hungry miserable people whose lives revolve around not eating certain things...
me either, I pretty much eat what I want, if I have the craving for it, but most of the time I am counting cals and eating ( hopefully) healthier foods...I eat alot more salads than ever, mostly the nights I work, which is 4-5 days a week...the other nights dinners are healthy, chicken or pork with vegs...I mostly eat my "bad" foods for lunch so I can work the cals off at work...
and I have lost 8 lbs in 1 month0 -
To each their own... but ya know we can't take away the fact that perhaps it is only once a week now rather than 3-4 times before they started.
Depriving oneself of what we really like and want is only a recipe for failure for some... kudos for those who can do it. We should stop putting down the efforts that some people are making just because they are doing it differently than us...
I used to love, love, love McDs - actually I still do - when I first started, an accomplishment to me was to have a kids meal rather than having the Big Mac I really wanted... that is a major step if you really look at it. Now, I don't even know when was the last time I had McDs but if I feel like having I wouldn't think it twice.
I am starting to see weight loss as religion - everyone has a belief and that is the only truth for them and everyone else should follow... grrrrr0 -
Well it's a good thing you aren't the boss of me 0
-
On the other hand, there are some people who take the statement "it's not good to eat cheeseburgers every day" to mean "CLEAN EATING ALL DAY EVERY DAY FOREVER"
Well we're just so very scared we'll be accused of cutting corners...0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions